النص 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: This is Macpherson Angle. Well, good evening and thanks for joining me. Here's what's coming up on the Macpherson Angle. Anthony Albanese has apologised for being caught joking at the climate conference that roaming warning might make Chris Bowen's pants uninhabitable. Melbourne used to be one of the great cities of the world. These days, the CBD is riddled with crime and the iconic Flinders Street station riddled with rats. I'll talk to Herald Sun associate editor James Campbell later in the show about what it will take to fix Melbourne. And why is the British government spending British taxpayer money teaching British young people to be good European citizens? Tom Slater will join me live from London shortly. But first, the Victorian election went into overdrive today with both the Liberal and Labour parties officially launching their campaigns. The Labor campaign launch began, as you would expect, with a welcome to country that went for five minutes. Now, the problem is Victoria doesn't have five minutes. With a daily interest bill of $ 24. 4 million, Victorians are paying $ 85, 000 every five minutes just to service the debt inflicted on them by this Labor government. Nevertheless, here's how Ben Carroll's campaign began.
00:01:14
Speaker 2: Good morning, everyone. How are we?
00:01:18
Speaker 3: Glad off.
00:01:22
Speaker 2: I'm honoured to be asked to welcome you all here today on the lands of my ancestors' country.
00:01:27
Speaker 4: Its purpose is to.
00:01:28
Speaker 2: Show respect, protect the spirit and physical safety of visitors and formally grant permission for events to take place on our country. I'm extending this for the next two weeks as we lead into pre-poll and election day. I've asked country and ancestors to protect us all and keep us all safe during this time.
00:01:48
Speaker 1: But a five-minute welcome to country wasn't enough. When Ben Carroll got up to speak, he felt the need to perform his own acknowledgement of country, which I'd show you except I like you, so I won't. Having performed a special acknowledgement for the 1% of voters who identify as Indigenous, the Premier then performed another acknowledgement that was significant for who was not acknowledged. See if you can pick the obvious omissions. I also want to acknowledge the Deputy Prime Minister, Richard Mayles, Deputy Premier, Gab Williams. Former Premiers Steve Brax and John Brumby. Now, I'm confused. Were people cheering because he acknowledged former Labor premiers Brax and Brumby, or were they cheering because he didn't acknowledge former Labor premiers Dan Andrews and Jacinta Allen? Neither of them were present for Labor's campaign launch. Despite Dan Andrews being such an esteemed Labor leader, he's worthy of a statue, and despite Jacinta Allen having led the Victorian Labor Party right up until just 15 weeks ago. I can't imagine why they were missing. Although, here's a clue. And yes, we could have done some things better. Labor
Load full transcript
could have done some things better. He's being modest. I mean, apart from law and order, the budget, energy policy, road maintenance, hospital waiting times, infrastructure cost blowouts, business confidence, integrity and transparency, I can't really think of much they could have done better. I had to laugh when Ben Carroll told those assembled that the road ahead would be tough. Half a million potholes will do that. And then he described what Victoria needed most, which I have to admit, I thought was a pitch for people to vote Liberal. It requires hard decisions and careful management of the budget. Speaking of the Liberal Party, they began their campaign launch without any welcome to country. Instead, those assembled stood to their feet and sang the national anthem. Now, Jess Wilson wasn't wrong when she told her supporters how Labor would campaign over the next two weeks.
00:04:05
Speaker 3: We also know that the Labor Party and Union Machine will throw everything at us. They will flood the airwaves with desperate lies and rubbish to muddy the water. We have a Labor government that cannot speak to its record. So they resort to scare campaigns and personal attacks.
00:04:28
Speaker 1: And like I said, she was not wrong. Here's Victorian Labor's latest election campaign ad, as predictable as a machete fight at Northlands Shopping Centre or Epping Plaza or Broadmeadows Central.
00:04:39
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:04:41
Speaker 5: Jess Wilson's pretty new.
00:04:42
Speaker 6: What are five things you think I should know about her?
00:04:45
Speaker 7: Well, firstly, she's the daughter of Ron Wilson, who was a Liberal MP in the Kennet government. Secondly, she was a prefect at Strathcona, which is an elite private girls' school, fees of over $ 40, 000 a year.
00:04:58
Speaker 1: Jess Wilson's dad once wore a MAGA hat. But wait, it's worse than that. Jess Wilson's dad sent her to an expensive private girls' school. If the worst they can say about Jess Wilson is that her dad likes Trump and that her dad sacrificed big time to make sure she got a good education, I think Jess Wilson is going to be just fine. I'll talk a little later in the program to national politics editor at The Herald Sun, James Campbell, about the respective campaign launches and how he expects the next fortnight to play out. I thought Jess Wilson's campaign launch today was good, and I want to like the Victorian Liberals. Really, I do, but, baby, do they make it difficult sometimes. It'd be easy to get caught in the fanfare of Jess Wilson's performance today, but I think it's important not to forget her performance on this network during the week just gone when she was asked why she had so quickly matched Labor's ghoulish promise of free abortions if you vote for us. Ben Carroll's promise was the sort of moral grotesquerie We've come to expect from a socialist government that regards power not as a responsibility, but as an appetite to be fed. But Wilson's response was hardly reassuring. Why had she matched Labor's offer? Here's what she told Paul Murray's audience when asked about it during the week.
00:06:17
Speaker 3: Can I acknowledge from the outset that there are a range of views on this issue and deeply held and strongly held.
00:06:25
Speaker 1: Well, yeah, we're discussing how to treat the unborn, so you'd hope people had some deeply held views about that. But then came the explanation, and I've got to say, it was a doozy.
00:06:37
Speaker 3: Let me talk a little bit about why I made that decision and my view.
00:06:41
Speaker 1: Let me cut in for a second. Remember, she's explaining why she took all of five minutes to agree with Labor that taxpayers should provide free abortions.
00:06:50
Speaker 3: I wasn't going to allow a desperate government to run a scare campaign on women's health care and to distract from the issues that are really important at this election. Keeping Victorians safe, fixing our roads, repairing the budget.
00:07:07
Speaker 1: She wasn't going to allow the small issue of whether expenses associated with aborting the unborn should be funded by the taxpayer to become a distraction from important issues? Is she for real? Don't get me wrong, I'm as annoyed by potholes as the next guy in a low-slung sports car, but Jess Wilson, really? As for not wanting to let the issue of abortion distract from the issue of keeping Victorians safe, in my opinion, she's going to make her mother's womb more dangerous in order to make the CBD safer? Is that really the compromise? There's also a question here that seems to have escaped the Liberal leader entirely. Might there be some connection between a society's casual disregard for the most vulnerable human life and it's growing indifference to human life elsewhere. Now, maybe not. Maybe these things are entirely unrelated. Maybe we can teach children that human life is precious while simultaneously teaching them that some human lives are negotiable. Like me, you'll have your own views. You might think I'm completely wrong, and that's fine, but I would have thought the question was at least worth considering. Alas, in the end, there appears to be only one consideration for Jess Wilson.
00:08:14
Speaker 3: This was a desperate scare campaign from a desperate premier and I simply wasn't going to allow it to become an election issue.
00:08:22
Speaker 1: So you matched it? Why not have the courage to call out Ben Carroll's grotesque desperation rather than immediately lowering yourself to his level? Labor offers something morally grotesque and rather than explain why it's wrong, the Liberals rush to offer their own version in the hope that nobody notices the difference. Politics first, principles later, if there's time. And right now, well, there's an election to be won. And that's the exact thing that makes people nervous about voting for the Liberals. Remember Angus Taylor's warning to the Liberals after their loss to One Nation in the Faribault election?
00:08:57
Speaker 4: For too long, we have been a party of convenience, not of conviction.
00:09:05
Speaker 1: And that must change. Angus Taylor was absolutely right. I just hope Jess Wilson and the Victorian Liberals heed that call. Well, spare a thought for lefties. It's been a bruising weekend. Their troubles began with an announcement on Friday that police would not be charging Sydney Swans players with sexual assault. The so-called Pullman Five, who posed as carpenters to hire strippers who were then quickly reimagined by the left as exotic dancers... are free to get on with life. There wasn't enough evidence to charge them with anything other than poor judgment and that, at least for the moment, is not a criminal offence. Were they stupid blokes being stupid blokes?
00:09:49
Speaker 8: Yes.
00:09:49
Speaker 1: Were they Russell Brand? Not even close. Between the lapse of judgment and a crime lies a vast moral canyon and a great many left-wing commentators had already built condos on the wrong side of it. Every second lefty with a phone, a blue sky account and an unhealthy appetite for public denunciations likely now owes the Swans an apology. Not least of all, the Governor-General, Sam Mostyn, had seized on allegations against the Swans as an opportunity to lecture the AFL and men more generally about their moral shortcomings. She told the ABC after the incident and well before the police investigation had been finalised, the lack of respect for women across the country remains an issue for us all to be concerned about. Well, quite so. And the lack of respect for the legal principle of innocent until proven guilty also remains an issue for us all to be concerned about. Just as the left was beginning to process the possibility that the Sydney Swans players might not, in fact, be the sexual predators they'd been enthusiastically imagined, along came another calamity. St Patrick, the one associated with reverse swing rather than the three-leaved shamrock, threw lefties into a complete spin. The left's favourite cricket captain and unofficial ambassador for the moral superiority of renewable energy held a press conference in which he effectively called the left's other cricket darling, Usman Khawaja, a liar. Khawaja had suggested that everyone knew about ball tampering during Australia's 2018 tour of South Africa. Cummins was not having any of that.
00:11:24
Speaker 9: When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew Sam Pape was going out on the field, he's 100% wrong. He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper. That's complete and utter nonsense. I think the way he's kind of been quite casual and flippant with people's lives in Australian cricket, I don't think that's OK.
00:11:49
Speaker 1: St Patrick also dismissed Khawaja's suggestion that he'd been overlooked for the Australian captaincy because of his skin colour, saying he'd never seen anything in Australian cricket that could be seriously categorised as racist.
00:12:02
Speaker 9: To think that the job that I hold is quarantined from people based on their skin colour, that's a pretty big statement. I think if you're going to say that, I think you've got to have some evidence. And I just don't think that's the case. There's nothing very, very racist that I've seen in the past and there's definitely nothing that I've seen in the last eight years.
00:12:27
Speaker 1: Well, as you can imagine, all of this presented the left with a rather awkward problem. For years, Cummins has been celebrated as proof that Australian sport can produce not merely great athletes, but enlightened citizens who understand that cricket is a platform for lecturing the rest of us about things like climate change. But now St Pat has gone and challenged the claims of a Pakistan-born Muslim, thereby threatening the cherished left-wing conviction that racism is so deeply embedded in Australian culture it can never be sandpapered over. Worse, Cummins has left progressives with no choice but to side with David Warner. David Warner, the man whose public relations strategy once appeared to consist largely of looking angry while wearing a cricket shirt. Imagine the existential distress. You have to laugh. So when your favourite climate crusader contradicts your favourite diversity crusader, who exactly are you supposed to believe? Just a week ago, Cummins was a progressive pin-up. Now he's nowhere. And worse, the Swans AFL players, well, they're not even sexual predators. Thank God the weekend is almost over. There's only so many inconvenient facts a political movement can be expected to absorb in 48 hours. Well, Chris Bowen has told COP 31 delegates that temperatures in his trouser pocket must be kept to within two degrees Celsius of pre-industrial levels or his nether regions will be doomed. Australia's climate change minister warned that without strong action to reduce warming, parts of his trousers would become uninhabitable, forcing the mass displacement of whatever lives down there. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese agreed, insisting this is why it was so important Australia did not withdraw from the pants agreement. Sorry, I'm confusing global warming and the Paris Agreement with a conversation between the PM and Bowen on the sidelines of the climate summit in Turkey over the weekend about how heat from their mobile phones might adversely affect the Labor member's member for downstairs. The pair were caught on a hot mic discussing warming, not from carbon emissions but from their iPhones, and the territory under threat was not the ends of the earth but the end of the man. If you missed the exchange, here's how it went down. Keep your phone here. Generally, yeah.
00:14:55
Speaker 6: It should be on there.
00:14:56
Speaker 8: It should be a little bit away from your hand.
00:14:59
Speaker 1: It's certainly missing. It could interfere with the rhythm. A little bit of radioactivity. Yeah, I'm more
conscious. It's rather important.
00:15:07
Speaker 4: That's right.
00:15:08
Speaker 1: Arguably more important than the heart. To be fair, I think Bowen's position is perfectly understandable for a man in his 50s and possibly the most honest thing a politician has said at an international summit since one of them admitted he was only there for the buffet. Perhaps this explains the minister's passion for climate action. It was never simply about polar bears, Pacific islands or the future of humanity. It was a more intimate constituency, completely without a lobby group to protect it. Somewhere in the developing world, a farmer is wondering whether his crops will survive another drought. Somewhere in the Pacific, a family is wondering whether their home will disappear beneath the ocean. Meanwhile, Chris Bowen is wondering whether his iPhone is cooking his... The Prime Minister's office described the whole exchange as a joke. Of course, astute observers note that's exactly what the oil industry said about the greenhouse effect back in 1988. I can't wait for the Greens to come out with a policy seeking an immediate ban on gas in trousers. But seriously, after hearing Bowen's concerns that iPhone warming may damage his precious, suddenly all past statements from UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres make sense. Humanity is in the hot seat. And here I was thinking humanity's seat was a metaphor, but no, for Chris Bowen, it's evidently quite literal.
00:16:34
Speaker 10: The era of global warming has ended.
00:16:37
Speaker 4: The era of global boiling has arrived.
00:16:42
Speaker 1: And all the boiling is happening in Chris Bowen's trousers. I fully expect the European Union to claim jurisdiction to deal with Bowen's problems since they have an entire bureaucracy experienced in regulating the curvature of cucumbers. And I can't wait for Greta Thunberg to call for the complete phasing out of trousers by 2023, which, according to her Twitter feed, was when the world ended. Workplace Relations Minister Amanda Rishworth was asked this morning about the conversation between Albanese and Bowen. Here's what she said.
00:17:11
Speaker 5: This is a private conversation in between meetings. I know that a hot mic incident is very exciting for people. It's interesting. But really, there are bigger issues to tackle and to discuss. And so I think, quite frankly, a joke between two people, we shouldn't get overexcited by it.
00:17:35
Speaker 1: Excited? Minister Rishworth, no one was excited by that conversation. Everyone's outraged. The PM and his energy minister are in Turkey throwing away taxpayer money like it's confetti to undermine the resources sector that underpins our entire economy while treating the whole thing as a bit of a lark. As for her comment that there are surely bigger issues to tackle, I don't think there's any question about that. To his credit, the Prime Minister owned up about the conversation. I, of course, regret that and I apologise.
00:18:09
Speaker 11: This was a private conversation, we thought, between two friends having a bit of lighthearted banter. You know, that happens and no one was hurt or harmed.
00:18:25
Speaker 1: And that's true. No one was hurt or harmed. And Chris Bowen might want to keep his phone out of his pocket to ensure things stay that way. Well, joining me now is Shadow Regional Health Minister Anne Webster. Anne, good evening to you. I want to talk to you about COP31, but it's difficult to go past the conversation caught on hot mic between Elbow and Bowen. Do you agree with Amanda Rishworth that this is a bit of a storm in a teacup, or does that candid moment reveal something more about our political leaders?
00:19:00
Speaker 12: Thank you, James. It's great to be with you, of course. And for our Prime Minister and the Minister for Energy to be caught on a hot mic is fantastic. bizarre in itself because they're very experienced politicians but to be having the primary school little boy conversation that they were having and then to effectively dismiss it just goes in line with the deep bush summit the embarrassment that the prime minister has been To all of us as Australians, with his melon jokes and his Kylie shagging, I mean, seriously, I don't think this Prime Minister could degrade the Post more.
00:19:46
Speaker 1: I guess the only good part about it is that at least the Prime Minister didn't deny that it had happened. So there is that. We're making progress, Anne. We've spent a huge amount of money at this climate conference in Turkey, not least of which on accommodation for the PM and Chris Bowen. It was revealed today a basic garden view room at the resort where they're staying starts at $ 1, 600 a night. Now, bear in mind, Chris Bowen is there for two weeks. What does that say about Labor's regard for the public purse?
00:20:19
Speaker 12: Well, I don't think they have a regard for the public purse. They see Australian taxpayers' money as their personal slush fund that they can throw $ 147 million at this, you know, maybe up to $ 2, 000 a night for a hotel room and while Australians are struggling to put food on their table. We've been talking about the cost of living crisis now for a long time. And it just seems to me that Labor are tin-eared, do not understand it, do not understand how tough people are doing. I mean, the Salvation Army are talking about enormous numbers of people who are coming for assistance to them across the nation. It is really tragic.
00:21:08
Speaker 1: So the question then has to be asked, what are we getting for all of this? Amanda Rishworth was asked that question this morning. Here's her reply.
00:21:16
Speaker 5: Well, I think what the Australian government has done is made sure, in partnership with the Pacific, that we are at the table discussing action on climate change.
00:21:29
Speaker 1: Okay, so we're at the table, a very expensive table, but here's the question again. What do we get? Have a listen.
00:21:35
Speaker 5: In particular, the Pacific, this is an issue that matters incredibly to the Pacific. They are at the front line of the impacts of rising sea levels. So to go in partnership with the Pacific to put our case forward is really important.
00:21:52
Speaker 1: And listening to that, it sounds like Australian taxpayers are forking out millions of dollars to represent the interests of Pacific Island nations.
00:22:02
Speaker 12: Look, the Pacific Islands are our neighbours and of course we want to behave in a neighbourly manner. That's why the Pacific Australia Labor Migration Scheme was developed under the Coalition to support those nations to get ahead, to develop their own economies. But what we have now is the Minister for Energy, pushing his presidency of negotiations at COP31 as his major job. And he's a part-time energy minister and We have in Australia Australians who are paying 40% more for their electricity under this government. And it's not getting better any time soon. And all the spin in the world that Chris Bowen wants to put on it will not change the facts. People cannot pay their mortgages, their rents, their electricity bills, food on the table. It is just harder and harder. Every day this government is in power.
00:23:05
Speaker 1: You've hit on a really good point. With Chris Bowen having an international role as the president of negotiations, who's representing us? Have a listen to UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres at the conference.
00:23:19
Speaker 10: Fossil fuels are driving the climate crisis. There is no credible path to a safe climate without moving away from them. Fossil fuel dependence leaves countries exposed to price shocks, geopolitical turmoil and instability. Changing suppliers does not solve the problem. Reducing dependence does.
00:23:46
Speaker 1: Well, that's all fine and dandy, but our entire economy relies on fossil fuels, not to mention what's left of our energy grid. So when this is the theme of the conference, who's representing Australia's interests? It can't be our energy minister because he's acting on behalf of COP.
00:24:03
Speaker 5: Absolutely.
00:24:05
Speaker 12: And he should be representing Australia's interests first. That is his primary job. And we are a country that is so rich in natural resources and energy and we export to the world. And the Minister for Energy is over there saying, no, no, no, we actually, we really want to shut all of this down and we want to just do renewables and hydrogen and we know how well that's going right now. It is absolutely dystopian fantasy land and you can't help feeling that he's gone over there to get a pat on the back for a job for the UN as opposed to Australia. I don't think there are many Australians who are particularly happy with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy now.
00:24:54
Speaker 1: I think you're absolutely right about that. Anne Webster, always a delight. Thanks so much for coming on the program this evening. All right, we're going to go to a break. Stick around after the break. Jackie Lambie comes up with a bizarre way to beat One Nation. And while lots of people have gotten their heads around driverless taxis, would you book a flight on a pilotless plane? I think I'm going to take a lot of convincing. Maybe my panel can change my mind after this. Well, Tasmanian Senator Jackie Lambie was asked about Pauline Hanson on the ABC this morning. Specifically, she was asked to explain the surging popularity of One Nation. Here's her explanation.
00:25:34
Speaker 8: If you think Pauline Hanson can step in tomorrow, run the country and fix all your problems overnight, you are terribly disillusioned. People are angry. They're under financial strain. I can tell you, I lived like that for 10 years and when you're under financial strain and your head is full of fog and you can't think properly... And you have all that pressure on you. You do really, really silly things and you don't think about things properly. And that's what's causing a lot of that is what's causing all that chaos out there.
00:26:00
Speaker 1: OK, so people are saying they'll vote for One Nation because they're under so much stress, they're not thinking properly. Jackie Lambie then immediately pivoted to the solution.
00:26:10
Speaker 8: Three out of every five people that are aged between 16 and 25 can't get the mental health that they need. So it's having all that mental health out there, it's having those psychologists, psychiatrists out there and making sure that we have plenty of them and we just do not.
00:26:28
Speaker 1: Presumably, once enough Australians have had their heads examined, they'll come to their senses and vote the Labor government back in again. Joining me now is Daily Telegraph Chief of Staff Jason Morrison and writer and broadcaster Kel Richards. Welcome to you both. Has Jackie Lambie struck on something here? Is the answer to defeating One Nation, Jason, more psychiatrists?
00:26:48
Speaker 4: She's not right. And when I say she's not right, you know what I mean when I say she's not right. Jackie's a snob. She thinks that, you know, that only she's enlightened enough to see what's going on in Australia right now. And the giveaway is the little definition about why people have strung this way. It is possible for people to be going through the fog of the crisis of what we're all living through right now and actually go, you know what, Coke and Pepsi, I'm not into them anymore. I'm going to try another brand. And that might be what's going on in Australia, despite what Jackie thinks. We're not all nuts.
00:27:20
Speaker 1: I think the more that our politicians talk about One Nation, Kel, the more they're inclined to persuade people to vote One Nation because, as Jason said, it's so insulting and not taking people's genuine concerns seriously.
00:27:34
Speaker 13: If you say people only want to vote One Nation because they are nuts, you are not actually taking One Nation
seriously. Can I put on my therapist hat and say, Jackie... Thank you for sharing. That was very warm of you. And our hearts go out to you, poor Jackie. But I'm not sure that explains One Nation. I mean, allowing for the fact there are some people with serious mental illnesses, you don't medicalise normal life. People get down a bit. It's not depression. It's just down a bit. I've just had a bad day.
00:28:03
Speaker 1: I'm a bit blue.
00:28:04
Speaker 13: And the idea that that explains One Nation is nonsense.
00:28:07
Speaker 1: Yeah, exactly. All right, the big story this week has been Usman Khawaja's claim that everyone in the Australian cricket team knew sandpaper was being used to scuff the ball during the 2018 series in South Africa. That's a claim denied by the Australian captain, Pat Cummins. I found the way in which it's been discussed to be quite interesting. Have a listen to this comment from commentator Tom Morris speaking to Gerard Waitley on SEN Radio.
00:28:31
Speaker 9: I thought today there might be a chance that we'd get some sort of resolution, that Cummins' truth might be.
00:28:38
Speaker 6: somehow dovetail into Usman Khawaja's truth.
00:28:42
Speaker 1: Kel, what's the difference between the truth and my truth? He talks there about Cummins' truth, Khawaja's truth. Maybe their truths will dovetail to... What is he talking about?
00:28:54
Speaker 13: The difference is this. truth exists. My truth doesn't exist. There's no such thing. There was this very good British analytical philosopher who spent a whole book discussing truth. And at the end of it, here's his conclusion. Truth, the word truth means how things are. It's no more complicated than that. And if you're talking about the past, how things were, that's Past tense. So Usman Khawaja said, here's how things were. I got up at a meeting of the team and I said, we should all take responsibility. Pat Cummings said, no, no one ever got up at a team meeting. No one has any memory of him getting up at a team meeting and saying, so either one is how things were or the other one is, you know, it's not true for him and not true for him. It's just absolute nonsense.
00:29:40
Speaker 1: Yeah, you can't have two opposite truths. That's right. You've got two opposite stories. Somewhere in there, there's the truth. Jason, does it frustrate you when journalists, and I like Tom Morris, good sports reporter, but As a chief of staff of a newspaper, does it frustrate you when journos start talking about his truth, their truth, my truth, your truth?
00:30:00
Speaker 4: Well, yeah, it is my truth that it's very frustrating because my truth is my opinion and that's it. Now, I have a feeling when you're talking about people's truths, you're becoming a barracker for that individual and journalism is not meant to be about that. It's meant to be about, as Kel pointed out, truth, an old-fashioned thing. The my truth thing, oh, I wish I could find the day it started because I'd love to be able to
stop the my truth because the my truth thing sort of, you know, it's like these phrases that just suddenly started being pumped at us and before that we never heard it and if only we could have shut it down on that day, we wouldn't be putting up with this because it is my truth that Usman Khawaja is very annoying. And it is my truth that this story needs to go away because it's my truth.
00:30:43
Speaker 9: It's boring.
00:30:45
Speaker 1: You know, I think it was actually Oprah Winfrey who sort of popularised the idea of my truth. So we're all living in an Oprah Winfrey world. God help us. I can't remember whether it was Charles Dickens or Jim Chalmers who said it was the best of times and the worst of times. Regardless, it's true. Here's the worst over the weekend. An oil tanker hitting and sinking a cruise ship in the port of New Orleans.
00:31:07
Speaker 4: Wow.
00:31:08
Speaker 3: Wow.
00:31:10
Speaker 1: Man.
00:31:14
Speaker 8: Wow.
00:31:17
Speaker 1: Now, guys, if you have not seen this, I've got to show you one more view. This is from inside one of the cruise ship cabins.
00:31:39
Speaker 14: Oh, gosh, hang on.
00:31:40
Speaker 1: Hang on, baby. Hang on, baby.
00:31:41
Speaker 13: Come on.
00:31:43
Speaker 1: Now, fortunately, everyone on board was rescued. But what's fascinating about that last grab is that they stayed there filming, only ran for their lives a couple of seconds before it hit. What does that say about human nature, James? It's weird, isn't it?
00:31:57
Speaker 2: It's weird.
00:31:58
Speaker 4: There's another video, and I don't know if it's true or not, but there's a video going around of somebody who's in the water filming themselves saying, I've just been thrown overboard.
00:32:06
Speaker 1: And you're thinking, what's wrong with this bloody world?
00:32:09
Speaker 4: I mean, imagine if it was Captain Scully that landed in the Hudson.
00:32:13
Speaker 1: That's right.
00:32:13
Speaker 4: If he'd just gone, we're going to the Hudson.
00:32:15
Speaker 1: Hang on a minute. What's changed?
00:32:18
Speaker 13: What you didn't see was his wife was beside him tugging at his sleeve and he's saying, no, no, no, I've got a good shot. I can't leave this.
00:32:25
Speaker 1: You know what it made me think is that Sometimes things are so unbelievable. I mean, you just can't imagine that the tanker is actually going to stop. And I wonder sometimes if I was in that kind of situation where I would immediately realize what's happening and flee or whether I'd be caught in this situation. state of disbelief and paralysed thinking, no, no, surely. And by the time you figure out what's actually happening, you're in real danger.
00:32:51
Speaker 13: And you think it's like your car. You put your foot on the brake. I'm sorry, with a tanker, you don't put your foot on the brake. It keeps going for a long time. All right.
00:33:00
Speaker 1: Well, that was the worst of the weekend. But in Texas, they were celebrating the best of times as Elon Musk did something that's never been done before. His company, SpaceX, launched a rocket that orbited Earth 14 times, deploying 26 satellites, travelling at a speed of about 27,000 kilometres an hour, before dropping, free-falling back to Earth, flipping upright to lodge gently in the launch tower. Jason, we sometimes easily forget we are living in extraordinary... I mean, there's a lot of problems, but we're living in extraordinary times.
00:33:59
Speaker 4: That's miracle stuff. Like, that is defying everything that we know. That is defying it. You know, this stuff is almost so unbelievable when you see it. The quality of the vision is so remarkable, it almost looks like it's been done in the sci-fi lab. And that is... Just to see that is extraordinary. I... I hope I'm around long enough to see the proceeds of all of this and where it takes us. But I know my kids will. And that's incredible.
00:34:25
Speaker 13: What I'd like is I'd like Elon Musk, having done that, to teach me how to pick up an olive in a pair of chopsticks because I can't manage it. And obviously you can, Elon.
00:34:35
Speaker 1: Well, I tell you, Google will provide humanoid robots that will do it for you, Kel. I just think sometimes, you know, you can become so cynical. and so downcast by all the stuff. And there's a lot to be downcast about. So I think it's important when you see stuff like that, that genuinely is historic. that you just take a moment and appreciate we're seeing things that our grandparents would never have believed possible. Before we go to the break, I want to talk about driverless planes. Driverless taxis are becoming common around the world. But what about pilotless planes? Reliable Robotics in the US has just gotten a billion dollars in funding to work on pilotless cargo planes. And obviously, if they can do it, pilotless passenger planes are would be next. Jason, I've got to ask, and I can tell by the look on your face what you're going to say here. Let's start with, would you go in a driverless taxi? That's the first question. I have been in a driverless taxi. You have? It is frightening.
00:35:35
Speaker 4: In Las Vegas, they were operating these things through tunnels. And even in a tunnel where there's really not where else to go and it's only you, you feel like saying, how is this thing going to stop? Because every inclination is to yell stop when it does.
00:35:49
Speaker 1: But it did.
00:35:50
Speaker 4: It did and it worked. And the first three or four times was frightening. And after that, it was fine. They use them as kind of shuttles around convention centres.
00:35:57
Speaker 1: But, you know, a.
00:36:01
Speaker 4: Taxi, I'm going to say you can kind of get out of a taxi, but you sort of can't get out of the plane. The test for me is The only way we really know someone's up the front of the plane is because a bloke comes over the PA system.
00:36:14
Speaker 1: And says, hey, gentlemen, welcome aboard.
00:36:16
Speaker 4: You know,
you just don't know. And most of it's being done by a machine until it really goes wrong anyway.
00:36:22
Speaker 1: I tell you what, next time I'm on a plane, now you've said that, I'll be thinking... Is that a human or is it AI?
00:36:27
Speaker 4: Is this a tape?
00:36:28
Speaker 1: We've only got 30 seconds left, Kel. Would you buy a ticket for a pilotless plane? How confident are you in technology?
00:36:33
Speaker 13: I came here on the Sydney Metro, which is a driverless train, but it has tracks underneath. 35,000 feet, that's different.
00:36:41
Speaker 1: I think I'm with both of you gentlemen. We will not be booking a seat on that flight. I appreciate you joining me. Thanks so much. Right, stick around. Coming up after the break, the Victorian election is Jess Wilson's to lose. And what will it take to fix Melbourne? James Campbell has some interesting suggestions and he joins me after this. I grew up in Melbourne and I love the place. I haven't been there for many years or lived there rather for many years, but still have a great affection for the place, not least because I'm a tragic AFL fan. And then there's the restaurants, the cafes, the shopping. It should be one of the great cities of the world. And it was always regarded as such. Not that much anymore, but maybe that's all about to change. The November election offers not just a change of government, but maybe a fresh start for Australia's second largest city. With early polling booths opening across the state on November 18 throughout this week, the Herald Sun and News 24 will provide the experts insights into what's gone wrong in Victoria and what can be done to fix it. Herald Sun Associate Editor James Campbell joins me now. James, welcome to the program. Just before we get into what it will take to fix Victoria, I'm keen to get your thoughts on the respective campaign launches today. Let's start with Labor. What do you think of Ben Carroll's launch and the fact there are only 200 people present?
00:38:04
Speaker 6: Well, a federal MP said to me he hadn't been invited and he was extremely grateful that neither he nor his colleagues had been invited to it, that they'd had to endure that on behalf of the poor old Ben. But yeah, it was one of those sort of shows where they have to crop in tight to make the audience look like there are more people there than there actually are. Look, they're in a world of hurt. They know they're in a world of hurt. Nobody really thinks they have any hope of winning this election. They're really down now. to trying to put a stake in the ground and kind of frame what's going to end up being an incoming government. They're basically, they're reduced to sort of saying that the incoming mob's numbers don't add up and therefore they will either have to cut more than they're saying they're going to do or they won't achieve the surpluses when they say they are. And the reality is most economists tend to agree with the government about this. But the fact
of the matter is nobody wants to hear from them anymore. They've had 12 years and people are sick of them.
00:39:26
Speaker 1: Excuse me.
00:39:27
Speaker 6: On the other hand, Wilson's was high energy. There were a lot of people there. You know, everybody loves a winner. The world, every lobbying firm at the moment, everybody's going through their address books, looking for unemployed liberals, trying to get them on the book because they know They're about to be running the show down here. Wilson is carrying an enormous burden. I mean, it's really the Jess Wilson caravan, Jess Wilson's show. She's young. She's interesting. People are warm to her.
00:40:05
Speaker 1: She had her.
00:40:05
Speaker 6: Family there today, a little boy who's two. You know, they're a great... She's a great package. They kind of... Sometimes political parties... just luck into a leader who clicks with the public. And in this case, they've done it with her. Labor, on the other hand, they got rid of Jacinta Allen and hoping that this guy would do better. And he's just looks like he's a nice guy, but he just sort of looks like a bit of a stumble bum. He can't walk and talk and chew gum at the same time. And they're heading for a massive, massive defeat. And everyone I know thinks it is, in this occasion.
00:40:41
Speaker 1: Richly deserved. Well, it's certainly Jess Wilson's election to lose. I want to move on to some other things, but just very quickly, who will be the official opposition in Victoria after the election? Will it be the Labor Party or will it be One Nation?
00:40:57
Speaker 6: Well, some polls have One Nation, you know, neck and neck with Labor, but no, Labor, it'll be Labor.
00:41:03
Speaker 1: Because the Liberal....
00:41:05
Speaker 6: Yeah, One Nation. I think One Nation are going to do OK. You know, they're going to get a lot of seats upstairs in the upper house. Probably there's eight. They'll have one in each reason. So I'll have at least eight MPs, maybe more. And they'll probably they could have up to six or eight lower house. Interestingly, I think most of those seats will be taken off Labor, not off the coalition.
00:41:25
Speaker 1: OK.
00:41:26
Speaker 6: I think it's going to really change the whole national conversation about One Nation, the fact that they're We're winning these seats off Labor, not off the coalition.
00:41:34
Speaker 1: Yeah, good point. Good point.
00:41:35
Speaker 14: All right.
00:41:36
Speaker 1: As I said, the Herald Sun has run or is running a series of articles about what experts say it will take to fix Victoria. Run me through some of the big ideas, particularly as they pertain to Melbourne.
00:41:49
Speaker 6: Well, I think the most exciting one, I think, was the one that Chris Lucas, Melbourne's legendary restaurateur, Chris Lucas was named Melburnian of the Year last night. He basically wants us to create a giant sort of Hudson Yard style redevelopment that would run all along the Yarra from Richmond Station next
to the MCG all the way down past Flinders Street down to Banana Alley, almost connecting up with the casino. He wants to demolish Federation Square, thinks that's been a dud. He wants to demolish everything but the facade of Flinders Street, and he wants to throw this redevelopment opportunity, cover the rail yards, over to the private sector. He thinks that if you basically, the government and the local council got out of the way and let the private sector have their way, they would fund it, they would build it, and it would basically revitalise the whole.
00:42:50
Speaker 1: Of the city.
00:42:50
Speaker 6: His point is that the centre of the heart of Melbourne is Flinders Street Station and that area. And it is effectively basically a derelict building. It's a very tired, rat infested building that's sort of empty aside from the bits where the trains come. And he thinks, you know, we need to follow the The examples, I think, what Abu Dhabi's done, basically we need, and Athens has done, land around the airport, like a huge urban renewal project is really what he's looking for, he thinks, is the way to bring Melbourne's mojo back. And it's worth considering because it certainly needs to come. We need it back. There's no doubt about that. Every Melbournian who visits Sydney knows that we're slipping further and further behind, I think.
00:43:44
Speaker 1: I tell you what, any plan to demolish Fed Square, which I've always hated ever since they built that thing, it's ugly. No one really wants to be there. There's nothing to attract anyone there. Get rid of that and do something better. And Flinders Street Station, you're right, it's old, it's tired, it's decrepit. It should be magnificent. That's not a bad idea. James Campbell, I appreciate you joining me this evening. Thanks so much. And for viewers, don't miss the special Fixing Vic series focusing on health, crime, infrastructure, education, cost of living, debt and the state's mojo, as James Campbell said. That's on News24 and at theheraldsun.com.au right through this week. All right, we're going to go to a break. Coming up, the British Labor government is spending millions to convince British young people they should become good European citizens. And William and Kate about to embark on their first working foreign trip together in four years. Tom Slater joins me after this. You know, you'd think governments would be keen for universities to instil national values or at least encourage them within young people. But the British Labor government is using British taxpayers' money to fund uni courses that promote European values and European citizenship. Joining me now is Spiked Online editor Tom Slater. Tom, it's arguable that there's no such thing as European values. What's Andy Burnham pushing and why is he doing it with British taxpayer money?
00:45:12
Speaker 14: Why exactly? I mean, this is classic Labour in the sense that they seem to love the European Union almost as much as they feel uncomfortable and dislike Britain itself. This is, of course, part and parcel of us getting back into the Erasmus scheme, this sort of student exchange, which is largely uncontroversial. But this part of it, that you have to fund these Jean Monnet classes for students across the country, is something which is just straight up pro-EU propaganda. Because the European Union is such a kind of phony, artificial thing, that even people who on balance support being in it, there's not much love or affection for it. They always feel the need to kind of preach its values, preach its citizenship. And if you look at the content of some of these classes in France, for instance, it's even things like it's not celebrating democracy or European civilisation or the genuine sort of liberal inheritance that we might glean from our shared history. It's about things like the Green New Deal in the European Union, which is being supported. So it's completely phony. It's totally obnoxious. And given the fact that we did vote to leave the European Union, having to pay for this propaganda in our own universities is utterly absurd.
00:46:16
Speaker 1: Yeah, well, we here in Australia know a little bit about what it's like to vote that we don't want something, only to have governments at federal and state level say that we're going to have a version of it anyway. So we're feeling your pain. While we're talking about UK universities, have a guess what the overwhelming majority of Jewish parents look for when considering which university to enrol their teenager in. Not just the fees, not just the facilities, not just academic results, but, Tom, 96% of Jewish parents in the UK.
00:46:46
Speaker 1: Said antisemitism was a major factor when deciding where to send their kids to university. And even then, many uni applicants told researchers they were deliberately omitting anything that might identify them as Jewish when enrolling at a British university. Are you surprised by this?
00:47:04
Speaker 14: Sadly not. I mean, the issue of antisemitism in higher education or education in general has been sort of an open secret for many years now, even before October the 7th, this is something that you would see the level of hostility that say university Jewish societies or pro-Israel societies would face when they hosted a speaker or just had any form of event was on a scale that you would not see in relation to any other form of speaker, any other form of event, the kind of low level and just interpersonal abuse that they would suffer is something that has Again, been around for a long time, but it's gotten a lot worse since October 2023. There was an independent review earlier this year by Sir David Bell, who found that one in five students had witnessed acts of anti-Semitism during their time at university, and that raised to three in five for Jewish students. So this is a real national shame. It's something that the government is paying lip service to the need to tackle by this review and its recommendations and what have you. But this poll just shows that it's becoming something which... really tragically is front and centre of young Jewish people and their parents' minds when they send them out into the world. That should not happen in Britain in 2026.
00:48:10
Speaker 1: Yeah, it's shocking for that to be happening anywhere, but particularly in the UK. We might as well finish with some good news. Kate and William are on their way to India for some charity work. It's the first time they've travelled overseas for work together in four years, back in 2020. 22 was the last time they travelled together for work. Kate, of course, having been restricted by her cancer treatment. This is good news, isn't it? No, it's really good news.
00:48:39
Speaker 14: I mean, when Kate went abroad to Italy on a solo trip a little earlier this year, she had this great reception. There's clearly a hell of a lot of affection for us. To see them going out and doing royal duties as a couple was something that can only be a good thing. And just a reminder that the royal family seems to be appearing out of this quite difficult time that they've had with the cancer struggles, not only in relation to Kate, but also the King. And it seems like they're now turning a corner and I'm sure they're going to get a very positive reception.
00:49:06
Speaker 1: I was just going to say, Tom, with all of the stuff that's been happening, I mean, you know, we could name five, six, seven scandalous stories involving the royals. To have Kate and William back front and centre must be a great relief for the monarchy.
00:49:24
Speaker 14: Absolutely, because as you say, it's not just been these sort of personal struggles with health, with family as well, if you think about the Harry and Meghan rupture in the House of Windsor at the moment but just the fact that it laid on top of that scandal after scandal and this is I suppose going to be an attempt a reminder of what the royal family is supposed to perform at its best you know forget the scandal forget all of the unseemly things you've been reading about in the press going out and doing these kinds of events is precisely what they want the monarchy to be associated with and there is so much affection as well for William and Kate in a way that is I think untarnished by a lot of what's been taking place elsewhere in the royal family in recent years I.
00:50:02
Speaker 1: Was going to say, when you say untarnished, I don't know there's many royals that are untarnished, but certainly they are. And it's great to see them back on duty. Tom, always great to chat. Thanks so much. And thanks to you at home for joining me. I really appreciate it. I'll see you tomorrow night on The Late Debate. But right now, here's Paul Murray.