ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:10.486 --> 00:00:15.647
Hello again, everybody. Lance Smith here, and welcome to episode 326 of the
00:00:15.647 --> 00:00:17.621
Bible Difficulties and Answers podcast.
00:00:18.269 --> 00:00:19.907
Have you ever noticed how one
00:00:19.907 --> 00:00:24.492
small detail in the Gospels can generate a surprisingly large question?
00:00:25.189 --> 00:00:31.835
In the Garden of Gethsemane, Matthew, Mark, and Luke describe Judas identifying Jesus with a kiss.
00:00:32.463 --> 00:00:37.403
But in John's Gospel, Jesus steps forward and identifies Himself.
00:00:38.147 --> 00:00:43.563
So, did Judas identify Jesus with a kiss, or did Jesus identify Himself?
00:00:44.156 --> 00:00:51.128
And if Jesus was willing to tell the soldiers who He was, why did Judas need a prearranged signal?
00:00:51.754 --> 00:00:56.218
Is this a contradiction, or are we looking at different emphases of the same event?
00:00:56.851 --> 00:01:01.697
Let's take a closer look. The Skeptic's Annotated Bible identifies this passage
00:01:01.697 --> 00:01:08.492
as a contradiction because the Synoptic Gospels describe Judas identifying Jesus with a kiss,
00:01:09.113 --> 00:01:13.919
while John's account emphasizes Jesus identifying Himself.
00:01:14.506 --> 00:01:16.950
Let's examine what each Gospel actually says.
00:01:17.635 --> 00:01:24.072
We'll begin with Matthew 26:47-49, our focus verse today, in the New Living Translation.
00:01:24.931 --> 00:01:29.866
"And even as Jesus said this, Judas, one of the twelve disciples,
00:01:30.330 --> 00:01:34.126
arrived with a crowd of men armed with swords and clubs.
00:01:34.808 --> 00:01:37.960
They had been sent by the leading priests and elders of the people.
00:01:38.634 --> 00:01:42.581
The traitor, Judas, had given them a prearranged signal:
00:01:43.295 --> 00:01:46.691
'You will know which one to arrest when I greet him with a kiss.'
00:01:47.285 --> 00:01:54.309
So Judas came straight to Jesus. 'Greetings, Rabbi,' he exclaimed and gave him the kiss."
00:01:55.019 --> 00:02:00.220
Mark 14:43-45 gives us essentially the same account.
00:02:00.969 --> 00:02:06.952
Mark includes an additional instruction from Judas: "Then you can take him away under guard."
00:02:07.842 --> 00:02:14.407
Luke 22:47-48 also describes Judas approaching Jesus with a kiss.
00:02:15.004 --> 00:02:18.632
But Luke adds Jesus' pointed response:
00:02:19.300 --> 00:02:22.133
"Judas, would you betray the Son of Man with a kiss?"
00:02:22.858 --> 00:02:29.006
So far, there's little mystery. All three Synoptic Gospels connect Judas' betrayal with a kiss.
00:02:29.691 --> 00:02:33.557
Now, let's turn to John 18:3-5:
00:02:34.366 --> 00:02:40.109
"The leading priests and Pharisees had given Judas a contingent of Roman soldiers
00:02:40.109 --> 00:02:41.976
and temple guards to accompany him.
00:02:42.598 --> 00:02:47.758
Now, with blazing torches, lanterns, and weapons, they arrived at the olive grove.
00:02:48.525 --> 00:02:54.045
Jesus fully realized all that was going to happen to him. So he stepped forward to meet them.
00:02:54.609 --> 00:02:59.135
'Who are you looking for?' he asked. 'Jesus the Nazarene,' they replied.
00:02:59.752 --> 00:03:05.443
'I am he,' Jesus said. (Judas, who betrayed him, was standing with them.)"
00:03:06.218 --> 00:03:11.749
Notice John's emphasis. Jesus steps forward and asks whom they're looking for
00:03:11.749 --> 00:03:13.875
and openly identifies Himself.
00:03:14.595 --> 00:03:23.709
John 18.6 adds that when Jesus said, "I am he," the entire group drew back and fell to the ground.
00:03:24.609 --> 00:03:29.640
That's quite an entrance! The soldiers arrive expecting to take Jesus by force,
00:03:30.040 --> 00:03:34.289
only to find themselves momentarily on the ground after He identifies Himself.
00:03:35.103 --> 00:03:41.668
Yet, John never says Judas did not kiss Jesus. He simply doesn't mention the kiss.
00:03:42.307 --> 00:03:49.253
And that distinction matters because there is a difference between omission and contradiction.
00:03:50.074 --> 00:03:54.283
Lee M. Jefferson, in his Bible Odyssey article, "The Kiss of Judas,"
00:03:54.834 --> 00:03:58.612
explains that a kiss was a customary greeting in the ancient world.
00:03:59.180 --> 00:04:03.801
As he puts it, a kiss was "an act of greeting and of deference,
00:04:03.940 --> 00:04:05.891
particularly between males."
00:04:06.647 --> 00:04:10.246
That makes Judas' actions particularly disturbing.
00:04:10.805 --> 00:04:15.807
He takes an ordinary expression of friendship and respect and turns it into
00:04:15.807 --> 00:04:17.353
an instrument of betrayal.
00:04:18.245 --> 00:04:24.717
Jefferson also observes that John's gospel avoids the kiss and instead focuses
00:04:24.717 --> 00:04:29.721
on Judas' treachery and Jesus' response to the arresting party,
00:04:30.352 --> 00:04:37.827
The Synoptic writers highlight the personal betrayal. John highlights Jesus'
00:04:37.827 --> 00:04:40.563
authority and willingness to surrender himself.
00:04:41.625 --> 00:04:46.339
Those are different emphases, but they aren't mutually exclusive.
00:04:47.093 --> 00:04:51.586
Think about it this way. If I told you about a traffic accident and mentioned
00:04:51.586 --> 00:04:55.896
that the driver ran a red light, while someone else described the ambulance
00:04:55.896 --> 00:05:01.312
arriving and treating the injured person, neither account would necessarily contradict the other.
00:05:01.904 --> 00:05:05.875
We're simply reporting different details of the same event.
00:05:06.453 --> 00:05:11.986
The same principle applies here. An author doesn't have to include every detail
00:05:11.986 --> 00:05:13.546
another author includes.
00:05:14.319 --> 00:05:19.892
The Veritas Domain article, "Bible Contradiction? Did Judas Identify Jesus With a Kiss?"
00:05:20.479 --> 00:05:27.663
makes this point directly: "John 18:3-5 does not deny Judas kissing Jesus."
00:05:28.250 --> 00:05:33.788
The writer explains that
Load full transcript
silence about an event isn't the same as denying that it occurred.
00:05:34.513 --> 00:05:39.526
And that's the heart of the issue. We shouldn't confuse an incomplete description
00:05:39.526 --> 00:05:41.897
with an incompatible description.
00:05:42.567 --> 00:05:46.666
Of course, we shouldn't automatically harmonize every difference in Scripture
00:05:46.666 --> 00:05:48.522
by inventing events that aren't there either.
00:05:48.998 --> 00:05:50.908
We need to be careful about that.
00:05:51.461 --> 00:05:55.252
But John provides no explicit denial of the kiss.
00:05:55.960 --> 00:06:01.306
So, why was the kiss necessary? And that brings us to another reasonable question.
00:06:01.306 --> 00:06:06.920
If Jesus was willing to identify himself, why did Judas need to provide a signal?
00:06:07.688 --> 00:06:12.047
Jimmy Akin addresses this in his article, "Judas Iscariot: Man of Mystery."
00:06:12.727 --> 00:06:18.276
Akin points out that even though Jesus was a public figure, the guards might
00:06:18.276 --> 00:06:20.169
not have recognized him by sight.
00:06:21.256 --> 00:06:25.590
Remember, this was nighttime, and the arresting party was approaching an olive
00:06:25.590 --> 00:06:28.232
grove with torches and lanterns.
00:06:28.967 --> 00:06:34.418
Akin even suggests that Judas himself might have needed to get close enough to recognize Jesus.
00:06:35.107 --> 00:06:39.490
That's a practical consideration. We sometimes picture the scene as though the
00:06:39.490 --> 00:06:43.541
soldiers were all familiar with Jesus and could pick him out of a lineup.
00:06:44.158 --> 00:06:49.056
But the arresting party included Roman soldiers and Temple guards.
00:06:49.682 --> 00:06:54.123
They weren't necessarily people who had spent time listening to Jesus teach.
00:06:54.880 --> 00:06:59.950
In the confusion of a nighttime arrest with disciples nearby and mixed Temple
00:06:59.950 --> 00:07:03.268
guards and Roman soldiers who may not have known Jesus by sight,
00:07:03.794 --> 00:07:07.777
a clear prearranged signal still made sense.
00:07:08.576 --> 00:07:12.941
Akin also suggests that the kiss gave Judas a degree of cover.
00:07:13.567 --> 00:07:17.038
Rather than openly shouting, "There's Jesus! Arrest Him!"
00:07:17.665 --> 00:07:21.542
Judas could approach him with what appeared to be a friendly greeting.
00:07:22.134 --> 00:07:24.334
Of course, there was nothing friendly about it.
00:07:24.970 --> 00:07:30.850
Imagine using a handshake to identify someone for arrest, or giving somebody
00:07:30.850 --> 00:07:34.912
a friendly wave while pointing out the person you're about to betray.
00:07:35.479 --> 00:07:40.338
It's difficult to come up with a more hypocritical use of an ordinary greeting.
00:07:40.979 --> 00:07:47.777
The kiss wasn't simply a means of identification. it was a calculated act of deception.
00:07:48.652 --> 00:07:54.103
So, why does John tell the story differently? So, let's take a look more closely
00:07:54.103 --> 00:07:55.650
at John's particular emphasis.
00:07:56.267 --> 00:08:01.550
Lindsey Scott, in her commentary on John 18 for Working Preacher at Luther Seminary,
00:08:02.170 --> 00:08:07.983
explains that John's presentation shifts the focus away from Judas' kiss and
00:08:07.983 --> 00:08:10.390
toward Jesus' authority.
00:08:11.018 --> 00:08:15.373
Scott writes this: "Rather than letting Judas' kiss betray him,
00:08:15.971 --> 00:08:20.035
Jesus identifies himself and approaches the arresting party."
00:08:20.813 --> 00:08:26.055
She also points out the significance of Jesus' words, "I am he."
00:08:26.663 --> 00:08:31.590
The Greek expression is ego eimi, literally, "I am."
00:08:32.372 --> 00:08:37.383
Scott connects this language with God's self-designation in Scripture and observes
00:08:37.383 --> 00:08:43.433
that John presents Jesus not as a helpless victim, but as the central authoritative
00:08:43.433 --> 00:08:44.695
figure in the encounter.
00:08:45.119 --> 00:08:46.512
That's an important distinction.
00:08:47.342 --> 00:08:51.034
In John's account, Jesus isn't stumbling into an ambush.
00:08:51.551 --> 00:08:57.547
He knows exactly what's about to happen, steps forward, and takes control of the encounter.
00:08:58.210 --> 00:09:02.471
The arresting party may have arrived with swords, clubs, and Roman soldiers,
00:09:02.935 --> 00:09:05.524
but Jesus isn't being taken by surprise.
00:09:06.179 --> 00:09:09.877
And that brings us to the theological significance of the scene.
00:09:10.661 --> 00:09:14.950
Jesus isn't being overpowered by circumstances beyond His control.
00:09:15.432 --> 00:09:19.031
He is willingly submitting to what He knows must happen.
00:09:19.855 --> 00:09:23.907
The kiss in the synoptic accounts highlights Judas' betrayal.
00:09:24.542 --> 00:09:29.443
John's account highlights Christ's sovereignty. And both truths belong in our
00:09:29.443 --> 00:09:30.794
understanding of that night.
00:09:31.984 --> 00:09:38.132
So, let's take a closer look at the Greek. There's another interesting detail worth mentioning.
00:09:38.711 --> 00:09:43.949
Mark Lamas Jr., in his entry, "Kiss of Judas," in the Encyclopedia of the Bible
00:09:43.949 --> 00:09:49.085
and Its Reception, discusses the Greek vocabulary used by the gospel writers.
00:09:49.687 --> 00:09:55.899
Matthew and Mark use the Greek verb phileō when describing the planned signal,
00:09:56.363 --> 00:10:03.561
but use the intensified form of kataphileō when describing the actual kiss.
00:10:04.216 --> 00:10:06.352
Luke uses phileō in his account.
00:10:07.022 --> 00:10:10.894
The difference in wording is interesting, although we shouldn't build too much on it.
00:10:11.438 --> 00:10:16.604
The intensified form can convey the act of kissing more emphatically,
00:10:16.877 --> 00:10:23.332
but it doesn't establish a different kind of event or create a contradiction between the accounts.
00:10:24.048 --> 00:10:29.447
In other words, the Greek gives us some
additional texture, but it doesn't change the basic picture.
00:10:30.183 --> 00:10:37.189
Jacek Rzepka, in his 2024 article, "Judas Proskynesis," published in the Biblical
00:10:37.189 --> 00:10:40.016
Annals, explores another possibility.
00:10:40.566 --> 00:10:45.699
He examines whether Judas' gesture might have carried the connotation of a formal
00:10:45.699 --> 00:10:47.654
act of reverence or homage.
00:10:48.372 --> 00:10:53.457
That's interesting because it adds another layer to the irony of Judas' actions.
00:10:53.979 --> 00:10:58.539
A gesture associated with respect and submission becomes the means by which
00:10:58.539 --> 00:11:01.294
he betrays the very person he should have honored.
00:11:02.249 --> 00:11:07.724
Rzepka's broader conclusion is also helpful. The different emphases in the Passion
00:11:07.724 --> 00:11:11.613
narratives "speak for the complementarity of the passion narratives."
00:11:12.333 --> 00:11:16.784
That's a useful way to approach these accounts. We don't have to flatten the
00:11:16.784 --> 00:11:18.416
differences to make them agree.
00:11:19.029 --> 00:11:23.264
We can recognize that each Gospel writer has selected details that contribute
00:11:23.264 --> 00:11:25.640
to his presentation of the events.
00:11:26.334 --> 00:11:30.046
So is there a contradiction? Let's put the pieces together.
00:11:30.526 --> 00:11:37.423
Matthew and Mark explicitly tell us that Judas arranged to identify Jesus with a kiss.
00:11:38.048 --> 00:11:44.428
Luke describes Judas approaching Jesus with a kiss and records Jesus confronting him about the betrayal.
00:11:45.011 --> 00:11:50.821
John, meanwhile, describes Jesus stepping forward and identifying himself to the arresting party.
00:11:51.345 --> 00:11:54.474
He also tells us that Judas was standing with a group.
00:11:55.087 --> 00:11:59.220
What John does not tell us is that Judas never kissed Jesus.
00:11:59.891 --> 00:12:04.994
A possible sequence is that the arresting party arrived, Jesus stepped forward
00:12:04.994 --> 00:12:09.334
and identified Himself, and Judas still carried out the prearranged signal by
00:12:09.334 --> 00:12:11.466
approaching Jesus with a kiss.
00:12:12.679 --> 00:12:16.044
That sequence accommodates the details in the various accounts,
00:12:16.044 --> 00:12:20.924
but we should be honest, none of the Gospel writers gives us a complete minute-by-minute
00:12:20.924 --> 00:12:27.353
chronology establishing precisely when the kiss occurred relative to Jesus' self-identification.
00:12:28.061 --> 00:12:32.804
And we don't need to claim that they do. The important distinction is between
00:12:32.804 --> 00:12:37.254
an event being omitted and an event being denied.
00:12:37.840 --> 00:12:41.289
John omits the kiss. He never explicitly denies it.
00:12:41.904 --> 00:12:47.730
So my conclusion is straightforward. Judas did identify Jesus with a kiss,
00:12:47.945 --> 00:12:49.971
as the Synoptic Gospels tell us.
00:12:50.441 --> 00:12:54.314
John's account supplements the picture by emphasizing that Jesus identified
00:12:54.314 --> 00:12:57.738
Himself and remain completely in control of the situation.
00:12:58.388 --> 00:13:01.012
There is no demonstrated contradiction here.
00:13:02.438 --> 00:13:08.336
I do have some final thoughts. What stands out to me is the tragic misuse of
00:13:08.336 --> 00:13:11.522
something ordinarily associated with friendship.
00:13:12.329 --> 00:13:16.398
A kiss was supposed to communicate affection, loyalty, and respect,
00:13:16.874 --> 00:13:20.148
but Judas turned it into a signal of betrayal.
00:13:20.650 --> 00:13:22.965
And there's something else worth noticing.
00:13:23.573 --> 00:13:28.565
Jesus knew what Judas was doing. He knew why the soldiers had come.
00:13:29.174 --> 00:13:32.895
Yet He didn't run or hide. He stepped forward.
00:13:33.662 --> 00:13:39.380
The cross wasn't an accident, and Jesus wasn't an unwilling participant in God's redemptive plan.
00:13:39.984 --> 00:13:46.369
The betrayal was real. The injustice was real. But so was the sovereignty of Christ.
00:13:47.134 --> 00:13:52.226
There's a lesson here for us, too. It's possible to use the outward language
00:13:52.226 --> 00:13:56.166
of loyalty while our hearts are somewhere else entirely.
00:13:56.724 --> 00:14:02.006
Judas reminds us that appearances can be deceiving and that genuine devotion
00:14:02.006 --> 00:14:06.209
to Christ involves much more than the right words or gestures.
00:14:06.832 --> 00:14:10.530
The question isn't simply whether we appear to be standing with Jesus.
00:14:11.099 --> 00:14:13.699
It's whether we're actually faithful to Him.
00:14:14.307 --> 00:14:17.067
And that's something worth thinking about.
00:14:17.844 --> 00:14:21.026
If this episode has helped you work through another apparent difficulty in Scripture,
00:14:21.026 --> 00:14:25.000
I'd love to hear from you. Send me any Bible difficulty you'd like for me to examine.
00:14:25.737 --> 00:14:29.316
And if today's episode has been helpful, you can support the Bible Difficulties
00:14:29.316 --> 00:14:32.959
and Answers podcast at buymeacoffee.com/LanceSmith.
00:14:33.446 --> 00:14:35.374
Your support is appreciated but never expected.
00:14:36.053 --> 00:14:39.826
You can find every episode at bibledifficultiesandanswers.podbean.com.
00:14:40.035 --> 00:14:41.426
You can also join the discussion on
00:14:41.426 --> 00:14:45.759
Facebook or email me anytime at bibledifficultiesandanswers@gmail.com.
00:14:46.258 --> 00:14:49.102
I read every message and I generally enjoy hearing from you.
00:14:49.718 --> 00:14:52.186
Until next time, this is Lance Smith, wishing you good health,
00:14:52.186 --> 00:14:57.027
good study, and God's richest blessings. So long, everybody.