النص 🔗
Weirdschooling: Season One, Episode 12
Texas Educational Symposium with Maxwell Carr
Episode 12: Texas Educational Policy Symposium
Originally Released November 15, 2023
Intro: <Original bright piano sea shanty music rising in the background with school bell sound.>
Sarah: Welcome to Weirdschooling. I’m Sarah.
Jennie: And I’m Jennie. We’re parents, friends, lifelong learners and self-proclaimed weirdos.
Sarah: We’ve found that some of the best educational methods have emerged when we let go of conformity and explore the unconventional and unique
Jennie: Because no one’s brain operates the same way and that’s exciting. And what works today may not work tomorrow, and we can adapt.
Sarah: We’re all in this weird and wonderful world together.
Jennie: So let’s learn outside the box!
<Original cheerful, organ and piano sea shanty music fading out in the background.>
Jennie: I couldn't help but smile proudly and somewhat conspiratorially as I saw my oldest child step on stage before more than a hundred kids, adults, and teachers at the end of his three month long homeschool public speaking class. He stood before an appropriately ceremonial red velvet backdrop and was decked out with a microphone and set in focus by maybe slightly too intense spotlight, but he took a deep breath and he began giving his presentation.
He could have chosen to talk about. Anything during his final speech, his peers had chosen topics ranging from chicken inspired idioms to sushi preparation, and even lobotomies, all admirable and truly bespoke content as unique as the children giving the speeches. But my 11 year old son, Maxwell's special brand of weird landed on.
The pros and cons of Texas Senate Bill 1 regarding educational savings accounts. He's a serious, injustice minded little dude, and he's also living proof that weirdness is genetic and runs thick in our family. But if my son and I have learned anything from the guests on WeirdSchooling, it is that even the most inherent Wonderful weirdness can benefit from support, guidance, and authentic experiences.
Sarah encouraged me to celebrate the learning journey that Maxwell and I took to prepare him for presentation day, and the lessons that we both learned along the way. In this week's very special episode of Weird Schooling, I bring you along with my son and I as we both embrace new experiences and celebrate our authentic selves as proudly weird child and adult learners at the second annual Texas Education Symposium.
First stop, jelly beans.
Maxwell: And this is the life, like this is just...
Jennie: Oh yeah, what are you liking about it so far? What are your
Maxwell: favorite parts? Well, I have unlimited jelly beans, unlimited Sprite. outrageously comfy seats
Jennie: You heard it here first folks. Educators are in it for the jelly beans and the swag.
Maxwell: No, it's very, it's a very big room. It feels a bit awkward how I'm dressed fancier than some people wearing denim jackets.
Jennie: But there are other people who are like suit jackets, right? There's a range. Yeah. Everyone's in what they feel comfortable in. Yeah. So you can imagine us dressed up fancy for the day of learning.
Me back after How old is Maxwell? After over 11 years away from the classroom, 11 years where I haven't been around a lot of educators all at one time. At one point when Maxwell was itty bitty, I was involved in community organizing and some different, opportunities for working and learning with other teachers.
But in the past five, six, seven, eight, Nine years, I haven't done much. So I got dressed with care that morning wanting to look professional. Maxwell got dressed with extra super lots of care, wanting to be fancy like me. And also just not knowing what to expect from something like a symposium, Dressed for the day armed with coffee for me, for him decaf, of course, but definitely pumpkin spice flavored this time of year we show up and what does Maxwell see and a giant.
And he's also really taken by how many different types of people there are. He was excited, I think, to be part of that kind of group, that mingling of people. Of course, he did get some looks really welcoming looks, but definitely people were like, Oh, hi, we all love kids. We're all educators in some way.
Um, please tell us what's your story. You know, mom and child who are here together and Maxwell did not disappoint. He was prepared to share why he was here, what his goals were, what his missions were, so his, um, elevator pitch matched the sharpness of his dress. And I'm excited to share it with you today because, one, I'm just a proud mom, but two, um, it's kind of inspiring after I'd put my own passions and advocacy on the shelf for so long to have my kid pick up that mantle without me even telling him that that was a thing that might be good to do. When I tell you he came up with this topic on his own, I am not making that up. He pulled it out of thin air, but really he pulled it straight out of my heart too. And he, there's no way he could have known how important learning about different educational options are for people.
And then the fact he chose to approach his speech in a way that Wasn't going to isolate people, but was going to give people information. Um, he didn't choose one side or another, and you'll hear that when he gives his explanation of why he is at the education symposium.
Maxwell: I am working on a Senate bill one speech, for my, um, speech group, so I'm trying to learn more about hopefully Senate bill one. my goal with my speech is to go and find the pros and cons about and the effects of education on everybody. On Senate
Jennie: Bill one for school vouchers, right? For Greg Abbott's, um, education
Maxwell: savings accounts.
Jennie: That's right. That's right. Right. So we're going to learn about how you can use policy to change action and then what's going on in Texas right now. I can still remember whenever Maxwell was young and had a hard time sitting
Load full transcript
through an episode of Curious George, but I'll be, if this guy did not sit through An hour of policy conversation from House Representative James Talarico, he listened and he not only listened, but he actually asked a question that was asked during the session, which I can honestly say, inspired me to step up my game a little bit as far as policy advocacy goes and just learning more because these are things I used to be passionate about and having my son being so engaged in this and asking questions thoughtfully.Thank you.
After the opening, opening remarks, he and I had a really cool conversation about policy.
Both of us love thinking through these things and he has different ideas than me. So it's a. It's fun sometimes to disagree and learn and he definitely shapes my opinions as well. So come join us now as we have a lunch break and discuss all of the policy things that we have discussed. Please accuse the clinking of silverware and the noise in the background.
It was a large open space with upbeat music playing in the background and Maxwell looking through the extensive notes he had taken about all of the policy conversations that he had just listened to. James Talarico, um, representative for District 50 in Texas and a San Antonio 2011 Teach for America Corps member, did the opening address for the Texas Education Symposium.
And Maxwell asked a question that, Representative Talarico actually answered. And Maxwell, what was your question that you asked him?
Maxwell: My main question was that I was wondering, Bailey, I was wondering how his schools would close if Senate Bill 1 would be passed.
Jennie: Yeah, so if Senate Bill 1 with, savings accounts or school vouchers was passed, how would it affect the funding of schools?
And what did Representative Talarico say?
Maxwell: Well, he said, what usually happens is if you take money away from already struggling schools, it would just make you struggle more,
Jennie: So basically he said that there's already not enough money for Texas schools. Like how much money was spent per student in Texas right now on average? What was he, what did he say, about?
Maxwell: around six, six thousand.
Jennie: Yeah, that's what, but how much would the voucher be for? Eight thousand. Yeah, exactly. So there'd be more money going there and they already have a budget shortfall.
Maxwell: They already don't have enough money and also another problem is that all of this would also be taking away from the security of schools because the Senate only increased the security for a child by 10 when schools of the spent tens of thousands of dollars security Also, the bill increases school payment by around 10 billion, but you need around 16 billion. 16 million dollars, so they're falling around 6 million dollars short of what the schools need. A billion. A billion. Except, you're running around 6 billion dollars short of what the schools actually need just to stay around.
Jennie: If I had gone to this symposium by myself,
I absolutely would have remembered a lot of things. I would have taken a lot away from it. But my, I Um, desire to model active listening for him and to debrief with him helped me learn more as well, which is not something that I had really anticipated. You can hear the back and forth where we're both checking each other's facts and trying to understand what we had just listened to and how it affected our community.
And I definitely learned more with him and I'd like to think he learned more with me too, but you can tell he's a pretty sharp, cookie. The next thing that we talked about was really one of the most exciting pieces for me, and that was what he learned, not just about policy and content, but about being a poised and effective speaker, because he learned some amazing things from the teachers and his public speaking class, but.
There's not a lot of opportunities in life, in the life of an 11 year old anyway, to get to see adults speaking with great purpose and with great practice and great poise. The way that a, um, house representative is going to be speaking or the way that the director of the symposium is going to be speaking whenever she presented people.
And so I was really, really happy for him to get to actually see that. And I'm going to talk a little bit about how Maxwell learned about public speaking from the experience as well. So here's a little bit about how Maxwell learned about public speaking from the experience as well. So, Maxwell, My next question is this, do you feel like you learned anything just from watching representative, Talarico speak? He's actually the, one of the youngest representatives at the Texas House.
Maxwell:Well, his strengths in speaking is, he has a bit of humor, a strong voice, uses gestures but not overkill, like no slamming on the table, good metaphors. No Monotone, which I do, explains why he's here. He's very convincing by saving deep facts. He has strong words. Explains his opinion very well. he usually, like, he doesn't Say, um, a lot, like you'll never hear us say, um, in this podcast, cause usually.
Jennie: Sometimes they still sneak in, they sneak in, even, even, but yeah, no, I noticed that he did not use a lot of filler words. And so are these similar to some of the things that you learn in your public speaking class and are you learning, you feel like you're learning different things in person than you did in your public speaking class?
Maxwell: A lot more, this is a lot more advanced.
Jennie: Like, can you see the more real world application of these skills more?
Yes. Yeah. Awesome.
Maxwell: One of the guys, he went to the 88th review session. He worked at Raise Your Hand Texas. And he mainly explains, explain what I'm doing on my report As here, one of my notes is that special education is underfunded by, underfunded by 1. 8 million dollars. Special education: Probably billion. I keep writing million just cause billion is Billion feels
Jennie: Crazy, it feels like BEE lion, it feels like More like BEE lion dollars. Yeah, it feels like super villain type stuff. Yeah.
Maxwell: I agree. Yeah, just like, Elon Musk beneath me struggling with this. I know, I know.
Jennie: Okay. Well, cool. Thank
Maxwell: you, buddy. Thank you.
Jennie: When our day began. Maxwell and I were both learning. I was learning how to use my microphone remotely. He was learning how to live in this space full of adults. And also, both of us were learning together how to interview in a live setting. And he was nervous to answer questions, and I was nervous to ask questions. And it's an odd place to be whenever you're learning together, and you're learning awkwardly with someone you know better than anyone.
But we did it. And by the end of the day, after we'd gone to several informational sessions, after we'd had fun lunches, after he'd eaten a full cup of jelly beans and more Sprite than was probably advisable, he felt confident enough to interview me, which I thought was the absolute best thing ever. He had some questions.
He wanted to know my thoughts and opinions. He was hard hitting, but also. I felt confident enough to also help guide him and this one short day I had grown in my confidence and he had grown beyond being nervous to answer questions to be a demanding and commanding interviewer himself.
Maxwell: What did you think of the opinion that public schools should get money and not the private schools because public schools need more support or else the teachers will shut down and And many families, which can't homeschool or private school that gets,
Jennie: I feel like it's important that we have a public school option, but I also think that people get kind of entrenched in their idea that it has to be all 1 thing or all the other.
Maxwell: What did you think? I'm interviewing you. You already interviewed me. Okay. Well, also, what did you think about possibly the idea in the first hearing that we went to what did he think about the guys overall message that the voucher idea is just pure on bad.
Jennie: I think that Representative James Talarico is. Advocating for a lot of things that if the voucher program got kicked, put it into effect, that wouldn't happen. And so he has priorities that he's trying to make happen.
Maxwell: But what about you? I would agree on most of the things, except for my listeners. I would not like to go and share my opinion. I like to go and share the public's opinion.
Jennie: Well, I know you're trying to do a fair and balanced report, right?
Maxwell: Except, individual families should get no money. I think that the public schools should get money. Just kids with special needs do need to get a bit of extra money, except I think that there should be a crime if they use that fraudulently, like on field trips to Disneyland.
Jennie: Yeah, there has to be oversight, right? It's, it's, it's funding and accountability.
Maxwell: That just sort of loops back to what he said. So then it's just what came forth, the
chicken or the egg, like schools and children.
Jennie: Our last topic of conversation before we left for the day was one of reflection and of was this whole experience worth doing?
We actually drove up from Houston to Austin, Texas and stayed with, Maxwell's great grandfather. it was quite a to do to come up and go to this symposium and to take time away from home and all of the, you know, boring things like dishes and laundry. I really wondered for myself, was this a worthwhile experience?
Am I forcing this on him more? Was this something that he actually did gain real insights from? Now I have the hindsight of seeing how he did on his actual presentation day. And I feel confident that he did a great job. I'm hoping that he feels that confidence. And so these last few questions are just to say, Hey, Maxwell, was this worth it? Because I know it was worth it for me.
And I grew so much through this experience with him. And there's no better way to learn as a wonderful weirdo than to do it with your kiddo. this experience Recording weird schooling and listening to all the guests has really empowered me to make decisions like, Hey, you know what, we're going to drive a couple of hours.
We're going to go do this different thing. We might be the only, mother child pairing there, but we're going to do it because I think that this might be just the kind of weird experience that's going to give you value and benefit that you can take with you into your life. I had the added bonus of getting to kind of relight a fire for education and policy and advocacy that I didn't realize was still burning in me.
So Maxwell, this is kind of one of the first times we've gone to something like this where it was all adults and then you were really one of the only kids here. what was this experience like going to an education symposium?
Maxwell: Well, I love the food. It was great. I love how this was sort of like a symphony and people wore a symposium, a symposium, like, like a symphony. Oh, okay. And people were just wearing. Bad clothing, like they, they all looked respectable, which I liked. the restrooms in the service were top notch and they spoke very, very well.
Jennie: How would you compare this learning environment to whenever we would just do research by just reading and looking online? Like, what's the difference? This is
Maxwell: a lot better because...usually the writers are doing that for money as people doing it for actual change like the writers went to get the clicks or You to buy that book. Mm hmm. Okay I'm not saying that all of them do that. Okay, but But what
Jennie: was it like, so, so there's a quality issue. Yes.
Maxwell: This, this one is quality and they're trying to convince us something and they are truly doing this plainly for America. And I think that you can rely on the source.
Jennie: So Maxwell, if you had to rate on a scale from one to 10, your understanding of the education policy after we had just done our internet research at home, what would you say it was? Just, just after internet research at home?
Maxwell: I would say that out of, after my research at home and looking at the sources about Senate bill one, I would say I knew it like a five.
Jennie: Now what about today after leaving the education symposium and talking to representatives and policymakers and policy analysts, um, what would you say on a scale from one to 10?
Your knowledge is now.
Maxwell: I think I learned it around nine. Uh, I think I learned it at a nine just because I learned more specific numbers and I learned more about the Pacific view on one side of the debate.
Jennie: And last, what is something that you think that you'll remember after leaving this?
Maxwell: What I will remember is the food. The food?
Jennie: The food, the food. In addition to the food, is there anything other than the delicious food and the jar full of jelly beans?
Maxwell: The jar containing the jelly beans. What else do you think you'll remember? Uh, uh, what I would actually remember is I would remember all the people that spoke up for America.
Jennie: Okay. And last, would you recommend doing something like this to a friend? Or what would you say to another homeschool student who might be nervous to do something like this? Or another student might be nervous. Uh, if you can't
Maxwell: Sit in a room for two hours at a time, don't do it, is what I recommend.
Jennie: Okay. Would you
Maxwell: recommend it to someone? Yes, I would definitely recommend it to some people. I think it's a very good learning opportunity that's more in depth than what you could just find at a website.
Jennie: Okay. Well, cool. Thank you, Maxwell. I'll remember bringing you. Thank you for joining me for this very special episode of weird schooling. Thank you also to all of the wonderful people at the symposium who made my son and I feel so welcomed. And so. included in the entire process. Thanks for whoever put out that big old thing and jelly beans.
Maybe thank you, maybe no, thank you. But it really made the experience special for him. And thanks to every single person who modeled excellent leadership, poise, adulthood, and, public speaking skills for my guy, learning how to be a public speaker himself. I also am so grateful for the community that we have that gave him the opportunity to.
dive into this passion for public speaking and then present it in a public forum amongst his peers and their supporters as well. Most importantly, thank you so much to Maxwell for inspiring me for being a partner, for being a growing aspiring ally for people who need help and support and for thinking thoughtfully and evenly and fairly about both sides of the issue with real purpose and passion.
I'm inspired by you every day. And I'm hoping that this conversation between my son and I can inspire other wonderful weirdos out there to take different paths, go on journeys, do things that don't seem obvious, because almost without a doubt, you're going to learn something along the way. And those experiences bear wonderful fruit, even if those fruits are jelly bean flavored.
Sarah: Weirdschooling is a My Kind of Weird Productions podcast and is co-created by hosts Sarah Woolverton-Mohler and Jennie Ziverk Carr with music by Brooks Milgate.
Jennie: You, your ideas and feedback MATTER, so like, subscribe and leave a review! Share your weirdschooling experiences or challenges on our social media channels at instagram, facebook, or our website at www.weirdschooling.com.
Sarah: We’re here for you– so feel free to join our engaging Weirdschooling Community Facebook group for inclusive, open-hearted idea sharing and camaraderie.
Jennie: You’re dismissed to go be the weirdest brick in the wall of this wonderful world!
<Original bright, organ and piano sea shanty music fading in the background with school bell sound.>
(bonus post episode banter)
Maxwell: Alright that’s enough. Cut.
Jennie: How’d I do?
Jennie: You did so well.