ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
00:00:31
Speaker 1: Hello, this is Let's talk about myths baby, and I am your host, live here with another exciting episode. Another exciting conversation episode, i should say, and one that I think a lot of people are going to really appreciate. I've already heard from a couple of people ever since I just said I was going to have this conversation episode about a sexuality in Greek mythology, and so I'm really thrilled to be able to bing it to you. I think that it's a really interesting topic and obviously really important as well, especially just when it comes to representation and people now feeling like they can see themselves back then. So today I'm utterly thrilled to have spoken with Julie Levy, an independent scholar who studies a lot of this stuff, amongst many other things. It was such a thrill talking to Julie. They really opened up my mind when it comes to all of these topics and a sexuality in general and all the varied levels of it, and I personally learned so much, kind of had my eyes opened in a lot of really fascinating ways. It was such a fun conversation. We just kind of kept talking and talking, and I had to whittle it down into this hour episode for you, but honestly, such a thrill, so important, so fascinating, so entertaining. So I am utterly thrilled to present it to you today. Conversations not just a phase Atalanta and Hippolytus and a sexuality in Greek Mythology with Julie Leafy. Thank you so much Julie for sitting down with me today and talking about this. We're talking about a sexuality in Greek myth which is super fascinating. So I'm so thrilled. I'm so thrilled when you sent me that message about it, because it's one of those things that I feel like I don't know remotely enough to talk about, and so I'm very excited to have somebody on who actually studies this. Yeah, well, you know, not too many people really have studied this yet. In fact, when I was sort of looking around, um, there's I mean, it's not too surprise razing that people haven't studied a sexuality in Greek myth and in antiquity in general, because it's still such a new concept even for our culture as a whole, Like there are still a lot of people who don't understand what a sexuality is and what it covers. And then there's the added layer of trying to apply a modern sexuality term to the ancient world where such things only kind of apply. So a sexuals, which is to say, people who do not experience sexual attraction, or a lot of other things that come under the a sexual or ace umbrella, like demisexual where you only feel sexual attraction after an emotional bond has been formed, or people who are a romantic who experienced sexual desire but not romantic desire, and all sorts of things like that. All of that is has always existed. There have always been people who were those things, but the categories and the terms are all different. So looking at a sexuality in the context of ancient myth or ancient world studies, you have to be careful, uh, not to impose too much categorization and to keep it sort of theoretical, like where might these people be? Um? And you know, we had this problem when when LGBT stuff was starting to be an accepted field, When when gay and lesbian people were starting to be accepted into society as a normal part of life in in the U s and so and so on, we suddenly had this problem of well, how do we talk about that in relation to Athens where pederasty is what people know about, which is not your average modern gay relationship, right, but some people think it is, and that's not a good thing. Um, So we can't just apply gay to pederasty. That doesn't work. Mm hmm. But we do have people in gay relationships in the ancient world. I mean, the Sacred Band of thebes is you know what else is that? Right, it's a bunch of gay lovers who fight. Um. And so when we talk about a sexuality and ancient myth, we're not talking about Okay, I'm going to point to a person who is definitely for sure a sexual and presented as specifically a sexual. I'm going to talk about signs that point to people with a sexual modes of existence. Right. It's a little bit more hedged than you can properly say quickly. It's that's all so fascinating and so much how I have been trying to approach stories in the more, you know, the last couple of years, say, and my podcast certainly in the last year. Um, the deeper I get into, just even like academic friends on Twitter, which has been a real game changer for me, has led me to hedge that a lot more as well, just when I'm talking about you know, the even you know, the more traditional lgbt Q characters, UM, and then also trying to to mention that pederasty was a thing in Athens, while also pointing out how it is clearly not like a traditional gay relationship or even like a remotely okay gay relationship. And it was just about power dynamics more than it was about um, you know, sexuality and genders and and you know who love too. It was about power, um, making it inherently problematic. And so yeah, it's been it's been really interesting UM making those points lately too, of just like making sure to clarify and say, like, as much as you know, we do want to put some certain labels, I think I think some labels are helpful, especially in the way I do this podcast. So I do try to use some labels UM at times when when appropriate, some modern labels, I should clarify, because I think that it can be very beneficial to people to see themselves in stories. And so you know, I'm going to call Dionysus by, but I'm going to clarify at the top to like hedge it on. You know, he would have not necessarily understood that, and you know there's no terminology blah blah blah. But like objectively, Dionysus is pretty bisexual. Like let's disaster by a justice, I mean, all of the Greek gods that were by our disaster by I was trying to do a lot today and so I actually am like I have. I'm about twenty minutes through a thirty minute recording of this week's episode, which is part two
Load full transcript
of um Notices Diane Zica story of Dionysus and Impelis, which is like the only version we have that's actually long and drawn out and not just like he died and became a grapevine. And it's fascinating because it's there's so much talk about all of those other it's like about that relationship, but then it's also talked about Apollo and hyacinthis and Zeus and Ganymede and Poseidon and peel Ops and you know, Zephyr and Supersis, and they're all tragic. They all need the mortal to be dead or I guess not the case of Pelops, but like his life wasn't great. Um yeah, well true, yeah, but yeah, they like to say in that whole version, it's all about how Ganymede had the best life, and you're like, did he eat? So? Like the thing that I can never get over is his name, Like how do you name a kid shining balls? Is that what that means? That's what that means. I love that I get to talk to people this is to learn things like that. Like I've already brought us totally off topic, but we've got that out of it, so that is exciting. Um yeah, I just it's so fascinating the way that they like I wanted to turn these stories into something that they objectively we're not Like in in known As, he's all like, look at im, he got everything. He had a ride on an eagle and then he got to be a cup bearer. And Zeus his talents as an eagle were very gentle, and you're like, okay, like does that make his experience good or consensual or not horrifying? Oh yea, the rape of a child by Zeus was gen the talent specifically we're gentle, So yeah, anyway, it's wild. But that's all to say. I think it is. It's very interesting to like to hedge these things and also to do what you do, which is like looking into it. And people have asked me a lot about a sexual characters in Greek mythology, and just because you know, I don't I I don't put too much. I don't like to put too many labels on um on women. I think mostly not because they wouldn't have been obviously, but because what tends to be the case is that we don't have their stories, we don't have their side of the story. So there it's not really fair to say that, for instance, that Artemis was a sexual, because we just don't have her stories. Like we know she hung out with a lot of nymphs and and and so like. I think that if if somebody were to actually sit down and be like, Okay, well what did they actually believe? But Artemis, what are the stories they actually told they didn't get written down, like I would say she was probably in love with a few of those nymps, if not just one. You know. So it's just an interesting thing to to to handle those situations. Um, but now I'm just talking so much, So please tell me about the characters you do study and then the a sexuality in general that you that you're studying. Well, um, in particular, I really wanted to talk about Artemis first, um and specifically for that reason, right because Um, you know, women and even goddesses don't often get agency in the myths that we receive, and Artemis in
particular is kind of aloof. We don't get much of her side of anything, except in like the Orion myths, sometimes when it's acceptable because she has the hotspur guy. Right. So, Um, whether or not Artemis is an a sexual figure, whether she is a sexual but celibate figure because she was taken from uh this this sort of corresponding mother of beasts, uh goddess who was more popular in the Near East, you know, or whether she's in fact sapphic or like you said, in love with those nymphs, very anti man, anti marriage and you know, of course marriage and and no longer being a virgin for the Greeks. Um, in terms of women was actually about childbirth, not about sex. So if you bore a child, you were no longer a virgin. But if you had sex, well maybe you know who could tell anyway? So so what is artemus? We just We can't really pin that down to any one thing, but what she is is a refuge for people who don't want sex, because we get a lot of these figures, and in particular the two I mentioned I wanted to talk about today. Both Hippolotus and Atlanta are devotees of Artemis, and we see this a lot with young male warriors who reject sex. Um. Atlanta's later son, for instance, Parthenopious, is also a devotee of Artemas, and sometimes he's depicted also as sort of a sexual leaning and sometimes he's depicted more as just too young to have really finished going through puberty and figured that out. Um. But I have to say that there's this pushback that you get sometimes when you talk about a sexuality in the ancient world and you talk about these characters who sort of reject sexuality, like Narcissus or or Hippolytus, and people will say, oh, well, they're just adolescence. They don't know what they want yet. It is like, how many adolescents do you know who go through puberty rejecting the idea of sexuality, Like either they're ace in some degree they're having issues outside of that spectrum in some degree, or they're full of hormones and our horny like that's the more common experience, right, There's no reason to assume that when a young man is rejecting sex like Hippolytis does Fiedra, that that's some kind of teenage rebellion that doesn't really jive. But that's why you hear a lot of times. Yeah, that's interesting because I mean, yeah, likelihood is you know, a sixteen, seventeen, eighteen year old cis hit man that is an ace is going to be going through some sexual like he's got the hormone. So yeah, I mean, the likelihood is he's not choosing just being like, no, I definitely feel the sexual desire, but I'm just actively deciding not to go for it. You know. That's an interesting thing, right, So um and and you know, there's a lot of confusion about what a sexuality is among older scholars in particular, but a lot of scholars who just their focus is not on the modern world. So you know, you say a sexual and they think, well, what do you bud? Like like that's like their their association with a sexual is like a sexual reproduction like fungi or mitochondria. So so like when you when you talk about no, there are people who lack sexual desire or all the possible variations are like maybe there are some aces who have sex, and I'll talk about that more when I get to Atlanta. Like they're like, well, aren't they just straight? No, No, this isn't This isn't heterosexual desire being repressed. This is not having that desire. So there's a lot of confusion I think in the scholarly world about what it actually means to have a sexual or anything on that end of the spectrum sort of characters. So I want to get into Hippolytus first, and so you were mentioning that Hippolytis is like really complicated as a story and like he's got this whole tangled web with Fedra and Theseus who are these larger than life outside characters and Theseus is the worst. I mean, I was like, oh, should I do I need to with every single person, do I have to say that Theseus is the worst? And then you did, He's the worst? Um, the only person where some theseis is Jason. Okay, so quick Tangent, We'll see how much days in Why know theseis is definitely worse. Jason is ship. I think of Jason Moore as benign shit and is like actively dangerous ship. I think, I think that is an entirely valid opinion. I just happened to hate Jason a little bit worse. Okay, but that may be because of my own personal experiences. All Right, I'll give you that Jason is the worst. Don't get me the need but and if you need another plug for hades theseus is the worst. He's so fucking annoying, it's great. I love to hate him so much, and I think that's my thing. I love to hate him. He's terrible. Um um. And then poor Fedra, like I feel so sorry for Fedra, Like everything about her situation is just rotten. Um. She's sacrificed to the biggest asshole in the world m a serialty a band did as to abandoned her sister on an island, like yeah, yeah yeah. And and then like Aphrodity, he is like, no, I'm just gonna funk with you to get at some other man, Like why why really why? Because a lot of women in great mythology or agents of the patriarchy doesn't. But Hippolytus is really really interesting as a character because you know, the thing that sets that whole plot off is that he comes in and he sees two statues. He sees Artemis, his you know, his great goddessly love, you know, the object of his devotion, who is virginal, who is sexless, who embodies this purity of staying hunting, staying out in the woods, staying doing natural physical things, of avoiding society and Hipolotis is like, yeah, I am all about And it's not like he's a feminine at all, not at all. He embodies Greek young warrior manhood. Right. He is super strong, he's super tough, he's uh, he's good looking, he's a great hunter. He's a good son, even though you know his dad is a ship and his mom is dead. But because his dad is a ship, right, Um, Like he doesn't he doesn't even like he's like, you know, I can respect whoever he marries next. That's you know, it's not my problem. Um, And I
don't even really care if I inherit, Like, that's not his deal. He's just like, I just want to be me and be free of this nonsense. Um. But his mistake is with the second statue of Aphrodite. He is so incensed with Aphrodite with the idea of sex that he rejects her. He spits on her, he's he curses her. And you know you can't you can't actively reject to God, that's never a good idea. Like if you don't like them, you just just don't say anything. Yeah, like that's your best that and like if you have to say something, be like, I respect what you do over there, Like that's that's fine. Fine, Like you know, if you've got to play Kate the furies, do you play Kate the furies. You don't want their attention, Do not piss off Aphrodite. But of course that's exactly what he does. He pisses off Aphrodite. And even like in the moment, like his attendants are like, maybe you want to walk that back, and he's like, no, no, Aphrodite. Respect represents the most disgusting aspect of humanity. And you know, I can understand how somebody who's raised by theseus, or well not raised by theseus might feel that way. Right, Um, he comes. He's a he's a male son of an Amazon and the world's biggest dickhead of course he feels that way. But even if he didn't feel that way, like for for you know, emotional reasons, the fact that he is repulsed by the idea of sex, that he never wants sex for himself as a young man, like we were saying, you know, this is a guy who was likely just flooded with hormones all the time, but he doesn't want sex. He doesn't want men, he doesn't want women, he doesn't want non binary people. He is just happy being by himself, being on the hunt. And that is a frankly very a sexual position. Not aces are sex repulsed, but some are. And I think it's actually a fairly you know, outside of aces, a fairly uncommon thing to be repulsed by sex um, to have that strong a reaction to it. And so, you know, I was talking this through with a friend of mine who's also working on sort of the Roman angle of a sexuality in in myth um and like, I don't think I would ever even have thought to apply my identity to mythology in this way if it hadn't been for those conversations, you know, And and she brought up, you know, at the end of that play Apoltis is killed by a bull, right like rushing out of the sea, like kind of non sequitor, like, what is a bull doing in the sea? What is this about? And a lot of people will argue back and forth about what the bull represents. I've heard one, one very respected classicist make an argument that it's his repressed sexual nature coming up out of the sea to claim him, right, right, So there's I made a face that that's the not that's a non audio things that I've got that reaction there. Yeah, so, um, it's a little bit far fetched, right, But it's also far fetched that a bull comes out of the sea and kills him, so like what is it doing? Um? And you know, it would at least you could kind of follow the steps if it were his repressed sexual desire, But there's absolutely no indication that it is, right, Like, there's just not much there unless you look forward to Avid who who does some some playing with that and talks about the swell of the waves and you know, all of those sorts of innuendo. But like, even even if that is, Hippolytus shows no sexual desire m hm, none at all. And this actually reminds me of one of the things that people in modern day get wrong about aces. Having no sexual attraction to other people doesn't necessarily mean that your body never wants sexual action. Sometimes aces have libido, Sometimes aces masturbate, Some aces even have sex, and like they're not necessarily just attracted to the person they're having sex with, but maybe they love them, or maybe it's sort of a fleeting interaction, or maybe it's more about friendship for them, Like, there are a lot of ways in which sex can still come into an ACES being. And so maybe as a teenager with raging hormones, these are his sexual feelings that have absolutely nowhere to go and no part in his day to day life. That seems plausible. But why why a bowl? Why the sea? I still have not quite figured that one out. It's very um I almost feel like it just it pulls it back to Fiedra in an interesting way because of her origins, right, I mean, a bowl from the sea is literally where she comes from as a as a person from Crete and that culture. So I find that quite interesting to just connected back to Europa and Zeus and and and the Cretan bowl, and you know that that's kind of it's an interesting piece. I don't know kind of where it goes, but that's that's my first thought when I hear you know, a bull coming from the sea is I'm thinking Zeus and Europa, Like, I know, this is a bowl and not obviously a god. Um, but it's an interesting connection, especially when with Fedra involved, who is so obviously you know from that bowl dynasty of crete and yeah, and that makes sense to UM. I actually like that a lot because then you have the connection back to Fiedra's actions are what killed him and nothing that he did at all. Mm hmmmm. He didn't do anything. He just said no, that's all. Yeah. So so Fiedra's note, Fiedra's bowl, Fiedra's desire not his. I like that. Here for a bowl iconography information that's really fascinating and Hippolytus as I kind of mentioned, you, you know, off Mike Um, I would say, it's not him. I feel this way about but this story, and I didn't. I covered the story of Fiedra back in March for Women's Month because I hadn't really talked about her before, and I think it's valid, but I also don't want to go too close to you know, of false brad accusation, which does exist in Hippolytus, the play I'm referring to broadly, Euripides is Hippolytis, which is where most of the story comes from. Um. And so it's kind of hard to wrap your head around, you know, like, yeah, it's just sort of it's a tricky thing. But I do think the story of Hippolytis as a person is very interesting, and Fiedra too. So I'm
you know, I tried to tell her story without the play and just more about her and then the character interactions. But I think this is a really perfect way to add to it and sort of add that layer of complexity and you know, where is she to blame and where is it Aphrodite inflicting this upon her? You know, it's an interesting thing. And I was talking to Jennifer st who's the author of that the new book Ariadne, and she Feedra is very much in that book, which I was very happy with. That's so sort of some of my favorite parts. We're looking at Fiedra, and in that it's a little bit more of Fiedra being this person who never experienced kind of anything of her own. Um, you know, she was taken by theseus and married him and didn't love him, and he didn't love her, and and it was all just so messy. And so I think she in that you kind of get the sense from her where she is almost a sort of latching onto the first person that she thinks she can actually love. And obviously there's a lot of problems there's it's not none of it, you know, ultimately makes you know her, you know, professing her attraction in that way and and and dealing with his rejection in that way to be okay, obviously, but it has an interesting layer about where she's kind of coming from. And then you know, add to that the the aphrodite aspects, and it's just an interesting, like additional kind of pieces to to the puzzle of that story. Right. And one thing you have to remember when you're dealing with Fiedra is that she is about hippolytus age. Yes, true, exactly. I actually meant to mention that because that's that's the key part in in the book as well. Is Yeah, she's not necessarily like an older woman. If you think about the math on it, she's probably not. She's often portrayed as such in representations of this story because she's married to theseus. But she's a lot younger than theseus too, So yeah, it's an interesting addition, right, And I think we see this actually a lot in these stories of unrequited love in Greek mythology, like in Narcissus where you know, you know, we we were talking earlier. How a lot of these figures, they'll get dismissed as oh they're a sexuality, is really just them going through a teenage rebellion. Well, the women in these stories are often of a very similar, if not literal age, then sort of comparative age like echo. Sure she's a nymph, she's whatever, but she is clearly in the mindset of a young woman when she goes after Narcissus. And yeah, okay, Narcissus is like in his late teens, but so are the other people involved. A lot of the time, and especially for women, we don't we don't actually see a lot of cougar stories. No, So that actually brings me around to the other person I wanted to talk about, which is Atlanta. Um And I love Atlanta. She was my hero as kid. How could you not. She's amazing. She's amazing, So just in brief to to go over her story. You know, Atlanta was born to someone who didn't want a daughter exposed, brought up in the wilderness. She is the fastest runner, the best hunter. She's from the wild, the mountains in Arcadia, and she is a badass. She is a warrior woman who takes no ship and um. She eventually, in most stories, get sort of re introduced to her father's family and taken into that, and then she there's sort of an expectation that she's going to get married off as a as a power pipe piece, because that's the lot of noble women and king's daughters in in ancient Greece. But she's like, no, I don't want to get married. You know what, here's the deal. I'll get married to the man who can beat me in a foot race. And she knows that no one can. She knows it's impossible. And the thing is, none of the myths ever contradict this. No one could ever beat her in a fair foot race. It just doesn't happen. And she, like Hippolotus, is devoted to Artemis and often is among Artemis. Is like literal Coterie. Like Artemis and her nymphs and her her women, her immortal women who are in her entourage, and Atlanta is one of them. So Atlanta doesn't want to get married. Um. And this foot race when it finally happens, Um, this one guy and his name varies in a couple of ways. He he figures out he's in love with her. He's obsessed, He's like, okay, he praised to Aphrodite to give him some way to beat her because he knows he's going to try, but all of the men who fail get killed. So he gets these three golden apples that are irresistible, like that's that is the quality Aphrodite bestows upon them. And so every time he almost catches up to her in the race, he tosses one ahead of her and she gets distracted and goes to pick it up, and this is how he beats her. So she says, well, okay, fine, I guess I have to get married. That sucks. But she still doesn't live like a normal married Greek woman. Yes, she has a son, Parthenopious, and god, I love that name too because you hear the Parthenos in that that's you know, the maiden um. And so Pios's face. Yeah, the Greeks love their speaking names. It's really fun. Atlanta's name. Um, I've never heard anybody say this, but I know that it has something to do with equal measurement in Greek and so I've always interpreted that as she's as good as any man. She carries it right, and you know she carries equal weight because the other story about her is her going on the hunt for the Caledonian boar. Mm hmm. She's on this war party hunting for a boar, which is the most dangerous ah wild game. They're really, really dangerous, they're really hard. An Assassin's creed Odyssey was really hard to kill. I bet, I bet they're they're super dangerous. Um, they're quick, they're smart, and they've got giant tusks and they can and they're big enough to take down a horse and rider. So so she's on this hunt with like big badasses like Melliager and whoever, and she's the one who ends up killing it. She's that good. So and like she gets to go on some versions on the Argo. She gets to go on on that journey, and she's one of the few who like really go all the way
and survive it. She's she is an utter badass. And then like in the next generation, because you know, the hero stories come in sort of generations, so in the next generation, you know, when Parthenopious is a young man, he's one of the Seven against Thebes. M hmmm, I didn't know that. Yeah, I realized just for my listeners here, I chose to cover that story by covering Phoenician women instead of East Glis. And so if anyone's interested in remembering that, I did cover that in Jocasta's episode from just this past March. We just went with Phoenician women instead of instead of um of eastchlist is Seven against Thebes because I love Euripodes. Uh, no argument there. I love Euripodes too, and it's so quicker. It's both stories and one and I like that. Yeah, it's it's a really it's a really nice way of putting it all together. And so in that version there's a very brief mention of Parthenopious there. And the interesting thing is that in Phoenicea Phoenician Women, Parthenopious is described as, you know, a young man with a beautiful, flowing mane of hair and a shield bearing the insignia of his mother hunting the Caledonian boar. I okay, I love that. I literally covered this three months ago and I forgot it until you're saying all this, and I'm like, I have literally settled this on the podcast. How am I not remembering? So thank you for reminding. Yeah, I remember now realizing all it is a It is a really small detail if you're looking at Seven against Thebes, but it's a really interesting detail if you're looking at Atlanta, right. I always am interested in her, So I'm sure that I very loudly was like, that was Atlantis. Yeah, yeah, it's awesome. So so at Atlanta is this figure, this warrior woman who is allowed to be a warrior woman, who is allowed to express her lack of sexual interest, her lack of romantic interest. She doesn't want a man. She needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle, Like she bore a child and then put him on the doorstep and walked away, went back to Artemis. And not too many people get to do that, right, because when this happened to Callisto, which I'm sure you've covered, when this happened to Callisto, Artemis was heck, no, you get to be a bear like you bore a child, you're out. Yeah, that story so sad, it is, it is ridiculous and screw the gods exactly. But in any case, Atalanta is so divorced from child bearing from sex that she's allowed to rejoin Artemis as group. I love that. That's yeah, that's a real thrill. Yeah. And I think it has to do a lot with her just complete indifference to her marriage too. She's like, yeah, okay, I had sex, I had sex, I produced a son. This is the point right here. You go have fun. I'm done now mm hmm. And like, you know, her husband is described as loving her, but she's never described as loving him, right, Like, that's just not even a part of it. And even if she does, like it's okay for her to be like, Okay, this isn't rape, this is something I agreed to. I can get this over with, fine, but I'm just gonna go and be with my ace pals now mm hmmm. And you know, like I said, there are plenty of people who will say, oh, but she's just like a sapphic or something, and I'm like, come on, But that's the thing. I think it goes back to this like assumption that if you don't want to have sex with men, then you want to have sex with women, which is like there is an in between, like that, it's not a binary. And I have to say, I just love a I love a story where a woman is allowed to have absolutely no maternal interest or or like or want to have a child at all. That that will thrill for um. I I am one of those people who didn't like children when she was a child, and and I never developed a liking for kids. Um I have. I have so so my my brother has kids, and there is this wonderful photo of me with his brand new baby where I'm holding her up kind of uncertainly, and he captioned it. So they tell me you're human. I identify with this. I love my nibblings, I do, but I did not know what to do with them when they were very little. Yeah, I'm with you so deeply. I mean. The point for me is it's it's really wonderful as somebody who is not only under the ace umbrella but also a gender to see that there is a place in Greek society for people like me, to see that there was a place in history for people who didn't give a damn. Yeah, Like, I don't think Atlanta could care one wit if she's a man or a woman, except that she gets to run with Artemis. Yeah, because priorities, right, Like, sometimes certain things matter to you more than others, and that's okay, right. So I think this is part of why Atalanta always appealed to me, Like, I have no maternal instinct, at least not towards actual literal children. I mean, my fur baby might disagree, but but you know, I don't have maternal instinct. I don't experience what most people would would think of when they think of sexual desire. I'm demisexual, if that matters to people listening. I have no esthetic attraction whatsoever. And so it's it's always sort of encouraging for me personally to look back and see there's a place for a woman who doesn't fit. There's a place for even even a woman of excellent upbringing more breeding to say that isn't me. And you know, I wouldn't begrudge anyone who who sees themselves in Atlanta as as a lesbian either, because that's one of the great things about these myths is you know, there there's so many versions that you can find a one that feels like you. But I also just think it's really important that we don't deny the the space that this creates, that we can have someone like Hippolytus or Atlanta and that's okay. That Artemis as a goddess holds space for adults who do not want to participate in sexual exchange or sexual desire or the the the life of parenthood that is laid out for most people. Mm hmm. I think it's so important. I mean, that's I think you just sort of exemplified sort of everything I try to do with you know, certain stories, at least on the podcast,
because I do think that's so important. And I think that, you know, it's a little bit different, I think when you're in certain academic circles, but it is really hard and when it comes to just like commercial representation of Greek mythology, because you fall into all of these like pre pre dug holes of like you know what Greek myth is and who these people are, and and it it's just it's like it really limits so much and and so many you know, experiences and lifestyles and just like existences in the world that you know, I mean, I started this because I wanted to bring the women, like the voices of women of Greek mythology, because they are severely underrepresented. Um and that's how I identify, you know, like, but at the same time, you know, I also my intention is to make sure that everyone can identify. So I'm a straight woman, but I am like the rilled with the idea that I mean, certainly like this conversation, but every episode I try to do as well of like that, making sure that you can see all the different possibilities and where different people and and genders and everything could fit into this world, all the different like the variations that just suggest it just makes it so clear that all of this is ancient, just like they are ancient. You know, all the things that so many you know, usually not tolerant people will say are new or because of the Internet, or because of who knows what. I don't even know the arguments these days, but all the things that people suggest are new, that's bullshit. It's just that people have voices now, People are louder, people are talking about it, this thing, and people aren't dying when they try exactly exactly They're able to talk well, not everyone is dying and not everywhere yeah, um, but but it is. Yeah, it's just a matter of of like that confidence in being able to be yourself versus having to hide it or pretend you're something else. So yeah, I just think that that part is so important and interesting when it comes to these myths, because they really do show everything. You just have to look in the right places, right. And you know, one of the things that I that I saw recently, um, you know, I've there's been a lot of transphobia, especially coming out of the UK recently, not that it isn't here too, but just it's particularly virulent over there. Um. And you know, one of one of the arguments that you see is, oh, like this is just a fad and it's just a trend and nobody was like this when we were growing up, except that that ignores all of the people who were silenced when they were growing up and they're like, no, no kids transitioned around me. Is like who would have let them? Look at the adults your age who are transitioning and you'll see all of those kids who would have if they'd been able to, right, So, like this is exactly that is nothing here is new mhm um. And you know I said that there aren't very many people working on stuff like this. One of the very few that I've read is Chris Mowatt. Um, I
think I think they're at Sheffield. Um has a book that just came out about gender in the ancient world. And yes, and um, you know, I haven't gotten a chance to read it yet, but I've read you know, snippets and um, I know they've done some presentations on the subject. And you know what you see there is this sort of consistent need to push back on the oh, we can't use those labels, well, how can you use the label heterosexual for them? Like that just wouldn't apply either. You have to be able to simultaneously hold in your head that the terminology and the categories we use are not the ones they would have used, and that everything we label now existed then and everything that existed then exists now. People. I love to say this, People do not change. Humanity does not fundamentally change. We have the same broad spectrum of variations, We have the same you know, general tendencies as a mass. And that's not a bad thing. I mean a lot of people will be like, oh, my god, are you saying we can never move pastward? No? No, no, no. What I'm saying is that people have always had the ability to understand the things that we understand now, and the ability to understand the things they understood then that we do mhm. We are capable of putting ourselves in those shoes. And just because the way we think, you know, the categories in our language may be different, that doesn't mean that they don't apply somewhere. M hm. So yes, there were definitely spaces for people to be a sexual, for women to say no, I don't want marriage, and you know, we don't have the evidence to know whether that was because they were ace, because they just hated the patriarchy that much. Because the boy, I understand that, that's where I'm at, That's that's me as a person, I would be back there like not quite ace, not ACE necessarily, but also just like no, like like things, I'm going to devote myself to being a vestal virgin because fuck you, that's why. Yeah, um, you know, like sure we don't. We don't know their internal motivations, but I'm going to tell you that those people existed, and these spaces allowed them to exist as themselves, and that I think is just the coolest thing that we can learn from people like Atalanta and Hippolytus, that that's it's so true, it's so important. It's something I haven't talked about enough. So I'm just so thrilled that you wanted to do this. This is so great. I I tend to focus more on on like I suppose, just everyone else, because it's just what I'm more familiar with. I think, like you're saying, you know, the study of a sexuality is so new, the understanding is not very broad like it is. It is hard, especially like you know, coming at it with nothing, and so this is just overall really exciting. I you know, I tend to fall back on, um, the stories of trans people being transitioned by gods, that that sort of those are my might go to thrilling ones where it's just like you know, like you're saying, like they had a space, a space was made for them
in whatever way, you know, you know, in terms of like real practical living people, we don't necessarily know. But the fact that these myths existed in the way that they do, I think really says a lot about the potential openness of those kind of things, and and you know, like the likelihood that people were able to live at least in in some way as them their true selves, right exactly, And if there was a place for Atlanta in the mythology, then maybe there was a place for a real life woman to just be a devotee of Artemis and say, no, exactly, yeah, that's just I think. I think that's beautiful honestly, because you know, people will point to like the Amazons as like the women warriors doing it for themselves, and like try to connect that to the Scythians, which maybe, yeah, sounds cool. Um, Scythians were badass, no argument there. But the Amazons are distinctly foreign in Greek myth at Atlanta is not only Greek, but nobility. Yeah, that's exactly that. That's a key distinction that I don't think gets brought up enough just because it is sort of like the broad strokes of this, but exactly right, Like the Amazons, their whole thing is that they're not Greek. That's what makes them the Amazons, And so it's not the same. It's not quite as as like visceral and important as to have somebody like Atlanta who who was everything that you've said, in addition to the just the overarching like a badass woman who got to go out and hunt and fight and do all these super cool things. And that's just so such a thrill. And you know, it's not like it caused no controversy. Like back in the story of the Caledonian Boar, right you have you have the whole thing with Melliagar. Meliager is like she killed it. She gets the hide, and his uncles were so mad about that that they tried to kill him and eventually did end up killing him in a roundabout fashion. Um, I don't know if you've told this story, but I have a long time ago. But yeah, the the wood getting thrown into the fire and his mother, his mother being so upset that he killed her brothers that she killed him like m okay, yeah, I need to redo that. Sorry to more justice. Oh such a crazy one. But all of this happened because there's a difference of opinion in the society over whether it's okay for a woman to occupy this space. But the fact is that badass, heroic Meliager, tragic Melleager who gets pindaric odes written about him. He said, yes, mm hmmm, eliager Sous women's rights. Yeah, oh I love that. Yeah. It just so like the story of Atlanta I told so long ago, and now all I want to do is write another episode for her that's like, does her all the justice in the world. One thing I found interesting about her is the idea that um, both Arcadia and Byeosha at times tried to claim her, and then it seems like there was also and this is like a very broad strokes. I read it on the dot com, the website that has my whole heart, and but basically the idea that like some presented as if there were actually two women who like both renamed Atlanta. Yeah, that's that's what it said there, which they're usually pretty great with that stuff. So yeah, no, I believe that. Well, I I like, I mean, I think obviously they both just loved her and tried to claim it her. I think they do. That there's two women I would buy, but that they're both named Atlanta, and that they both were raised by after being exposed, it's like, well, I think probably both of those regions just wanted her. Oh yeah, yeah, and then and then you get the stories later that try to smooth that distinction out by saying, oh, she was she was born in Boetia, but she was raised in Arcadia. That's what the deans, so, so that makes total sense to me that both regions were And you know, the deal with all of these myths is that every region had their own version, every every polis, every city state has its own version of every myth. And like even as like I mentioned before that that Artemis is in some places closer to the to the Near East, she is actually um sort of this mother of beasts character, and Artemis plus mother is just nonsensical when we think about her. Her Attic conversion the one we usually think about. But like you see statues of Artemis with hundreds of breasts really yeah, yeah, it's really fascinating. So like the these can vary really widely between regions, between cities, um, and even even something as like central to our understanding of Greek mythology as Athena can be really different outside of Athens, where she's not the patron goddess, right, her importance is a lot lower elsewhere. So we get all sorts of really just weird versions that make very little sense with what we're used to, um, and that's kind of hard to hold in our heads. Is like we tended to think of we tend to think of Greek mythology is like Lord of the Rings or something where all of the characters have a role, but it's more like DC comics where there are eighteen different versions and they're all cannon somehow. Um. I like seeing it that way. Yeah, that's the thing I try to reckon with a lot lately, because I'm deeply obsessed with with like referring to all of the sources I can possibly find and explaining that away. And but then I still have poor, poor kind souls listening to this show who want to understand it, and like I wanted understand chronology, and like they want like finite answers about these things, and I just want to like, don't don't stress yourself out over it. Just yeah, you'll never get what you want. There there are no easy answers. I'm sad to say, I'm actually not that sad to say, um, Like like this is what drew me to it, same, I love it, like it's I love looking at all those little intricate bits and pieces and what differs and where and who told what and what changed? And speaking of which, there is a little detail I mentioned earlier that I wanted to come back to. So so we were talking about Parthenopious and his appearance in Phonisa. Well, if you actually look at Seven against Thebes and his
appearance there, Um, like he's he's described in a little bit more detail, and like who his mother is and where you know why he's important and all that, his devotion to Artemis. But then his device on his shield is actually the sphinx eating a theban and and like I read that, and and just thinking about these two devices, Atlanta killing a boar and the Sphinx killing a man. They're both warrior females m hm. And they're both killing something that is a very sort of masculine embodiment m h. And I kind of love that. I think that those two aren't that different. Um. I think it has a very different sort of view on Atalanta's acceptability. Yeah, definitely says a little it's very easy less versus Euripides, I think. Yeah, I agree, especially because Euripides is so much more focused on the women's perspective at all times. Um. I mean, these are people I know right, and and you know, I think you can you can get some really interesting stuff out of how Euripides is portrayed and other things like in Aristophanes. Um. I don't know if you've read the Thesmaphoria as you say, No I need to. Yeah, it's it's a wild ride. So for for the listeners, the thesmas foy, as you say, Thesmaphoria was a women's festival in Athens where all of the men were shut out. It was sacrilege for them to come out during this festival, and the only men allowed to actually be present were foreigners. Foreign men were allowed, but Athenian men were not. Greek men in general were not. But the relevant thing in the Thusma Freya, as you say, which is an Aristophanes, it's a comedy about this festival and about guys trying to sneak into the festival. They actually go to Euripides for tips on how to pass as a woman. Yeah, it's interesting in it, Like and what how does it because I know that a lot, I know, there's a lot of like I don't know. I think it is from Aristophanes where we we got this idea that Euripides was like a misogynistum, and so it is that kind of where it's coming from, and he doesn't give a bad answer, like what what's the story there? So, as far as I can tell, and you may get different opinions on this, but as far as I can tell, Euripides was either a straight trans woman or very very gay, like exclusively loved men and was not shy about the fact that he was okay being the bottom, which is not okay Greek and Roman culture, like that's what makes you a feminine, not loving another man. Mm hmm. So he seems to be a woman hater in the set that he doesn't want to have sex with them, and traditionalists find his portrayal of them ugly somehow, because they're real, right, exactly, Like I read Euripides women and I'm like, these are relatable women. Yeah, they have agency, they're real people. They're like complex and yeah, oh my god, yeah exactly. I'm obsessed with him. So I read that that sort of portrayal by Euripides as him being able to step back from the imposed gender roles for whichever reason and say, Okay, these women are people, they have their reasons, and they're all going to be reasonable reasons, even if the actions they do are bad. And that's why someone like Fiedra is so compelling m hm. And Medeia. Yeah, that's why Medeia is even though he invented her killing her children, that wasn't part of the story before. I always I always forget that because it just feels so right, right, yeah, that it's yeah, that's the thing, right. He he gives us this horrific woman, but she is so compelling and complex and interesting, and she's just so many things that make me love her in a way where I'm like, well, I recognize that you are objectively bad, you're doing not great things, but you're so interesting and you're so well written in that play that I just like, I just want to be your best friend in this way where I'm like I probably wouldn't in the end, you know, but you know, like I just love her. But right and so and so I think that's why he writes PHONICSI the way he does, where where our principal viewpoint characters are not at Aquas and Paula NICs but Joe cast and right so um so when when he sees because Escalis was writing much earlier, I mean not much earlier, but earlier when he sees the introduction of Parthenopious with this warrior woman of the Sphinx killing a theban, he takes that and says, a warrior woman killing a symbol of masculinity for Parthenopious is not going to be abstract like that. It's his mother, and it's a pose not could be. Yeah, it's also not could be like the ocean. He's not coming from there. Yeah, he's against Thebes, so it's not going to be the sphinx that was of Thebes. I mean, like in in some sense that makes sense, like, you know, if he wants to be intimidating, sure, but but like for Euripides writing that as Parthenopious is symbol, I think it really makes sense if he's thinking about gender relationships, if he's thinking about you know, what is a symbol of badassory to Perthenopius his his mother, his badass ace Artemis loving mother m and the most you know, widely recognized badass things she ever did m hm. And you know, between that and and sort of the very compelling a sexuality of Hippolytus right where he's he you know, Fidra is written lovingly, but Hippolytis really he feels real too. His rejection of her feels just as real as her longing for him, And it doesn't feel like it's about her right like the way it's written, you know, he does. He does sort of insult her, but the main thing that we've already had set up in that play is that he is anti aphrodite and everything she stands for. M hm. And so that's really what's going on with him in that scene, is like he is disgusted, not necessarily by her, but by what she's suggesting, and not because of some you know, concern for his asshole of a father either. God, now, who would care about that. It's not like theseisar did anything for him lord m hm. So yeah, that's that's It's all just so damn interesting. I'm just sort of sitting here, like in I'm having one of my moments of like, this is my job. But I do
think my listeners would be really mad at me for not asking, what are your thoughts on Athena when it comes to sexuality and a sexuality? Yeah, Athena is a really fascinating case, And um, I was actually just having this conversation with one of my friends. You know, Atalanta was my hero as a kid, but my goddess of choice was never artem as it was Athena. Because books, plus kicking the ship out of bullies, plus you know, wise counsel like and crafty things like this is my jam. I love her so problematic faith, problematic faith, but I love her to death. I think if there's any case for any of the gods being genderless, it would be Athena. M Um. She's presented as a woman, but she doesn't. The only womanly thing she does is craft right. Otherwise she is kind of shorn of gender in a way that you seem mostly with like eunuchs. Yeah, she is. She's very competent, she's very respectable, and the only time anyone ever even tries anything with her, she just wipes them off onto the ground. M I don't know if you've told the story of Erectheus and and the Athenian claimed to to having come from their land, come from their land. Yeah, I have a long time ago, and I've it's definitely been mentioned. But we can mention it again because it's a thing and it's entertaining, and I will tell you like right now, because I I I didn't think I was going to be talking about this today. I don't remember which god it is as a Poseidon's okay, yeah, that makes sense. Basically ends up jacking off on her leg and she's like gross and wipes the semen, often to the dirt. And that's where Athenians supposedly come from. And this is how the Athenians can claim to be children of Athena, with Athena still being a maide in goddess. Yep, that's the only time anybody ever even slightly impinges on Athena's complete sexlessness. Like there just aren't myths of that. There are no myths of her falling for anybody ever, Like even Artemis gets that sometimes, like I mentioned a Ryan earlier in Calisto to an extent. Yeah, and and you know, there's there is a lot of interpretation of Artemis as a lesbian. So yeah. So so my take on Athena is that I think that she is the most sexless, genderless and just complete completely removed from all of that side of humanity of all the gods um. And so you know, we have these three maiden goddesses and we've talked about Artemis and her sort of like variable levels of sexuality depending on how you look at her. And the other one that people more on the Roman side like to talk about is Hestia. Now, Hestia is a really interesting case because, of course she is the goddess of the hearth, and she's sort of an older woman. I mean, we get the idea that is more matronly than maidenly, and so for her to be sexless means that she is what we would think of as a spinster. Right. She's she's never been interested, and I love that, but she's also a little bit of an outsider in some ways. From the mythology, there aren't There are two stories about Hestia, and barely
anything even in those two. Like, so her one story that we're not even sure where it comes from is that is of her giving up her spot on Olympus, and like, on the one hand, that's kind of like but why though, But on the other hand, she was of primary importance within the homes, and like Greeks had heart shrines in every house, they were sacrificing to Hestia every day, all the time. Yeah, I like to say that she just had better things to do than with the Olympian crap. Yes, exact. Actually that's also how I think of it. And like the other story is of somebody trying to assault her with preapis, which again is more of a Roman side thing. Yeah, it's not. I think it's I'm trying to think what the sourcing is on that. That's the one story I've had to tell about her because people are always asking me, like I want you to cover hest yet, and I'm like, but haven't you want me to? But there's there's nothing Here's That's the thing that that I think unless you're in this, you don't really get. And and it's another fascinating part, right, is that the number of characters who are there's nothing. But she is vital. She is so important. I can't stress. Yeah, she's like everything, she meant everything. But also she has absolutely no stories, so I can't tell you about her. And it's fascinating. Yeah. Yeah. And and so like just like you were saying, like there's the sense that she just had better ship to do than deal with the Olympians. There's the sense that she had better shipped to do then deal with sexuality. Mm hmm. Yeah, I feel like I connect with Hestia. Most just feel like I have better things to do for me. I you know, when I when I found the word a gender, I was like, yes, I've always been that thing. But when I came across a sexuality and uh and like demisexual and all of those words, I'm like, where don't like this feels good? But where do I actually fit? And I actually spent a long time thinking about it. And I think questioning is really important to that process and for people to understand that questioning does happen, that it's not just a phase so much as it is part of figuring it out. Um. People, individuals are not static and are not simple. So I don't know precisely what the deal with Hestia is, but I think, like Artemis, more in Rome than in Greece, she creates this space for people who don't want to deal with that bullshit mm hmm, but are really important. Yes, yes, you know, when when we talk about vessel virgins and this is really not my area of study, Like I don't know all that much about the vessels, um Roman Roman ritual is not my thing. But when we talk about the vessels, like this much I can say is like a lot of vessels really got into it, but a lot of vessels also like got married as soon as they got out. So like you have you have people who stay in the priesthood forever. You have people who are celibate who aren't necessarily ace right. And there is a distinction because it's not about what you do, it's about how you feel, what you experience. Yeah, celibacy is a is more so a choice of of just not partaking versus not feeling right. And so I think this is one of those ongoing sort of confusions that people have about non straight sexuality and and attraction is like, well, of course a gay man can choose to be in a heterosexual relationship. That has happened a lot. That's you know, it's not really healthy, but it happens, and it happens for social pressure reasons, and it happens because they think they should or because they're scared. You know, it happens for all kinds of reasons. And and and also like marriage is one of those things where the definition has changed so much and people are like, the definition is one man and one woman. I'm like, whose definition? Yeah, like what I mean? And this the expectations around it and all of those like very things that add to all the societal pressures, you know. Right, So it doesn't make a person less gay if they're in a straight relationship. It just means that they're not being honest with themselves and their partner for one reason or another, knowingly or knowingly. And that's you know, that can turn out okay. It doesn't mean they're evil. It just means that they haven't figured it out, right, um, And so like it's totally normal for I mean, maybe Atalanta did love the man who beat her in a her face for a while. That's okay. Aces can have sex to a arrows can occasionally have real relationships. It does happen. It doesn't make them not what they identify as because it's not about the action, it's about the feeling. M And you know, like like we said earlier, it's all a spectrum, right, And it's not just you know, the spectrum of desire from male to female, like on the Kinsey scale. It's the spectrum also of none to lots, right, Like there can be people who never have any sexual desire ever, and there can be people who only experienced sexual desire once in a while, and those are both sort of under the Ace umbrella, and they're both have been pathologized, right, like you hear all the time about frigid women, right or men who just can't get it up. And one of my favorites actually is and this is getting into again Roman side, but also real life, not mythology. You've heard of Horace, the poet, who is probably the Roman poet closest to my heart because he loves Sappho, and Sapho is my absolute all time favorite. Horace his nickname because you know, they all get nicknames because Rome only has five male names. I don't understand why they do this, but whatever, his nickname was Flaccos. Do you know what flaccos means? Flacid? I would have gin yeah, oh yeah. And you know he basically never talks about sex. And you you know, you're used to like your Catullus, who is you know, the sparrow is my penis, and you know the your you know, Propertious, who's like, oh Cynthia, please fuck me, you know, like you have all of this passion, and then you have Horace who's like, god, damn, a tree almost fell on me today. I haven't read Horizon. Now I think I have to that's one of my favorites. That's really funny. And you know, with the combination of the subject matter and the nickname, I'm like ace icon. Yeah, Oh that's so that's so fascinating. Oh my gosh, this is like it's filled into so many different places. I love it. Thank you so much for doing this. This has been such a fascinating conversation and I'm I'm just so thrilled to have had it. And it's I think it's I think it's very important and I personally just have like only have really been, you know, aware of the intricacies of a sexuality and and a romanticism. And I'm just I'm very interested to know more in general, but then also to be able to connect it to the thing I love more than anything in this world, which is just like learning more ship about great mythology. Was a real thrill. So thank you so much, Julie, Thank you so much for having me. I had so much fun today. I'm so glad. This is the most fun thing I get to do, is have these conversations and when people are obviously having as much fun, and just it's so much it's wonderful, so Thank you, oh nerds. Thank you all so much for listening. Like I said, such a thrill. This was such an incredible episode to record. I just absolutely loved every moment of our conversation, and I am so thrilled that you all get to listen to it. So I hope you loved it as much as I did. I don't see how you could not. That's where we're at with this one. Thank you all so much. You are all the best. I am live and I love this ship.