ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
Jackie Slaght: Welcome to Beyond Tech, where innovation meets insight. I'm your host, Jackie Slatt, joined by my guest co-host, business development manager at eTech Group, Mike Gerst, and our guest group engineering manager Michael Tomer. Today we're talking about a part of manufacturing and distribution that often doesn't get much attention until something goes wrong. Material handling. Every product, every ingredient, package, and palette has to move through a facility efficiently. To keep operations running smoothly. Yet many organizations are facing challenges related to labor, labor availability, increasing production demands, changing customer expectations, and aging infrastructure. As a result, companies are looking at new ways to improve how materials move throughout their operations, through automation technology, and smarter system design. In this episode, we'll discuss what modern material handling looks like. the challenges organizations are trying to solve and how companies can position themselves for greater efficiency, flexibility, and long-term growth. So with that, let's get started and I'll start pretty basic What exactly falls under the umbrella of material handling?
Mike T: So I like to argue at the core material handling, it is moving, storing and controlling material throughout a facility, whether we are talking about finished products in a manufacturing facility, the raw material for it, or moving cartons, packages, pallets throughout a warehouse distribution center. anything that has to do with the process of getting those into the facility and moving them throughout the facility or storing them within the facility is material handling.
Mike Gerst: I would agree. I would say from a business viewpoint it's everything between the receiving dock and the shipping dock, from conveyors, storage, robots, vehicles, and all the controls tying them together. I guess a simple way would be if it moves and it isn't being made right then, it's material handling.
Jackie Slaght: That's a good description.
Mike Gerst: so Mike, why has material handling become such an important topic these days?
Mike T: Well, part of it is the increasing need to move product across the country. With the development e-commerce in the early two thousands, it's really brought the need for people to have product as quickly as possible to home. When it becomes important for the manufacturers and the all the DCs is the actual equipment helps to offset the cost of the labor that they're having difficulty getting or the injuries that are being created in the unsafe in working environments or the standard material handling working environments without automation. But on top of that, we also gain efficiencies through automation of moving material or storing it in either a tighter footprint or faster than humans can physically move it across a facility.
Mike Gerst: So are you saying that moving material doesn't add value to the product, but it adds cost?
Mike T: Moving material inherently doesn't add value to product. It is the ability to move the material efficiently and accurately to its final destination that's gonna save us a cost.
Mike Gerst: Sure. you know, people are hard to hire these days. It's hard to find you know, good people that that continue to show up in some of these repetitive, mundane tasks. and when people are hard to hire, you know, those those it just becomes a a cost to them and limiting how much they can grow. So through proper material handling processes they can continue to grow and that alleviates some of that headcount issue and hiring issues as
Jackie Slaght: that's a really good point, something I didn't necessarily always connect to material handling, just your opinion, how much Amazon Prime two day delivery like changed the expectations of people getting packages? 'Cause I know now when I when I order something I'm like, it can't be here in two days, this is crazy. Where
Mike Gerst: Right.
Jackie Slaght: previously you ordered less but it accepted that you had to pay for shipping and it would take several weeks to get there and now I
Mike Gerst: Sure.
Jackie Slaght: that expectation has totally changed. and the impact on manufacturers I I don't know that I ever paid attention to that.
Mike Gerst: Right.
Mike T: Yeah, I mean we you have manufacturers that are providing material to Amazon. You have Amazon that's getting it to your house. Amazon has an entire division dedicated just to less than two day deliveries. Right. there's an entire brand new I'm not gonna sell say operation, but style building they've spun up in the last couple of years just to handle same day deliveries.
Mike Gerst: So yeah, they
Mike T: Right, and these are cr these are cropping out all cropping up all across the country. I mean I think we've got ten of them within a hundred mile radius of us here in out of our Westchester office.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, I've well I've said I they come to my house quite frequently, so I they have to be somewhat close. but I am always impressed. Like I'm like, but where are you where is this all coming from? I'm but I'm just happy to get it. So they've saved me lots of lots of errands out late at night. So
Mike Gerst: You know, so th I think a big portion of of the material handling is you know, the impact on labor utilization and reducing that labor. you know, so if you don't have good labor utilization, you have skilled people who end up, waiting on the line for whatever the material is coming through, instead of doing the work that they're hired for. So, in a tight labor market, I think that that capacity a company pays for, is what they're looking for to replace that labor, begin to be more efficient in that aspect of it. so
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, I I mean that's I think we hear across the board that labor is always the like I guess maybe the first thing that people look to control so or to reduce their costs. But I would say probably especially in the material
Load full transcript
handling division, 'cause it was, I believe, so labor intensive previously. So how have the operational requirements changed over the past decade?
Mike T: I think personally there's three major items I've seen in the last decade of material handling is there's been a much greater push for ASRS, which is short for automated storage or retrieval systems. So trying to work on automating the racking, whether it's POWET or individual goods that were previously done with manual operations. I've seen a much greater focus on safety and operational ergonomics. So whether it's putting in lift tables to help lift pallets up as operators put material on or redesigning entire conveyor systems so that somebody doesn't have to bend four inches lower to reach product direct directly off of it to try to avoid the injuries caused by repetitive motion. And I think the third biggest one I've seen the most is a drive for data. Every possible data point that we can provide, whether it's a purely just a performance based KPI, preventative maintenance data, anything that we can drag out of the system and provide to the customer has been pretty heavily asked for more recently than it was when I started this journey.
Mike Gerst: I'd say requirements I I'd say expectations went up on on all sides as you know, kinda as we just talked about, customers want their packages within a day or two. You know, they want them to be accurate. the the employees expect a safer workplace as well. so I think what's changed over the past decade is rather than just focusing on material handling speed. they're starting to focus on more accuracy of it and the safety of the line at the same time, not just cost. So they're measuring, you know, more benefits that come out of you know a good material handling system that includes, you know, includes speed but adds accuracy and safety on top of that as well for the worker safety.
Jackie Slaght: Do you have any I guess previous like examples of how packages previously were tracked through a system and how that has improved over the decade years.
Mike T: I think it depends on the type of facility we're talking about, whether it's manufacturing versus a warehousing situation. But one thing that I've seen especially recently is a full blown integration from the warehouse management system all the way down to the control systems where product is scanned in once brought into the facility and using vision systems, typically AI driven vision systems or barcode systems, we're able to track the movement of the package throughout the entire facility, all the way to where it either gets stored in the racking or sent off to its next destination.
Jackie Slaght: what are the most common material flow challenges that you've seen facilities face today?
Mike T: Pre existing infrastructure is probably one of the most difficult ones, s because some of that's difficult to change. The location of the dock doors, throughout the facility, the location of where the racking
for any storage is, where the operations actually take place. I think the other one I've seen a lot of more recently with a lot of the rework we've been doing is the premature automation or haphazard automation, where They ask an integrator to come in and design a system for them without taking time to do a full study of what their actual operational needs are. So they get delivered a system that does not meet meet either their current requirements or what their expec expected throughput or future requirements are.
Mike Gerst: Yeah, I would agree. I would say many facilities that we run into grew in pieces and the layout reflects that. it's it's not how the work flows today, but how it worked before. automation bought one piece at a time over time, just moves that bottleneck down the line. but I think it's it's a Not necessarily the the automation but the process becomes important at that point.
Jackie Slaght: And fixing something like that that has grown in pieces and is maybe not been optimized or planned correctly for future needs, I s I'm assuming that's kind of a hard challenge to overcome, especially I know you mentioned like doctors. That's not easy thing to change the location of. are are there options for that that can improve without starting over essentially?
Mike T: there's always the ability to partially remove and integrate a new system on there. a couple years ago I had a customer reach out to me. They had an existing warehouse that ran majority of their infrastructure for southern Florida, and they wanted to take out their old material handling system or ports parts of it and replace it with a brand new material handling system that removed about nine Of the operational requirements in the area. So that we were down to, I think we went from 45 operators and pickers down to six, but we only had about 30,000 square feet to work with inside the existing infrastructure. So it's definitely possible. It's a difficult scenario and it has to be taken on a case-by-case basis.
Jackie Slaght: What are some signs that a facility may be outgrowing their current material handling systems?
Mike T: I mean, an easy one is probably the increased downtime due to parts wearing out or extra a maintenance cost due to the age of some of the equipment. You could have throughput delays or worker strain from either workers having been overworked to try to reach the throughput required for the facility, or you just simply cannot hit it because the system is unable to. and that I think probably the easiest one is the inability to increase the capacity throughout your facility.
Mike Gerst: Yeah, when, the business leaders start saying we can't take that order, you know, is it a throughput problem or is it a an actual manufacturing problem? we've heard, we added a shift but output barely moved, you know, and the overtime never goes away. Those are often material flow problems in disguise rather than manufacturing process problems.
Jackie Slaght: What is what does that mean?
Mike Gerst: the material handling system could be seen as inefficient to the manufacturing process where the bottleneck isn't necessarily the manufacturing process. The throughput of the manufacturing it's the throughput of the material handling being able to move whatever the product is through the line at a optimized pace to keep that production up and efficient.
Jackie Slaght: Okay. you.
Mike Gerst: your if your material handling isn't moving fast enough and and efficient enough, you know, it's gonna be it'll it will become the bottleneck, not your manufacturing process.
Jackie Slaght: I see. Okay.
Mike Gerst: So You know, material handling is designed to help fix some of the safety risks and repetitive motion inj injuries that we see often in you know, either warehouses moving boxes or on a on a manufacturing line. so in many times it's there to increase worker safety. But Mike, what have you seen where poor material handling can create increase risks.
Mike T: I mean sure. there's obviously the option of an improperly designed safety system. if we have areas where operators need to cross through or move through where the material handling system is operating, I have run into facilities where they do not have the proper s safety mitigation in place, whether that is a actual process stop that removes the ability for the machine to operate while someone's in the area, or they have poor maintenance that has caused the safety devices to be jumped out so that they don't function any lon any anymore. Separate from that, poor material handling can definitely create a lot of pinch points for operators if things are not properly guarded, if things do not have the proper gapping between different portions of the MHE, it creates the ability for an operator to put their hand on there and get trapped. I think One of the less thought about ones is what we were talking about with standard material handling without an automation involving involvement is the musculoskeletal disorders from repetitive motion injuries or poor ergonomics, where they will bring product in and say the product's at two feet tall, you're asking an operator down to pick to bend down to pick that up, place it on a pallet or place it on something else. a lot of older systems or systems with poor designs definitely suffer from poor ergonomics for the operators.
Mike Gerst: So in if what I'm hearing is an improperly designed unsafe system can actually increase worker risk and You know, injuries mean lost time, turnover. You know, you have a hard time replacing the people. You get you know, you can have issues in the worker p in the worker area where you get a bad reputation of unsafe working conditions. so that just makes hiring and filling those gaps even more difficult. so it's it is good to make sure that the safety aspect is paramount, you know, because safety and product productivity aren't really trade-offs. You know, you can't you can't have one without the other. So
Jackie Slaght: that's a really good I hope all the manufacturers are are prioritizing safety. so I think kind of going along with safety, maybe where do automated guided vehicles and autonomous mobile robots fit into today's facilities?
Mike T: I mean, since their introduction they've kinda had the same functions, but Obviously with the upgrade upgraded technology, especially with utilization of AI recently, we've had a greater ability to use them, but AGVs typically are phenomenal for single path motions from one point to another where we were repeating the same task over and over, right? AGVs like to run on tracks, they like to follow a simple planned line, and they typically don't have the ability on board to move around obstacles, they will typically have a safety sensor built into the front of them. So once something crosses into that safety zone, it will stop. So those are great for moving product from a high volume line to a high volume line, moving extremely heavy product that needs to be worked on, say like a giant car battery for a electric vehicle. Those are phenomenal to put on an AGV because they're extremely heavy heavy. They're relatively unsafe. The AGV can move it from one location to another in a smooth fashion. AMRs are much greater in a flexible environment where we have the ability to on the fly change what they're being used for, what they're programming. They have the ability to navigate around the environment in a safe manner to allow us to grab product on and off of a conveyor line move move product from the truck, out of the truck, back and forth where we don't have a set pattern every time where it's moving to the point where it can see that it has an operation it needs to do, perform the operation, then move back to whatever the next operation it needs to take.
Jackie Slaght: The H Vs
Mike Gerst: I think that
Jackie Slaght: are reminding me of the like rides at the at a theme park where like the old fashioned cars that are on the track and they just can only go
Mike T: Yeah.
Mike Gerst: I think function.
Jackie Slaght: a little you kind of bop them back and forth. I'm assuming they're
Mike Gerst: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: probably a little smoother than that, but that is what my
Mike T: I mean I think the best way to think about it is like a Roomba but on rails.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Mike Gerst: Yeah. Yeah. An A G V's like a train on track
Mike T: A V's like a
Mike Gerst: AMR is like a rideshare kind of thing, you know. It it
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Mike Gerst: it can go wherever, you know, but I I think You know, the c the business question is how stable your your process is. You know, if your layout changes, volumes change a lot, you know, flexibility of of an AMR would would, you know, work in th in that situation or be, you know, something to consider, based on some of the parameters that Mike laid out there of of what you're actually moving. but yeah. AGV is like a train on tracks and the AMR is is like an Uber for your
material.
Jackie Slaght: is a that's a really good analogy. That makes a lot of sense to me. So what what are some misconceptions that organizations often have about automating material movement?
Mike T: that it's gonna make your processes better. If you have poor operations that exist, poor processes, and then you put an automated system which is designed to be repeatable based off the input you provide, to provide the same output over and over and over again. If you have s issues with your process over and over again, you know, these guys are inefficient about picking material, so when it gets to the MHE, it takes longer because they have it's the material handling equipment is starved of volume that is only going to be exacerbated by something that just repeats over and over and over again as accurately as it can.
Jackie Slaght: So if if you don't have the good process, it's n it's not going to fix fix it, it's probably going to make it highlight it.
Mike T: Exactly. I think the other thing to that a lot of people think is that automation is extremely inflexible, right? I pay for a conveyor system, I get this conveyor system, it can never change. Right? You go to some facilities and they've been running a conveyor system that is older than me. It's not a joke. I took one out last year that is older than my father.
Jackie Slaght: my gosh.
Mike T: And at the end of the day depending how your process is, you can set up material handling to be a flexible system, right? If you sit down during the design phase of a system and you work with your main automation partner to figure out how you can potentially move forward in the future, how your operational changes may move to the left, move to the right, whatever it may be, you can design a system that has the ability to work with that. Utilizing different portions of MHE, whether it's robotics, AGVs, AMRs, MechLite or Flex Conveyor, you have a lot of options to not just have a stagnant system that does one thing for the rest of its life.
Mike Gerst: fix the process, then automate it. otherwise you're
Mike T: I would say so.
Mike Gerst: just gonna make faster mistakes and and make those mistakes more expensively, I think is probably an easy way to put it.
Jackie Slaght: Do you see people often in your in your experience when they come to you with a project, are they mostly reacting to a problem or do they have do you see people taking the time to kind of think through How do I want this to solve today's problem, but also grow for the future? It's I I guess have you seen people clients go down a path that you're like, this is probably solve or work for like a year, but you're gonna realize there's things that you wish you would have taken a little bit more time to think through how this would grow and work long term.
Mike T: one hundred percent. I mean there is obviously it depends on the customer and who exactly we're working with, but there have been some times where I've gotten to work with some people and some customers where we get to sit down and have meetings as high up to the sea level from know other countries to sit down to talk about this is what the business the like projected business needs are. This is what we think we're gonna be flowing through the facility. This is how we need it to operate and how we need to change it. What can you do to fix it? In the opposite direction, I've had people come to me and go, I want this. Okay, I
Jackie Slaght: And
Mike T: think that's a bad idea. Why don't we sit down and talk about it? you know, I d
Jackie Slaght: Ha ha
Mike Gerst: know why I
Mike T: I had somebody come to me and go, hey, we're doing something for for for this company. I just need 200 feet of conveyor. I said, You don't need any peripherals, you don't need they're like, we just want two hundred feet of conveyor. I'm like, what about safety? What about this? They're I don't care about that. I want two hundred feet of conveyor. And it's like You know, that doesn't work. And then six months later I got a call from the guy and he goes, Hey, you're right. I think I need you to get safety in the system. I think I need you to come here and actually integrate it with everything else and then we could talk about putting it as extra conveyor on the end to actually have it flow into the system. I was like, you hate to say all
Jackie Slaght: That's
Mike T: I'm right, but I I think I was right in that scenario.
Jackie Slaght: Ha ha
Mike Gerst: Yeah, I I think from a you know, from the sales standpoint, you know, we we like to look at you know, somebody says, Hey, I I need a conveyor, okay. begin to ask the questions as to why do you need that conveyor, where is it going? What problems is it solving? What's the return on that conveyor? I think that, you know, from our standpoint, looking at a client's request is really understanding the problem and what are we trying to solve here and looking at it from a you know a more holistic point of view. Because typically a material handling system it does have a start and an end, but sometimes they're asking us to do something in the middle of it where let's make sure that that bottleneck isn't somewhere else in the process or somewhere else upstream or downstream. So I think it's important to really you know understand the problems, the issues that they're having and you know look at it from a holistic point of view rather than we need a conveyor right there. maybe sometimes they do, and sometimes they don't and there's other solutions that we can help provide.
Jackie Slaght: I know in in my like work experience, which is very different in working on marketing projects than what you guys are doing, but sometimes I've caught myself I'm too close to the project, so it's hard to see with like fresh eyes, like how can redo something,
Mike Gerst: Sure.
Jackie Slaght: rework something. I I would imagine there's a similar aspect from the client's perspective they're see the immediate problem and if
they're in a reactionary state of just we need to fix this, it's easy to want to move faster and then end up, you know, like you said, kind of pushing the problem down until it becomes too big that yeah we we are forced now to take a look and take take a step back.
Mike Gerst: Find the root cause. Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: so I guess how did how do companies determine which process is maybe a good a good fit for for an automation solution?
Mike T: I mean, I think the easy answer across most material handling is something that's high volume and repeatable. But if you really break down to some of the major reasons I've gotten involved in some of these material handling projects are labor. Whether it's the inability to hire labor or the concern around safety for any of the associates who are working in certain areas, it that's probably been one of the biggest drivers where spent a year or two working on a facility where we automated their entire warehouse because the county would not let them put air conditioning in there and in the summer it was too hot for people to safely work.
Jackie Slaght: My goodness.
Mike Gerst: Yeah. you know, I'll add you know, tasks that are unsafe, that are hard to staff or have cause costly errors, if there is an error on the line. know, so I think you know but it has to be repeatable. But I think another question is, Mike, what what's a bad candidate automation?
Mike T: I think know if it's bad as the correct answer, but something that is so heavily reliant on manual tasks that are leaning back to my first answer, not repeatable, right? If I have a a good example is like you go to a machine shop. If I have a repair shop where people bring me in drive shafts over and over and over again, I have to repair these drive shafts, every single shaft is gonna be different. It does not make sense for me to build a material handling system to pick it up, bring it over, put in a robotic welder that's gonna weld that shaft back up before you machine it down, because it's not gonna be the same every single time. The variability in there can be extremely costly and just the return on investment for can be s much greater than the typical twenty year expected return.
Jackie Slaght: yeah, you mentioned earlier in the discussion that data was becoming a more requested item and clients wanting to get all the data out of their system. Why do you think that is becoming a more important aspect of material handling operations?
Mike T: God, I mean, d depends on which way you want to look at it. Some of it is simple as operations planning, right? So they can see all the product moving in and out through their f facility and they can, keep track either keep track of their inventory better or do a better forecasting of the demand coming up so that way they can try to properly staff to avoid like seasonal peaks. In other directions, some of it is I'm gonna say selfishness on the side of engineers or maintenance where we want the ability to look at systems and see data of pain points of, you know, hey, this area stops a lot. Why? Right? Over and over again. Or even pr predictive maintenance where there are so many smart devices out out there nowadays that have built-in ability to monitor you know, the oil temperature or when was the last time somebody performed maintenance on there just so that we can easily track when we need to go repair items or perform the PM tasks day to day to day.
Mike Gerst: I think an easy way to describe what Mike just explained is it it it helps with decision making, you know, at the at the leadership level. the data means investments are decisions are mean are based on facts and not complaints or you know, seeming issues, at least you have data to back up what your what your thought process is. most of these come back to, getting more out of the equipment, space, and people that a company already has. So I I think that all the data comes down to the the thirst for it is to make better more qualified decisions as to, you know, how to how to work with their inventory, how to work with maintenance, how to work with their space and their current layout, cost, sustainability, all that stuff gets balled up from those decisions are based on the data that are coming off the material handling so Mike, if I'm if I'm thinking about designing a system that can scale, what are what are top three things I should be considering?
Mike T: I think the system location within a facility, right? we don't want to build it in a spot where we are going to run into operational issues where you know if we build on top of the dock doors and we lose those dock doors for whatever reason if we're co-oping a building or something. I think the power availability within the building is something that is typically not looked at until way too late, where we don't know if we need to upgrade the service to the system or provide a switch gear within the building and those are not exactly the cheapest resolutions. And personally I think black box engineering is probably one of the biggest things to avoid. if you get a system that has a black box, you cannot really scale over it without paying the original company, if they still exist at the point that you decide to s to add on to that system to come back and integrate with it.
Mike Gerst: Yeah, I I just ran into a situation with a client that has you know, a a s a black box based system. And it's it's become a problem for because the the OEM isn't in this country and so supports very hard. So I think black box is also one of the things I'd stress for the owners. you know, if the original builder can't support it or change the system or it's opens open enough that you could bring in another contractor to work on the system, I think you're setting yourself up for some pain later in life. So when the owner loses control of the cost and uptime, I think open documented systems are are the way to go for those types of investments.
Jackie Slaght: if there is one message for manufacturers and facility leaders that you would like them to take away from today's discussion, what would it be?
Mike T: For me it would be take the time to reach out to your your main automation partner and have them do a study on your warehouse with your operations team to forecast whether or not you guys actually need material handling upgrades or a new system. I think it can save a lot of pain points in the future.
Mike Gerst: Yep, I agree. I think starting with an engineering study to you know, really examine the process and fix that, because I you'll you'll typically find issues in the process before you automate it and then build it so you can grow into it. don't lock yourself down into like we mentioned, black box OEMs, make it scalable, make it flexible, with the future in mind as as best you can.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, that's great. So I want to thank you guys for for joining today and having taking the time to have this discussion. I always learn a lot from these. I always like to end on a couple of fun questions, if you could instantly improve one process in every facility, what would it be? I've stumped you. It's gonna be di well, that's a good one.
Mike T: Well, it's it's not as simple as that. I mean, for me the answer would be trash collection. Right? 'Cause you have the ability to automate it. Some people do, some people don't, but one of the things that for me personally always just irks me is when I go to a facility and I see trash everywhere. Right?
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, no, that that's a good one. what is one technology trend that you're most excited about right now?
Mike Gerst: Well, I d I know everybody's gonna say AI and cautiously optimistic about that. I think it has its place for certain things, but I do think it has the ability to make us dumber. I think it still needs to have some good consideration for it. But I I I think it'll grow and and it'll take over the world at some point, so
Mike T: Personally, I I think it's IOLINK. the further development and creation more IO Link devices make things for us automation engineers much easier. Being able to provide a single twelve cable to a device and then pull a ridiculous amount of data down, the cost of it is almost nothing versus what we get and what we have the ability to do with them.
Jackie Slaght: I have not heard of that before, so thank last question I have is what would you like to see us explore on future episodes of Beyond Tech?
Mike T: I think just because we covered it so much on this, I'd love to have a episode on safety and automation, risk assessments, how the T U V standards work, in relation to our industry.
Jackie Slaght: I I think that's a great idea. that is all I have, unless there's anything else you guys wanna add. otherwise I would just thanks for thanks for joining us.
Mike Gerst: Thanks for having us. Appreciate