النص 🔗
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:13,460
You may have heard of genes that act selfishly, organisms that adapt in order to survive,
2
00:00:13,460 --> 00:00:17,240
ecosystems that behave as cohesive units.
3
00:00:17,240 --> 00:00:21,160
Biologists often talk about these things as though they were purposeful, exhibiting
4
00:00:21,160 --> 00:00:24,320
agency directionality or function.
5
00:00:24,320 --> 00:00:25,320
Should they?
6
00:00:25,320 --> 00:00:31,160
That's the big question that brings together the experimentalists, theoreticians and philosophers
7
00:00:31,160 --> 00:00:34,040
involved in the biological purpose project.
8
00:00:34,040 --> 00:00:40,000
This is the Purpose Podcast, where we will hear different interpretations of agency directionality
9
00:00:40,000 --> 00:00:47,080
and function, how people use these interpretations to solve real world problems and tackle long
10
00:00:47,080 --> 00:00:49,600
standing questions in biology.
11
00:00:49,600 --> 00:00:52,320
Welcome to Episode 5, I'm Siddharth.
12
00:00:52,320 --> 00:00:56,240
In this episode, we will be talking to Sharbell Elhany.
13
00:00:56,240 --> 00:01:00,880
So okay, so I'm a food professor, Eastern philosopher of science in the Institute of
14
00:01:00,880 --> 00:01:03,520
Biology, Federal Universal Bahia.
15
00:01:03,520 --> 00:01:07,920
The traditional view in science predicts town ecosystems into its constituent parts, which
16
00:01:07,920 --> 00:01:09,800
are organisms.
17
00:01:09,800 --> 00:01:15,840
And it assumes that the role of the organism, the way the organism evolves, is to fend for
18
00:01:15,840 --> 00:01:22,280
itself, is to, it's adapted to survive in a given environment and maximize its reproductive
19
00:01:22,280 --> 00:01:23,280
offspring.
20
00:01:23,280 --> 00:01:25,160
That's evolutionary biology, right?
21
00:01:25,160 --> 00:01:29,040
But the way Sharbell thinks about it is slightly different.
22
00:01:29,040 --> 00:01:34,240
So we usually classify as we learn in high school, animals in ecological classes, predators,
23
00:01:34,240 --> 00:01:36,280
sprays, the composers.
24
00:01:36,280 --> 00:01:38,080
These are ecological functions.
25
00:01:38,080 --> 00:01:42,280
But these are ecological functions that we can call ecological functions activities, as
26
00:01:42,280 --> 00:01:44,640
Roberta Mielstein's proposes.
27
00:01:44,640 --> 00:01:51,720
And this is just a population level evolution that produces this kind of functioning.
28
00:01:51,720 --> 00:01:57,520
But then we also take these function roles, predators, consumers, and we put in a trough
29
00:01:57,520 --> 00:02:02,040
network, in a food network, which structures the ecosystem.
30
00:02:02,040 --> 00:02:05,600
And then these animals who are predators, prey, they're also playing a role in the flow
31
00:02:05,600 --> 00:02:08,160
of matter and energy in the ecosystem.
32
00:02:08,160 --> 00:02:10,000
So this is ecosystem level function.
33
00:02:10,000 --> 00:02:13,800
They are contributing to a capacity of the ecosystem.
34
00:02:13,800 --> 00:02:18,280
So what we say that's not, you don't need that selection level of the ecosystem, this
35
00:02:18,280 --> 00:02:24,720
kind of function, with an extension of the ecological function that each population plays,
36
00:02:24,720 --> 00:02:30,160
because they are now part of a larger whole, which has this capacity of cycling nutrients
37
00:02:30,160 --> 00:02:35,120
and allowing a flow of matter and energy pass through it in a way that they decrease the
38
00:02:35,120 --> 00:02:36,120
entropy.
39
00:02:36,120 --> 00:02:37,680
So that's another kind of function.
40
00:02:37,680 --> 00:02:42,600
We also have functions that ecological systems play in relation to social economical systems,
41
00:02:42,600 --> 00:02:45,280
which usually call ecosystem services.
42
00:02:45,280 --> 00:02:50,080
These functions are defined by the use of human beings, how human beings use resource
43
00:02:50,080 --> 00:02:51,080
and ecosystem.
44
00:02:51,080 --> 00:02:54,360
They are not functions for the ecosystem, they are functions for us.
45
00:02:54,360 --> 00:02:56,720
So they are defined by our goals.
46
00:02:56,720 --> 00:03:02,960
So this is a kind of external function ascribed to the ecological process.
47
00:03:02,960 --> 00:03:07,720
So there are three different ways of looking at the way ecosystems function.
48
00:03:07,720 --> 00:03:12,360
Is this stuff that organisms do for their own survival and maximize the numbers of their
49
00:03:12,360 --> 00:03:13,360
own species?
50
00:03:13,360 --> 00:03:19,760
There's a second kind, the things that organisms do for the continued existence of the ecosystem
51
00:03:19,760 --> 00:03:24,120
for matter to continue to flow through the ecosystem.
52
00:03:24,120 --> 00:03:30,720
And then there's the way of looking at ecosystem functions that only serve human ends.
53
00:03:30,720 --> 00:03:35,360
And if it's not already obvious, the third one is kind of bad.
54
00:03:35,360 --> 00:03:40,760
And even though this seems kind of abstract, that second way of looking at ecosystem function,
55
00:03:40,760 --> 00:03:46,480
why organisms contribute to the flow of matter and energy through an ecosystem for its continued
56
00:03:46,480 --> 00:03:52,400
function may be useful and beneficial not only to us, but to other organisms as well.
57
00:03:52,400 --> 00:03:58,080
Because if we want really to understand how can we build better, more sustainable relations
58
00:03:58,080 --> 00:04:01,280
with ecological systems, we need to understand their dynamics.
59
00:04:01,280 --> 00:04:05,080
I can take an example for agroecosystems for instance.
60
00:04:05,080 --> 00:04:09,000
This researcher just mentioned, Jefferson Coutinho, he works with agroecosystems.
61
00:04:09,000 --> 00:04:15,440
And his question is how can an agroecosystem have a diverse landscape planning such that
62
00:04:15,440 --> 00:04:20,960
a number of ecological processes that are
Load full transcript
typically interrupted in the typical green revolution
63
00:04:20,960 --> 00:04:23,400
model farming can be maintained.
64
00:04:23,400 --> 00:04:28,080
So if you take the green revolution model farming, which is usually monoculture based
65
00:04:28,080 --> 00:04:36,000
on planting hundreds and thousands of kilometers of the same thing, this model is completely
66
00:04:36,000 --> 00:04:38,000
anti-ecological.
67
00:04:38,000 --> 00:04:41,800
It doesn't fit into the dynamics of ecosystems.
68
00:04:41,800 --> 00:04:42,800
And this creates problems.
69
00:04:42,800 --> 00:04:47,240
For instance, there are some insects, they are just normal insects, but they become pests
70
00:04:47,240 --> 00:04:48,560
for the agriculture.
71
00:04:48,560 --> 00:04:53,440
And the reason is you plant one single crop and you take this insect that fits on that
72
00:04:53,440 --> 00:04:59,000
crop, then it immediately creates an immense amount of food for that insect.
73
00:04:59,000 --> 00:05:03,520
And you unbalance the population completely because they grow exponentially and they have
74
00:05:03,520 --> 00:05:06,800
a lot of food and they harbor the agriculture.
75
00:05:06,800 --> 00:05:10,560
So if you understand ecological dynamics, you can do agriculture different.
76
00:05:10,560 --> 00:05:13,760
This is what the agroecological movement proposes.
77
00:05:13,760 --> 00:05:17,520
So if you take the agroecological movement, they try to understand the functions, the
78
00:05:17,520 --> 00:05:22,280
components of the system plays in relation to the ecological process and try to mimic
79
00:05:22,280 --> 00:05:24,720
in the agroecosystem ecological process.
80
00:05:24,720 --> 00:05:29,440
So for instance, if you don't want pests, you just want regular insects.
81
00:05:29,440 --> 00:05:33,000
What you do is to plant a diverse of plants.
82
00:05:33,000 --> 00:05:39,400
And you, for instance, let's say you are planting ananas and our insects are very fond of eating
83
00:05:39,400 --> 00:05:40,640
ananas.
84
00:05:40,640 --> 00:05:45,680
But you have other plants that these insects fit much better on them.
85
00:05:45,680 --> 00:05:48,240
So we call this feeding electivity.
86
00:05:48,240 --> 00:05:52,880
So you find a plant that the feeding electivity of the insects much more for that plant that's
87
00:05:52,880 --> 00:05:54,400
not your plant of interest.
88
00:05:54,400 --> 00:05:57,200
And you plant these together with ananas.
89
00:05:57,200 --> 00:06:00,520
It's true that you lose space where you could be planting ananas.
90
00:06:00,520 --> 00:06:04,520
But then you don't need chemical defensives because you have this plant.
91
00:06:04,520 --> 00:06:12,560
So this is making our farming system which is one of the highest problems ecologically
92
00:06:12,560 --> 00:06:14,240
in our planet today.
93
00:06:14,240 --> 00:06:16,640
So our agrobusiness is destroying everything.
94
00:06:16,640 --> 00:06:19,760
And we start to make these with forests.
95
00:06:19,760 --> 00:06:24,160
You don't plant fields of soil, you plant forests.
96
00:06:24,160 --> 00:06:29,040
And if you plant forests, you make better agriculture in terms of sustainability.
97
00:06:29,040 --> 00:06:33,480
It can be productive because there are research showing productivity, but also productivity
98
00:06:33,480 --> 00:06:38,160
is not the only measure for the success of the system because you're looking at productivity,
99
00:06:38,160 --> 00:06:42,520
look at food security, you're looking at the organization of the rural communities, you're
100
00:06:42,520 --> 00:06:44,600
looking biodiversity.
101
00:06:44,600 --> 00:06:49,800
And this is because you understand how the ecosystem works and you try to first mimics
102
00:06:49,800 --> 00:06:55,360
the ecosystem dynamics into your agrocosystem and also make an agrocosystem that contributes
103
00:06:55,360 --> 00:07:01,680
at a landscape level with the natural ecosystems around because you need a natural ecosystem.
104
00:07:01,680 --> 00:07:07,600
So for instance, if you have bees, which are important pollinators of your cultures or crops,
105
00:07:07,600 --> 00:07:11,880
many times these bees, they nests in native ecosystems.
106
00:07:11,880 --> 00:07:16,600
So you need to have native ecosystems close to the crops because that's where the bees
107
00:07:16,600 --> 00:07:17,600
will reproduce.
108
00:07:17,600 --> 00:07:19,720
And while the bees don't have pollination.
109
00:07:19,720 --> 00:07:25,200
So there is a study in my state, people who plant passion fruit and they had a decline
110
00:07:25,200 --> 00:07:30,040
in pollination, it costs them millions of dollars of loss.
111
00:07:30,040 --> 00:07:34,560
And that's because they start planting passion fruit, passion fruit, passion fruit.
112
00:07:34,560 --> 00:07:37,240
And the bees, they need to pollinate the passion fruit.
113
00:07:37,240 --> 00:07:42,520
They live in the semi-arid environment around, but now they are kilometers apart, so they
114
00:07:42,520 --> 00:07:44,320
cannot pollinate.
115
00:07:44,320 --> 00:07:50,840
And the solution they do is to bring beehives, which costly and creates an ecological problem
116
00:07:50,840 --> 00:07:55,400
when they could do much better if they understand the landscape dynamics because they plant
117
00:07:55,400 --> 00:08:02,040
passion fruit in between the forest patches where the bees, the native bees that they
118
00:08:02,040 --> 00:08:06,720
don't need to pay for them, they are just there, they would be there to pollinate the
119
00:08:06,720 --> 00:08:07,720
passion fruit.
120
00:08:07,720 --> 00:08:14,120
So I think to understand ecosystem is a crucial, crucial for us to have a more sustainable
121
00:08:14,120 --> 00:08:21,080
mold relation with human, with a natural systems, because if you don't understand the systems,
122
00:08:21,080 --> 00:08:24,720
it's a game of chance that we can be sustainable.
123
00:08:24,720 --> 00:08:28,040
Sharpell is not a
philosopher in the classical mold.
124
00:08:28,040 --> 00:08:31,600
He works with large teams spread across the world.
125
00:08:31,600 --> 00:08:36,360
And he also works with indigenous and peasant communities on cultural exchange of ideas
126
00:08:36,360 --> 00:08:38,280
that feed back into his philosophy.
127
00:08:38,280 --> 00:08:42,720
I know you also work with a lot of indigenous and peasant communities.
128
00:08:42,720 --> 00:08:47,600
Can you talk about the importance of those kinds of interactions?
129
00:08:47,600 --> 00:08:48,600
Yeah, yeah.
130
00:08:48,600 --> 00:08:53,200
That's a great question, Sidham, because we have two lines of research in the lab, when
131
00:08:53,200 --> 00:08:55,320
is this an ecological function?
132
00:08:55,320 --> 00:09:00,400
There are these intercultural relations between knowledge systems.
133
00:09:00,400 --> 00:09:07,480
And you'll touch exactly where the two combine, because indigenous communities and local
134
00:09:07,480 --> 00:09:13,320
communities, they usually have a wealth of knowledge about the consistent dynamics.
135
00:09:13,320 --> 00:09:15,160
Their lives depend on that.
136
00:09:15,160 --> 00:09:20,760
And if you look at their knowledge and we are more humble.
137
00:09:20,760 --> 00:09:26,040
So you work, for instance, with an ethnic virtue that comes from a feminist thinker from
138
00:09:26,040 --> 00:09:27,960
India called Vrindadalmia.
139
00:09:27,960 --> 00:09:29,280
It's a relational humility.
140
00:09:29,280 --> 00:09:30,920
And it's a very complex virtue.
141
00:09:30,920 --> 00:09:35,200
It's the virtue that you self ascribe to you ignorance.
142
00:09:35,200 --> 00:09:37,840
And you ascribe knowledge to others.
143
00:09:37,840 --> 00:09:46,040
And then this is part of our training of our students that usually academics are very arrogant
144
00:09:46,040 --> 00:09:47,040
people.
145
00:09:47,040 --> 00:09:51,680
And usually when they are ignorant, they think they can solve themselves, the ignorance,
146
00:09:51,680 --> 00:09:56,120
or at most you look at scientific knowledge to solve ignorance.
147
00:09:56,120 --> 00:09:57,600
But we go beyond that.
148
00:09:57,600 --> 00:09:59,800
So we say there are things we don't know.
149
00:09:59,800 --> 00:10:03,440
And there are things other communities know which are not academics.
150
00:10:03,440 --> 00:10:07,960
And we can learn with them if you start building intercultural relations.
151
00:10:07,960 --> 00:10:13,920
It's run by Padish Bolletian who is an anthropologist from the Czech Republic and myself.
152
00:10:13,920 --> 00:10:20,800
And the way Charbel works with these communities is not, he doesn't study them like an outsider.
153
00:10:20,800 --> 00:10:23,080
It's a collaboration.
154
00:10:23,080 --> 00:10:27,560
Because you go to work in the community, they are trying to understand you.
155
00:10:27,560 --> 00:10:33,160
They are doing an anthropology of you researchers, of us researchers.
156
00:10:33,160 --> 00:10:35,560
Why we are doing an anthropology of them?
157
00:10:35,560 --> 00:10:37,680
So it's a game of mirrors.
158
00:10:37,680 --> 00:10:39,800
And we are trying to make this into a method.
159
00:10:39,800 --> 00:10:45,800
Then we went, in fact, I didn't go because I had got COVID two days before the trip.
160
00:10:45,800 --> 00:10:51,560
But one of our doctors students, Yulia Turska and Padish, they went to work with the one
161
00:10:51,560 --> 00:10:57,920
indigenous tribe in the, one Amerindian tribe in the Amazon called the Mebegokre.
162
00:10:57,920 --> 00:11:04,720
We whom Padish works for 22 years now and I began working much earlier, much more recently
163
00:11:04,720 --> 00:11:06,400
with them.
164
00:11:06,400 --> 00:11:15,400
And we talked to them about several narratives while planting with them or hunting with them.
165
00:11:15,400 --> 00:11:20,600
And we collected several stories that have to do with ecological functions.
166
00:11:20,600 --> 00:11:28,480
They tell us that the agute is a farmer, while the macaul is not a farmer.
167
00:11:28,480 --> 00:11:29,840
And why they say this?
168
00:11:29,840 --> 00:11:39,120
Because the agute they plant the Brazil nut seeds, while the macaul they destroy the
169
00:11:39,120 --> 00:11:41,200
Brazil nut seeds.
170
00:11:41,200 --> 00:11:46,400
But interestingly enough, the agute is a farmer of Brazil nut.
171
00:11:46,400 --> 00:11:54,320
Out of a maniol, a cassava, it is not a farmer, it's still cassava, because they don't do
172
00:11:54,320 --> 00:11:55,680
anything about cassava.
173
00:11:55,680 --> 00:12:01,880
If you translate this into our theory, what we would say is the agute has the ecological
174
00:12:01,880 --> 00:12:04,400
function of being a grunivore just as the macaul.
175
00:12:04,400 --> 00:12:09,760
But the macaul doesn't play the ecosystem level function of contributing to the germination
176
00:12:09,760 --> 00:12:15,840
of trees, which are quite central to the composition structure of the Amazon forest, like the Brazil
177
00:12:15,840 --> 00:12:20,280
nut, while the macaul doesn't play the ecosystem function.
178
00:12:20,280 --> 00:12:22,520
So that's why the agutes are farmer.
179
00:12:22,520 --> 00:12:30,600
The agute is a genus of many species of rodent that's found in Central and South America.
180
00:12:30,600 --> 00:12:37,520
And according to Charbell's conception, the agute serve the ecosystem function of being
181
00:12:37,520 --> 00:12:39,320
a gardener.
182
00:12:39,320 --> 00:12:44,960
So that contribution to the ecosystem is to continue to maintain the ecosystem, which
183
00:12:44,960 --> 00:12:50,440
is the contribution of every organism within that ecosystem.
184
00:12:50,440 --> 00:12:57,280
And his work is trying to figure out how we can understand the contributions of all organisms
185
00:12:57,280 --> 00:13:03,960
within an ecosystem in maintaining that ecosystem, not simply in maintaining itself.
186
00:13:03,960 -->
00:13:08,720
And the work that he does with these indigenous communities on cultural exchange takes him
187
00:13:08,720 --> 00:13:09,720
quite far from home.
188
00:13:09,720 --> 00:13:12,400
It's a really long journey.
189
00:13:12,400 --> 00:13:14,720
It's very hard to reach there.
190
00:13:14,720 --> 00:13:17,160
It's as expensive as going to Europe.
191
00:13:17,160 --> 00:13:26,160
It will take a plane from Salvador and fly like three and hours and a half to either
192
00:13:26,160 --> 00:13:30,880
one of two cities, either a city called Altamira or a city called Maraba, depends on the price
193
00:13:30,880 --> 00:13:32,800
of their flight.
194
00:13:32,800 --> 00:13:34,840
And then they have to take us there.
195
00:13:34,840 --> 00:13:39,320
So the indigenous people, they come with the cars and they take us there and takes like
196
00:13:39,320 --> 00:13:48,160
12 hours by land to reach their indigenous land, 12 hours by land, or if you go by boat,
197
00:13:48,160 --> 00:13:51,880
it's very pleasant, but they have a very organized society.
198
00:13:51,880 --> 00:14:01,400
So we do something that we call mutirão is a word in Portuguese for doing things, everybody
199
00:14:01,400 --> 00:14:02,400
together.
200
00:14:02,400 --> 00:14:09,720
So we do research in a way that we try to work with the whole group, it's like 300 people.
201
00:14:09,720 --> 00:14:15,040
So there are meetings where they meet in their ceremonial place and all of them are there.
202
00:14:15,040 --> 00:14:18,120
And then they participate.
203
00:14:18,120 --> 00:14:23,880
But we have two people who are the representatives, Bepecois, Chikrins, and Catoprores, Chikrins.
204
00:14:23,880 --> 00:14:25,880
And they talk with us all the time.
205
00:14:25,880 --> 00:14:31,240
So while we are not there, they are doing things and they sign the papers with us.
206
00:14:31,240 --> 00:14:37,680
So for instance, with that Gootie paper, we have now a first draft and Pali is sending
207
00:14:37,680 --> 00:14:43,360
through WhatsApp the argument to them, because no point to send a Word document for them
208
00:14:43,360 --> 00:14:45,200
to not do that.
209
00:14:45,200 --> 00:14:51,920
And then we record the arguments and then they record back saying that's correct, that's
210
00:14:51,920 --> 00:14:54,160
correct, this should change here.
211
00:14:54,160 --> 00:14:59,320
And sometimes there is more information that is needed, then they get the information.
212
00:14:59,320 --> 00:15:05,920
Now see a lot of people work with indigenous communities with local people to get information
213
00:15:05,920 --> 00:15:08,920
on the local biodiversity.
214
00:15:08,920 --> 00:15:10,960
They have them as guides to take them through forests.
215
00:15:10,960 --> 00:15:12,840
They usually pay them as well.
216
00:15:12,840 --> 00:15:19,600
But given the level of intellectual exchange between these communities and Charbel, I
217
00:15:19,600 --> 00:15:23,040
had to ask whether they get authorship.
218
00:15:23,040 --> 00:15:24,040
And this is what he said.
219
00:15:24,040 --> 00:15:25,560
Usually they are the first halfers.
220
00:15:25,560 --> 00:15:26,560
Is there knowledge?
221
00:15:26,560 --> 00:15:33,960
This is a very unusual way of doing science or doing philosophy.
222
00:15:33,960 --> 00:15:41,880
Not only is it a challenge, a lot of academic orthodoxy, it's also a lot of work.
223
00:15:41,880 --> 00:15:44,800
So why go through all this?
224
00:15:44,800 --> 00:15:48,960
We can learn by being challenged by the order to think the unthinkable, what you are not
225
00:15:48,960 --> 00:15:49,960
thinking.
226
00:15:49,960 --> 00:15:58,840
Instead of seeing their worldview as imaginary or mythical or simply sort of quaint and interesting,
227
00:15:58,840 --> 00:16:01,400
Charbel actually sees intellectual value in this.
228
00:16:01,400 --> 00:16:08,520
He sees he thinks that something we, as in the rest of the world, can learn from this.
229
00:16:08,520 --> 00:16:14,960
The mode of human-nature relations we build is based on the relational value of using,
230
00:16:14,960 --> 00:16:21,560
utilization, which means that we are limited to talk about natural resources and rational
231
00:16:21,560 --> 00:16:23,640
use of natural resources.
232
00:16:23,640 --> 00:16:27,680
And all are talking about sustainability about that.
233
00:16:27,680 --> 00:16:31,080
And let's be frank, we are not very good at that.
234
00:16:31,080 --> 00:16:33,560
Because we are not getting any better.
235
00:16:33,560 --> 00:16:34,560
Any better.
236
00:16:34,560 --> 00:16:38,960
We talk about sustainable development since 1987.
237
00:16:38,960 --> 00:16:41,160
This concept is a complete failure.
238
00:16:41,160 --> 00:16:45,840
It generated a lot of development, much less sustainable.
239
00:16:45,840 --> 00:16:48,560
So we are failing as a society.
240
00:16:48,560 --> 00:16:53,440
And if you look at the Amerindian people, now we know that a significant part of the Amazon
241
00:16:53,440 --> 00:16:58,520
forest is not a pristine environment, like is described for people.
242
00:16:58,520 --> 00:17:04,440
It's a domesticated environment in several places, where we can see that hotspots of biodiversity
243
00:17:04,440 --> 00:17:10,640
in Amazon, they map with the places where the Amerindians were living, where they were
244
00:17:10,640 --> 00:17:18,200
capable of increasing the fertility of the land, of the soil, up to a thousand percent,
245
00:17:18,200 --> 00:17:23,800
and create something we call the dark earth, the dark lands of indigenous people, which
246
00:17:23,800 --> 00:17:27,400
map to hotspots of biodiversity of the forest today.
247
00:17:27,400 --> 00:17:29,040
So these people are living in the forest.
248
00:17:29,040 --> 00:17:35,080
We know now from the archaeological record new data, there are even cities inside the
249
00:17:35,080 --> 00:17:40,960
Amazon with a hundred thousand people living there, and they're not
doing what we are doing.
250
00:17:40,960 --> 00:17:42,560
The forest is there.
251
00:17:42,560 --> 00:17:49,560
They live in the forest, the forest is standing, and they don't have a mode of utilization
252
00:17:49,560 --> 00:17:51,840
of using.
253
00:17:51,840 --> 00:17:54,360
This concept doesn't mean anything for them.
254
00:17:54,360 --> 00:17:58,360
Sustainability, rationality, the use of natural resource, natural resource doesn't make a
255
00:17:58,360 --> 00:18:04,560
sense because they have an idea about nature that Europeans called anthropomorphism.
256
00:18:04,560 --> 00:18:10,400
And there are bad words, like saying they are primitive people.
257
00:18:10,400 --> 00:18:15,440
Instead of just saying they are same things we don't believe, we should open up our ears
258
00:18:15,440 --> 00:18:18,040
and say, well, what you can learn from that?
259
00:18:18,040 --> 00:18:24,920
The first thing we can learn is if some people think everything is human.
260
00:18:24,920 --> 00:18:29,520
They don't use the word human, they use the word peoples.
261
00:18:29,520 --> 00:18:32,640
Everything in nature is a people.
262
00:18:32,640 --> 00:18:36,040
So an aguti is a people.
263
00:18:36,040 --> 00:18:39,920
The aguts are people because they are the center of their ontology, they are the center of
264
00:18:39,920 --> 00:18:40,920
their world.
265
00:18:40,920 --> 00:18:45,360
The jaguars are peoples because they are the center of their world, and we are people because
266
00:18:45,360 --> 00:18:49,120
we are the center of our world.
267
00:18:49,120 --> 00:18:55,880
And then what this means is that every being is a social being too.
268
00:18:55,880 --> 00:18:58,480
And so we should be careful.
269
00:18:58,480 --> 00:19:04,920
We should be careful to deal with nature, with animals, plants, as careful as we are to deal
270
00:19:04,920 --> 00:19:07,960
with another human being.
271
00:19:07,960 --> 00:19:14,760
And this is why they build a model that people in conservation call the ritualized mode of
272
00:19:14,760 --> 00:19:16,760
relation of nature.
273
00:19:16,760 --> 00:19:21,680
It's ritualized because we humans, we ritualize the relations between ourselves.
274
00:19:21,680 --> 00:19:23,240
So they ritualize everything.
275
00:19:23,240 --> 00:19:30,880
And that's one basic reason why they can live in the natural system much better than we.
276
00:19:30,880 --> 00:19:36,200
And this has all to do with natural norms because if every being in the world is a people,
277
00:19:36,200 --> 00:19:40,960
all of them have their norms and we need to negotiate norms all the time.
278
00:19:40,960 --> 00:19:42,720
You have to negotiate norms.
279
00:19:42,720 --> 00:19:44,720
And so you cannot simply go there.
280
00:19:44,720 --> 00:19:48,520
I could hunt one aguti, I would hunt a hundred.
281
00:19:48,520 --> 00:19:49,920
No, you can't do that.
282
00:19:49,920 --> 00:19:54,280
You have to obey the rules, the norms.
283
00:19:54,280 --> 00:19:59,560
So I think this idea of natural norms with science usually rejects can be very important
284
00:19:59,560 --> 00:20:04,600
to build another way of relating with nature that we deeply need.
285
00:20:04,600 --> 00:20:07,760
And doesn't matter if it comes from science or not, in fact.
286
00:20:07,760 --> 00:20:15,720
And the norms are that for ecosystems to survive, every organism that lives in that ecosystem
287
00:20:15,720 --> 00:20:21,520
has to serve a function that supports the continued existence of that ecosystem, even
288
00:20:21,520 --> 00:20:25,560
if that organism thinks it is separate from the ecosystem.
289
00:20:25,560 --> 00:20:30,400
We interfere with ecosystems with our goals, our social goals.
290
00:20:30,400 --> 00:20:36,920
And by doing this, if we don't do what the indigenous people do, we don't negotiate our
291
00:20:36,920 --> 00:20:39,320
norms with the natural norms of the ecosystem.
292
00:20:39,320 --> 00:20:44,760
When we don't do this, we create problems for the dynamics of the ecosystem.
293
00:20:44,760 --> 00:20:48,760
You can say for instance, fire in a savanna ecosystem is integrated with the dynamics
294
00:20:48,760 --> 00:20:49,760
of the system.
295
00:20:49,760 --> 00:20:53,000
So when a savanna gets fire, there's no problem.
296
00:20:53,000 --> 00:20:57,400
Because this will be important for the savanna, in fact.
297
00:20:57,400 --> 00:21:01,200
But we go and build a lot of cities in between the savanna houses.
298
00:21:01,200 --> 00:21:02,800
Then what you do?
299
00:21:02,800 --> 00:21:04,680
We add more fuel.
300
00:21:04,680 --> 00:21:07,520
Because the savanna has its fuel to take fire.
301
00:21:07,520 --> 00:21:10,760
Is the plant adapted species were flammable.
302
00:21:10,760 --> 00:21:12,520
But then you have houses.
303
00:21:12,520 --> 00:21:14,720
Then you have a gas station.
304
00:21:14,720 --> 00:21:17,520
Then we increase the magnitude of the fire.
305
00:21:17,520 --> 00:21:22,280
And this fire can go beyond the threshold that the natural norms of the system can handle.
306
00:21:22,280 --> 00:21:27,960
And that's when the fire becomes destructive for an ecosystem that always leaves the fire.
307
00:21:27,960 --> 00:21:32,960
There was not never problem fire, but we had problems because we are fulfilling our goals.
308
00:21:32,960 --> 00:21:37,480
We can fulfill our goals because we need to pay more attention to the goals of the natural
309
00:21:37,480 --> 00:21:39,960
system and negotiate better.
310
00:21:39,960 --> 00:21:42,760
Then we can really be more sustainable.
311
00:21:42,760 --> 00:21:47,840
If we don't do this, sustainability is a ship dream.
312
00:21:47,840 --> 00:21:51,160
So what do we do about it?
313
00:21:51,160 --> 00:21:52,880
Can we do anything about it?
314
00:21:52,880 --> 00:21:56,880
We are using 2.5 Earths per year of resources.
315
00:21:56,880 --> 00:21:57,880
So how can we develop?
316
00:21:57,880 --> 00:21:59,720
We cannot develop.
317
00:21:59,720 --> 00:22:01,880
We need to move back.
318
00:22:01,880 --> 00:22:06,720
Because we cannot use not even one Earth resource, because there are other beings on Earth.
319
00:22:06,720 --> 00:22:15,960
So the idea of developing sustainably is like you earn $10,000 per month, but you want
320
00:22:15,960 --> 00:22:16,960
to live on $20,000.
321
00:22:16,960 --> 00:22:18,760
And you think this will work.
322
00:22:18,760 --> 00:22:20,360
We know this will not work.
323
00:22:20,360 --> 00:22:22,480
So we know in our house this does not work.
324
00:22:22,480 --> 00:22:26,040
So it's amazing how in planetary terms we think this will work.
325
00:22:26,040 --> 00:22:28,400
But it's because the alternative is quite serious.
326
00:22:28,400 --> 00:22:34,240
The alternative is that we change completely our mode of political and economic organization.
327
00:22:34,240 --> 00:22:40,200
Because the only way we can do that is by distributing income globally.
328
00:22:40,200 --> 00:22:43,920
So that people who are starving can have things to eat.
329
00:22:43,920 --> 00:22:51,000
Because for instance, me in Brazil as a middle class guy or many Americans, we are living
330
00:22:51,000 --> 00:22:54,040
four or five times better than we need.
331
00:22:54,040 --> 00:22:59,960
And we need now to share with the rest of the world for the poor to be able to eat.
332
00:22:59,960 --> 00:23:04,640
Well, but that's the end of the modern state here.
333
00:23:04,640 --> 00:23:10,440
So we are thinking about a quite radical political reorganization.
334
00:23:10,440 --> 00:23:11,440
I know what you're thinking.
335
00:23:11,440 --> 00:23:13,280
This all sounds a bit too radical.
336
00:23:13,280 --> 00:23:14,280
It's too unrealistic.
337
00:23:14,280 --> 00:23:15,280
Well, Sharper knows.
338
00:23:15,280 --> 00:23:20,560
It would be a little difficult to think about the next election.
339
00:23:20,560 --> 00:23:25,480
The next election in the US or in Brazil can date for the president.
340
00:23:25,480 --> 00:23:32,560
He says, well, we need to decrease the quality of life of the Americans or the Brazilian
341
00:23:32,560 --> 00:23:36,280
because we need to help people in Africa who are starving.
342
00:23:36,280 --> 00:23:41,800
It's been very unlikely to win the election.
343
00:23:41,800 --> 00:23:44,520
So with modern states, we cannot really do that.
344
00:23:44,520 --> 00:23:50,240
We need some kind of global civilization, which we really don't have.
345
00:23:50,240 --> 00:23:52,800
And perhaps we create a problem we cannot solve.
346
00:23:52,800 --> 00:23:57,240
Because no Marx once wrote that humans create problems that they can solve.
347
00:23:57,240 --> 00:23:59,880
I think he wasn't wrong.
348
00:23:59,880 --> 00:24:02,840
That is a really dire note to end on.
349
00:24:02,840 --> 00:24:07,080
And you may be thinking that, of course, there are solutions.
350
00:24:07,080 --> 00:24:09,640
We will switch to renewable energy.
351
00:24:09,640 --> 00:24:11,240
We will recycle.
352
00:24:11,240 --> 00:24:12,800
We can change our ways.
353
00:24:12,800 --> 00:24:16,320
If each of us just does their bit, we can get through this.
354
00:24:16,320 --> 00:24:20,400
I'm going to leave a video in the description that I think does a good job of explaining
355
00:24:20,400 --> 00:24:25,200
why each of us doing our bit might never be enough.
356
00:24:25,200 --> 00:24:29,440
And as for those energy transition goals, there are several reports that have been coming
357
00:24:29,440 --> 00:24:33,680
out that say that we're far behind the goals we set out for ourselves.
358
00:24:33,680 --> 00:24:37,800
I wish I had something reassuring to say, but I don't.
359
00:24:37,800 --> 00:24:39,760
And maybe that's okay.
360
00:24:39,760 --> 00:24:46,000
Maybe it's okay to face the full reality of existential dread and not have an easy answer
361
00:24:46,000 --> 00:24:48,840
to sugarcoated with.
362
00:24:48,840 --> 00:24:52,200
That's all from this episode of the Purpose Podcast.
363
00:24:52,200 --> 00:24:57,520
The Purpose Podcast is brought to you by the Biological Purpose Project, funded by the
364
00:24:57,520 --> 00:24:59,560
John Temperton Foundation.
365
00:24:59,560 --> 00:25:06,400
To learn more about the Biological Purpose Project, you can visit biologicalpurpose.org.
366
00:25:06,400 --> 00:25:19,680
Thank you for listening.
367
00:37:36,400 --> 00:38:02,320
So if humans do not contribute to the functioning of ecosystems, ecosystems will be developed.
368
00:38:02,320 --> 00:38:04,380
you
369
00:38:32,320 --> 00:38:34,380
you