ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:03.173 --> 00:00:07.993
Hey folks, so I am Chisom Udeze and this is Overnight Wisdom.
00:00:08.673 --> 00:00:24.277
So today's an exciting episode for me because I wrote a book and my new book is called Hostile to Thinking, Finding Clarity in a World Designed to Distract You.
00:00:24.937 --> 00:00:31.219
And I'm really proud of it because I designed it, the cover and...
00:00:31.736 --> 00:00:38.317
I also include that, you know, uh African symbols that are meaningful, but that is not what this conversation is about.
00:00:38.317 --> 00:00:42.838
I want to keep my focus and make this a meaningful episode for you.
00:00:43.915 --> 00:00:57.904
And today, of course, the title and the topic of this episode is also hostile to thinking. And I'm telling you now at the start, because of course, you deserve to know what we're getting into.
00:00:58.511 --> 00:01:02.732
um What I'm going to talk about is not going to be a reading from the book.
00:01:02.753 --> 00:01:13.012
is uh the case essentially that the book makes or one of the many cases that the book makes.
00:01:09.596 --> 00:01:17.399
I'm putting it to you directly and I think that a lot of the cases also stand on its own.
00:01:18.260 --> 00:01:22.021
Whether or not you pick up a copy, but I hope you pick up a copy.
00:01:22.262 --> 00:01:25.203
The success of any book depends on the people who read it.
00:01:25.772 --> 00:01:30.626
and the people who share the ideas, challenge the ideas, argue with it.
00:01:30.987 --> 00:01:45.099
And I've put in here a lot of my, some of my best thinking. So I really hope that those who are able to purchase a copy or two or three will do so.
00:01:45.099 --> 00:01:51.945
ah Of course you can find a copy on my website at chisomudaze.com and you can get a signed copy.
00:01:52.647 --> 00:02:02.469
or you can also purchase from Amazon, um where it is accessible from anywhere in the world, but also on my website, we ship everywhere in the world.
00:02:02.891 --> 00:02:07.977
Okay, so I am going to get started on the conversation today.
00:02:08.079 --> 00:02:30.639
This book is titled Hostile to Thinking which I fought long and hard for with my ah publishers at the time and um it really captures what I think the world we are currently living in is, is that we live in a world that is consistently hostile to thinking.
00:02:30.639 --> 00:02:49.686
it properly captures how many of us, regardless of your context, we exist in environments that punishes careful thought. And that punishment is really hard to detect because from the inside it feels like being well informed.
00:02:49.807 --> 00:02:53.348
So I want to start this by talking about the speed of knowing.
00:02:53.907 --> 00:03:01.587
Think about the last time you had a strong opinion about something that happened the same day.
00:02:58.828 --> 00:03:09.068
It could be a clip, it could be screenshots, it could be a headline, a minute long, 30 seconds or even less.
00:03:09.427 --> 00:03:15.728
You saw it, you understood it and within the hour you could have told somebody exactly who was wrong.
00:03:16.349 --> 00:03:30.567
what it revealed ah about the world, about the person, about the context, and what ought to happen to them next as a result of that 30 second or one minute clip that you have just watched.
00:03:31.347 --> 00:03:34.943
You felt informed.
00:03:31.347 --> 00:03:39.189
You may even have felt good about yourself and the decisions you arrived at.
00:03:39.225 --> 00:03:50.444
Now if we were to ask how long did that answer take to build, the honest answer is that it took however long that clip lasted or ran.
00:03:51.086 --> 00:03:57.789
Real understanding of anything involving people, history, power does not really arrive that fast.
00:03:58.169 --> 00:04:09.383
I am not going to ignore the fact that you might know a lot about a specific context or content to see something and say I know what happened here.
00:04:09.723 --> 00:04:18.103
But the reality is that when we're looking at things systematically, it rarely comes with clarity that quickly.
00:04:18.312 --> 00:04:34.449
important that wherever we find ourselves in discourse, when the sense of knowing arrives to super fast, it is worth asking what produced it because oftentimes it was not knowledge.
00:04:34.586 --> 00:04:37.298
In my view, what produced it is design.
00:04:37.877 --> 00:04:45.651
The feeds on social media, they're not carrying most of what we know about the world, are tuned to hold our attention.
00:04:45.651 --> 00:04:48.391
They are designed.
00:04:45.651 --> 00:04:55.478
And the thing that holds attention best are the things that make us feel sure, angry or vindicated.
00:04:55.478 --> 00:05:03.740
That keeps nobody scrolling. A post that says, I'm still working this out. So I'm still trying to figure out this context.
00:05:03.761 --> 00:05:09.343
It goes nowhere. A post that names a villain goes everywhere.
00:05:09.642 --> 00:05:20.677
And the person who wrote it learns from the numbers which kind of content and mind the platform actually wants from them.
00:05:20.677 --> 00:05:24.297
And this is not only about my perception or suspicion.
00:05:28.605 --> 00:05:34.425
published a large experiment run on a short video app in India.
00:05:35.064 --> 00:05:40.288
covering around 8 million users for a randomly chosen group.
00:05:40.487 --> 00:05:45.870
She switched off the ranking systems and served them content at random instead.
00:05:46.232 --> 00:05:56.617
Their exposure to toxic material dropped by 27 % and the time they spent on the app dropped by 35%.
00:05:56.997 --> 00:06:09.725
So if you put those two things side by side, the ranking system was keeping people on the app partly by feeding them what was worst for them, but what was worst for them also engages them.
00:06:10.127 --> 00:06:13.391
That is not a glitch someone forgot to fix.
00:06:13.591 --> 00:06:16.545
It is how the product earns its money.
00:06:16.774 --> 00:06:22.173
Load full transcript
Over years, an environment like that, you know, trains us.
00:06:19.225 --> 00:06:25.052
We learn to arrive at positions quickly and defend them loudly.
00:06:25.331 --> 00:06:33.259
We learn that admitting uncertainty costs us standing in society, in public, with our friend groups.
00:06:33.540 --> 00:06:45.742
we start hearing the words, it's more complicated than that, as a sign that someone is dodging when they are often the first honest thing said in a conversation.
00:06:46.069 --> 00:06:51.403
And a society that can no longer sit with complexity cannot solve complex problems.
00:06:51.764 --> 00:07:04.954
While almost every problem worth solving, climate, inequality, know, uh gender inequity, migration, the future of work, is exactly that. It is complex.
00:07:05.274 --> 00:07:16.427
So when I say hostile to thinking, when I say that we live in a world that is structurally hostile and un-conducive to thinking, I do not mean that we have stopped thinking.
00:07:16.708 --> 00:07:19.088
We have never had more opinions.
00:07:19.088 --> 00:07:22.269
I think in 2026, people have opinions for days.
00:07:22.668 --> 00:07:49.237
But I do mean that the conditions that we engage in and we live in now penalize one particular capacity, This capacity is the one that's hard problems demand most, which is holding to or more true things that sometimes even contradict and conflict at once without letting one of them swallow the other.
00:07:49.411 --> 00:08:15.927
So what does this look like if we think about a room with more than, you know, one truth in it? You know, I can show you what that capacity looks like and what it costs to lose it from my own office. A few years ago when Russia brutally invaded Ukraine in February, 2022, my team, which comes from many countries, you know, was shaken and rightfully so.
00:08:16.327 --> 00:08:24.706
And the people around me, you know, myself included responded with real grief and real solidarity.
00:08:24.901 --> 00:08:27.860
I say this because I'm about to complicate it.
00:08:28.802 --> 00:08:38.010
At this point in time, one of my closest friends, uh Anna and her family were in Ukraine and trying to do their Ukrainian and trying to get out of the country to safety.
00:08:38.451 --> 00:08:49.273
At the time as well, my father-in-law was stationed as a UN peacekeeper in the Ukraine and we were scrambling to see how he was because we hadn't heard from him.
00:08:49.273 --> 00:08:54.048
So the sense of grief and solidarity was right.
00:08:55.051 --> 00:08:58.534
And I want to be completely clear about that.
00:08:58.796 --> 00:09:01.999
The invasion was a horror.
00:09:02.580 --> 00:09:06.785
Because what I'm about to say next is not a way of shrinking it.
00:09:07.004 --> 00:09:25.927
But as the weeks went on and people kept calling what was happening in Ukraine the greatest catastrophe of our lifetimes, I realized that I was not only just grieving, I was also worn out in the way that sat heavily with me.
00:09:26.386 --> 00:09:38.572
I kept asking myself why this level of attention and fear had never filled the room when countries like Sudan, you know, was at war or the Congo or Cameroon.
00:09:38.991 --> 00:10:00.638
I thought about the African students in Ukraine who ran from the same bombs and were held back at the borders or not even allowed on the train because of racism. So why does the world mourn some of its dead loudly and others barely at all?
00:10:00.868 --> 00:10:07.561
And it was a really interesting thing that happened in my office over those weeks.
00:10:07.561 --> 00:10:12.994
I still think that the questions I asked were the right questions to ask.
00:10:13.494 --> 00:10:24.619
But what I did not do well was I did not hold it well alongside everything else or perhaps everyone else in that room, because in that room, I was the leader.
00:10:26.061 --> 00:10:30.913
So several of my colleagues uh at the time came from Eastern Europe.
00:10:31.114 --> 00:10:34.606
And for a lot of them, the fear was not abstract.
00:10:34.606 --> 00:10:38.719
They had living memory of the Soviet rule.
00:10:38.719 --> 00:10:41.753
Some of them did.
00:10:38.719 --> 00:10:52.008
And I also at the same time had a Russian colleague, an employee who, while everyone talked about what Russia was doing, seemed to shrink a little bit more each day.
00:10:52.347 --> 00:10:55.090
I want to be clear that nobody in my office at all.
00:10:55.573 --> 00:11:01.816
blamed her for what the awful invasion of the Russian government in Ukraine.
00:11:02.115 --> 00:11:18.581
But the reality is in those periods of time or in that period of time, a lot of Russians felt as though they had to apologize for their country or they had to hide their identity so they would not meet hostility.
00:11:18.953 --> 00:11:33.821
and while no one accused her of anything, she knew how people beyond our walls, essentially, were, you know, looking at Russians that spring and the seasons after. And she carried that every day with her for a while.
00:11:33.821 --> 00:11:56.087
At the same time I was also so occupied with the grief that no one was naming that I neglected the grief, you know, sitting right beside me. I was correct about the world's uneven compassion, especially when those people, you know, are not white or those people, you know, who are suffering are black or brown or Muslim.
00:11:56.087 --> 00:12:05.216
But at the same time, I was also the one responsible for that room and in some capacity I let people in it down.
00:12:05.544 --> 00:12:14.610
now if we were to compress that morning where I expressed my frustration and other people were holding their realities and their fear and their grief.
00:12:15.090 --> 00:12:19.172
if you compress that morning into one clip you get one truth.
00:12:19.832 --> 00:12:22.173
and you get to choose which one sits well with you.
00:12:22.533 --> 00:12:27.177
seen whole though, it held at least four different truths.
00:12:27.616 -->
00:12:31.418
it held a wall that deserved every bit of grief.
00:12:31.982 --> 00:12:34.585
It held a fear that was legitimate.
00:12:34.923 --> 00:12:38.849
It held a pattern of selective mourning that was real.
00:12:39.409 --> 00:12:43.394
And it also held my own failure as a leader in that room.
00:12:44.475 --> 00:12:50.419
Thinking in this sense, I mean, is therefore refusing to drop any of them.
00:12:50.721 --> 00:12:55.946
Being right about one should never excuse me from the rest.
00:12:56.182 --> 00:13:09.320
So now let's talk, I consider myself a clever person and I am not humble about being clever or brilliant. And sometimes there is a trap in the sense of being clever and brilliant.
00:13:09.320 --> 00:13:27.241
So here's your uncomfortable part, and it is aimed at clever and brilliant people like me, and possibly at you. It is tempting to treat hostility to thinking as someone else's problem. The person who forwards the clip without, say, reading past the caption.
00:13:27.782 --> 00:13:31.240
It is not only theirs.
00:13:27.782 --> 00:13:37.619
There is a lot more refined way of not thinking, and it belongs to the critically minded like myself.
00:13:38.373 --> 00:13:44.941
It is the refrain that feels so clarifying that you stop the moment you reach it.
00:13:45.322 --> 00:13:47.883
Consider the words developed and developing.
00:13:48.383 --> 00:13:59.993
So according to the Global Footprint Network, if everyone in the world consumed the way Norway consumed, it will take, it will require 3.9 Earths to sustain all of us.
00:14:00.594 --> 00:14:21.884
If the whole world consumed the way the average Nigerian consumes, it will require less than one world, so around 0.7 planets. Yet Norway is a country we called developed, And Nigeria is the country we describe as developing, so on its way to Norway.
00:14:22.142 --> 00:14:25.894
And the reframe almost writes itself, you know? The labels are upside down.
00:14:25.894 --> 00:14:28.676
The so-called developed world is the reckless one.
00:14:28.676 --> 00:14:32.717
The so-called developing world lives inside planetary limits.
00:14:32.979 --> 00:14:36.080
So perhaps the rich could be learning from the poor.
00:14:36.921 --> 00:15:03.331
I have also made a version of this argument or something close to it myself in a research I worked on earlier on late last year, earlier on this year, and I still stand by lot of it because in there we're arguing about the importance of reframing the language of development and consumption to over consumption to really properly capture what we are doing to our planet.
00:15:03.731 --> 00:15:15.654
Nonetheless, those words developing and developed carry judgments about who has arrived and who has not and that judgment really deserves to be challenged.
00:15:15.923 --> 00:15:26.479
But if you stop there at saying, well, we can't just say a country is developing and another country is developed, whereas Norway is over consuming and Nigeria is under consuming.
00:15:26.919 --> 00:15:34.342
If you stop there, you would have mistaken a good line for a finished thoughts and it's not finished thoughts.
00:15:34.342 --> 00:15:42.548
know, much of Nigeria's small uh footprint exists because a great many of Nigerians have gone without.
00:15:42.807 --> 00:15:44.808
They've gone without power and electricity.
00:15:45.181 --> 00:15:49.583
they don't have reliable health care, they have gone without enough.
00:15:49.624 --> 00:15:54.407
And then the reality is that nobody should hold off that as a model.
00:15:54.668 --> 00:15:56.808
And as a Nigerian, I will not.
00:15:56.808 --> 00:16:13.614
and then the opposite story, which the language of developments, you know, depends on. That's basically every nation will eventually climb to where Norway stands does not survive the planet's arithmetic.
00:16:14.394 --> 00:16:28.219
We have just one planet and to the best of my knowledge we still currently only have one. We haven't figured out somewhere else where human beings can actually inhabit at the mass and the scale at which we are growing.
00:16:28.504 --> 00:16:39.153
And the reality is that with anything like the technology we have now, it cannot carry eight billion people living Norwegian lifestyles of overconsumption.
00:16:39.331 --> 00:17:01.249
So that leaves you holding to facts that pull against each other and will not let go. Everyone deserves what the Norwegian can usually count on to recover from illness that can be treated, to go to school, to live without fear of being able to eat or having social security, to reach old age decently.
00:17:01.948 --> 00:17:05.801
And at the same time, the reality is that Nigerians deserve it today.
00:17:06.385 --> 00:17:11.248
not a reward for waiting. they need and deserve it right now.
00:17:11.248 --> 00:17:21.772
and yet the reality is that the route norway took to that lifestyle that i also enjoy today cannot be taken by everyone.
00:17:22.712 --> 00:17:30.230
the way through if there is one is to pull apart the thing we usually treat as a single package.
00:17:30.450 --> 00:17:46.761
The parts of a good life that cause the planet little, such as clean water, vaccines, skilled midwives, and the part that cost it enormously, such as constant flying and the endless churn of things bought and discarded.
00:17:47.182 --> 00:17:50.744
No one has a catchy phrase for that work.
00:17:51.186 --> 00:17:55.047
And that is a large part of why so little of it gets done.
00:17:55.275 --> 00:18:05.593
And listen, the honest reality here is that a great deal of Norway's comfort is paid for with oil. Which is to say, it is the very thing that is heating the planet.
00:18:06.834 --> 00:18:12.478
I also carry multiple passports, uh including the Norwegian one.
00:18:12.919 --> 00:18:17.292
So I am not really describing this from somewhere safe above or outside.
00:18:17.292 --> 00:18:24.978
I live in the middle of it. And you know, neither nationalities or identities
hand me a tidy answer.
00:18:25.424 --> 00:18:31.393
So I had to take a break because mommyhood called, uh and now continuing from where I stopped.
00:18:31.393 --> 00:18:46.154
Alright, so now let's talk about a little bit around what we're often not raised to see. You know, um how much of this you can see at all, I think oftentimes has a lot to do with the place that raised you.
00:18:46.976 --> 00:18:57.243
And my partnership taught me and my marriage taught me uh that well before any research realistically did in such a tangible way.
00:18:58.204 --> 00:19:07.700
So some years ago My partner, my husband, uh and I were in uh Nigeria and my mother and I were setting up a school.
00:19:07.700 --> 00:19:18.414
Uh my husband was asked to uh help on a project and he really did good work and was paid in cash for that work.
00:19:18.414 --> 00:19:32.064
Um, you know, a lot of people would have simply just pocketed that cash But instead, my husband was stressed worn about how to declare what he had earned to the tax authorities back in Norway.
00:19:32.064 --> 00:19:35.267
Mind you, this man is in Norway.
00:19:35.527 --> 00:19:50.195
Sorry, is in Nigeria rather. You know, I asked him, of course, like why on earth, you know, like how would they even find out that you made this money where you were paid in cash? Nothing was wired to your bank account, just in cash.
00:19:50.443 --> 00:19:53.615
You know, and he was convinced that they always find out.
00:19:54.176 --> 00:20:02.662
You know, I asked, uh what exactly like who were they who would f do this finding out? And of course he did not know.
00:20:03.034 --> 00:20:09.006
He had just declared like he just knew that he's always declared what he'd earned.
00:20:09.184 --> 00:20:21.413
And really for me, what was interesting about that scenario was that it wasn't really about money. You know, it was about what each of us, in some sense, had been taught to expect from a state.
00:20:21.854 --> 00:20:34.050
You know, my husband grew up in a country where most people assume the government will largely do what it says, and where, you know, uh corruption scandal still shocks.
00:20:34.050 --> 00:20:37.502
You know, a lot of people are gonna clutch, how did the kids say it?
00:20:39.428 --> 00:20:45.809
When corruption happens, whereas from the context I'm from, a lack of corruption is what would be shocking.
00:20:46.849 --> 00:21:06.935
You know, so in this capacity, this is to say that I grew up in a context where, you know, between the US and Nigeria, where corruption was like the the standard of the day, you know. Um, so where my husband inherited a sense of trust, I inherited doubt.
00:21:07.404 --> 00:21:10.708
And I think doubt is not just a negative thing.
00:21:10.708 --> 00:21:20.585
I've come to think of doubt as something that lets you notice what other people walk past. So here is also where it stops being a conversation about my marriage.
00:21:21.486 --> 00:21:36.325
If you come from somewhere where there is high trust in society or in government, it's easy to put an old bag of you know clothes, uh To a recycling being and leave feeling like you've done your bit for the planet.
00:21:36.325 --> 00:21:38.826
You've recycled your clothes.
00:21:36.325 --> 00:21:44.809
Maybe you've helped some, you know, children in, you know, East South Asia or Africa or South America.
00:21:44.817 --> 00:22:03.806
And then you're like, I've done the work, I've done my bits. But it's quite interesting to think about it because In 2023, journalists at a Swedish newspaper called Afton Bladet put trackers on uh items of clothing as a way to track where it actually ended up.
00:22:04.012 --> 00:22:14.595
Some of the items reached the recycler and others kept and a lot of those items kept going. One of them went as far as far as Benin in West Africa.
00:22:14.796 --> 00:22:26.618
And it's interesting to think about how our good deeds good deeds in the West also exports harm in global south contexts that we may not be fully aware of.
00:22:26.863 --> 00:22:48.911
This same reporting had found that uh through custom records that the cha like the the main partners of HM had sent to Ghana over 300,000 kilograms of textile in one year, which was basically close to a million gamuts.
00:22:49.310 --> 00:22:55.155
The company says those clothes are reused or recycled where there is demand.
00:22:56.153 --> 00:23:12.942
And perhaps there are some that are, you know, the the the secondhand market is a legitimate market, but no country takes in a million garments every year without much of that clothing turning into rubbish on its beaches and in its landfills.
00:23:13.115 --> 00:23:29.359
And a friendly word about recycling or recycling for good does not change that outcome. So a trusting person like my husband trusts the box, and that trust is genuinely sincere.
00:23:29.940 --> 00:23:34.422
It also makes it easy never to ask where the bag went.
00:23:34.743 --> 00:23:39.295
Listen, I am not claiming that doubt is a better inheritance.
00:23:39.295 --> 00:23:51.817
That would be, you know, the same tidy flip that, you know, I talked about when we're looking at development versus uh or developed countries versus developing countries.
00:23:52.157 --> 00:24:03.201
I think that Norway's trust in the government and the system is mostly deserved from a very interpersonal and relational perspective.
00:24:03.854 --> 00:24:11.826
You know, and I know that I personally and my b my family has also benefited from it in ways that I am very grateful for.
00:24:11.826 --> 00:24:17.201
Uh, there's of course the reality that doubt has a prize of its own.
00:24:17.561 --> 00:24:27.987
When you leave permanently on guard, it is tiring. And suspicion can essentially sour into a cynicism that does nothing meaningful.
00:24:27.987 --> 00:24:35.659
Just as trust can slide into going along and not taking responsibility for the impact of your goodness.
00:24:36.219 -->
00:24:49.942
The lesson here is not that one upbringing or one way of living in the world uh is better than the other, or that you know, one upbringing sees more clearly.
00:24:50.321 --> 00:24:56.923
It is really that every upbringing shows you some things and hides others, and that's the reality.
00:24:57.384 --> 00:25:02.769
And the work really begins when you find out which one your upbringing hides.
00:25:02.997 --> 00:25:08.219
So everything in this book is organized around three main questions.
00:25:08.239 --> 00:25:12.881
And they begin as deceptively simple questions.
00:25:12.881 --> 00:25:15.471
it looks at the three clarities.
00:25:15.471 --> 00:25:29.757
Um and I have spent almost 20 years using them with leaders and teams, and they are the most useful thing I can leave you with.
00:25:29.888 --> 00:25:43.724
The first is identity. So when we look at identity clarity, it begins with the simple question, who am I? So who are you once you strip away the description that other people have attached to you?
00:25:41.172 --> 00:25:50.251
So things like your job title, your passport, what you are useful for, the polished self you show in public.
00:25:50.826 --> 00:25:53.728
What do you hold when it would be easier not to?
00:25:53.728 --> 00:25:57.298
Is what you need to be thinking about in terms of like who are you actually.
00:25:57.680 --> 00:26:01.833
I call this identity clarity.
00:25:57.680 --> 00:26:05.614
And when it is missing, people turn into whatever the each situation seems to want.
00:26:05.614 --> 00:26:10.586
So they shape shift and they wear themselves out eventually doing so.
00:26:11.238 --> 00:26:15.670
The second clarity is context, which is basically where are you?
00:26:15.670 --> 00:26:18.112
It is the ground in which you were standing on.
00:26:18.112 --> 00:26:26.226
It's understanding who wrote the rules before you got there, who gets rewarded, and who gets punished.
00:26:26.586 --> 00:26:30.688
And what that the same thing keeps over and over again.
00:26:30.688 --> 00:26:34.069
Is there something to string along and to learn here?
00:26:34.617 --> 00:26:42.364
And this is, of course, why I call it context clarity, because you need to really understand where you are and what shapes the environment in which you're operating in.
00:26:42.763 --> 00:26:51.730
You know, and without it, people take problems that uh build into systems and carry them as per private shame.
00:26:52.332 --> 00:26:58.826
The third is power clarity. Uh, what can you actually meaningfully influence?
00:26:58.826 --> 00:27:02.318
What can you change?
00:26:58.826 --> 00:27:02.318
Where is your real leverage?
00:27:02.619 --> 00:27:09.680
And which of your limits Are real rather than simply accepted without ever being tested.
00:27:09.681 --> 00:27:11.986
Which levers can you not push?
00:27:12.267 --> 00:27:25.858
And of course, this is why I call this power clarity, because without it, people take the blame for things they were never in that were never in your hands in the first place, or give up the responsibility and accountability for things that are.
00:27:25.961 --> 00:27:27.683
So how does this work in practice?
00:27:27.743 --> 00:27:29.784
So the three clarities work together.
00:27:30.545 --> 00:27:37.326
Strong identity with no reading of context gives you someone who is principled, working confidently into the wrong room.
00:27:37.945 --> 00:27:48.409
A sharp reading of context with no sense of power gives you someone who can explain details of why nothing can change and stops right there.
00:27:48.888 --> 00:27:58.916
And then power with no stable sense of identity gives you someone very effective at pursuing goals that were never really theirs so how does this work in practice?
00:27:58.916 --> 00:28:06.499
Let's take an example that a manager learns that her team's engagement scores have fallen sharply.
00:28:03.367 --> 00:28:11.539
The first answer is that team building day and a motivational speaker would fix all the problems.
00:28:11.980 --> 00:28:18.460
But when you run the three Clarities than the three questions: who am I, where am I, what can I meaningfully influence?
00:28:18.460 --> 00:28:31.594
When you run those questions instead, identity forces you to ask what she actually believes good work on her team would look like, as opposed to what the survey happens to measure.
00:28:32.273 --> 00:28:41.016
Contest asks what has changed around the team in the past year, or in the past two or three, four years, or even five months.
00:28:38.275 --> 00:28:41.016
And the answer.
00:28:41.451 --> 00:28:57.904
Turns out to be a reorganization, a colleague who left and was never replaced, and a deadline brought forward twice, for example. Paula could ask you to interrogate which of those she can actually touch. She might not be able to reverse the reorg.
00:28:58.267 --> 00:29:29.111
Uh, she might not be able to stop the employee who uh left and went elsewhere or was fired, but she can probably stop covering, you know, uh the empty post with unpaid evenings and she can put the staffing case in writing to the people above her because we need people, otherwise the team would be exhausted, un disengaged, and burnt out. You know, so these three questions show up in whichever aspect of life.
00:29:29.663 --> 00:29:31.173
essentially that you were dealing with.
00:29:31.173 --> 00:29:43.089
So feel free to ask me any question to prove that these three questions in the most granular form can unpack a lot for you, but of course they get a lot more complex as we look into it.
00:29:43.259 --> 00:29:54.974
You know, with three questions, at least ten minutes of honest thoughts, and a completely different decision from the one the fast answer offers.
00:29:55.190 --> 00:30:02.055
in the beginning I started this conversation by talking about like the you know the one-minute clip or like the 30-minute clip.
00:30:02.355 --> 00:30:10.030
So if we look at what a minute-long
clip does to all three, it offers you a ready-made identity.
00:30:10.030 --> 00:30:12.083
The good person who reposed the thing.
00:30:12.583 --> 00:30:17.866
It strips away the context because history does not fit into a minute.
00:30:18.147 --> 00:30:25.092
And it gives you a false picture of power because pressing share feels like You're doing something.
00:30:22.827 --> 00:30:36.615
An environment that is hostile to thinking does not damage one of these. It damages all three together while leaving you feeling better informed than ever, even though you are not better informed.
00:30:36.839 --> 00:30:38.900
So, what does this ask of you?
00:30:40.340 --> 00:30:51.064
With this book, Hostile to Thinking, you start to ask what changes now, what changes tomorrow, what changing next, what changes next week? Right?
00:30:51.064 --> 00:30:53.963
So let's look at what happens when the next clip arrives.
00:30:53.963 --> 00:30:57.484
First, you notice how fast you became certain.
00:30:57.525 --> 00:30:59.766
And you treat that speed as a warning.
00:31:00.405 --> 00:31:05.027
If you feel You fully understand something you first heard about this morning.
00:31:05.266 --> 00:31:13.351
The feeling tells you more about the design of the thing and of the platform than about the events you have an opinion on.
00:31:14.191 --> 00:31:18.063
Give it time before you move to action or you respond.
00:31:18.063 --> 00:31:28.196
It is, of course, true that if you are seeped in a conversation or a theme or a topic or expertise, that you're able to keep like give the fast takes.
00:31:28.576 --> 00:31:31.118
But sometimes we need to take a beat and go, okay.
00:31:31.118 --> 00:31:33.953
What do I need to reflect on before I can respond meaningfully?
00:31:34.076 --> 00:31:40.780
And it doesn't have to be days, it just has to be long enough to ask what would have to be true for you to be wrong.
00:31:41.038 --> 00:31:45.319
Second, turn on the three questions on yourself before anyone else.
00:31:45.599 --> 00:31:48.842
What does believing this let me feel about myself?
00:31:49.182 --> 00:31:53.884
What part of the history is missing from what I was shown?
00:31:54.204 --> 00:32:02.368
And what can I do actually here as opposed to what I can be seen doing?
00:32:02.500 --> 00:32:07.342
And of course, third, do not let complexity become a hiding place.
00:32:07.422 --> 00:32:16.204
I think holding several truths as at once is not the same as believing every argument has two equal sides. That is not the reality of the world.
00:32:16.565 --> 00:32:20.105
Some things are wrong anywhere.
00:32:20.365 --> 00:32:31.548
Building a product to hook children into a a sense of um addiction is wrong regardless of the context.
00:32:31.936 --> 00:32:34.537
It is wrong in every culture there is.
00:32:34.577 --> 00:32:39.759
the point is to stay with the hard question so that you can answer it better.
00:32:40.160 --> 00:32:42.820
Not so that you never have to answer it at all.
00:32:42.820 --> 00:32:53.837
And listen, complication is where the thinking begins and it never cancels out the obligation to act. You don't have to save the world.
00:32:53.837 --> 00:33:00.692
You cannot recycle yourself into a climate, green climate transition.
00:32:57.760 --> 00:33:05.871
But what can you meaningfully do in the space where you do have power?
00:33:03.065 --> 00:33:11.109
And fourth is protect the conditions in which people can think, your own and for everyone else.
00:33:11.536 --> 00:33:17.808
Thinking is painful and delicious and time consuming.
00:33:18.306 --> 00:33:23.570
It needs a lot of distance from the feed and information overload.
00:33:23.871 --> 00:33:29.614
And it needs place where saying, I have not decided yet, will not get you mocked.
00:33:30.173 --> 00:33:39.768
If you were responsible for any group of people, a team, a household, kids, a classroom, a congregation, you set that tone.
00:33:40.554 --> 00:33:43.836
Make uncertainty safe to admit.
00:33:44.178 --> 00:33:52.405
It would do more for the quality of thought around you than any advice I could actually give you right now.
00:33:52.626 --> 00:34:00.521
So I'm gonna be talking a bit about my book, uh, but pulling out meaningful topics that are relevant to you.
00:34:00.521 --> 00:34:03.596
ah so this is where I'll leave this one.
00:34:03.824 --> 00:34:14.170
Everything around us essentially is pulling towards speed and certainty, the quick verdict and the obvious villain.
00:34:14.650 --> 00:34:22.204
What I have tried and what I think I have succeeded in offering in this book instead is habits.
00:34:22.757 --> 00:34:28.708
The habit of staying with a question past the point where it becomes uncomfortable.
00:34:28.989 --> 00:34:38.880
Because that is where anything new or innovative begins and gets actually thought.
00:34:35.831 --> 00:34:49.695
Yeah. You know, I spent an entire book on that habit in our working lives, in society, the wider world, and in our personal lives.
00:34:50.614 --> 00:35:04.121
And I called it hostile to thinking because I think we live in a world that is structurally hostile to thinking and we can meaningfully take that power back intentionally.
00:35:04.297 --> 00:35:09.101
So it is out now wherever you get your books or ebooks.
00:35:10.123 --> 00:35:19.228
And you know what I've learned about books is you can put in all the work and write it. It's really important that it's actually read and argued with.
00:35:19.228 --> 00:35:22.090
So I really hope you will get a copy and have a read.
00:35:22.090 --> 00:35:30.197
ah But, anyways, if this is kind of thinking you want more of, I read a weekly newsletter called The Weekly Clarity.
00:35:31.157 --> 00:35:44.304
And I take topics and I turn them on your heads and try to unpack it and you know think about it with clarity. If this episode gave you something, send it to one person who needs to hear it.
00:35:45.244 --> 00:35:48.686
And of course, follow overnight wisdom wherever you get your podcast.
00:35:49.347 --> 00:35:52.927
And yeah, see you next week. Okay.
00:35:52.947 --> 00:35:56.581
I am Chisom This is Overnight wisdom.
00:35:54.088 --> 00:35:56.581
Thank you for being here.