ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
Carl Leibowitz: Hello and welcome to another episode of A Conversation with Carl. to like, follow, and subscribe for the latest content. Today I am very excited to welcome Phil Lempart, famously known as the Supermark Guru. For over 25 years, Phil has been a leading expert, analyst on consumer behavior and retail landscape. His impressive media footprint includes serving on FoodTrans editor for NBC's Today Show for near for over 20 years, alongside regular appearances on The View, Fox Business, and The Oprah Winfrey Show. A veteran broadcaster, he spent nearly two decades hosting Shopping Smart on the WOR Radio Network and currently hosts the popular podcast. The Lempert Report Live, Lost in the Supermarket and Farm Food Facts. Welcome Phil Lempert to the Conversation.
Phil Lempert: Thank you, Carl. It's a pleasure.
Carl Leibowitz: so let's get started. Supermarkets are incredibly telling places. Whenever I travel somewhere, the first thing I do is I go to the local supermarket to see and understand the culture. While stores differ globally, is there always an underlying uniformity to them?
Phil Lempert: Carl, you know, I do the exact same thing. and you know, you can find out about the culture of a neighborhood, ⁓ what the people are like. However, that's really changing ⁓ of different upstarts like Aldi, obviously Walmart. it's really changing how the traditional supermarket operates ⁓ and that square foot supermarket that we're used to. ⁓ To be with you, with the whole K economy. They're really under a lot of pressure. It's either extreme that's doing really well, but the conventional supermarket, they're struggling.
Carl Leibowitz: business is notoriously brutal with razor thin profit margins. is this ⁓ industry generally harder than others?
Phil Lempert: Absolutely, and it's under more pressure than ever before. Let's not forget that since COVID, prices are up about twenty-five percent. ⁓ on top of that, ⁓ got climate change, which is affecting how we grow our foods and where we grow our foods. ⁓ got the war in Iran, which is driving up the price of diesel, ⁓ all of our food gets transported to the supermarket, you know, in trucks, whether it's refrigerated or non-refrigerated trucks. We've got the price of fertilizer that's going through the roof. We've got ice raids that are really eliminating labor on our on our farms as well as in poultry and meat processing plants. So supermarkets are under more pressure today than ever before.
Carl Leibowitz: So how do we fix this problem?
Phil Lempert: Well easier said than done. what we have to do is we have to really reimagine ⁓ how grow our foods. what we've seen because of climate change, for example, you know, coffee prices are through the roof because of, you know, the the climate conditions in Brazil. Chocolate prices are through the roof because of the climate conditions in South Africa. ⁓ you know, berry production, because it it it has moved from California down to Central and South America,
Load full transcript
⁓ we have added costs of distribution. so we've got to really reimagine it. ⁓ And me, it's a lot about vertical farming and indoor farming. it's easy for us to say we want to grow all of our food here in the US, ⁓ but frankly, that's not gonna happen. but if we do start to think about, ⁓ know, robotics ⁓ meat processing facilities and poultry processing facilities ⁓ we look at, you know, indoor farming and vertical farming, we look at, ⁓ know, ⁓ in Europe we see a lot of chicken coops that are vertical farms. so we really need to make some heavy duty investments because these are very expensive ⁓ if gonna fix the problem.
Carl Leibowitz: how the tariffs affecting the supermarkets?
Phil Lempert: Well so not only not only has it affected and food companies, ⁓ really the up and down part of the tariffs that's very disruptive. ⁓ 'cause people can't plan. So you have a food company who's or food distributor ⁓ or who's really unsure of what's gonna happen tomorrow. ⁓ So as result, they're really keeping inventories much lower. There's products that are disappearing. And also, unfortunately, for a lot of the ethnic grocers, we have an Indian grocer here in Santa Monica that I talk to all the time. ⁓ can't get the foods that he used to get. ⁓ he's about ready to go out of business. He can't afford the tariffs, he can't pass it on ⁓ his ⁓ customers, ⁓ you know, ⁓ can't get the product. So what is he gonna do?
Carl Leibowitz: No, that's that's very scary when you think about what you need and you need food and you need to get it to you and how expensive it is to just with the as you said, fertilizer's going up, truck driving costs are going up, every all the prices getting the ice raids are causing a problem. So it's a big issue today. ⁓
Phil Lempert: It's a it's a tremendous issue. And you know, what I hear from consumers all the time is, you know, don't screw around with my food. now that we have electronic shelf labels, ⁓ you going into supermarkets and there's this fear of surge pricing, you know, consumers are saying I don't have to take an Uber, I don't have to get on an airline, but I do have to eat. and when when we look at our history of the world A lot of the wars that took place were over food, because people didn't have food. so ⁓ you yes, I I agree with you. I think it's a very serious issue, ⁓ and really need to pay attention to what's going on.
Carl Leibowitz: It's the one thing we do need is food. ⁓ let's pull back the curtain a little bit and talk about grocery layouts because they are completely engineered around consumer psychology. So can you tell us about how store planners design these spaces and how do they maximize shelf shelf space and sales?
Phil Lempert: Exactly. Sure. well there's two parts to it. ⁓ is keep in mind that most supermarkets today when you walk in, ⁓ walking in in a produce department. ⁓ the reason for that is like aromatherapy. ⁓ all these great colors, it's all these great aromas. They put you in a better mood. ⁓
what I always tell consumers is start your shopping trip in the middle of the store, ⁓ unemotional boxes and jars and cans. ⁓ you're not gonna spend more you're not gonna spend more time in the store. ⁓ the way things are outlined on the shelves really has to do with what's called a planogram. And planograms are set so that you know they maximize the profit per item. And that could be because there's a certain brand who pays the store a certain amount of money to get that I level location. and also what you're gonna see is store brands typically to the right of you know, the national brand so that your eye goes there and you can compare easily. so a lot of it has to do with, ⁓ know, ⁓ pay for play, if you would, end aisle displays. ⁓ People that, ⁓ if it's at the end of the Nile and it's piled high, it's going to be cheaper. ⁓ Not ⁓ Always for that sign. if it's on sale, there's going to be a sign there. If it's not on sale, there's no sign.
Carl Leibowitz: How does stuff get to eye level? if you're walking down an aisle you have twelve different say pasta brands. Which which one's gonna get to eye
Phil Lempert: So the the retailer has what's called a category manager. And that category manager has computer programs that say that if I put this product here, ⁓ velocity is going to be X, if I put this product here, ⁓ velocity is going to be X. ⁓ and actually a lot of the original computer programs were developed by Anheuser-Busch for Budweiser Beer ⁓ to calculate that. And it's calculated on a store-by-store basis. ⁓ So That's number one. Number two is again, ⁓ where a brand will go to that retailer and say, Okay, I'm gonna give you X amount of dollars, X amount of promotional dollars, ⁓ some free goods if you put me at that eye level. but keep in mind we have different eye levels. ⁓ So you when you go into the cereal aisle, for example, you're gonna see a lot of those sugar coated cereals at the kids' eye level, ⁓ not the parents' eye level. ⁓ And healthier cereals are gonna be at the
Carl Leibowitz: Lower.
Phil Lempert: Parents eye level.
Carl Leibowitz: Yeah. And then well that makes sense because, you know, you want to make sure where the you at your eye level for what you're gonna want. Like I'm not gonna want the sugary cereal, but you know, a child will want that. So and then once a new product actually makes it to the shelf, how long is the trial period ⁓ the store decides to keep it or kill it?
Phil Lempert: Exactly. Depends on the retailer. ⁓ typically they'll give it about three months. and again, you know, when they take a new product on, ⁓ know, that that manufacturer's gonna have to, whether it's coupons, whether it's sampling, they're gonna push as much as they can to get consumer acceptance of that product. ⁓ and there's also some retailers who started over the past ten years charging a failure fee. ⁓ if I take your new product and it doesn't work, I'm gonna charge you a fee for having put it on my shelf. ⁓ so typically it's about three months. Yeah. ⁓ then ⁓ you've you've got other stores like Sprouts. and I love what Sprouts does. they've got this section as you walk in Sprouts ⁓ where they emerging brands
Carl Leibowitz: Wow, that's fascinating.
Phil Lempert: a period of six weeks to make it. you know, they don't charge ⁓ allowances or anything else, but they put ⁓ there. ⁓ a all about discovery. ⁓ I'd like to see every retailer do that.
Carl Leibowitz: Are there slow rollouts? Like let's say we'll start with a I don't know, say a pasta brand 'cause that's popping in my head or a pasta sauce. ⁓ it starts at beginning of the aisle and then we move it to the middle. Do we move things around a lot or we leave things once they get there to the shelf, we leave it there.
Phil Lempert: store sets are are typically done every six months. so when you when you find a product there and and I'm not talking about the end of the aisle ⁓ that changes practically every week. ⁓ but you know, ⁓ a store set is done about every six months.
Carl Leibowitz: Daily, yeah. So wow, that's a that's fascinating to think that they every ⁓ six months they come in there and they do that. tastes are incredibly regional. I've seen markets fifteen minutes apart carry entirely different merchandise. What goes into deciding which non staple items will appeal to a local demographic?
Phil Lempert: It's all about you and me. it's that retailer understanding ⁓ we want and not only is it a different product mix, but it could be different prices as well. so I'm here in Santa Monica ⁓ and prices that I'll pay in Santa Monica are vastly different ⁓ than prices if I drive fifteen minutes to Inglewood. so you know there there's a whole formula ⁓ behind, you not only the assortment and understanding who your demographics are, and that's everything from race and age and ⁓ concerns as well as economics. ⁓ And know, the retailer really needs to understand that shopper. And again, that's done by a store by store level.
Carl Leibowitz: And you we meant you mentioned Aldi before and we talked about you talked about Lidl too. my dad loves Aldi. So if you come to him, he wants to take you to Aldi. how is that playing the supermarket chains?
Phil Lempert: So Aldi is now the third largest grocer in the US. the interesting aspect of Aldi, and I've been to their headquarters, I've been to their test kitchens, ⁓ store brands are exceptional. ⁓ they also in every store have a list ⁓ over a hundred different ingredients that they will never use in their store brands, ⁓ whether they be chemical artificial colors, high fructose syrup and the like. so they're really focused. high quality and efficiency. it's owned by a German family. In fact, ⁓ the other part of the family actually owns Trader Joe's. they're totally separate companies. They don't talk to each other. ⁓ The rumor that the two brothers who had a fight, ⁓ you know, years are now ⁓ reconciling and maybe it's become one company again. ⁓ but we'll see. but Aldi, you know,
has very strict specs ⁓ for manufacturers. So they might tell a manufacturer, Okay, I want twelve cans of corn in a tray and put plastic overwrap on it. You'll never see a box ⁓ in where you know the employee has open up the box and take the cans out. They just remove the covering, put the tray right on the shelf. ⁓ So it's about efficiency. the other thing that I really ⁓ applaud Aldi for doing, and they're probably the only ⁓ ⁓ store who does it, ⁓ cashiers sit down. ⁓ and that's something that we always see in in Europe, ⁓ not here in the US. And when you think about that, ⁓ culture ⁓ saying to that employee, I care about you. ⁓ don't want you to have to stand for eight hours, ten hours, even if I give you a little rubber mat. so that the floor isn't so hard. ⁓ Aldi really cares about their customers, they about their employees, and ⁓ you know, ⁓ that Isle Shame when you walk in, ⁓ you know, is ⁓ filled with bargains every month. ⁓ And you look their Facebook page, and I think they've got, you know, over a million people ⁓ on their aisle shame Facebook page.
Carl Leibowitz: So but they also have the you put the quarter in the in the shopping cart it makes you return the shopping cart.
Phil Lempert: Well, there there's two reasons for that. number one is so that you do bring the shopping cart back and you just don't leave it in the parking lot. ⁓ other, psychologically, ⁓ very telling to a shopper where know it again, the personality of Aldi ⁓ is here for you. We're gonna make this experience as good as possible, we're gonna make it as economical as possible ⁓ for And just having that little, you know, quarter in the shopping cart sends a signal to that shopper that says, you know, this is gonna be a a a good value proposition for me.
Carl Leibowitz: And what is happening to other brands now, because I guess like ShopRite other stores have their own brands, is all the taking is moving into that competition and taking that away from other br other supermarket brands?
Phil Lempert: ⁓ yes and no. You know, I you you mentioned ShopRite. Shopright has a very good store brand program. a lot of store brands have up the game over the past ten years. ⁓ used to be in our parents' generation, ⁓ know, if you couldn't afford the real thing, then you bought the store brand and it wasn't as good quality. ⁓ the store brands are as good quality if not better. ⁓ Aldi, Trader Joe's. Shop rate, you know, Kroger. There's a lot of innovation going on there. And the reason for that is relatively simple. You can't buy an Aldi store brand at another retailer. So if I can get you hooked on my store brand, both because of price and because of taste and and quality, you're gonna come back. And also what a lot of people don't realize is every store brand has a money back guarantee. So try it. If you don't like it, bring the unused portion back to the store, you'll get a full refund.
Carl Leibowitz: Wow. ⁓ we also talked about having cleaner ingredients. You said there's a
hundred items that Alduan put in there. ⁓ how is with the health and wellness supercycle that we're ⁓ you've called it that How has that been influ influencing like factors like the G GLP one drug and medications and weight loss
Phil Lempert: So a lot to unpack there. ⁓ GLP one ⁓ especially now that it's in ⁓ in the pill form, ⁓ changing the way people eat. ⁓ people are eating less. we look at surveys probably every month that ⁓ the consumers less, they're changing their diet to to conform ⁓ with eating healthier. one concern that I do have ⁓ is we are addicted protein. the average American does not have a protein deficiency, ⁓ there's reports that are coming out saying, you know, consuming too much protein isn't a great thing for you. it could create kidney problems, kidney stones, and and the like. ⁓ So got to balance that information out. ⁓ but GLP 1 is is changing the way we eat, changing supermarkets. ⁓ Kroger, who I just mentioned, came out with their own GLP 1 line of food. ⁓ Conagra done it. Nestle has done it. We're gonna see more companies do that. that's number one. ⁓ Number coming out of Washington, there's a lot of conflicting information, and it's getting for consumers to to really ⁓ separate what what is. you know, RFK Jr. wants to get rid of artificial dyes. ⁓ I don't think that there's anybody who wants artificial dyes. ⁓ However, it's a complicated process.
Carl Leibowitz: Wow.
Phil Lempert: The reason that food companies use artificial colors, ⁓ for example, is because of the eye appeal. we want our ⁓ we talked about kids' cereal, we want our kids' cereal to be bright blue and bright pink and stuff like that. when we start removing artificial colors, ⁓ the is gonna look different. Doritos now has a naked Dorito that doesn't have any artificial colors in it. ⁓ And you know, people aren't really buying it. ⁓ they want that yellow stuff on their fingers. ⁓ so have to do that. And then also a lot of food allergy experts are very concerned. ⁓ I serve on the ⁓ board for for fair, the advisory board, which is the food allergy research and education ⁓ board. And you when you take these things out and you replace it with natural colors,
Carl Leibowitz: Yeah.
Phil Lempert: it you could have food allergens. one of the most famous stories about ⁓ food coloring ⁓ to do with Starbucks. Howard Schultz, probably ⁓ over a decade ago, wanted remove the artificial pink color ⁓ that in one of their summer beverages. And they that. ⁓ They replaced with the extract from the insect beetle. And what happened is then had Vegans and vegetarians picketing all the Starbucks because insects are not vegetarian or vegan. ⁓ So, you know, you've got to balance this out. You just can't say, okay, remove everything. And again, it's been a request, not a law, from He's also said for about four months ⁓ that they're to come out with a new definition of what ultra-processed foods are. And again,
Carl Leibowitz: Yeah.
Phil Lempert: It's very complicated, because you
can't just remove processed foods ⁓ from diet ⁓ because what pro yeah, what ultra process means is that it's, know, cooked basically. so you can't
Carl Leibowitz: We're addicted to it.
Phil Lempert: It it's not that simple. So I think that the government is moving a little too quick on stuff, not really educating consumers to what this is. And also I have a ⁓ a severe ⁓ reaction to when RFK Jr. is saying, you know, butter is back, beef is back, you know, fry your French fries and beef tallow. mean, all the science is in in the face of all of that. ⁓ what we know is we've been able to reduce the incidence of heart disease and cancers because of changing people's diet, eating less meat, know, not frying French fries and beef tallow and so on. So ⁓ it's really getting complicated for consumers to figure it out. ⁓ the good news is that now we've got a lot of apps that are out there that can go shopping with, ⁓ you one of these apps and just scan the barcode ⁓ and It'll tell you whether or not it meets your criteria.
Carl Leibowitz: the ⁓ my next question is talking about mobile scanners and how tech is rapidly changing grocery stores. Where do you see technology taking the in-store shopping experience to next?
Phil Lempert: I believe we're gonna see a vast change in soup markets. That gonna take a 40,000 square foot store and cut it in half. The back of it ⁓ is gonna fully robotic. What we're gonna ⁓ is the same we make a restaurant reservation, ⁓ we're gonna go and we're gonna make a reservation to go food shopping. After we make that it's gonna bring us to the portal ⁓ where we're gonna order certain things online. those are gonna be the unemotional cans and boxes and ⁓ know, I don't need to walk past forty thousand products to get twenty thousand ⁓ get twenty products. ⁓ don't need to see, ⁓ know, a jar of Heinz ketchup. I know what it looks like. so can just go online, order all that, and then store is just gonna be fresh. ⁓ I'm gonna able to pick my produce, ⁓ my meats, baked goods, all of that and have a great shopping experience. And then when I'm done with all of that, my canned goods and my jars and my boxes are gonna be waiting for me to check out. So I think that that's gonna be the hybrid that we're gonna see. you know, from a mobile standpoint, retailers, grocery retailers do not make any money on delivery. ⁓ So why they have this click and collect program where they're trying to get us to order online and pick it up ourselves. ⁓ And gonna be the most efficient model.
Carl Leibowitz: But But that getting Heinz catch up, that works for you and me because we've been to a supermarket, we know what Heinz is. If you're 18, 19, 20, figuring out life and you're just starting to go there, you might not know what Heinz looks like, or you might not know what you like. And doesn't that land up taking away choice from us because we haven't had the chance to look down, walk down the aisle and see all the different products that are there?
Phil Lempert: I don't think so because especially with Generation Z and millennials, they're very food involved and they've grown up with mobile devices. So they know everything globally as far as food, better than you and I do, ⁓ because they live and breathe it. and you know, Aldi and Trader Joe's and Lidl are great examples of of stores don't to have forty thousand products. ⁓ They've got 2,000 products, 2500 products in it, and their shoppers, your dad, are very well satisfied. we don't need that overabundance of choices. ⁓ It's it's you know, when I was a kid, I remember the Khrushchev came over and saw a supermarket, US supermarket for the first time. ⁓ And I don't who the president was then. but but he said, Why do you have so much stuff? And and you know Think about McDonald's, for example. McDonald's used to have menu boards were not electronic. And would see, you know, twenty or items on it, ⁓ and it down everything. ⁓ Now McDonald's menu boards that just put on the breakfast items, just put on the lunch items, just put on the dinner items, ⁓ and it speeds up everything. ⁓ Sometimes we just have too much choice, and when you at again back to ⁓ cereals. ⁓ I really need Cheuritos in giant size, family size, ⁓ size, ⁓ size? ⁓ know, we just don't need all that stuff. ⁓ keep in mind, both for a retailer and a manufacturer, ⁓ costs money. ⁓ ⁓ our prices go up higher ⁓ a result. during during COVID, ⁓ the CEO of Progresso.
Carl Leibowitz: Mm.
Phil Lempert: the canned soup company, went through their, you know, line of products ⁓ and discovered, and I'll I'll probably get the number wrong, but they had something like seventy varieties of chicken and noodle soups. And he it in half and was able be much more efficient both in a production standpoint ⁓ and a and profit standpoint. ⁓ Sometimes we get away and these product managers and brand managers, ⁓ you know, they They get graded and promoted based on, you know, incremental revenue. So if I'm a brand manager I come up with, you know, yet another Kraft macaroni and cheese, you know, ⁓ I'm get promoted ⁓ to a a better brand, a bigger brand, ⁓ things that. ⁓ So, you and ⁓ craft and cheese is a great example. ⁓ They came out with n a new one which was higher in protein. Now they came out with a new one that's higher in protein and higher in fiber. I mean, we just keep on doing this stuff.
Carl Leibowitz: Mm-hmm. And what does that do to stores like C V S and Walgreens?
Phil Lempert: Absolutely. ⁓ in fact I was just at V and Kroger just ⁓ a week or so ago, had Nourishing Change, which is all about health and wellness, ⁓ and I on the stage the the ⁓ of CVS we were talking that and what CVS looks at being your your corner grocery store, if you would, in addition to prescriptions. When you need something quick, ⁓ want to have it there. ⁓ they're not going to have 20 varieties of craft macaroni and cheese. ⁓ going to have two of the most popular ones. And expanding their food footprint ⁓ because what you and
I want. We want get in and out quickly. We want to have for the most part named brands. ⁓ as it as it relates to C V S they're growing terrifically.
Carl Leibowitz: And how does I this of everyone, how does AI fit into this?
Phil Lempert: AI fits in a bunch of different ways. so for me, what I'm looking forward to, and I've seen tests of it, is being to go on a website and saying, you know, Carl and are gonna have a barbecue for 10 people ⁓ this Saturday. person has disease, one person is vegan, person has some kind of food allergy, ⁓ one person is on GLP ⁓ I don't want to spend more than ten dollars a person. want it to be easily prepared. And a nanosecond, it's gonna give me the entire shopping list and any recipes that gotta include. So from a consumer ⁓ it's really terrific. ⁓ a brand standpoint, it's really speeding up and new product introduction. ⁓ Because I can put there, again, I wanna develop an Italian ⁓ cuisine GLP one users ⁓ that looking ⁓ th GLP one users. That's it. That's all I gotta say. ⁓ And will come up with ⁓ a of products ⁓ that that criteria for the GLP one user ⁓ with Italian flair to it.
Carl Leibowitz: Wow, it's gonna change the way we we shop.
Phil Lempert: It will. and ⁓ and again I think that's good. let's keep in mind and we and we hear this all the time, ⁓ you garbage in, garbage out. ⁓ So you can ⁓ be specific as possible with whether chat GPT or Claude or Perplexity, you'll get a good But you've also got to check that answer. So if I type in, know, I've got a food allergy, you know, of whatever kind. I I can't trust it a hundred percent yet, 'cause it's going out there and it's just searching the web for information, but it's just doing it much quicker. And people understand that especially Chat GPT. All it is a faster search engine. ⁓ And it's a and it's a
Carl Leibowitz: Yes, that's what it is. Done by a coder.
Phil Lempert: Yeah, and it's a broader search engine. So I don't have to, you know, go through all these lines that I used to have to go through on Google anymore. I can just type in something. so yes, I think it's gonna make our shopping experience ⁓ better, easier. I can also type in, you know, what's the cheapest supermarket to buy Cheerios in in my zip code, ⁓ and will find out for
Carl Leibowitz: No, that's that's great because sometimes you have that for the gas app. You can find like the cheapest gas around. So that that changes everything. as we wrap up, is there anything that I should have asked you that I didn't ask you?
Phil Lempert: Yes. Correct. one thing is and keeps me up at night, and we about this briefly, is climate change, labor shortages, the of diesel, of that is going affect our food supply. And ⁓ you know, people always to Well, when are food prices going down? Never. Not in our lifetime. ⁓ ⁓ so we we just have to reimagine our food supply. We've got to rethink our food. And probably the best way for people to save money is to stop wasting food. ⁓ Forty percent of all of our food in the US is wasted, whether it's at farm level, and right now because of the labor labor problem on farms, it's even higher. whether it's at home, whether it's taking leftovers from when we go out to a restaurant. we have to stop wasting our food and that's the best way to save money.
Carl Leibowitz: But I also imagine the people that are running these stores are making a lot of money.
Phil Lempert: supermarket makes about one and a half percent net profit. and again when you look at, you know, stores like Ollie and Kroger, ⁓ one and a half percent over three, four thousand stores, that's a lot of money. but still it ⁓ it's razor thin. ⁓ And one of things that electronic labels will enable the store to do, and you know, the whole surge pricing thing two sides to it. ⁓ One is if it's a hot summer day, raise the price of ice cream. ⁓ But also at the end of the day, when baked goods are, you know, not gonna be fresh, they can lower the price. So, you I think it's gonna change our shopping patterns ⁓ as shelf labels get into the stores and we're gonna see more people shopping later in the day to get those discounts.
Carl Leibowitz: So Phil Lampard, thank you so much for joining me. The podcast is the Lempert Report Live, Lost in the Supermarket and Farm Food Facts. Thank you out there for listening today. Let me know what you think. As always, put your thoughts in the comment section. And until next time, everyone, be safe.