ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.190 --> 00:00:02.649
You stream music every day, right? Like you wake up,
2
00:00:02.850 --> 00:00:04.889
you tap a playlist on your phone, put in your
3
00:00:04.929 --> 00:00:06.370
earbuds and just go about your life.
4
00:00:06.650 --> 00:00:08.800
Oh, yeah. It's practically second nature for most of us
5
00:00:08.839 --> 00:00:09.359
at this point.
6
00:00:09.679 --> 00:00:13.300
Totally. You hit play and the assumption is that somewhere
7
00:00:13.320 --> 00:00:15.460
out there in the world, someone is getting paid for
8
00:00:15.500 --> 00:00:15.859
that play.
9
00:00:15.880 --> 00:00:17.679
Right, because you're consuming their product.
10
00:00:17.920 --> 00:00:21.969
Exactly. But do you actually know who gets that money? Or,
11
00:00:22.550 --> 00:00:23.789
I mean, how much it even is?
12
00:00:24.230 --> 00:00:26.050
Most people have absolutely no idea.
13
00:00:26.690 --> 00:00:29.269
So today we are pulling back the curtain on this
14
00:00:29.489 --> 00:00:33.530
massive brief detailing the economics of the world's largest music
15
00:00:33.549 --> 00:00:35.170
streaming service, Spotify.
16
00:00:35.549 --> 00:00:38.049
It is a dense piece of source material, but it's
17
00:00:38.109 --> 00:00:38.770
so important.
18
00:00:38.890 --> 00:00:41.270
It really is. Our mission for this deep dive is
19
00:00:41.289 --> 00:00:45.170
to uncover exactly who stands between you and your favorite
20
00:00:45.210 --> 00:00:48.579
artist and why the money you pay for your monthly
21
00:00:48.619 --> 00:00:51.340
subscription is just fiercely debated right now.
22
00:00:51.640 --> 00:00:54.979
It's basically the center of the biggest argument in the
23
00:00:55.020 --> 00:00:55.960
entire music industry.
24
00:00:56.549 --> 00:00:59.869
Because there's this profound paradox we need to unpack, right?
25
00:00:59.969 --> 00:01:04.370
Yeah, it's a huge industry-defining paradox. I mean, streaming undeniably
26
00:01:04.549 --> 00:01:07.590
revived the recorded music industry. It dragged it out of
27
00:01:07.629 --> 00:01:09.920
the dark days of rampant piracy.
28
00:01:10.000 --> 00:01:11.420
Right, the whole file-sharing era.
29
00:01:11.680 --> 00:01:16.620
Exactly. It stabilized the market and injected this massive, reliable
30
00:01:16.739 --> 00:01:18.400
revenue back into the global ecosystem.
31
00:01:18.579 --> 00:01:20.859
Yeah, the industry on a macro level is booming. It is.
32
00:01:21.719 --> 00:01:26.000
Yet. Despite that massive financial revival, it remains incredibly hard
33
00:01:26.040 --> 00:01:28.239
for many working musicians to actually make a living wage.
34
00:01:28.959 --> 00:01:32.109
The individual creators fueling the boom are, you know, often
35
00:01:32.269 --> 00:01:32.810
scraping by.
36
00:01:32.829 --> 00:01:37.489
Okay. Let's unpack this. Because to truly understand why working
37
00:01:37.530 --> 00:01:41.769
musicians are struggling while the overall industry thrives, we have
38
00:01:41.790 --> 00:01:42.390
to look at the math.
39
00:01:42.609 --> 00:01:45.769
Yes. And the math is where things get really messy. Right.
40
00:01:46.390 --> 00:01:47.890
And to look at the math, we basically have to
41
00:01:48.019 --> 00:01:51.700
completely throw out everything you think you know About what
42
00:01:51.739 --> 00:01:53.200
people call the per stream rate.
43
00:01:53.400 --> 00:01:55.200
The infamous per stream rate.
44
00:01:55.920 --> 00:01:58.439
People ask this question constantly online. You know, they want
45
00:01:58.469 --> 00:02:01.129
to know what exactly does Spotify pay per stream?
46
00:02:01.370 --> 00:02:02.709
And it's the wrong question to ask.
47
00:02:03.010 --> 00:02:05.310
Because they're imagining a vending machine. They think the streaming
48
00:02:05.329 --> 00:02:09.509
platform is this giant digital vending machine where you, the listener,
49
00:02:09.590 --> 00:02:13.780
put in one stream and a very specific predetermined digital
50
00:02:13.879 --> 00:02:15.939
coin clinks down into the artist's pocket.
51
00:02:16.460 --> 00:02:20.180
Yeah, that vending machine analogy is the root of so
52
00:02:20.340 --> 00:02:21.699
much public confusion.
53
00:02:22.080 --> 00:02:24.479
So tell us why that idea is just fundamentally flawed.
54
00:02:25.150 --> 00:02:29.189
Well, there is no fixed per stream rate, period. Spotify
55
00:02:29.210 --> 00:02:31.229
does not pay a set amount every time a song
56
00:02:31.270 --> 00:02:31.610
is played.
57
00:02:31.930 --> 00:02:32.610
Oh, wow. Okay.
58
00:02:32.969 --> 00:02:36.069
Instead, they use what's called a pro rata model or
59
00:02:36.090 --> 00:02:37.439
a stream share model.
60
00:02:38.189 --> 00:02:39.039
A stream share model.
61
00:02:39.319 --> 00:02:43.060
Right. So think of it as a massive swimming pool
62
00:02:43.219 --> 00:02:46.949
filled with revenue. Every single month, Spotify collects all the
63
00:02:46.990 --> 00:02:50.210
money from user subscriptions, plus all the revenue generated from
64
00:02:50.349 --> 00:02:51.650
advertising on the free tiers.
65
00:02:52.090 --> 00:02:54.240
So they take all that cash, take their cut, and
66
00:02:54.280 --> 00:02:55.159
dump the rest in a pool?
67
00:02:55.520 --> 00:02:58.340
Exactly. They take a large share. They've stated it's roughly
68
00:02:58.479 --> 00:03:01.699
two-thirds of every dollar they earn from music. And they
69
00:03:01.740 --> 00:03:03.939
dump it into this giant pool for the rights holders.
70
00:03:04.439 --> 00:03:07.990
Okay. So two-thirds of the money goes into this giant
71
00:03:08.030 --> 00:03:12.030
communal pool. And instead of getting a flat fee per play...
72
00:03:12.469 --> 00:03:14.289
A rights holder just gets a slice of that pool
73
00:03:14.349 --> 00:03:16.509
based on their proportion of the total streams.
74
00:03:16.930 --> 00:03:18.069
That's the core mechanism, yeah.
75
00:03:18.389 --> 00:03:22.069
So if a major record label accounts for, say, 10%
76
Load full transcript
00:03:22.069 --> 00:03:24.830
of all the music listened to in a specific country
77
00:03:24.870 --> 00:03:25.550
during a given month.
78
00:03:26.069 --> 00:03:28.629
Then they take a ladle and scoop out roughly 10%
79
00:03:28.629 --> 00:03:30.449
of that month's financial pool for that country.
80
00:03:31.150 --> 00:03:34.409
That makes sense. But the math gets exponentially more complicated,
81
00:03:34.460 --> 00:03:34.750
doesn't it?
82
00:03:35.060 --> 00:03:35.969
Oh, massively.
83
00:03:36.360 --> 00:03:36.539
Okay.
84
00:03:36.759 --> 00:03:39.919
Because that pool isn't just one single uniform body of water.
85
00:03:40.389 --> 00:03:43.629
The payout is adjusted by a highly complex set of variables.
86
00:03:44.009 --> 00:03:44.710
What kind of variables?
87
00:03:45.169 --> 00:03:48.330
Well, it's adjusted for subscription prices in that specific region,
88
00:03:49.090 --> 00:03:53.599
currency exchange rates, and the ratio of free ad-supported listening
89
00:03:53.680 --> 00:03:55.439
versus paid premium listening.
90
00:03:55.900 --> 00:03:57.659
Wait, let me see if I grasp the scale of this.
91
00:03:58.439 --> 00:04:00.680
If a listener in the market with a very strong
92
00:04:00.740 --> 00:04:04.500
currency and like a high monthly subscription fee streams a
93
00:04:04.539 --> 00:04:09.409
song on a premium account, that stream essentially carries more weight, right?
94
00:04:09.900 --> 00:04:12.280
It's putting more high-value currency into the pool.
95
00:04:12.740 --> 00:04:13.219
Precisely.
96
00:04:13.740 --> 00:04:15.819
But if someone in a region with a lower ad
97
00:04:15.879 --> 00:04:18.660
market value streams that exact same song on a free
98
00:04:18.899 --> 00:04:22.279
ad-supported tier, the revenue generated by those few commercials is
99
00:04:22.399 --> 00:04:22.839
much lower.
100
00:04:23.160 --> 00:04:27.209
Therefore, that specific stream adds significantly less value to the pool.
101
00:04:27.970 --> 00:04:31.389
Every single one of those geographical and tier-based factors alters
102
00:04:31.689 --> 00:04:33.089
the ultimate value of a play.
103
00:04:34.209 --> 00:04:36.629
So when you see those articles online claiming, you know,
104
00:04:36.949 --> 00:04:40.240
Spotify pays exactly this, fractions of a penny per stream.
105
00:04:40.660 --> 00:04:42.779
You're looking at an after the fact estimate.
106
00:04:43.519 --> 00:04:44.339
It's totally misleading.
107
00:04:44.620 --> 00:04:48.279
It's totally misleading. Right. People are just taking a rights
108
00:04:48.319 --> 00:04:50.540
holder's total check at the end of the month, dividing
109
00:04:50.560 --> 00:04:52.600
it by their total streams and coming up with an average.
110
00:04:52.980 --> 00:04:54.399
But that average is a moving target.
111
00:04:54.439 --> 00:04:58.279
Completely. It fluctuates wildly from month to month and from
112
00:04:58.319 --> 00:05:01.129
artist to artist based entirely on who is listening to
113
00:05:01.149 --> 00:05:02.430
them and how they are listening.
114
00:05:03.410 --> 00:05:05.889
So to you, our listener right now, when you see
115
00:05:05.930 --> 00:05:10.310
those exact per stream numbers, weaponized in online arguments, you
116
00:05:10.389 --> 00:05:13.139
now know they are a mirage. There is no fixed rate.
117
00:05:13.439 --> 00:05:15.240
It's all about the pool. Right.
118
00:05:15.319 --> 00:05:18.540
But understanding the pool only solves half the mystery. We
119
00:05:18.560 --> 00:05:20.420
know there is a giant pool of money divided up
120
00:05:20.439 --> 00:05:24.139
by stream share. The next logical step is figuring out
121
00:05:24.360 --> 00:05:26.569
whose pockets that money actually flows into.
122
00:05:26.990 --> 00:05:29.889
And spoiler alert, it is rarely the artist directly.
123
00:05:29.910 --> 00:05:33.449
Yeah, the sheer number of invisible middlemen standing between the
124
00:05:33.470 --> 00:05:35.790
play button and the musician is staggering.
125
00:05:36.240 --> 00:05:39.959
What's fascinating here is that Spotify generally does not pay
126
00:05:40.019 --> 00:05:42.500
artists directly. They pay rights holders.
127
00:05:43.019 --> 00:05:44.139
Okay, rights holders. Right.
128
00:05:44.720 --> 00:05:47.360
And in the music industry, there are two completely distinct,
129
00:05:47.620 --> 00:05:51.519
entirely separate sets of copyrights for every single song you hear.
130
00:05:51.939 --> 00:05:54.259
We have to break these into two distinct streams of revenue, right?
131
00:05:54.459 --> 00:05:58.339
Recording rights and publishing rights. Exactly. I always try to
132
00:05:58.360 --> 00:06:00.339
visualize this like building a house. I think it makes
133
00:06:00.379 --> 00:06:00.779
it easier.
134
00:06:00.800 --> 00:06:01.620
It's a great analogy, yeah.
135
00:06:01.759 --> 00:06:05.060
So the publishing rights are the blueprints. It's the original idea,
136
00:06:05.110 --> 00:06:06.269
the architecture of the song.
137
00:06:06.290 --> 00:06:07.670
The core composition. Right.
138
00:06:07.730 --> 00:06:10.430
And the recording rights are the physical house built from
139
00:06:10.470 --> 00:06:13.509
those blueprints, like the actual audio recording you can listen to.
140
00:06:13.889 --> 00:06:15.149
Let's start with the physical house.
141
00:06:15.470 --> 00:06:15.689
Okay.
142
00:06:15.990 --> 00:06:16.709
The recording rights.
143
00:06:16.790 --> 00:06:17.889
Okay. The master recording.
144
00:06:17.970 --> 00:06:21.589
Yeah. Often called the master. This covers the actual audio
145
00:06:21.629 --> 00:06:24.709
recording of a performance. The money generated from this side
146
00:06:24.750 --> 00:06:27.149
goes to whoever owns that master recording.
147
00:06:27.310 --> 00:06:28.730
Which is usually the record label, right?
148
00:06:29.170 --> 00:06:32.569
Historically, yes. For independent artists who aren't signed to a
149
00:06:32.589 --> 00:06:35.170
traditional label...
This money goes to a distributor.
150
00:06:35.410 --> 00:06:36.949
Like the digital delivery trucks.
151
00:06:37.569 --> 00:06:40.949
Right. Companies like DistroKid, TuneCore, or CD Baby.
152
00:06:41.310 --> 00:06:43.550
Because, I mean, you can't just upload an MP3 directly
153
00:06:43.589 --> 00:06:46.209
to Spotify's servers yourself. You have to hire one of
154
00:06:46.250 --> 00:06:48.329
these distributors to route it into the system.
155
00:06:48.709 --> 00:06:53.040
Exactly. The distributor collects the recording royalties from Spotify, takes
156
00:06:53.060 --> 00:06:56.100
their fee or their cut, depending on the specific service agreement,
157
00:06:56.639 --> 00:06:58.420
and then passes the rest to the indie artist.
158
00:06:58.899 --> 00:07:01.639
But if an artist is signed to a major label?
159
00:07:02.079 --> 00:07:04.600
The money flows straight to the label. The artist then
160
00:07:04.629 --> 00:07:08.319
receives whatever their specific contract dictates, which honestly might be
161
00:07:08.420 --> 00:07:11.680
a remarkably small fraction of what the label actually pulled
162
00:07:11.720 --> 00:07:12.680
from the Spotify pool.
163
00:07:12.980 --> 00:07:15.720
Okay, so that's the master recording, the physical house. But
164
00:07:15.779 --> 00:07:16.540
what about the blueprints?
165
00:07:17.000 --> 00:07:20.649
The publishing rights are entirely separate. This revenue stream has
166
00:07:20.790 --> 00:07:22.790
nothing to do with the audio recording itself.
167
00:07:23.329 --> 00:07:25.170
Okay, so it's just the idea of the song.
168
00:07:25.490 --> 00:07:29.470
Right. This compensates the composition, the underlying melody, the chords,
169
00:07:29.509 --> 00:07:32.120
and the lyrics. This money goes to the songwriters and
170
00:07:32.129 --> 00:07:32.879
the music publishers.
171
00:07:33.459 --> 00:07:36.480
And the administration of this money gets incredibly complex, right?
172
00:07:36.500 --> 00:07:40.740
Because streaming triggers two different types of publishing royalties simultaneously.
173
00:07:41.040 --> 00:07:44.069
Yes. Mechanical royalties and performance royalties.
174
00:07:44.490 --> 00:07:47.529
Okay. Here's where the terminology always trips people up. What
175
00:07:47.569 --> 00:07:50.810
is the actual difference between a mechanical right and a
176
00:07:50.870 --> 00:07:52.850
performance right in the context of streaming?
177
00:07:53.290 --> 00:07:55.750
It really helps to look at the history here. A
178
00:07:55.829 --> 00:07:59.250
mechanical royalty is the right to reproduce a composition.
179
00:07:59.649 --> 00:08:00.240
Reproduce it how?
180
00:08:00.970 --> 00:08:04.350
Well, the term mechanical literally dates back to reproducing songs
181
00:08:04.509 --> 00:08:08.449
on mechanical piano rolls. Oh, wow. Yeah, and later it
182
00:08:08.470 --> 00:08:12.680
applied to physically pressing vinyl records or CDs. Every single
183
00:08:12.740 --> 00:08:16.160
time a physical copy was made, a mechanical royalty was owed.
184
00:08:16.519 --> 00:08:18.620
But we aren't making physical copies with streaming.
185
00:08:18.920 --> 00:08:21.220
No, but in the streaming age, the law views a
186
00:08:21.300 --> 00:08:25.420
stream as a digital reproduction. Every time a user hits play,
187
00:08:25.439 --> 00:08:28.459
a temporary digital copy is transmitted from a server to
188
00:08:28.500 --> 00:08:30.480
a phone, triggering a mechanical royalty.
189
00:08:30.949 --> 00:08:33.720
That is fascinating. And what about the performance royalty?
190
00:08:34.100 --> 00:08:37.080
A performance royalty is triggered when a song is broadcast
191
00:08:37.100 --> 00:08:39.379
or played publicly. Think of a song playing over the
192
00:08:39.419 --> 00:08:42.279
speakers in a restaurant or being broadcast over FM radio.
193
00:08:42.519 --> 00:08:43.289
Okay, that makes sense.
194
00:08:43.750 --> 00:08:46.789
Because streaming services broadcast the music to the public on demand,
195
00:08:46.929 --> 00:08:48.929
they also trigger a performance royalty.
196
00:08:49.610 --> 00:08:53.149
Wait, really? So hitting play on your phone is somehow
197
00:08:53.210 --> 00:08:55.899
legally categorized as both making a digital copy of the
198
00:08:55.940 --> 00:08:57.639
song and broadcasting it.
199
00:08:58.009 --> 00:09:00.830
Which means money has to flow to multiple different organizations
200
00:09:00.909 --> 00:09:02.029
just to pay the songwriter.
201
00:09:02.250 --> 00:09:02.559
Like who?
202
00:09:03.220 --> 00:09:06.039
Well, in the United States, mechanical royalties from streaming are
203
00:09:06.080 --> 00:09:09.700
administered by an organization called the Mechanical Licensing Collective, or
204
00:09:09.779 --> 00:09:10.399
the MLC.
205
00:09:10.620 --> 00:09:12.620
Right, that was born out of the Music Modernization Act
206
00:09:12.659 --> 00:09:13.299
of 2018, wasn't it?
207
00:09:13.679 --> 00:09:17.809
Exactly. It was designed to centralize this massive, chaotic data
208
00:09:17.850 --> 00:09:21.029
problem of billions of streams and ensure songwriters actually get
209
00:09:21.070 --> 00:09:23.230
paid for the digital reproduction of their work.
210
00:09:23.429 --> 00:09:25.889
And what about the broadcast side? The performance royalties?
211
00:09:26.340 --> 00:09:31.059
Meanwhile, those performance royalties flow through performing rights organizations, or PROs,
212
00:09:31.159 --> 00:09:32.580
like ASCAP and BMI.
213
00:09:33.620 --> 00:09:36.820
Okay, let's ground this in a real-world scenario to show
214
00:09:36.860 --> 00:09:40.379
how wild this gets, because here's where it gets really interesting.
215
00:09:40.700 --> 00:09:41.759
Oh, I know where you're going with this.
216
00:09:42.500 --> 00:09:45.090
Let's say I decide to record a heavy metal cover
217
00:09:45.169 --> 00:09:47.110
of a famous 1970s pop song.
218
00:09:47.730 --> 00:09:49.049
Okay, a metal cover. Right.
219
00:09:49.789 -->
00:09:52.409
And I'm an independent artist. I record the track in
220
00:09:52.450 --> 00:09:54.610
my basement, and I use a distributor to get my
221
00:09:54.690 --> 00:09:55.789
metal cover onto Spotify.
222
00:09:56.220 --> 00:09:56.470
Got it.
223
00:09:57.419 --> 00:10:00.820
When a listener plays my track, the recording rights, the
224
00:10:00.879 --> 00:10:03.840
master royalty we talked about, flow to my distributor and
225
00:10:04.080 --> 00:10:06.639
eventually to me because I own that specific heavy metal
226
00:10:06.720 --> 00:10:07.360
audio recording.
227
00:10:07.860 --> 00:10:09.950
You built that specific physical house.
228
00:10:10.279 --> 00:10:13.929
Exactly. But the publishing rights, the money generated by the
229
00:10:13.990 --> 00:10:17.789
underlying melody and lyrics, flow entirely away from me, don't they?
230
00:10:18.169 --> 00:10:21.240
They absolutely do. You didn't write the original song. You
231
00:10:21.259 --> 00:10:22.200
didn't draw the blueprints.
232
00:10:22.419 --> 00:10:22.600
Right.
233
00:10:23.179 --> 00:10:26.139
So the mechanical royalty travels through the MLC and the
234
00:10:26.179 --> 00:10:28.460
performance royalty travels through the PROs.
235
00:10:29.080 --> 00:10:31.480
And both streams of revenue eventually land in the bank
236
00:10:31.519 --> 00:10:35.899
account of the original 1970s pop songwriter and their publisher. Exactly.
237
00:10:36.539 --> 00:10:39.120
You could literally have a songwriter who hasn't set foot
238
00:10:39.200 --> 00:10:42.159
in a studio in 40 years earning money off a
239
00:10:42.179 --> 00:10:44.580
stream of a heavy metal song they don't even know exists.
240
00:10:45.039 --> 00:10:48.450
That's just wild to think about. When you, the listener,
241
00:10:48.470 --> 00:10:51.909
stream a cover song, your single play splinters off into fractions,
242
00:10:52.250 --> 00:10:57.100
traveling through totally different financial pipelines, paying entirely different organizations
243
00:10:57.169 --> 00:10:57.840
behind the scenes.
244
00:10:58.379 --> 00:11:01.059
It is an invisible web of commerce happening in the
245
00:11:01.259 --> 00:11:02.860
milliseconds after you hit play.
246
00:11:03.220 --> 00:11:05.759
And because the pro rata pool is finite and there
247
00:11:05.820 --> 00:11:09.139
are so many middlemen taking a cut, the rules dictating
248
00:11:09.179 --> 00:11:11.429
who is actually allowed to participate in this pool are
249
00:11:11.529 --> 00:11:12.350
fiercely debated.
250
00:11:12.750 --> 00:11:13.610
Highly debated.
251
00:11:14.129 --> 00:11:17.850
Which brings us to the massive disruption we saw in 2024.
252
00:11:17.850 --> 00:11:20.629
Knowing how this pool works and knowing who sits at
253
00:11:20.649 --> 00:11:23.700
the table, Spotify basically moved the goalposts.
254
00:11:24.179 --> 00:11:24.759
They really did.
255
00:11:25.100 --> 00:11:28.440
They implemented some highly controversial changes regarding who is even
256
00:11:28.500 --> 00:11:30.279
allowed to earn money from the system.
257
00:11:30.740 --> 00:11:33.529
Let's get into those rules. They introduced a series of
258
00:11:33.629 --> 00:11:37.470
sweeping policy changes that dramatically shifted the landscape, particularly for
259
00:11:37.509 --> 00:11:40.870
smaller creators. And the most fiercely debated change was the
260
00:11:40.909 --> 00:11:42.929
introduction of a minimum stream threshold.
261
00:11:43.269 --> 00:11:44.500
The thousand stream rule.
262
00:11:44.809 --> 00:11:47.600
Right. Under the new rules, a track must reach 1,000
263
00:11:47.600 --> 00:11:50.580
streams in the previous 12 months to earn any recorded
264
00:11:50.659 --> 00:11:51.899
music royalties at all.
265
00:11:52.360 --> 00:11:55.419
Meaning if your song gets 999 streams in a year,
266
00:11:55.919 --> 00:11:58.620
you get $ 0 for the master recording. It just doesn't
267
00:11:58.659 --> 00:12:01.059
trigger a payout. $ 0.
268
00:12:00.679 --> 00:12:02.470
$ 0. It triggers nothing on the recording side.
269
00:12:02.909 --> 00:12:05.730
Why would they implement a hard cutoff like that? I mean,
270
00:12:05.769 --> 00:12:06.490
what was the reasoning?
271
00:12:06.809 --> 00:12:09.470
Well, we have to look at this impartially. Spotify's stated
272
00:12:09.509 --> 00:12:13.070
rationale for this is logistical and financial efficiency. Okay.
273
00:12:13.370 --> 00:12:13.610
How so?
274
00:12:14.240 --> 00:12:17.720
Tracks with under 1,000 streams generate what amounts to micropennies.
275
00:12:18.440 --> 00:12:20.399
In the past, these fractions of a cent were being
276
00:12:20.460 --> 00:12:23.200
calculated and paid out to distributors, but they were largely
277
00:12:23.220 --> 00:12:24.779
never reaching the artists anyway.
278
00:12:25.460 --> 00:12:26.659
Why weren't they reaching the artists?
279
00:12:27.179 --> 00:12:30.809
Distributors and banks have minimum payout thresholds and withdrawal fees.
280
00:12:31.370 --> 00:12:33.769
If your song earns like three cents a month, but
281
00:12:33.870 --> 00:12:36.370
your distributor requires you to have a $ 10 balance before
282
00:12:36.389 --> 00:12:37.370
you can withdraw funds.
283
00:12:37.590 --> 00:12:38.870
You're never seeing that three cents.
284
00:12:38.929 --> 00:12:39.110
Exactly.
285
00:12:39.330 --> 00:12:39.750
Exactly.
286
00:12:40.299 --> 00:12:43.759
Furthermore, the banking fees to process millions of 3-cent transactions
287
00:12:43.830 --> 00:12:45.769
cost more than the transactions themselves.
288
00:12:46.409 --> 00:12:48.110
That makes sense from a banking perspective.
289
00:12:48.269 --> 00:12:51.870
Right. Spotify argued that by demonetizing these low-play tracks, they
290
00:12:51.889 --> 00:12:55.610
could take those lost micropennies, pool them together, and redirect
291
00:12:55.690 --> 00:12:57.750
tens of millions of dollars back into the pool for
292
00:12:57.929 --> 00:12:58.730
working artists.
293
00:12:59.190 --> 00:13:02.740
I understand the administrative headache of processing 3-cent payments. I
294
00:13:02.779 --> 00:13:06.259
really do. But on behalf of the creators listening, this
295
00:13:06.279 --> 00:13:08.620
feels like a gut punch to the grassroots indie artist.
296
00:13:09.360 --> 00:13:11.100
It absolutely caused an uproar.
297
00:13:11.559 --> 00:13:15.220
Because a thousand streams can feel like a massive mountain
298
00:13:15.240 --> 00:13:18.269
to climb for someone just starting out. If you upload
299
00:13:18.470 --> 00:13:21.429
your very first acoustic demo and your local community streams
300
00:13:21.470 --> 00:13:24.730
it 400 times, seeing a few pennies hit your distributor
301
00:13:24.769 --> 00:13:27.450
account is psychological validation.
302
00:13:27.970 --> 00:13:28.990
It proves the system works.
303
00:13:29.370 --> 00:13:34.039
Exactly. Removing that first rung of the ladder feels exclusionary,
304
00:13:34.179 --> 00:13:35.879
even if the math makes sense for the platform.
305
00:13:36.539 --> 00:13:40.320
It highlights a Brutal friction, really, between the reality of
306
00:13:40.409 --> 00:13:44.360
small-scale art creation and the demands of a global technological platform.
307
00:13:44.740 --> 00:13:47.960
Yeah, because you have a system managing over 100 million tracks,
308
00:13:48.519 --> 00:13:51.159
trying to optimize an economic model at scale.
309
00:13:51.879 --> 00:13:53.490
And if the money is just sitting in a giant
310
00:13:53.519 --> 00:13:56.370
pool waiting to be claimed by whoever accumulates the most streams,
311
00:13:56.809 --> 00:13:58.769
that sounds like an open invitation for people to game
312
00:13:58.809 --> 00:13:59.269
the system.
313
00:13:59.490 --> 00:14:04.370
Oh, definitely. Which perfectly explains the other major changes in 2024. Precisely.
314
00:14:04.809 --> 00:14:07.919
The pool model is inherently vulnerable to fraud. If you
315
00:14:07.960 --> 00:14:11.159
can artificially inflate your stream share, you can siphon money
316
00:14:11.220 --> 00:14:12.620
away from legitimate artists.
317
00:14:13.080 --> 00:14:13.919
So they had to crack down.
318
00:14:14.600 --> 00:14:19.860
Spotify instituted strict anti-fraud measures, including actual financial penalties levied
319
00:14:19.899 --> 00:14:23.230
against labels and distributors when artificial streaming is detected.
320
00:14:23.539 --> 00:14:25.389
So this targets, like, bot farms?
321
00:14:25.929 --> 00:14:29.470
Yes, bot farms that stream silence or specific tracks on
322
00:14:29.490 --> 00:14:31.970
an endless loop, purely to steal royalties.
323
00:14:32.529 --> 00:14:34.570
But bots aren't the only way to gain the system,
324
00:14:34.610 --> 00:14:37.789
are they? Human listeners are doing it too with functional audio.
325
00:14:38.350 --> 00:14:42.309
Right. The platform also targeted noise and functional tracks. Think
326
00:14:42.370 --> 00:14:47.690
of white noise, whale sounds, static, or rain sounds
used
327
00:14:47.730 --> 00:14:48.289
for sleeping.
328
00:14:48.590 --> 00:14:50.190
I use a rain sounds playlist every night.
329
00:14:50.750 --> 00:14:53.620
Many people do. And the rules dictate that a stream
330
00:14:53.669 --> 00:14:55.419
counts after 30 seconds of listening.
331
00:14:55.759 --> 00:14:56.899
Okay, I see where this is going.
332
00:14:57.559 --> 00:15:02.340
Opportunists were uploading 31-second tracks of rain noise, and listeners
333
00:15:02.399 --> 00:15:05.409
would leave them on repeat all night long while they slept. Wow.
334
00:15:05.990 --> 00:15:10.169
Because these tracks generated massive continuous volume, they were pulling
335
00:15:10.210 --> 00:15:13.320
a disproportionate amount of money out of the pro rata pool,
336
00:15:13.600 --> 00:15:15.840
taking it away from traditional musicians.
337
00:15:16.340 --> 00:15:17.399
So how did Spotify fix that?
338
00:15:18.399 --> 00:15:22.620
Spotify countered this by instituting new, much longer minimum length
339
00:15:22.659 --> 00:15:26.360
requirements for those specific types of functional noise tracks before
340
00:15:26.399 --> 00:15:28.019
they can trigger a royalty payment.
341
00:15:28.600 --> 00:15:30.710
They are trying to clean up the pool. But this
342
00:15:30.769 --> 00:15:34.269
entire concept of pooling money together leads perfectly into the
343
00:15:34.389 --> 00:15:35.970
ultimate debate in streaming today.
344
00:15:36.730 --> 00:15:37.970
The fairness debate? Right.
345
00:15:38.929 --> 00:15:41.090
And this is a question directly for you, the listener.
346
00:15:41.669 --> 00:15:45.539
Is the entire system actually fair to you? Let me
347
00:15:45.580 --> 00:15:48.799
pose a scenario. Let's hear it. I am a massive
348
00:15:48.840 --> 00:15:52.580
jazz fan. I pay my subscription fee every month, but
349
00:15:52.639 --> 00:15:56.759
I exclusively listen to an obscure local jazz trio. I
350
00:15:56.759 --> 00:15:57.519
don't listen to anything else.
351
00:15:58.080 --> 00:15:59.320
Okay, a very dedicated fan.
352
00:16:00.080 --> 00:16:02.759
Under the current pro-rata model, where everything goes into a
353
00:16:02.799 --> 00:16:06.340
giant pool based on total global stream share, a chunk
354
00:16:06.360 --> 00:16:08.759
of my personal subscription money is still going to the
355
00:16:08.779 --> 00:16:10.419
biggest pop stars in the world, right?
356
00:16:11.419 --> 00:16:15.120
Because those pop stars dominate the overall percentages of the pool, yes.
357
00:16:15.720 --> 00:16:17.840
That is just wild when you map it out like that.
358
00:16:18.080 --> 00:16:20.639
Under the pro rata model, your monthly fee goes into
359
00:16:20.679 --> 00:16:24.200
the communal pot. And because massive global pop stars command
360
00:16:24.240 --> 00:16:26.559
the lion's share of the total streams on the platform,
361
00:16:27.159 --> 00:16:29.799
a portion of the financial value you brought to the
362
00:16:29.850 --> 00:16:33.570
platform ultimately flows to them, regardless of what you actually
363
00:16:33.610 --> 00:16:34.610
chose to hit play on.
364
00:16:34.909 --> 00:16:38.190
Think about that. If I walk into a local record
365
00:16:38.210 --> 00:16:41.830
store and buy a jazz CD for $ 10, the biggest
366
00:16:41.870 --> 00:16:43.549
pop star in the world doesn't get a cut of
367
00:16:43.649 --> 00:16:44.509
my $ 10 bill.
368
00:16:44.950 --> 00:16:45.470
No, they don't.
369
00:16:46.000 --> 00:16:48.039
But in the streaming economy, they do.
370
00:16:48.639 --> 00:16:51.519
Which is exactly why there is a massive push for
371
00:16:51.559 --> 00:16:53.399
what is called the user-centric model.
372
00:16:53.860 --> 00:16:54.870
Okay, break that down for us.
373
00:16:55.490 --> 00:16:59.389
In a theoretical user-centric system, the giant communal pool is
374
00:16:59.669 --> 00:17:04.089
eliminated entirely. Instead, your monthly subscription fee is walled off.
375
00:17:04.650 --> 00:17:05.049
Walled off?
376
00:17:05.470 --> 00:17:08.470
Yes, it is divided only among the specific artists that
377
00:17:08.609 --> 00:17:11.529
you personally listen to that month. If you only listen
378
00:17:11.569 --> 00:17:15.549
to that obscure jazz trio, your entire subscription fee... Minus
379
00:17:15.589 --> 00:17:17.630
Spotify's cut. Goes directly to that trio.
380
00:17:18.150 --> 00:17:20.730
On its face, that sounds infinitely more logical and fair.
381
00:17:21.089 --> 00:17:23.910
I mean, it mirrors the real world. Why isn't the
382
00:17:23.950 --> 00:17:27.470
entire industry aggressively pivoting to this immediately?
383
00:17:28.150 --> 00:17:30.170
Because when you dig into the mechanics of how it
384
00:17:30.210 --> 00:17:34.150
would actually function at scale, the results are surprisingly mixed. Really?
385
00:17:34.670 --> 00:17:34.970
How so?
386
00:17:35.529 --> 00:17:39.430
Numerous academic researchers and smaller streaming services have modeled out
387
00:17:39.470 --> 00:17:43.329
the user-centric system. It turns out that while it might
388
00:17:43.390 --> 00:17:47.759
significantly help certain niche artists with highly dedicated, focused fan bases,
389
00:17:47.990 --> 00:17:51.440
like your jazz trio, it could actually cause massive financial
390
00:17:51.480 --> 00:17:53.259
harm to middle-class indie artists.
391
00:17:53.859 --> 00:17:56.539
Unpack the math for me there. How does a fairer
392
00:17:56.599 --> 00:17:58.180
system hurt the middle class?
393
00:17:58.779 --> 00:18:02.079
It comes down to listening habits and volume. Under the
394
00:18:02.119 --> 00:18:05.700
current pro-rata model, every stream within a certain tier is
395
00:18:05.740 --> 00:18:09.700
weighed relatively equally. Right. But under a user-centric model, the
396
00:18:09.740 --> 00:18:12.660
value of a stream becomes entirely dependent on the specific
397
00:18:12.769 --> 00:18:16.390
user's behavior. Let's compare a casual fan to a power user.
398
00:18:16.410 -->
00:18:16.890
Okay.
399
00:18:17.250 --> 00:18:19.569
If a casual fan pays $ 10 a month and only
400
00:18:19.609 --> 00:18:23.009
streams 10 songs, each of their streams is worth roughly
401
00:18:23.109 --> 00:18:23.490
a dollar.
402
00:18:23.609 --> 00:18:24.289
Huge payout.
403
00:18:24.650 --> 00:18:27.950
Exactly. But if a power user pays $ 10 a month
404
00:18:28.009 --> 00:18:32.069
and streams 10,000 songs, maybe they leave playlists running 24-7
405
00:18:32.509 --> 00:18:36.740
in the background, their $ 10 is divided 10,000 ways. each
406
00:18:36.819 --> 00:18:39.759
stream from that power user is worth a microscopic fraction
407
00:18:39.779 --> 00:18:40.180
of a penny.
408
00:18:40.740 --> 00:18:44.599
Ah, I see. And middle-class artists often rely heavily on
409
00:18:44.839 --> 00:18:45.720
playlist placement.
410
00:18:45.980 --> 00:18:49.740
Precisely. Their music is being consumed by these power users
411
00:18:49.779 --> 00:18:52.460
who are passively listening to massive volumes of music throughout
412
00:18:52.480 --> 00:18:52.769
the day.
413
00:18:53.210 --> 00:18:56.250
So if an artist relies on passive playlist listening rather
414
00:18:56.269 --> 00:18:59.150
than a dedicated core of fans who only listen to them,
415
00:18:59.849 --> 00:19:02.490
the per-string value they receive under a user-centric model would
416
00:19:02.509 --> 00:19:03.329
just plummet.
417
00:19:03.670 --> 00:19:06.660
The power user's money is spread too thin. The debate
418
00:19:06.700 --> 00:19:10.200
is fierce because there is no perfect mathematical solution. It
419
00:19:10.240 --> 00:19:13.490
centers entirely on our philosophical definition of fairness in a
420
00:19:13.549 --> 00:19:14.269
digital economy.
421
00:19:15.210 --> 00:19:17.750
So what does this all mean for the artists? If
422
00:19:17.809 --> 00:19:20.650
streaming is this fiercely competitive, if the payouts are this
423
00:19:20.930 --> 00:19:24.789
mathematically complex, if thousands of streams might still only buy
424
00:19:24.809 --> 00:19:25.829
you a cup of coffee.
425
00:19:26.190 --> 00:19:28.210
And you have to split that coffee with your distributor,
426
00:19:28.230 --> 00:19:30.480
the MLC, and your publisher.
427
00:19:30.799 --> 00:19:31.200
Exactly.
428
00:19:31.720 --> 00:19:34.500
How are artists actually surviving in this ecosystem?
429
00:19:35.380 --> 00:19:37.759
The harsh reality is that for the vast majority of
430
00:19:37.859 --> 00:19:41.569
working musicians, streaming just cannot be their sole source of income.
431
00:19:42.400 --> 00:19:44.750
It acts as a foundational layer, a way to distribute
432
00:19:44.769 --> 00:19:45.769
the music globally.
433
00:19:46.230 --> 00:19:47.529
But they rely on other avenues.
434
00:19:47.930 --> 00:19:48.970
Heavily. Heavily.
435
00:19:49.049 --> 00:19:52.240
They rely on touring. and live performances, which remains the
436
00:19:52.420 --> 00:19:56.460
primary engine for income. Right. They rely on physical merchandise sales.
437
00:19:57.039 --> 00:20:00.720
Spotify actually has integrated features allowing artists to list their
438
00:20:00.740 --> 00:20:03.740
merch and concert dates directly on their profiles, turning the
439
00:20:03.779 --> 00:20:07.180
platform into a hub for these other, more lucrative revenue streams.
440
00:20:07.759 --> 00:20:09.059
And what about things outside the platform?
441
00:20:09.650 --> 00:20:13.059
Artists also rely on direct fan support through crowdfunding and
442
00:20:13.160 --> 00:20:16.000
sync licensing, you know, getting their songs placed in TV
443
00:20:16.039 --> 00:20:18.319
shows and movies and video games.
444
00:20:19.339 --> 00:20:22.200
But within the Spotify ecosystem itself, there are other tools
445
00:20:22.240 --> 00:20:24.069
that artists and labels are using to try and gain
446
00:20:24.109 --> 00:20:26.569
an edge in the algorithm. And we need to talk
447
00:20:26.609 --> 00:20:28.230
about these because they are highly debated.
448
00:20:28.730 --> 00:20:28.930
Yes.
449
00:20:29.230 --> 00:20:32.170
Specifically, we need to talk about discovery mode because this
450
00:20:32.210 --> 00:20:34.630
fundamentally alters the royalty math we outlined earlier.
451
00:20:35.089 --> 00:20:39.940
Discovery mode is a fascinating, highly polarizing opt-in program. Rights holders,
452
00:20:40.279 --> 00:20:44.190
the labels or distributors, can select specific tracks and offer
453
00:20:44.250 --> 00:20:47.670
to accept a lower royalty rate for those tracks. In
454
00:20:47.710 --> 00:20:51.089
exchange for taking a pay cut on the royalties, Spotify's
455
00:20:51.230 --> 00:20:55.470
algorithm will actively promote that track to listeners in personalized
456
00:20:55.619 --> 00:20:58.460
algorithmic spaces like autoplay or radio.
457
00:20:58.680 --> 00:21:01.539
Okay, wait, let me push back on this. You accept
458
00:21:01.599 --> 00:21:04.819
less money per stream, and in exchange, the platform pushes
459
00:21:04.859 --> 00:21:08.009
your song to thousands of new people. Isn't this just
460
00:21:08.069 --> 00:21:09.150
a digital version of paywall?
461
00:21:09.769 --> 00:21:11.509
A lot of people say exactly that.
462
00:21:11.529 --> 00:21:15.009
Because traditional radio stations were heavily regulated and fined for
463
00:21:15.029 --> 00:21:18.470
taking compensation in exchange for airplay. How is this legally permissible?
464
00:21:18.880 --> 00:21:21.960
Well, it is heavily scrutinized by industry critics who make
465
00:21:22.000 --> 00:21:25.160
that exact comparison, calling it a form of pay for play.
466
00:21:26.259 --> 00:21:28.720
The critics argue it forces artists into a race to
467
00:21:28.759 --> 00:21:32.769
the bottom, essentially sacrificing their already small royalties just to
468
00:21:32.990 --> 00:21:34.650
buy visibility on the platform.
469
00:21:34.990 --> 00:21:36.569
What does the platform say in its defense?
470
00:21:37.400 --> 00:21:40.279
The
platform and its supporters argue there is a distinct
471
00:21:40.500 --> 00:21:44.440
legal and operational difference. No upfront cash changes hands.
472
00:21:45.079 --> 00:21:46.559
Oh, because it's a royalty concession.
473
00:21:47.220 --> 00:21:51.089
Exactly. Traditional payola involved a label handing a radio DJ
474
00:21:51.119 --> 00:21:54.490
an envelope of cash. Discovery mode is just taking a
475
00:21:54.509 --> 00:21:55.609
smaller cut on the back end.
476
00:21:56.109 --> 00:21:56.250
Hmm.
477
00:21:56.950 --> 00:22:00.480
Supporters frame it as a democratized marketing tool. It allows
478
00:22:00.519 --> 00:22:03.539
an independent artist with zero marketing budget to compete for
479
00:22:03.640 --> 00:22:07.019
algorithmic reach without needing thousands of dollars in upfront capital
480
00:22:07.079 --> 00:22:08.700
for traditional advertising campaigns.
481
00:22:09.200 --> 00:22:11.289
Though if you do have the upfront capital, there are
482
00:22:11.349 --> 00:22:15.329
paid promotional tools as well, right? Like Marquee and Showcase,
483
00:22:15.869 --> 00:22:18.210
where you can pay Spotify directly to display banners to
484
00:22:18.269 --> 00:22:19.069
targeted listeners.
485
00:22:19.559 --> 00:22:23.779
Yes, it is a dizzying, multi-layered ecosystem where artists are
486
00:22:23.839 --> 00:22:26.559
constantly weighing the cost of exposure against the value of
487
00:22:26.599 --> 00:22:27.240
their royalties.
488
00:22:27.960 --> 00:22:30.920
We have covered an incredible amount of ground today, and
489
00:22:30.940 --> 00:22:33.759
I want to bring this all together. What we've learned
490
00:22:33.839 --> 00:22:37.420
from diving into this brief is that every single time
491
00:22:37.440 --> 00:22:40.609
you hit play, you are slicing a tiny piece of
492
00:22:40.650 --> 00:22:43.569
a giant, fluctuating global pie.
493
00:22:43.970 --> 00:22:46.369
The money does not drop like a single coin in
494
00:22:46.410 --> 00:22:47.109
a vending machine.
495
00:22:47.470 --> 00:22:50.829
Not at all. It flows through a complex, invisible web
496
00:22:50.869 --> 00:22:56.160
of rights holders, labels, distributors, mechanical collectives, and publishers, all
497
00:22:56.220 --> 00:22:59.819
based on proportional stream share, not a fixed rate.
498
00:23:00.380 --> 00:23:03.140
And with new rules like the 1,000 stream threshold, the
499
00:23:03.180 --> 00:23:06.089
barrier to entry for actually earning from that pie is
500
00:23:06.210 --> 00:23:10.029
higher than ever. Designed to optimize a platform hosting hundreds
501
00:23:10.150 --> 00:23:11.289
of millions of tracks.
502
00:23:11.809 --> 00:23:14.990
This complex reality perfectly explains the paradox we started with.
503
00:23:15.700 --> 00:23:18.440
It explains why a musician could look at their digital profile,
504
00:23:19.000 --> 00:23:22.079
see millions of plays, and still have to pack themselves
505
00:23:22.119 --> 00:23:25.720
into a van to tour relentlessly just to pay their rent.
506
00:23:26.400 --> 00:23:29.960
But it also emphasizes that your listening habits, the tiers
507
00:23:30.000 --> 00:23:32.819
you subscribe to, the volume of music you consume, and
508
00:23:32.960 --> 00:23:36.420
the artists you choose to engage with directly ultimately shape
509
00:23:36.440 --> 00:23:38.079
the financial realities of this industry.
510
00:23:38.599 --> 00:23:42.140
The listener is an active participant in this economic web.
511
00:23:42.440 --> 00:23:44.710
You have a lot more influence than you think.
512
00:23:45.150 --> 00:23:47.089
It definitely changes how you look at the play button
513
00:23:47.130 --> 00:23:50.119
on your phone. I want to leave you, the listener,
514
00:23:50.160 --> 00:23:53.000
with a final thought to mull over today. We talked
515
00:23:53.039 --> 00:23:57.400
about discovery mode, where artists trade their royalties for algorithmic exposure.
516
00:23:57.859 --> 00:23:58.099
Right.
517
00:23:58.779 --> 00:24:00.799
And we talked about how artists rely on touring and
518
00:24:00.839 --> 00:24:05.109
selling T-shirts to actually make their living. So, if live
519
00:24:05.140 --> 00:24:07.990
shows and merchandise are where the real money is, and
520
00:24:08.049 --> 00:24:10.910
if tools like discovery mode allow artists to essentially trade
521
00:24:10.950 --> 00:24:14.490
their music for exposure... Where does that leave us? Exactly. Exactly.
522
00:24:15.079 --> 00:24:18.339
You have to ask yourself, is streaming actually a digital
523
00:24:18.400 --> 00:24:21.920
music store where artists sell their art? Or is it
524
00:24:21.980 --> 00:24:25.599
rapidly becoming a giant interactive billboard where artists are essentially
525
00:24:25.660 --> 00:24:29.720
paying to market themselves to you? Think about that next
526
00:24:29.740 --> 00:24:30.730
time you put your earbuds in.
527
00:24:31.109 --> 00:24:33.170
It is a phenomenal question to consider.
528
00:24:34.109 --> 00:24:35.829
Until next time, keep exploring.