النص 🔗
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:09,808
Jamin Warren: you are a part of a machine and this machine will continue with or without you. but no one individually can actually stop that machine from actually like functioning. And that to me felt like
2
00:00:09,842 --> 00:00:10,149
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
3
00:00:10,162 --> 00:00:17,722
Jamin Warren: that is a more powerful way to think about industrial farming as opposed to just saying Hey, it's wrong to wrong to kill animals.
4
00:00:16,481 --> 00:00:16,791
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
5
00:00:17,722 --> 00:00:19,415
Jamin Warren: Hello, Danny. How you doing?
6
00:00:19,246 --> 00:00:19,590
Danny Snelson: Hey
7
00:00:19,590 --> 00:00:21,968
Danny Snelson: Jamin. Good, good to see you.
8
00:00:21,968 --> 00:00:26,391
Jamin Warren: I had trouble sleeping last night for I told myself yesterday,
9
00:00:25,092 --> 00:00:26,388
Danny Snelson: Ha ha ha
10
00:00:26,391 --> 00:00:40,679
Jamin Warren: I was like, I told my wife, I was like, I'm gonna turn off my phone and don't tell me anything about what's going on. I can't, I can't I can't real time election results anymore. I'm I'm too I I it's too it's too too fraught. But then every time the T V or something would be on, or
11
00:00:40,235 --> 00:00:40,625
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
12
00:00:40,679 --> 00:00:43,580
Jamin Warren: I hear my wife be like, Ha ha you know
13
00:00:42,683 --> 00:00:43,626
Danny Snelson: The blue wave is
14
00:00:43,626 --> 00:00:45,273
Danny Snelson: a turbulent ride.
15
00:00:44,736 --> 00:00:45,537
Jamin Warren: I yeah,
16
00:00:45,537 --> 00:00:54,902
Jamin Warren: to live through a a generational there hasn't been a moment like this in American politics in fifty fifty years. Yeah.
17
00:00:52,896 --> 00:00:55,047
Danny Snelson: No, it it's wild. Yeah. It it's
18
00:00:55,047 --> 00:01:04,445
Danny Snelson: it's absolutely incredible. And there are so much of the news is just the most depressing things you can imagine. And so to be like, fuck yeah, Abdul, or like right
19
00:01:03,989 --> 00:01:04,353
Jamin Warren: I know.
20
00:01:04,445 --> 00:01:10,360
Danny Snelson: now, but it's still like, yeah, I guess we we don't know what our mayor is yet. Like Karen Nitya are still like neck and neck
21
00:01:09,880 --> 00:01:10,206
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
22
00:01:10,360 --> 00:01:16,495
Danny Snelson: and like the votes are coming in. So it's that like I don't know, it's like the Super Bowl, but it like lasts for three days or like two weeks
23
00:01:16,086 --> 00:01:16,458
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
24
00:01:16,495 --> 00:01:17,948
Danny Snelson: or like two months.
25
00:01:17,948 --> 00:01:19,305
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah, no. So
26
00:01:18,334 --> 00:01:19,434
Danny Snelson: But also can I get
27
00:01:19,434 --> 00:01:22,586
Danny Snelson: some frustration that Prop forty failed? you know, we
28
00:01:22,231 --> 00:01:22,557
Jamin Warren: I know.
29
00:01:22,586 --> 00:01:31,640
Danny Snelson: have a chance to like actually have a
Load full transcript
billionaire tax, like a one-time five percent billionaire tax, and everyone's like, no, no, I don't want. It's too much. We
30
00:01:30,691 --> 00:01:31,616
Jamin Warren: I stuff like that.
31
00:01:31,640 --> 00:01:34,791
Danny Snelson: have to preserve, we have to save our poor billionaires who spent, I think
32
00:01:34,296 --> 00:01:34,675
Jamin Warren: I know.
33
00:01:34,791 --> 00:01:37,032
Danny Snelson: what, like 160 million dollars in ads.
34
00:01:37,217 --> 00:01:56,398
Jamin Warren: I know. I like part of the issue is that there is no there's no there's there are people who obviously a very small cohort of people for whom it's very important this doesn't pass and everybody else, but there's no like there's no ad campaign in defense of prop 40. And so it just makes it very easy. It doesn't help that, you know, the governor obviously doesn't want it for obvious
35
00:01:55,692 --> 00:01:56,078
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
36
00:01:56,398 --> 00:02:04,190
Jamin Warren: reasons. And so it's just very hard. You have a position that is like morally very clear, but it still needs like a a paid advocate. And so it's like well who's who's
37
00:02:03,627 --> 00:02:04,114
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
38
00:02:04,190 --> 00:02:04,752
Jamin Warren: the party that
39
00:02:04,973 --> 00:02:10,425
Jamin Warren: should be responsible for that. In any case, for those who are do not live in California or in the United States
40
00:02:09,635 --> 00:02:10,259
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
41
00:02:10,425 --> 00:02:20,681
Jamin Warren: for that matter, it was it's been a it's been a a a good a good day for good day for democracy. and yeah I had a little time actually last week when we were talking about Threshold to reflect a little bit on on on that
42
00:02:19,522 --> 00:02:20,678
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
43
00:02:20,681 --> 00:02:30,556
Jamin Warren: made this I feel like a a good good natural good natural segue. one of the things I think with Prop 40, one of the challenges is this question of like enumeracy and how
44
00:02:29,822 --> 00:02:30,240
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
45
00:02:30,556 --> 00:02:31,348
Jamin Warren: do you
46
00:02:31,348 --> 00:02:39,504
Jamin Warren: get people to understand what large numbers functionally mean. what does it mean to say someone has a billion dollars and why that is
47
00:02:39,296 --> 00:02:39,547
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
48
00:02:39,765 --> 00:02:56,189
Jamin Warren: so much more than a million dollars. It's not just a question of zeros, but it's like, like with the, you know, with Ray and Charles Eames's famous film, The Powers of Ten, that kind of like goes from a picnic table to, you know, out to a universe back down to the size of an atom. Alice Bucknell, the artist, has referenced that and I think their new work for for
49
00:02:56,189 --> 00:03:22,904
Jamin Warren: for for some of their new work as well. And so this question of how do you get people to understand in their bones what it means to have a billion dollars
in a way that is not just a doesn't feel like a doesn't feel prescriptive, but actually has like some sentimentality to it. I think that's a lot of like what's at heart with like selling this idea. I mean there's a moral argument for people like, no, no one should have this much money, you know, all billionaires are a tax failure, et cetera, et cetera. But there is this sense like in politics that like you do need to get people to sort of like
50
00:03:22,904 --> 00:03:31,764
Jamin Warren: feel that if you were on the fence of what that means. And so you try to do it in some ways. One is like to say Jeff Bezos could buy a Porsche every single day for the rest of his life, But that's still
51
00:03:31,447 --> 00:03:31,733
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
52
00:03:31,764 --> 00:03:37,981
Jamin Warren: about numbers, And so I think there is this open question of how do you get people to feel numbers in their bones,
53
00:03:37,497 --> 00:03:37,801
Danny Snelson: Yes.
54
00:03:37,981 --> 00:03:40,563
Jamin Warren: when maybe they don't understand them like logically.
55
00:03:40,582 --> 00:04:09,128
Danny Snelson: Yeah, and I I know we're segueing into to thinking about Threshold, which I think is such a a poignant way to think about this. But it's it's also the power of metaphor to to address scale. I write about actually my book, The The Little Database, which is all about scale. Like how do you get people to recognize scale? And think that's one of the things that a lot of people are having a hard time with, say with like hyperscale data centers. Like you can't say, you know, it's like so so it's such and such square feet or so many square miles because like it's hard to understand that. But you can say something like, it's two thousand Walmarts. It's the size
56
00:04:09,128 --> 00:04:20,782
Danny Snelson: It's like or it's like it's like two Manhattans, the the one they're building in Utah, for example. It's like, okay, like there's some kind of like metaphoricity that that aids in scale. And I think these kinds of games well we'll we'll talk about it. I won't jump the gun. But I I think that
57
00:04:20,147 --> 00:04:20,740
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah.
58
00:04:20,782 --> 00:04:31,511
Danny Snelson: is one of the challenge with these billionaires. Like, you know, the the staggering amount of money that they have accumulated, which is like doesn't come from nowhere. It comes from all of us. Like it
59
00:04:29,726 --> 00:04:31,543
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Right, right, right. Yeah, that's the other part of
60
00:04:31,543 --> 00:04:49,327
Jamin Warren: the problem. It's like this connection between the individual and the the the the the individual and the near infinite, that the two are connected. It does not come from it does not come from yeah, it does not come from from from nothing. It's all these a little accumulated. I've heard you Matt Stoller Zeit talks about economic termites, right? That there are these little
61
00:04:48,626 --> 00:04:49,166
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
62
00:04:49,327 --> 00:04:58,775
Jamin Warren: these businesses that shave a little bit here, a little bit there, all along, all on the way, take a little bit and aggregate adds up to,
63
00:04:59,015 --> 00:05:21,518
Jamin Warren: godly amount of money. in any case it's a good segu to talk about Threshold. That was my playlist peak pick from last week. It was a game that was released in 2024 by a solo French developer and artist named Julien. I had a great conversation with him about two weeks ago. He worked at Arkane, Legendary Studio Arkane. And then he left in the summer of 2023 and he started making this game called Threshold on the side.
64
00:05:21,518 --> 00:05:48,333
Jamin Warren: The the premise is very simple. You wake up in a mountain work camp. There's very little air, there's very little oxygen. You have this coworker, this very terse coworker named Mo, spooky. Mo is like the, if you look at the thumbnail, Mo is the character, the featured character. Mo shows you all of these different chores that you basically have to do. So at one point there's some white crud that's like accumulated over this storm grape. at another point, there's there's sort of there's planks that are kind of distributed around the property.
65
00:05:48,333 --> 00:06:15,661
Jamin Warren: But the the main thing that you do is you punch your tickets. You have these little little ticket cards that you use. You're really trying to keep this train in the background against this valley. It's kind of this perspective. This valley is set inside of this mountain town. There's this train that is just running endlessly, endlessly at different speeds. And there's a little, there's a little gauge, a little monitor that tells you when the train's moving too fast and the train's moving too slow. And you have a whistle. And so when the train slows down, you basically, you basically blow it.
66
00:06:15,899 --> 00:06:45,052
Jamin Warren: Now, the catches obviously it's a very it's like very telling is like, well, what is the thing? What is the thing on the train? what why is this train so important? What have I been asked to do? Nobody's gonna tell you what's on the train. and there is this a bit of a mystery in this game as well. There's someone who's worked in the town before you, this person named Ni, and was trying to build something. There's supposed to be something out of this spare wood. And so through the crowd process of this game, it's only an hour, hour and a half. You basically pick up where you left off. That's really where the plots or the story piece of it really starts to.
67
00:06:45,052 --> 00:07:03,698
Jamin Warren: dig in you you alu there's this illusion Mo tells you there's this planks. Ni was trying to build something. And what Ni was trying to build was a bridge so that you can ultimately look inside. And there's really telling moment in the game where telling moment game you finally can reconstruct this bridge and look out and
it zooms in and it's just like animal carcasses, like more than you could
68
00:07:03,098 --> 00:07:03,575
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
69
00:07:03,698 --> 00:07:09,798
Jamin Warren: possibly count. And the game has been this process of basically counting all of these animal carcasses over
70
00:07:09,798 --> 00:07:19,296
Jamin Warren: a long, a long point of time. It's a really a really powerful work, really short work as well, which I, you know, I, you know, I love, but it really speaks to kind of this question that we were asking. It like, how do you get someone to
71
00:07:16,449 --> 00:07:19,224
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
72
00:07:19,296 --> 00:07:35,269
Jamin Warren: think when we say something is like a billion, what is it, what does it mean to really get a hold of that number? the first clip I have is I'll play this first is I spoke to Julien and I asked him about kind of what the starting point for the starting point for the for the game would be
73
00:07:55,116 --> 00:07:57,149
Jamin Warren: So that was this moment of realization
74
00:07:56,341 --> 00:07:56,647
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
75
00:07:57,149 --> 00:08:03,641
Jamin Warren: for mom of realization for Julien about the about the scale. have you had a moment like that? I guess encountering a a number
76
00:08:03,129 --> 00:08:03,411
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
77
00:08:03,641 --> 00:08:06,785
Jamin Warren: that made you really stop or took your took your breath away.
78
00:08:06,921 --> 00:08:32,605
Danny Snelson: Yeah, I think that's one of the I mean I I like returning to Eames and like the power of ten. like I love those visualizations. So you you know, that that film like zooms in and out from like a a picnic, like deep into a body and then like out to space. But I think you see those online all the time where it's sort of like the solar system, like you you start to see. I think the one I saw last week that I really liked was the like a demonstration of like the folding. like if you if you fold a sheet of paper a certain number of times and say, like, you know, the laws of physics with
79
00:08:32,605 --> 00:09:01,036
Danny Snelson: paper doesn't hold up. And so you get to keep having it. And like how quickly the exponential growth rate of of paper can like, you know, extend beyond the universe, like extend beyond the solar system, beyond the universe, and so on, from like a single sheet of paper. So I think it's like that, like I always get like really captivated by that like move from the microscopic to the macroscopic in in some kind of way. But connecting that to real numbers, yeah. Like I mean, I've been shocked by the I mean hyperscale data centers, I guess, is where I'm doing a lot of my research.
80
00:09:01,036 --> 00:09:30,307
Danny Snelson: And you know, there was the proposed Utah data center, which has been scaled back a bit, but it's supposed to take nine gigawatts. And and like that number, I was like, I like it it's really hard to like, unless you're like a like an electrical engineer, like it's hard to say like well, what does nine gigawatts actually mean? And it it and I had to like have this relation to the sense that like, the entirety of Utah only uses five gigawatts as a whole. And and like nine gigawatts is like how much energy like Manhattan uses, and that this like data center in a remote area in Utah is gonna use the same amount of energy. So like there's that
81
00:09:30,307 --> 00:09:42,403
Danny Snelson: I feel like yeah, th those numbers I that are incomprehensible or surprising, yeah, I find myself I think having that moment of surprise maybe, through some metaphorical relation.
82
00:09:42,403 --> 00:10:10,366
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. No, a hundred percent. I thought it was very smart that Julien was thinking about the target is not like the diet, the way that maybe games would normally approach something like this is to maybe focus on the like animal lives or that moral question. It's like, it's wrong, it's wrong to, you know, kill animals, or he's a vegetarian. He became a vegetarian, I believe like as part of that process. He says on tape, you know, one of things he said he's like he's not an activist in that in that sense. And so the animals are like how he kind of gets to this like bigger
83
00:10:10,366 --> 00:10:39,076
Jamin Warren: issue which is like that big numbers it's hard to really understand what it means to have big numbers. one of the readings I did for you know in preparation for for writing the piece was looking at Paul Slovic who's a writer who's writing about genocide there's obviously been a lot of writing about genocide and how things like happen what happens in particular. You obviously see this was happening like in Palestine but before Palestine there's been you know the you know there's Darfur, there's been Rwanda, there have been other genocides that have happened. And so he was asking this big question of like, okay, why is it that when presented with big numbers
84
00:10:39,076 --> 00:10:48,880
Jamin Warren: Or presented with something that you know is wrong, more, why do humans don't act? And there's this concept that's called psychic numbing is the name of term, which is
85
00:10:48,476 --> 00:10:48,844
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
86
00:10:48,880 --> 00:10:56,102
Jamin Warren: basically that we don't really feel much of a difference between saving 87 versus saving 88 lives, which is pretty nuts. And so the other
87
00:10:55,772 --> 00:10:56,065
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
88
00:10:56,102 --> 00:10:59,540
Jamin Warren: thing that happens is that you know, the other thing that happens is is that people
89
00:10:59,681 --> 00:11:07,297
Jamin Warren: the n the number of people that are required for you or the number once it get becomes two or more, basically you can see it basically drops off a cliff that when it's an intimate
90
00:11:06,933 --> 00:11:07,227
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
91
00:11:07,297 --> 00:11:29,972
Jamin Warren: one-to-one relationship, then
people are willing to or able to make the right decision. But in anything more than one, basically it's like I it's too it becomes like too abstract. So there's something about how our brains basically function that makes it very hard sometimes to do the thing that in aggregate is the right thing to do when but it's if we're not encountering it on a a very intimate like one to one, like individual individual basis.
92
00:11:29,972 --> 00:11:42,347
Danny Snelson: Yeah. And that's also an inside outside issue. I think, in a lot of writing around Last of Us, it's like, yeah, the whole game is about you're working to save this one young girl who who matters to you, but you're like slaughtering people left and right the entire time.
93
00:11:41,762 --> 00:11:42,122
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
94
00:11:42,402 --> 00:11:46,089
Danny Snelson: Because, you know, they're not like us, right? Like so it's like that like inside outside thing.
95
00:11:44,638 --> 00:11:45,779
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah.
96
00:11:46,269 --> 00:11:59,510
Danny Snelson: And so like I think that like establishment of like that one to one like intimacy or or sort of like intimate knowledge. I mean that's what the arts have always tried to do, right? Like, you know, like a first person perspective from a novel can like highlight the horrors of you know, genocide or
97
00:11:59,510 --> 00:12:23,373
Danny Snelson: systematic erasure or, these scales of human life that are too big to comprehend. But we can get like, I don't know, saving Private Ryan's view, or we can get like some kind of like or Anne Frank's view. And then like that somehow like stands in as a kind of metonymy for like large scale suffering, which our our human brains, like our simian brains have been like coded to have these like inside outside relationships and to like be able to care about certain things and not others. and and particularly
98
00:12:23,032 --> 00:12:23,339
Jamin Warren: It's it
99
00:12:23,373 --> 00:12:27,961
Danny Snelson: not like that that that cliff that you fall off when the numbers get bigger is I think like
100
00:12:27,968 --> 00:12:29,918
Danny Snelson: truly fascinating. Yeah.
101
00:12:29,918 --> 00:12:54,410
Jamin Warren: It's interesting. Slovic talks about literature as being one of the ways that you can create more intimate interactions. you create like more intimate interactions between between those be like pulling people into like a single a single human being, a single human being's life can be and can be can be really interesting. let's see here. the the one of the things I did want to talk about. So one of things that's i really interesting in Threshold is that when you start the game, you're presented with a map.
102
00:12:54,410 --> 00:13:20,356
Jamin Warren: Of well, not map, it's like a bunch of different countries with flags. And I think as game players, we're very familiar with those types of like choose your country, you know. it was really interesting, like you're thinking about when you start the game and you have all these countries, you're like, I'll just pick the country like where it's from. And Julien did this very smart thing where the country that you're from, it's actually like a proxy like difficulty slider and it's connected to basically sort of he has a sort of a I guess it's not an algorithm, but it's just like a formula that he uses.
103
00:13:20,568 --> 00:13:49,731
Jamin Warren: To look at meat consumption and the size of the population. And that actually determines the difficulty level for the game itself. So it's actually much harder if you're playing from U United States or Brazil versus like a country like Vietnam for it, not just because of size. And so he wanted to use that as a way to maybe like subtly influence the thing is an interesting, I guess a good question for you is like he doesn't tell you that this is what is happening, but it is a thing that is happening. It's sort of interesting to think about dynamic difficulty in that way that's not communicated to the player.
104
00:13:49,731 --> 00:14:18,859
Jamin Warren: That it's actually creating a more stressful experience. There's less oxygen. You have to blow the whistle more often if you play from the United States. But he was trying to create this localized experience to really, really focus on when you we because you are a member of a country that is more responsible for the slaughter of animals, the way that you play this game should impact your experience playing the game, which I thought was really interesting. I guess my question for you is how much do you feel like it's important to communicate that to players that this is what is happening? If you communicate it to them, does it like
105
00:14:19,071 --> 00:14:34,570
Jamin Warren: numb the effect. he does kind of tell you at the end of the game you can see there's a loadout of the number of animals that are basically basically killed. But like, you know, I I I'm just curious the extent to which you you you you have to sort of like give the critique up front in order for it to basically hit in a in a d a distinct way.
106
00:14:34,570 --> 00:14:35,390
Danny Snelson: that's such a good question.
107
00:14:35,399 --> 00:14:46,876
Danny Snelson: yeah, I think that's really interesting. And you know, I think like the famous example in video games is the the racialized slider in the South Park game, where you know, if you're you're playing as a non-white person, it's a higher difficulty setting, right?
108
00:14:43,859 --> 00:14:46,802
Jamin Warren: Okay. right, yeah, yeah.
109
00:14:46,876 --> 00:14:53,562
Danny Snelson: So it's kind of like you know, and and and there's lots of critiques of that. It's it's been written a lot, so I won't I won't parse the whole thing.
110
00:14:53,562 --> 00:15:20,467
Danny Snelson: But, I think that there's something really interesting about on one hand, I don't know if it needs to be up front. Like I like
the idea that it's this kind of like subtle difficulty setting. Like I think that there's like an artistry to that. And I think these games in particular, like I find this so cryptic and mysterious, and that's part of my draw to the game. And so, like, you know, all these games are also connected to online discourses and and being able to look up and find that out afterwards, like, I was having an experience that was quite different than someone else might have had. I I think that actually
111
00:15:20,467 --> 00:15:48,057
Danny Snelson: produces a secondary effect that might be as interesting as front loading that kind of information. But but more compelling even, I think, is the the way that that kind of effect can localize you in your own embodied experience of a game. That that so much of our media, so much of the arts presume some I don't know, like standard universal perspective, which is of course usually like a white mask perspective. And that like by by by situating your experience, your your even just like your geolocative position
112
00:15:48,208 --> 00:16:12,842
Danny Snelson: Is is one way to think about, this game is not just about this fantasy scape or or this abstracted non place, but but is a game that speaks back directly to wherever the player is or or wherever the player imagines themselves to be, or that it connects, I guess, to to real politics in the way that think this article so beautifully, you know, starting with starting with our our our electoral evening and and kind of parsing these questions of enumeracy. that like this is one
113
00:16:13,024 --> 00:16:21,216
Danny Snelson: Power to these kinds of games is being able to see where we are and how we are imbricated and and complicit, I think, with these systems that that are surrounding
114
00:16:20,490 --> 00:16:20,811
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
115
00:16:21,216 --> 00:16:21,857
Danny Snelson: us.
116
00:16:21,857 --> 00:16:25,704
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah. imbricated? imbricated. Ooh, I don't know that one.
117
00:16:25,823 --> 00:16:27,828
Danny Snelson: I'm I I hope I'm using it right.
118
00:16:27,828 --> 00:16:33,011
Jamin Warren: No, no, I must always say is one of the joys of the English language, particularly when you have an English professor on the
119
00:16:31,942 --> 00:16:33,283
Danny Snelson: Yeah, imbricated.
120
00:16:33,283 --> 00:16:41,510
Danny Snelson: lying or arranged to overlap each other in a regular sequential order, much like roof tiles, fish scales, or wood shingles. So in the same way that
121
00:16:39,759 --> 00:16:40,411
Jamin Warren: my goodness.
122
00:16:41,515 --> 00:16:49,923
Danny Snelson: is it, yeah, one one you know, the the power of metaphor. I'm surrounded by my I'm in my office today, so maybe I'm I'm lexicologically rich.
123
00:16:46,806 --> 00:16:50,619
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah, of course, of course.
124
00:16:50,619 --> 00:17:14,439
Jamin Warren: Well, let's talk about one of the second themes. So one of the things
that I found playing the game was you know, I found that like there's the games have sort of struggled to to lever critiques on a second order, right? So you have this like first order critique, which which is like it's you know, it's wrong to eat animals and you can kind of like debate down the merits about how you think about it, about the scale, industrial farming. And to me, I was like, Well, if the game stops there, to me.
125
00:17:14,439 --> 00:17:41,156
Jamin Warren: that's a less it's not that it's less interesting, but it's just more like that is more like the meat is meat is murder, wearing a meat is murder I just it felt very it would be very naked. And I feel like Julien with this game with with Threshold, it operates on a second order, which is kind of talk about like systems, which I feel is like sort of unique to games. one of the things in the game is that the bosses in the game, they never like explicitly like threaten you. They don't like tell they don't force you to do the thing. they sort of reassure you and your motivations for coming into it
126
00:17:41,388 --> 00:17:50,058
Jamin Warren: are unclear, you're like, I need a job and this is a job that I have. I wanna talk a a little bit about kind of that side of it. Let me play a short a short note from from Julien on that front.
127
00:18:07,003 --> 00:18:31,488
Jamin Warren: There's this sense that you are a voluntary, you're both voluntary, but there also is this system that you are basically stepping, that the system that you're basically stepping into. One of the things it reminded me of is Dan Davies wrote a book called The Unaccountability Machine and he introduced this concept of like an accountability sink, which is it's a system built so that the feedback never reaches the people like making the decisions. And so
128
00:18:31,488 --> 00:19:00,556
Jamin Warren: The the highlight I pulled out was, Dan Davies says for an accountability sink to function, it has to break a link. And so you have this in Threshold where you have this building, it's called building two, and there's infinite oxygen there, even though oxygen is very is very sparse in the rest of the town. You actually have to break open these canisters that like hurt your mouth and that it like becomes a very tense thing when you run out of oxygen, you pass out, and then basically the game is over. So you're kind of going back and forth, and there's this room, which has these like sort of like video conferenced in like overlord, like these are they're working from New York.
129
00:19:00,748 --> 00:19:24,710
Jamin Warren: And they're managing your site remotely. and they promise you, like, you know, that basically like they'll compensate you basically for your efforts. And so, you know, one of the things I thought was very interesting is that we talked about that first the first order critique that, hey, it's wrong to kill animals, and there's a second order critique, which is that, you know, basically that there's a system at play and you are a part of that system, but no one individually is responsible for that system. Like you're not individually responsible.
130
00:19:24,413 --> 00:19:24,706
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
131
00:19:24,710 --> 00:19:27,921
Jamin Warren: Mo, your boss, isn't individually responsible.
132
00:19:27,921 --> 00:19:29,772
Jamin Warren: Because Mo is just working for someone else. The
133
00:19:29,426 --> 00:19:29,716
Danny Snelson: Mm.
134
00:19:29,772 --> 00:19:37,465
Jamin Warren: managers, I think I believe they mentioned that they have stakeholders as well. And so no one is really responsible for what is actually happening on the train tracks.
135
00:19:37,465 --> 00:19:38,534
Danny Snelson: Yeah, and
136
00:19:37,895 --> 00:19:38,381
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
137
00:19:38,534 --> 00:20:01,721
Danny Snelson: I think that's yeah, the power of this kind of media. I think people used to write about the wire a lot in this regard, right? To like you can see everyone's personal motivations. It's set in, you know, Baltimore, we can see like the personal motivations of everything from like high level politicians to to people like living in in these communities. and you know, I think that there's limits to that, kind of like system. I I would the the piece I was thinking about a lot while you were just talking, Jamin, was Killer of Sheep, the the great film and things from the
138
00:20:01,375 --> 00:20:01,977
Jamin Warren: The Charles Burnett
139
00:20:01,977 --> 00:20:04,537
Jamin Warren: film. Yeah. Yeah.
140
00:20:02,633 --> 00:20:04,674
Danny Snelson: The Charles Burnett film, right? Which
141
00:20:04,674 --> 00:20:17,068
Danny Snelson: there's something about the action rise or or that scene, I guess, the killer sheep I've always thought of in relationship to what remains of Edith Finch. That you the climactic scene where you're like working in the fish factory. And so there is this scene that's like
142
00:20:15,992 --> 00:20:17,492
Jamin Warren: Right. Yes, yeah, yeah.
143
00:20:17,568 --> 00:20:30,962
Danny Snelson: so that, you are like, I mean something like I don't know, film has always tried to do this, like with modern life, like to show what does it mean to be part of like industrialized modern society? And like, what does it mean to become a cog? And and I think there's like one way that like films like
144
00:20:31,052 --> 00:21:00,214
Danny Snelson: Killer of Sheep or or TV shows The Wire, whatever, can show us these things. But there's something really different when you're like cutting the fish and you're or you're loading the bodies or you're taking the oxygen. there's this proprioceptive, you feel like a cog when you're doing these things. and I think that extends out to these other in our conversation around scale earlier, Universal Paperclips or or Cookie Clicker, where you start you're just like cooking clicky like cookies and like watching them grow, or or paper clips and like watching them
grow and then like slowly that machine becomes automated.
145
00:21:00,214 --> 00:21:24,508
Danny Snelson: And so as watch it scale, but you also as a person hitting buttons and doing the the core mechanic of what like a video game is, like, I feel like there's a different way that it accesses that, like being a cog in a machine, or being a node in a network, or like being one part of the system that's like bigger than you. And I think that's like one of the, you know, most useful things that the games can show us is like how I mean they're all they're all databases. Like they're like a video game is a database.
146
00:21:24,508 --> 00:21:46,453
Danny Snelson: A video game is like a system and and so being able to map those what I guess Bogost calls unit operations onto those system operations is is like one of the powers of of games. But I'd love to, I don't know, we hear more about yeah, do you feel like a cog when you're playing this? or that that that experience of being like you play so many of these games, and and and I think that there's something that it can become almost transparent if you do it too much.
147
00:21:45,990 --> 00:21:46,262
Jamin Warren: Right.
148
00:21:46,453 --> 00:21:54,489
Danny Snelson: And so it's like I feel like games like this though, really or that moment in Edith Finch that I that still haunts me where you're you're cutting up these fish.
149
00:21:54,489 --> 00:22:04,038
Danny Snelson: And you know, it's like a a really emotionally charged moment. like they they say with you. And I I I guess I don't know, I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on like that experience of being plugged in.
150
00:22:01,677 --> 00:22:03,578
Jamin Warren: Yeah, it's it's been interesting this
151
00:22:04,038 --> 00:22:30,694
Jamin Warren: yeah, to look at the development of games, the way that games have approached this question, the it's this this idea of taking advantage of what Bernard Suits calls the lusory attitude, right? there's this there's this mode that we get into when we play games, and you have to accept that mode in order to play games. And that is a really powerful thing that you do. and so I feel like there was like, you know, games like Bioshock, for example, where it's like, you think you're in control? You're not actually in control.
152
00:22:30,694 --> 00:22:43,703
Jamin Warren: it's a pretty I like it's a pretty simplistic, like, you know, kind of like pretty pretty simplistic, but that did open the door, I think, to to future designers who could then play with that subversion of agency, right? So it's like, I'm gonna
153
00:22:43,360 --> 00:22:43,675
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
154
00:22:43,703 --> 00:22:54,947
Jamin Warren: ask you to do a bunch of things. And I think it's taken some time maybe for game makers to figure out but the thing is like if it's not applied for a meaningful political end, then I feel like it's sort of like less interesting, right? So it's like, if
155
00:22:54,475 --> 00:22:54,865
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
156
00:22:54,947 --> 00:22:59,453
Jamin Warren: it's just like applied in the spirit of like I want you to understand, you know.
157
00:22:59,453 --> 00:23:02,734
Jamin Warren: objectivism as a philosophy or something like that, as opposed to saying, hey,
158
00:23:01,601 --> 00:23:02,538
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
159
00:23:02,734 --> 00:23:23,338
Jamin Warren: there are things that are actually happening in the real world. So I I kinda feel like things need to happen. One was I think for you you need to sort of tear the band-aid off and say, like, hey, it is it is an interesting thing to play with players' willingness to do things that they will step into this like magic circle, whatever it might be. They're willing to do certain types of things. that's really interesting. I think the other part of it is
160
00:23:23,338 --> 00:23:32,511
Jamin Warren: maybe moving past serious games or this idea that the subject matter has to explicitly be serious in order to carry the critique. And so I think when those
161
00:23:32,033 --> 00:23:32,293
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
162
00:23:32,511 --> 00:23:43,706
Jamin Warren: two are layered together, then I think you end up in some very interesting, some very, very interesting places. Cause you can see a world where it is this game, Threshold ends up being like a, games for change title or something like that. Right. and it's not.
163
00:23:43,307 --> 00:23:43,667
Danny Snelson: Yeah, yeah.
164
00:23:43,766 --> 00:23:52,311
Jamin Warren: And I I think that's really that's that the fact that it isn't, I think is what really like makes it powerful. So I I think it's just maybe it's just a sign that like games you now have more
165
00:23:52,311 --> 00:24:04,942
Jamin Warren: Other games come before you and they they give you the resources, the language to be able to do something interesting. I was talking to I I did an article last week on this game called Skinface, which is like a horror game where you steal people's faces. And
166
00:24:02,544 --> 00:24:05,123
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
167
00:24:05,130 --> 00:24:18,238
Jamin Warren: I didn't make it into the interview, but one of the things we talked about was like the importance of game, like the big the beginner's guide and this idea like, you can make games about game designers and that can be like an interesting thing and have a personal story or reflect on the craft itself.
168
00:24:18,238 --> 00:24:45,662
Jamin Warren: And so I think with younger game makers that they're able to grow up and see whether starting point or other games are already subverting these conventions and then they they can do something like super, super interesting with it. So to me, Threshold felt like a very mature work in that way because it is built on this idea of unreliable narrators, but also it's tough, it's wedded to a a social critique critique that Julien feels as a person. and I think that made it a much more convincing, much more, much
more of a convincing.
169
00:24:45,662 --> 00:25:00,059
Jamin Warren: convincing work in the at the end of the day. That's my that's my that's my sense. You need these other things to happen first and then you can build on it. but yeah that it it it does feel like a unique game in the in in that respect for because it's it's also built as like a horror game. It's on critical reflex who makes these like indie horror
170
00:24:59,482 --> 00:24:59,780
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
171
00:25:00,059 --> 00:25:11,565
Jamin Warren: games and like, you know, it's it's not it's it's it's a very non-traditional horror game in that way. But it's not like a Soylent Green rug pull moment where it's like, all along you're always it doesn't it does it didn't
172
00:25:07,732 --> 00:25:11,542
Danny Snelson: Right.
173
00:25:11,565 --> 00:25:13,153
Jamin Warren: read to me that way.
174
00:25:13,153 --> 00:25:17,550
Jamin Warren: because of some of these other things that we were discussing, in terms of the accountability of systems and whatnot.
175
00:25:17,550 --> 00:25:39,030
Danny Snelson: Yeah, and I'm glad to get past that that division of serious games. and any game can be serious. It's not like it, you know, we make these kinds of metaphors all the time. Or like to to put that in relief, like, yeah, and I'll plug it again, Killer of Sheep like a film everyone should watch. It like changed my life. It was like an amazing film on blackness, on on like factory work, on on on animals, and like killing animals and like the you
176
00:25:37,695 --> 00:25:38,973
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah.
177
00:25:39,030 --> 00:25:45,431
Danny Snelson: the industrial meat production. I mean it's like the filmic version of like a Richard Kipling like revealing how the sausage is actually made.
178
00:25:45,431 --> 00:25:52,926
Danny Snelson: But you don't have to say, Killer of Sheep is a serious film. it's like, it's a film and it's about its own construction. It's all these things. And so it's like,
179
00:25:49,771 --> 00:25:52,863
Jamin Warren: Right. Right. It's a Yeah.
180
00:25:53,007 --> 00:26:13,303
Danny Snelson: yeah, a game can be serious it and it can be about itself. It can have, self-referentiality. And I think with horror in particular, we're seeing the the ascendancy of folks like Jordan Peel and and social critique and and activist approaches, critical race theory it within investigations of of whether it's like gender or race or other forms of like
181
00:26:13,303 --> 00:26:21,935
Danny Snelson: big political questions inside of the horror genre in particular as a a potent form of of activist media. so,
182
00:26:20,929 --> 00:26:21,799
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah.
183
00:26:21,935 --> 00:26:42,394
Danny Snelson: I think that's of course I think we're rissing that also as a general cultural trend, I think, within horror, to think about yeah, w we live in a pretty horrifying place. And that the conventions of of horror as a genre are actually quite effective
maybe to to amplifying and understanding and and better, you know, recognizing again our our implication, but also our alienation.
184
00:26:42,394 --> 00:26:45,446
Danny Snelson: within these within these quite horrifying systems that we live in.
185
00:26:45,408 --> 00:26:45,698
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
186
00:26:45,698 --> 00:27:08,893
Jamin Warren: Yeah. well I definitely recommend people check out Threshold. The the last thing I would add is I just I was reading I read Frank Lantz's The Beauty of Games. And one of the things that he I try not to instrumentalize games. Like I don't think games have to have to do these things in order to be I don't think your meaning has to be like useful in that way. but one of the things that Lantz talks about is you know, in a world built on complicated systems, maybe a place that
187
00:27:09,044 --> 00:27:13,466
Jamin Warren: some of films that you mentioned. I also think of Jacques Tati's playtime, which is about
188
00:27:13,096 --> 00:27:13,432
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
189
00:27:13,466 --> 00:27:35,464
Jamin Warren: the man in the gray suit and how do you get the feel how do you create these you know, we live in a world of complicated systems and games provide a unique entree as a way to understand those systems through the play of those systems. And that is recontact you reconfiguring a system in in a playful context, I think is something really powerful. And maybe that is what we need is that the games are the medium for the you know the the ludic century, as it were.
190
00:27:35,464 --> 00:28:01,133
Jamin Warren: that the games are the medium of critique because things are not flat and things are interconnected and they move very quickly. And so to get people to capture the feeling of that system back to that question of enumery, how do capture the feel of how do you capture the field of the the feel of, you know, three million animals a day. Well maybe a game is a better way to go about capturing that than a film or, you know, a book or and maybe that that that is the way that we can sort of think about these systems in a complex way. So anyway.
191
00:28:01,313 --> 00:28:03,223
Danny Snelson: Yeah. Yeah.
192
00:28:03,223 --> 00:28:26,691
Jamin Warren: All right, moving along, quick little lightning pick here. I had the pleasure of talking with the folks from Mouthwashing a couple weeks ago as part of the Killscreen Horror Month. there's a little bit of news this week. Karyn Kusama has been tapped to direct the Mouthwashing film for for Sony. Sony's Screen Gems bought the Screen Gems, also did the new Resident Evil film. They bought the rights to Mouthwashing, and we were talking about Mouthwashing, I think.
193
00:28:26,913 --> 00:28:52,756
Jamin Warren: weeks ago with Wrong Organ. yeah, Karyn Kusama is attached to direct, as well as Matt Manfredi and Phil Hay, who wrote The Invitationer on the script. Mouthwashing is a game about five people stuck in a crashed freighter. but it's really about responsibility and abuse of power and about like longing and desire and mistakes. And it was interesting hearing actually talking to Johanna, the narrative the narrative lead for the game. She was saying that like, you the game had features this sort of like one of the things she talked about was like it has, you know,
194
00:28:52,756 --> 00:29:07,930
Jamin Warren: It has this disfigured disfigured captain on the on the on the front of the front of the game and then there's also a mascot. And she was like, Yeah, streamers would pick up the game and think it was like, this is a traditional horror game. It's like, it's a mascot horror, or it's a jump scare horror,
195
00:29:07,543 --> 00:29:07,857
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
196
00:29:07,930 --> 00:29:20,571
Jamin Warren: and it's like, it is none of those things. It is is much, much more in the vein Annihilation was the other film that we we talked about, but it's like much form more in the film vein of that or Event Horizon or any of these, psychological space horror.
197
00:29:20,743 --> 00:29:31,717
Jamin Warren: type games. Anyway, we'll be very interesting. I guess my question for you, my question for you, Danny, it may this just like a do you feel like Mouthwashing is a story that's told out of order? Johanna said that she had watched Memento or that was a real touch point
198
00:29:31,382 --> 00:29:31,643
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
199
00:29:31,717 --> 00:29:46,959
Jamin Warren: for the for for the for the film. It kind of goes backwards. You you sort of see like two days before the crash and then three days after the crash and like it goes back and forth between these like different timelines. do you think that's something that they'll adopt for the for the film? I guess maybe it's a broader question about like when you have it's interesting as games have become
200
00:29:46,589 --> 00:29:46,904
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
201
00:29:46,959 --> 00:29:48,081
Jamin Warren: more developed
202
00:29:48,081 --> 00:29:57,556
Jamin Warren: In terms of storytelling techniques, it does raise this interesting question like with Resident Evil, Resident Evil, it's campy horror fun or whatever. I wouldn't say that's a great story
203
00:29:57,106 --> 00:29:57,495
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
204
00:29:57,556 --> 00:30:11,384
Jamin Warren: or something like that. And so it gives you this blank is you so when you diverge from it, it gives Zach Cregger the ability to have black spa blank space and say, I'm gonna do this something set in the universe. I think it's a more interesting question, which is like when you take a game that actually that has that has a good story,
205
00:30:10,203 --> 00:30:11,460
Danny Snelson: Yeah. Yeah.
206
00:30:11,524 --> 00:30:16,509
Jamin Warren: how do you how do you go what are the things that you think that that that that filmmakers should be learning or retaining from
207
00:30:16,509 --> 00:30:19,824
Jamin Warren: those experiences when they're thinking about adapting, before we
move on.
208
00:30:19,824 --> 00:30:30,040
Danny Snelson: Yeah. that love that question. And I think it's, I think with Mouthwashing, it's specifically interesting. by contrast maybe to Resident Evil, which is a pretty open game and it's also a big game. And so you can only
209
00:30:29,725 --> 00:30:30,074
Jamin Warren: Right.
210
00:30:30,160 --> 00:30:46,727
Danny Snelson: focus on specific aspects. And we talked about, right, like translating the mechanics of the typewriter, as like a save point, which is still one of my favorite moments in a conversation we've had. it was like such a like epiphany for me. but with Mouthwashing, like, you know, the critique and and it's like kind of like the same critique that people used to have. Like these are deep Reddit forums, not something I agree with.
211
00:30:46,965 --> 00:30:47,634
Jamin Warren: Ha ha ha.
212
00:30:47,190 --> 00:30:47,780
Danny Snelson: So
213
00:30:47,820 --> 00:31:12,284
Danny Snelson: to put the to put the voice out there that Gone Home was like a walking simulator, this critique of these games that are not action oriented or not traditional games. but you Mouthwashing people are like, this is a playable movie, I wouldn't even call it a game. and of course, it's it's a profound narrative, it jumps through time, deals a lot with trauma and and and assault, and you know, within the the kind of like, yeah, psycho in the tradition of the psychological horror of of a space narrative.
214
00:31:12,622 --> 00:31:31,626
Danny Snelson: So I think it'll be an interesting challenge to see, yeah, how how true do you stay to that? And and I think there's other models for this, I think the the East Asian media ecologies of you know, the the kind of like pipeline from like web novel to light novel to manga to anime to like feature film, where they're like pretty fidelitous to each other, right? Like so, like
215
00:31:31,214 --> 00:31:31,528
Jamin Warren: Hm.
216
00:31:31,626 --> 00:31:38,391
Danny Snelson: the like through that pipeline, like they might get refined, but like because there are fans of those specific media properties, even in
217
00:31:38,008 --> 00:31:38,365
Jamin Warren: Right.
218
00:31:38,391 --> 00:31:40,216
Danny Snelson: their earlier media formats.
219
00:31:40,216 --> 00:31:44,699
Danny Snelson: it's really just the adaptation just broadens the audience or brings it to new media,
220
00:31:44,109 --> 00:31:44,478
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
221
00:31:44,699 --> 00:32:05,402
Danny Snelson: but it it stays pretty true. you don't like you would get you'd get into a lot of trouble if you diverge wildly from the structure or the plot of how a manga was was produced. I think that's one side of it. And I think, you know, some of the adaptations I've been most the other big news this week, of course, is that they're making Death Stranding anime, for Netflix. I don't know if you saw this. But it's like
222
00:32:02,904 --> 00:32:05,451
Jamin Warren: interesting. interesting. I did not see that.
223
00:32:05,451 --> 00:32:06,022
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah.
224
00:32:06,022 --> 00:32:31,550
Danny Snelson: Yeah, so there's these adaptation and or Edge Runners for for Cyberpunk twenty seventy seven, which lives in that universe but maybe tells a different story. and and I know that there's been collaboration back and forth between C D Project Red and the makers of Netflix to say like like for example they're like the hard line is you can't destroy Night City, but like otherwise we're pretty open to like you living in this environment. And so I think with these games, like I think there's either sorry, it's a long roundabout way to say
225
00:32:31,392 --> 00:32:31,656
Jamin Warren: Ha
226
00:32:31,656 --> 00:32:32,005
Jamin Warren: ha ha.
227
00:32:31,902 --> 00:32:32,182
Danny Snelson: Because
228
00:32:32,182 --> 00:32:54,684
Danny Snelson: if I were adapting this and thinking about adapting Mouthwashing, you either I think have to be really fidelitous to the way that this like tight narrative is constructed, because there are like specific reveals that happen it through that kind of memento like structure, or it's an opportunity to kind of like live in that universe and tell maybe a slightly different story. But but I think like yeah, I think either either way could be really powerful. But it's a really different thing than adapting
229
00:32:54,947 --> 00:33:01,665
Danny Snelson: one of these branching narrative games or or a a game that's more of an open world game, into like a filmic form.
230
00:33:01,665 --> 00:33:14,280
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah. Well, we'll see. I I think there requires some maturity on audiences also not to, you know, so thoroughly wed or d to create too much expectations and kind of like let each medium do the thing that it's uniquely good at. But I I do think as like game stories
231
00:33:12,961 --> 00:33:14,152
Danny Snelson: Yeah, that too. Yeah.
232
00:33:14,280 --> 00:33:28,741
Jamin Warren: like do get better, it is going to be an interesting question. yeah, maybe it's a little bit of a tail wagging the dog situation now. It's like if games are leading the if games are leading like the the if games are the places where you know, there's more innovation in narrative long term, then you know, maybe film becomes
233
00:33:28,923 --> 00:33:32,987
Jamin Warren: the that becomes the the secondary medium. you kinda think about games as being the
234
00:33:32,229 --> 00:33:33,611
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
235
00:33:33,628 --> 00:33:41,034
Jamin Warren: being the tip of the sphere and then it's like, yeah, of course you're doing a film adaptation of this this huge game as opposed to historically it's always been like the other way around, right? So
236
00:33:37,231 --> 00:33:41,233
Danny Snelson: Yeah. Yeah,
237
00:33:41,233 --> 00:33:48,275
Danny Snelson: or like I'm thinking about like the like video game novelizations. So it's like like the novelization of Halo, for
example. So like
238
00:33:44,867 --> 00:33:48,185
Jamin Warren: Right, right, right.
239
00:33:48,295 --> 00:33:57,428
Danny Snelson: maybe Phil was like taking on the role of like that kind of like secondary novelization, sort of like yeah, transmedia augmentation rather than the prestige format for storytelling.
240
00:33:56,002 --> 00:33:57,513
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah.
241
00:33:57,552 --> 00:34:22,302
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah. All right. Well, moving along. just real quick, all the things we talk about is available on the newsletter. The Friday newsletter is available for members. You can always just search kill screen and the name of whatever it is that we talked about. But we do love people having having being a part of the the newsletter, newsletter community. So if you take a minute, just click on any of the links in the show notes and that'll take you there if you're not already either a free or a paying member. All right.
242
00:34:22,302 --> 00:34:49,095
Jamin Warren: Couple news items here and then we'll talk about we'll I'm I'm gonna buzz through these and then we'll we'll jump over to jump over to AI. Just a couple things worth like working through. yeah, I'll just I'll buzz through a couple of these. One is My Magic Diary was turning a Casio toy into a secrets console. our most read story over the past few weeks was about a nineteen nineties Casio toy. It's called My Magic Diary, and it was a kid's gadget for keeping secrets. Super cool. I hope it comes back someday, but held
243
00:34:48,965 --> 00:34:49,290
Danny Snelson: Amen.
244
00:34:49,318 --> 00:34:59,405
Jamin Warren: private notes. There's so much experimentation with these types of like I f I feel like I I having a daughter now and like there are this thing called the Odoo. Is it is it Odoo? No, it's called the Yo Yodo, which is like a it's like a kids
245
00:34:58,816 --> 00:34:59,078
Danny Snelson: Mm.
246
00:34:59,405 --> 00:35:01,896
Jamin Warren: podcast player, basically. You you load it with
247
00:35:01,430 --> 00:35:01,776
Danny Snelson: Hello.
248
00:35:01,896 --> 00:35:10,262
Jamin Warren: little you load it with little stories. It's basically like a response for parents against screen time basically. It's like, hey, this is something you can give and
249
00:35:09,171 --> 00:35:10,182
Danny Snelson: Yeah, okay.
250
00:35:10,262 --> 00:35:18,697
Jamin Warren: you give them little stories and they can be engaged with a form of media and it's just like little podcasts and stories and stuff like that. It has its own like morning radio channel, I guess which is kinda
251
00:35:18,697 --> 00:35:21,970
Jamin Warren: Kind interesting too. Anyway, this toy, the magic diary,
252
00:35:19,679 --> 00:35:21,637
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
253
00:35:21,970 --> 00:35:45,356
Jamin Warren: was a part of that. And Lea van Hall and Éléa Brando rebuilt it as a paper mache structure for clutch, a group show in Berlin. You can check it out on the website. But the the artist did it to connect it to the history of coded messages in queer community. So recontextualizing this children's toy and then thinking about asking us questions about who can read a message, who controls what moves through private space. it ran just over over the weekend, but that jumped out as that jumped out as a
254
00:35:45,382 --> 00:36:09,208
Jamin Warren: that jumped out as a really popular story that we had this week. The the the second second most popular story this week was Caves of Qud is getting a 1500 copy physical edition. this is one of these like forever forever projects. Caves of Qud started back in 2007 and then finally they hit 1.0, the first full release in 2024. Killscreen wrote about it back in 2015 when the game was already eight years old at that point.
255
00:36:07,150 --> 00:36:08,993
Danny Snelson: Wow. Great. Yeah.
256
00:36:09,838 --> 00:36:31,600
Jamin Warren: So now Lost in Cult, who's been doing a lot of really interesting work with physical, as he physical releases, is putting it out on the switch too. There's only 1,500 copies, but it comes with a fold out map of the overworld. Great throwback to anybody who grew up with those inside of booklets. you can buy it bundled with three LPs. I had a great time like sitting with so I guess this is an interesting question. So I guess it would this will be a good segue because we're gonna be thinking about
257
00:36:29,456 --> 00:36:31,417
Danny Snelson: Hmm. Yeah.
258
00:36:31,648 --> 00:36:37,237
Jamin Warren: maybe some AI stuff is one of the conversations I was looking at a conversation with Jason Grinblat.
259
00:36:37,237 --> 00:37:02,674
Jamin Warren: Grinblat and game developers. So one of things that happens with Caves of Qud is that you know, it's a it's in a fantasy universe, but there's basically what it allows is for every single object like inside of the system can become its own creature, you can interact with it. It allows for this high degree of generativity with each individual objects, down to body parts, and you get these loyalties across like 70 different factions. So they use an example of like a wall, for example, which has all this like loaded meaning. You can dig through a wall, you can eat it, you can turn it into a golem. There's
260
00:37:02,310 --> 00:37:02,672
Danny Snelson: I see.
261
00:37:02,674 --> 00:37:05,810
Jamin Warren: like a lot of things that you can do with each individual object. Anyway.
262
00:37:05,810 --> 00:37:27,352
Jamin Warren: I was looking at an interview with Jason Grinblat and game developer. And one of the questions was how they find that balance between the handwritten written lore pieces of it and there's all this procedural content. And one of the things he said was that he thinks of the writing as a kind of trell, quote his quote, a kind of trellis for the more procedural stuff to grow on, because the procedural
263
00:37:25,903 --> 00:37:27,211
Danny Snelson: Mm.
264
00:37:27,352 --> 00:37:30,715
Jamin Warren: content needs something stable to be read against.
265
00:37:30,491 --> 00:37:31,191
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
266
00:37:31,191 --> 00:37:32,191
Jamin Warren: Very interesting,
267
00:37:31,424 --> 00:37:31,726
Danny Snelson: Cool.
268
00:37:32,191 --> 00:37:39,264
Jamin Warren: I feel like, because the discourse around AI and games goes very much in one direction. And it's very interesting
269
00:37:39,264 --> 00:37:59,730
Jamin Warren: to see someone who's talking and we use the word procedural. That is another way of saying, like, we have an AI intelligent system. Maybe it's not the one you might be familiar with, but there is some element in which we are creating a body of work and then we are allowing the system to build something like out of that. I guess my question for you is like when we're having this conversation, because we're gonna talk about three works that are kind of informed by AI.
270
00:37:59,730 --> 00:38:17,121
Jamin Warren: What is that distinction? Where does it does it matter? What is the distinction between using is it like I'm curious why the Caves of Qud developers maybe have not received the same kind of pushback as, say, Paolo Pedercini, for example, this week for his game Future? No Thanks! it was revealed or whatever you want to say. Is like you know,
271
00:38:16,671 --> 00:38:17,021
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
272
00:38:17,121 --> 00:38:20,793
Jamin Warren: he used some AI generated music for that piece of the work. He's talked about it in
273
00:38:20,426 --> 00:38:20,773
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
274
00:38:20,793 --> 00:38:25,087
Jamin Warren: public, received like more public criticism for that. I have thoughts about that, but like
275
00:38:25,258 --> 00:38:36,815
Jamin Warren: I'm curious about why s maybe some types of games we allow for there to be a generative system that builds story out of it. And maybe for others we don't. I don't know. I'm curious what you think how how you sort of see that see
276
00:38:36,451 --> 00:38:36,747
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
277
00:38:36,815 --> 00:38:43,339
Jamin Warren: that question. Is it just a is it just a branding exercise, like if you say procedural versus if you say say AI, or do you feel like there's something deeper there?
278
00:38:39,442 --> 00:38:43,624
Danny Snelson: Yeah. Well yeah.
279
00:38:43,638 --> 00:38:59,530
Danny Snelson: From the beginning AI was a branding. I mean, think that's the you know, AI was a a a branding term that was used by the the the founders of a of a machine learning group in the fifties to get more money. Like so AI we talk about AI as though it's like a coherent thing, but of course it's always been like you know, it it's
280
00:38:55,553 --> 00:38:59,379
Jamin Warren: Right. Right. Yeah.
281
00:38:59,530 --> 00:39:08,105
Danny Snelson: a branding term, it's a marketing term. and like there are very specific types of models that do very specific things, the rise of neural networks, autoencoders, and large language models.
282
00:39:08,105 --> 00:39:29,775
Danny Snelson: I I won't go I won't go full geek in in the technical details, but they're really different things and they've like evolved at different moments. And and so like, you know, the kinds of procedural system building and you know, to go back to our previous conversation about Threshold, like, you know, Caves of Qud is like this phenomenal experience of a system. But what makes it beautiful, what makes it meaningful are the stories that emerge from that system. And and I think, you
283
00:39:29,448 --> 00:39:29,744
Jamin Warren: Right.
284
00:39:29,775 --> 00:39:34,353
Danny Snelson: know, Caves of Qud I think is like productively in dialogue with Dwarf Fortress and and and these kinds of
285
00:39:33,639 --> 00:39:34,307
Jamin Warren: Right. Yeah, yeah.
286
00:39:34,353 --> 00:39:38,111
Danny Snelson: like highly but the the procedure like it's clear that like
287
00:39:38,137 --> 00:39:41,804
Danny Snelson: The procedural elements are are like carefully coded, right? They're like like
288
00:39:41,439 --> 00:39:41,724
Jamin Warren: Hm.
289
00:39:41,804 --> 00:39:46,287
Danny Snelson: the wall is not like there's not like a large language like a stupid large language model that's like deciding what the
290
00:39:45,471 --> 00:39:46,287
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
291
00:39:46,287 --> 00:40:06,023
Danny Snelson: wall does. Like those are specific decisions by Bucklew and and and Grinblat. And so I think that you can also feel the kind of like you know, like the human choice in a procedural system. And there's like a long history of of procedural arts, of of generative art, generative writing, long before the kind of rise or ascendancy of what we call AI now.
292
00:40:06,023 --> 00:40:33,689
Danny Snelson: which is really just a specific type of large language model, which is actively destroying the planet and and has consumed all the media. So I think there's a really qualitative difference between say using a large language model to generate the sound for for a game, which is, you know, like really relying on on a certain kind of you know data, a certain kind of approach to data, the a certain kind of ecosystem of this kind of like generative, you know, stealing of like to to make
293
00:40:33,874 --> 00:40:42,128
Danny Snelson: convincing sound for a soundtrack, that large language model is trained on all of the music and and none of the musicians got paid. And so their the politics
294
00:40:39,068 --> 00:40:41,825
Jamin Warren: Right. Right, right, right, right.
295
00:40:42,128 --> 00:40:52,994
Danny Snelson: are quite different than say like, I set up like a a a a synthesizer that is like you know, that is playing music according to an algorithm, which I think is more of like the the Caves of Qud model where it's
296
00:40:52,605 --> 00:40:52,935
Jamin Warren: Hm.
297
00:40:52,994 --> 00:40:59,326
Danny Snelson: like a very human designed system. and I think like, you know, this
conversation I think is really useful to like disentangle maybe
298
00:40:59,515 --> 00:41:24,721
Danny Snelson: I love algorithms and and and systems and things are able to think about systems because, we live our lives on them. We live our lives on these devices. And and I think works like Cave of Caves of Qud shows us how to have meaningful stories within the kinds of systems that that that we inhabit. And I love that metap the the trellis metaphor is so smart. it's so good. And I think like I think that's it's it reverses the figure in the ground there where it's like, yeah, the trellis, like the support
299
00:41:24,721 --> 00:41:51,333
Danny Snelson: is the writing. It's it's like the human stories that are going to be meaningful y for you when you play this game. Over my my one of my dearest friends, and and great gamer, loves Caves of Qud. I know that that they've played this game, you know, hundreds of times and and they keep coming back to it, not because like, the procedural stuff is slick, but because the stories are wacky and and like meaningful and profound and puzzling and and and delightsome. And and I think that's
300
00:41:51,333 --> 00:41:54,117
Danny Snelson: Sorry, long answer because I do think about these questions a lot. But
301
00:41:53,851 --> 00:41:54,779
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
302
00:41:54,779 --> 00:42:06,686
Danny Snelson: yeah, I think that's how I would disamb disambiguate maybe the the the large language model side of generativity from the the procedural generative aesthetics of a game like Caves of Qud.
303
00:42:06,686 --> 00:42:32,912
Jamin Warren: Yeah. I feel like there's also a sense because the game predates, there's a little bit of atomic steel. atomic steel is very famously, it's the steel that was not impacted by by the nuclear age and it's well sought after. It all lives under the sea and they use it for I think for radio for radioactive testing. But it's a good analogy, right? We're sort of in this era where it's like, okay, there was a before moment the before moment before LLMs became like widely available. now we're sort of living in the after moment.
304
00:42:33,082 --> 00:43:01,715
Jamin Warren: I think it is helpful to say I started this game in 2007 and I've been working on a long time. I do think there is a credibility thing. I just I I think my worry is that if you were approaching this question, let's say you're a developer and you started working on this question in a post LLM era, you know, the concern I think would be that like you wouldn't get to a place where you could talk about like I'm using a procedural tool in a way that is creating unique stories. It just becomes like a very flat conversation. It's like, what I'm hearing is you're actually using, you're actually using AI.
305
00:43:01,715 --> 00:43:21,916
Jamin Warren: Which is a good conversation to have. I just I I I did did kind of jump out at me, jump out at me. I like, it's really interesting to see to be the be o and the freedom to be able to talk about talking use of procedural systems and a and and you and talk about using them in a way that is like really impactful. maybe that is only something that's given to people who worked on games kind of before ChatGPT became available, which makes you a little sad.
306
00:43:19,557 --> 00:43:21,676
Danny Snelson: Yeah. And
307
00:43:21,916 --> 00:43:24,901
Jamin Warren: But like, you know, maybe that is also a part of the story as well.
308
00:43:24,901 --> 00:43:41,400
Danny Snelson: And games are so wrapped up into, like look at trying to buy any NVIDIA, like any kind of graphics processing unit. Like there's there's a real reason why, like, you know, I think that the the relationship to games and and AI is is real and and it's about this like parallel processing. It you know, like the architecture of those chips comes out of like, you know,
309
00:43:40,846 --> 00:43:41,129
Jamin Warren: Right.
310
00:43:41,400 --> 00:43:52,513
Danny Snelson: design for games. but I think that, you know, having these kinds of conversations and being able to like even within large language models, like, you know, I've I I think like, you know, it's really important to separate out what Caves of Qud is doing from, say, what a large language model is doing.
311
00:43:52,269 --> 00:43:52,985
Jamin Warren: Of course.
312
00:43:52,985 --> 00:43:58,848
Danny Snelson: But even within large language models, at least on this side, like there's a whole range of it's not all just Chat GPT and open AI and
313
00:43:58,553 --> 00:43:58,814
Jamin Warren: Right.
314
00:43:58,848 --> 00:44:18,864
Danny Snelson: the horrors that's wrought on the world. Like there are like tiny models. There are open source, open weight models. There are like specifically targeted models that can be used. So like the technology itself isn't, I think, inherently bound up to the politics of use that like the kind of prestige enterprise platforms, the tech oligarchs are putting them toward. And and being able to have like
315
00:44:18,864 --> 00:44:38,096
Danny Snelson: Yeah, there might be really useful ways to use a small, sophisticated, large language model or or, something that's not feeding back into those systems. but I I I think that we we need more we need more vocabulary than just AI, because then I think we're stuck in the space where we're only talking about Microsoft and and Meta and and
316
00:44:33,463 --> 00:44:37,631
Jamin Warren: Right. Right. Yeah.
317
00:44:38,116 --> 00:44:45,664
Danny Snelson: and you know, fucking open AI, which like the i it makes so that the the conversations get shut down and and it means that we only rely on those
318
00:44:45,664 --> 00:44:51,419
Danny Snelson: tech oligarchs for our discourse. And and I think that that can be yeah, mystifying and disempowering for for everyone.
319
00:44:51,419 --> 00:44:56,153
Jamin Warren: Yeah. One palate cleanser before we talk about more AI. We're talking about more AI
stuff.
320
00:44:54,295 --> 00:44:55,377
Danny Snelson: Yeah, sorry.
321
00:44:56,435 --> 00:45:02,728
Danny Snelson: I will vent. I will James you have to cut me off before I go too too hard on this.
322
00:45:00,994 --> 00:45:02,756
Jamin Warren: No, no, no. This is all this is all great. I well,
323
00:45:02,756 --> 00:45:26,533
Jamin Warren: I I guess we have a couple things that are worth checking out. another book project from Read-Only Memory. There's a PlayStation book that's coming out the first 30 years that ships this month. It's 400 pages of Sony's industrial design. I can't wait to get my hands on it. definitely worth checking out. It's got prototypes that never shipped in it. another was another physical thing was Yuri Suzuki, who's a sound designer, not a game maker per se, but builds these
324
00:45:26,533 --> 00:45:52,540
Jamin Warren: Sound-based structures or structures that play with the idea of sound. so cool is this little chess set that basically all of the individual pieces on the chessboard are all these tuned bells. he worked with the metal shop in Norfolk. I thought that was really cool. While he was a partner at Pentagram, he showed off prototypes. I don't think it'll ever be like available. I don't think it'll ever be available to the public, but such a cool, like a cool little item. And then the last one is if you're looking to add something to your demo list.
325
00:45:52,540 --> 00:46:00,560
Jamin Warren: Panflip Studio released this a deck builder called Stack Order. It's a hand drawn deck builder. It looks super cool. It's due out next year.
326
00:45:57,020 --> 00:46:00,218
Danny Snelson: Yeah, it looks so good. Yeah.
327
00:46:00,560 --> 00:46:18,557
Jamin Warren: the big it seems like the big the the unique piece here is like the order of the cards is what matters, the the name Stack Order. So maybe unlike some other deck builders where you sort of other deck builders where we maybe like play a card like sort of like one at a time. This the cards have a a relational aspect to them and so they work together when they're played in a certain order. So
328
00:46:18,557 --> 00:46:28,092
Jamin Warren: I'm gonna try and check out the demo this weekend. But the the visual look and feel of it very Goblin's school of animation, very French animation style.
329
00:46:25,867 --> 00:46:27,621
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
330
00:46:28,111 --> 00:46:43,046
Jamin Warren: very French animation. I love the I love the the initial one, but those are three things. cool. Well, let's go back to AI. The last piece that we're gonna talk about today, there were three individual news stories we had over the past week. I kind of bundled them together because I thought that they were useful for the conversation.
331
00:46:43,046 --> 00:47:04,730
Jamin Warren: The first was a piece that I actually got to check out here in Los Angeles by Aurora Mititelu, who I believe teaches at UCLA in the social software department. there is a it's called Abel & I, and there's a bed in a gallery, and there's an iPhone on it, and you can text with this character called Abel. Abel is Aurora Mititelu's synthetic boyfriend and is built out of these old messages that she had with partners and
332
00:47:04,730 --> 00:47:18,455
Jamin Warren: face is modeled basically after her down to they have a matching basically a matching mole and he runs on an LM agent that sits inside of this live unreal sequence. It's unfortunate when w went to go see the piece it was not there's no direction that you're supposed to pick up the phone. And so I just
333
00:47:18,455 --> 00:47:31,540
Jamin Warren: looked at it. I just looked at the phone and didn't get chance to actually like text with text with Abel. but Mititelu talks a lot about the idea of like building building this character. You know, men have built you basically have figured women in clay and on canvas.
334
00:47:31,540 --> 00:47:56,083
Jamin Warren: And that is a way to create this perfect, this perfect and quote unquote perfect entity that you can control. And so she became very interested in maybe I can do the same thing. and asks you as a as a visitor to look at that to basically engage in the same way. The second work is Sarah Rothberg, who has a show in Manhattan that's built around these two avatars who are having a never-ending conversation with one another. So each one gets an opposing persona and then they talk back and forth.
335
00:47:56,249 --> 00:48:19,632
Jamin Warren: they talk back and forth about whether or not it's whether or not it's okay to do things like holding an elevator. And every three minutes the software sh reshuffles all three. You can actually look at this work online, which is really cool. They have a a model of it. And then the last one is Gary, Gary Zhexi Zhang's Autodrama is a game engine stage that directs itself. It's based on there's all these characters, these sort of like modeled sort of sort of grotesque baby-like characters.
336
00:48:19,067 --> 00:48:19,477
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
337
00:48:19,842 --> 00:48:24,298
Jamin Warren: but everything else about it, it's like it's a virtual chamber play, but everything else is
338
00:48:24,298 --> 00:48:50,638
Jamin Warren: is dictated by i is basically audit automated in the sense that characters act on their own, the lights and the cameras perform, and Zhang is basically uses melodrama and also I believe micro microdramas as a as a as a model. He's very interested in these questions of like parisociology. I think maybe looking at these three works, they're all very different. I guess I want to contrast it maybe a little bit. It's been very interesting to see artists working it's like if you're a game maker that works with a game engine and then uses AI in some capacity, your
339
00:48:51,010 --> 00:49:02,957
Jamin Warren: way that you discourse about your work in the world does seem different with art artists who also use many of the same tools but are using
them. And I feel like some of it's just a question of what are the questions that you're asking of this technology and what you're
340
00:49:02,445 --> 00:49:02,858
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
341
00:49:02,957 --> 00:49:18,886
Jamin Warren: trying to interrogate. Maybe back to that question you're saying about with Caves of Qud. it's like it's not just a question that you're using the tech technology, but it's like what is what are you asking of the technology and are you creating something that maybe only that experience could only be created with with using using this technology in a in in in a particular way.
342
00:49:18,886 --> 00:49:19,448
Jamin Warren: yeah, I was curious
343
00:49:19,173 --> 00:49:19,438
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
344
00:49:19,448 --> 00:49:30,889
Jamin Warren: about what you thought about these three works. We'll link to all three of them in the description, but it did seem like a nice like little kicker. it's like, yeah, we have three works kind of in the world that are kind of asking these. They're all dialogic, which I thought was very interesting, right? And all of them Aurora's
345
00:49:29,570 --> 00:49:30,611
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
346
00:49:30,889 --> 00:49:45,758
Jamin Warren: talking to his synthetic boyfriend, with Gary Zhexi Zhang's work, the characters are talking to one another, and the same with Sarah Rothberg's work. They're having this like, you know, infinite forever like argument, occasionally stumbling upon like moments of brilliance. yeah, just curious about your initial reactions to each one of the work, maybe not necessarily having seen them, but
347
00:49:46,018 --> 00:49:47,284
Jamin Warren: Yeah, curious what what what what
348
00:49:46,872 --> 00:49:47,219
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
349
00:49:47,284 --> 00:49:51,053
Jamin Warren: what you might be seeing as a through line between these three individual works.
350
00:49:51,053 --> 00:50:10,987
Danny Snelson: Yeah, I know them quite well. So Aurora's work comes out of the her MFA thesis. and and so got to have conversations in the development of that and and was really interested in this kind of archive of texts that that are used to generate the the character. It's a kind of like weird, like haunted necromancy or something. Like to you know, to like you know, use these texts to to train a model. But you know, one of the things that
351
00:50:10,450 --> 00:50:11,143
Jamin Warren: from past
352
00:50:11,143 --> 00:50:14,009
Jamin Warren: boyfriends or it's like from past relationships or whatever. Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
353
00:50:13,189 --> 00:50:14,219
Danny Snelson: Yeah. Yeah.
354
00:50:14,219 --> 00:50:38,481
Danny Snelson: Personal archives and and that personal reflection, I think, is the most interesting thing. and you know, I think like each of these to to follow, I guess, on our previous conversation about, you know, scale, thematic today on on scale, is you know, thinking about like what what specific models, how specifically are they using these kinds of AI platforms. And and you know, I think your your point about like the arts pointing to AI is really interesting to me because I think that's often I think when successful and something I've been thinking about a lot.
355
00:50:38,481 --> 00:50:58,499
Danny Snelson: is from a critical AI perspective, right? To use these tools as a way to critique them, to demystify them, to better understand, how they're operating. And and the fact that these are all dialogic, I think, is not by chance. I met with Mark Marino earlier this week, who's who's a co-author on an amazing book, Inventing ELIZA, that's on the the origins of the chat bot, the the ELIZA chat bot. And
356
00:50:56,931 --> 00:50:59,148
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I yes, yeah, yeah.
357
00:50:59,148 --> 00:51:06,799
Danny Snelson: so a long history and and but most of our interfaces with these AI systems are are chat based. And so I think that there's a a
358
00:51:06,799 --> 00:51:32,895
Danny Snelson: There's a lot of people thinking about, what does that interface look like? How do we fit into it? Or how are we cut out of it? But there's also a long history of Annie Dorsen and and others who who have been thinking about the aesthetics and the politics of chatbots, from from the last whatever, sixty years. in this regard, I was really interested in Sarah Rothberg's work, who who I I I love and and got to meet up at ITP not too long ago, thinking about these like, you know, it's a long series of these these chatbot pieces that she's been making.
359
00:51:32,895 --> 00:51:40,800
Danny Snelson: And between meetings, I think is the only one that I know that that specifically points to the fact that it uses local Llama 3.2 models for
360
00:51:40,158 --> 00:51:40,463
Jamin Warren: Right.
361
00:51:40,800 --> 00:52:00,934
Danny Snelson: the conversation, which I I think you quoted the curator Katherine Behar with this great line, that like those using these local models that are running offline that are not kind of tapping into the cloud keeps them frozen, quote, like a time capsule of the moment in which they were trained. And so I think there's something really useful about that. Like there's something really interesting about A kind of like resisting the cloud.
362
00:52:00,934 --> 00:52:20,841
Danny Snelson: using a local, free open source model, where I think there's a kind of like there's a lot I guess you could do with these kind of paid subscription kind of cloud-based services. and and I I I know very little about how Autodrama is actually coded. So like it's also I guess go to go back to that question you had about Threshold, like how much do you front end the technical infrastructure you're using? And I think that's an increasingly
363
00:52:20,122 --> 00:52:20,394
Jamin Warren: Right.
364
00:52:20,841 --> 00:52:26,841
Danny Snelson: political question to say, yeah, what are the models you're using? How are you using them? Like, you know, what sort
like
365
00:52:26,841 --> 00:52:40,230
Danny Snelson: What servers are they operating on? And and I think that becomes part of the the the politics of the work and part of the you know, part of the meaning of the work. I think the meaning of between meetings is like you're watching like one local model continue to play itself out kind of indefinitely.
366
00:52:39,842 --> 00:52:40,138
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
367
00:52:40,230 --> 00:52:52,822
Danny Snelson: and you know, I I really don't know how autodrama was made, but I would be interested to know, yeah, how like how how handwritten is this? How how encoded is it? Like what are the systems that that produce these these kinds of artworks?
368
00:52:52,822 --> 00:53:20,737
Danny Snelson: And and I feel like here, when you're working with large language models, I think it's actually really important, maybe more so than the the stats of like the geolocation and Threshold. I think it's important to say, like, yeah, how like what what tools are you using and and how are you able to create these structures if you're making a work that's about about AI in some way or about our relationship to avatars or about our relationship to each other. I I feel like that that, you know, in the same way that when you go to a museum and you see a painting, it's like, you know, whatever, it's like oil paint on
369
00:53:20,737 --> 00:53:27,513
Danny Snelson: oil paint, gouache, charcoal, the what what are the materials that make the artwork because Yeah, yeah, right,
370
00:53:24,621 --> 00:53:27,401
Jamin Warren: Llama three point two watt, yeah, yeah.
371
00:53:27,513 --> 00:53:47,851
Danny Snelson: so I think like seeing gouache on a you know on a on a museum placard, I seeing Llama three point two is useful for me at least as a as a critical A scholar, as somebody who's thinking actively about these kinds of questions that I think these works are all trying to raise, it it gives me a kind of entry point into yeah, a better understanding what what that work is doing within those technical infrastructures.
372
00:53:47,851 --> 00:54:14,003
Jamin Warren: Yeah, it's interesting if you think about these models having a particular thumbprint. but but then it also requires people to be literate with those literate with those models. I I it's it it is like I it is is this like hard. It is this hard it is this like very difficult question, right? It's like to become to become conversant and to critique these things, you must use them, but then to critique and use them also is a complicated is also like a a complicated a complicated act. Especially as ostensibly like the models are
373
00:54:14,003 --> 00:54:41,643
Jamin Warren: are are trying to get to a place where they are indistinguishable, right? They they should not have a they should not have they they should not have a obviously all technology has some kind of thing you know has some kind of like mood or feeling. but maybe there's a question about this like literacy thing is like people continue to become more literate with how these things work, then they're able to say like or identify or appreciate appreciate the the different complexities. I mean, I don't feel like my understanding of like the distinctions between all these different I like I don't feel like I could
374
00:54:41,815 --> 00:54:42,565
Jamin Warren: Necessarily
375
00:54:41,890 --> 00:54:42,653
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
376
00:54:42,806 --> 00:55:02,892
Jamin Warren: the point that out and say, yeah, this is definitely this, this is that definitely that. but maybe it is more of like a mood or feeling. Cause then I do feel like that is maybe the sense I get from from like the text. There's just like maybe a little like ineffable quality, even if I can't like point to it necessarily. Like you sort of like get a sense of like, okay, like Gemini, the way it produces text is like kind of this way, or Claude is particularly
377
00:55:02,299 --> 00:55:02,733
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm.
378
00:55:02,892 --> 00:55:07,359
Jamin Warren: this way, or you know, or you know, local model is gonna be this particular way.
379
00:55:07,359 --> 00:55:27,315
Jamin Warren: Good point. I a really interesting point about the dialogic work. maybe maybe that is the place where that is the so much attention obviously is paid to the the generative AI side of things with image building, which I generally think is less interesting to me individually. But but maybe that dialogic piece is like, yeah, picking up the pieces of like past experiments with AI. That's the place where i
380
00:55:27,041 --> 00:55:27,303
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
381
00:55:27,315 --> 00:55:34,029
Jamin Warren: there's the most interesting work to be done is to provide that kind of like narrat narrative scaffolding because we are
382
00:55:34,029 --> 00:55:51,406
Jamin Warren: We are beings that talk to one another and to have a thing that in some ways engages with that side of our engages with that element of speech. That's the place that the most interesting work may ultimately like end up if that is where things end up. Particularly if like the Gen AI stands up stuff ends up being like maybe more of a maybe more of a dead end long term.
383
00:55:51,068 --> 00:55:51,438
Danny Snelson: And that all
384
00:55:51,438 --> 00:56:01,401
Danny Snelson: these things have rich long histories. that there's continuities. there's discontinuity sure, but there's continuities with the therapist couch. I mean, for me, I've been thinking a lot about D&D. Right. Like, you know, like in a lot of ways,
385
00:56:00,898 --> 00:56:01,310
Jamin Warren: Right.
386
00:56:01,401 --> 00:56:16,443
Danny Snelson: like a large language model plays a lot like a game master. and you know, that that kind of like iterative emergent storytelling that one does around the table with a tabletop role playing game, is not all that different from I guess what the kind of world building that one does when engaged with one of
these models. So I think there's a lot
387
00:56:16,086 --> 00:56:16,386
Jamin Warren: Yeah.
388
00:56:16,443 --> 00:56:19,646
Danny Snelson: to parse, but I think the specificity is important. And I think it's like
389
00:56:19,646 --> 00:56:28,433
Danny Snelson: increasingly important to to to, get out from the yeah, the situation that we're in where there's a a kind of like all or nothing. But again,
390
00:56:28,134 --> 00:56:28,430
Jamin Warren: Right.
391
00:56:28,433 --> 00:56:35,280
Danny Snelson: like all of that like the all or nothing discourse just means that like these things remain like mystified and and homogenous. Yeah.
392
00:56:33,424 --> 00:56:35,564
Jamin Warren: Mys is mystifying. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
393
00:56:35,686 --> 00:56:59,480
Jamin Warren: Yeah. Yeah. it's very interesting. I did some work for Spaghetti last year and provenance is obviously that was their their theme for the institution was provenance. And so it does make me wonder it's like, maybe this is what we're sort of like moving towards. Like, we want like you want to communicate some kind of like question of provenance, like what models you're using and but that requires you to be transparent about it and there's a freedom that I think that artists maybe have that game makers don't yet have where they can't talk about here's how the
394
00:56:59,704 --> 00:57:18,002
Jamin Warren: how here's how me using these tools in this way is enhances the overall work. I feel like artists are able to be there's just more flex I don't know. I just feel like there's more flexibility for them. for artists and yeah that's my that that's my that's my sense. Anyway. last little item here. One last thing before we go. Bleed Map. I had a great conversation with archaeologist
395
00:57:16,847 --> 00:57:17,470
Danny Snelson: Yes.
396
00:57:18,002 --> 00:57:22,252
Jamin Warren: Florence Smith Nicholls. who had a paper at DiGRA a couple of years ago.
397
00:57:22,252 --> 00:57:41,367
Jamin Warren: Florence has made this thing called Bleed Map. It's a free zine that you can download off of itch.io that you play alongside any video game. Florence, really interesting background started, I believe, as an urban archaeologist. So this is the person that goes into city streets, so a place like Rome or whatever, and you figure out where the objects that are buried beneath like the other, you know, Rome is a lasagna, as they tell you when you go. Like there's all these things
398
00:57:40,275 --> 00:57:41,081
Danny Snelson: Ha ha.
399
00:57:41,367 --> 00:57:48,909
Jamin Warren: that are underneath city streets in London and all of these much older cities. in the United States, we have less of that because our cities don't necessarily the oldest cities are not the places where
400
00:57:48,909 --> 00:58:10,880
Jamin Warren: The oldest cities on the Americas are not necessarily the place in the United States are not necessarily the places where the oldest civilizations have been. Like I with their in Indiana, there's that huge mound, I believe, an indigenous mound that's been there for quite some time. In any case, Florence has been very invested in how do you take an archaeological approach to I I believe started with Dark Souls and looking at the bloodstains in Dark Souls and looking looking at that
401
00:58:08,344 --> 00:58:10,649
Danny Snelson: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
402
00:58:10,880 --> 00:58:16,266
Jamin Warren: as a form of archaeological remembrance that, like, these notes from players that they're leaving.
403
00:58:16,266 --> 00:58:21,108
Jamin Warren: inside of this game as in the little archaeology spidey sense whatever that might be like the
404
00:58:20,830 --> 00:58:21,090
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
405
00:58:21,348 --> 00:58:25,639
Jamin Warren: inside in in inside of Florence was like my gosh this is like material so Florence's work
406
00:58:25,325 --> 00:58:25,608
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
407
00:58:25,639 --> 00:58:40,631
Jamin Warren: was going through and I believe hand coding thousands of these messages to try to build a sense of what are the messages that players are leaving for one another. Bleed Map grows out of that work. You draw a map of the space by hand while you play and then you write down whatever from your day bleeds into it. It takes about an hour.
408
00:58:40,900 --> 00:59:05,832
Jamin Warren: I love this idea of turning game practices into other types of things, opening the door to other types of other types of practices. and yeah, encouraging people to not have all of their activity be s solely something. It feels like a kind of journaling, honestly. It's like it's a way to journal game experiences, right? Like it's a way to think about wha how your real life might move into a game space that's not just like writing.
409
00:59:05,832 --> 00:59:09,249
Jamin Warren: what happened inside of a game a game work. Anyway, super interesting
410
00:59:08,844 --> 00:59:09,148
Danny Snelson: Yeah.
411
00:59:09,249 --> 00:59:14,710
Jamin Warren: work. Curious what you thought. you said I believe you told me off call you're gonna be using it in your professional
412
00:59:12,765 --> 00:59:14,446
Danny Snelson: Yeah. my God.
413
00:59:14,710 --> 00:59:15,252
Jamin Warren: life, so
414
00:59:15,357 --> 00:59:34,691
Danny Snelson: I love this so much. No, I'm I'm like such a huge fan. And and again, I'm so grateful to to be alerted to this work, which I I I learned through through Killscreen this week. but you know, I've I've written a book called Full Bleed, which is on the subject of like, you know, you know, how does literature bleed from the like the full bleed is the bleed on a page is like the part that you cut when when it goes to print,
415
00:59:32,341 --> 00:59:34,378
Jamin Warren: Right. Yeah.
416
00:59:34,772 --> 00:59:38,789
Danny Snelson: but like how does that bleed into the world? So that kind of infratin, which
417
00:59:38,789 --> 00:59:53,536
Danny Snelson: Threshold, right?
the bleed is a Threshold to go back to the beginning of our conversation. how do games bleed into our daily life? absolutely my jam. to say nothing of like the FromSoft bloodstains like the best part because you know the bloodstains are like that's where you die. So I wrote a book called Hilden
418
00:59:52,568 --> 00:59:53,193
Jamin Warren: Right, yeah, yeah.
419
00:59:53,536 --> 01:00:04,505
Danny Snelson: poem, which is it ends with the refrain about the bloodstain, which is like, you know, it's like the ode, like it it's like watching like that that moment of of death and it kind of like populates the landscape and you get to see these ghostly apparitions.
420
01:00:04,505 --> 01:00:30,786
Danny Snelson: stupidly fall to their death or get ravaged by some kind of beast in in in any of the FromSoftware games. so I I don't know. I think that there's like a really, really powerful metaphor there for thinking about like those kinds of like in-game remnants, histories of play that to do that kind of like which is really ephemeral. Like it's this like ephemeral archaeology. It's the kind of thing that archaeologists like, you know, finding like the the resin of wine on a discarded pot from like 3,000 years ago.
421
01:00:30,845 --> 01:00:33,457
Danny Snelson: to try to figure out what were the ephemeral activities
422
01:00:33,096 --> 01:00:33,368
Jamin Warren: Right.
423
01:00:33,457 --> 01:00:50,629
Danny Snelson: that that occurred in these spaces. And I I just think that this work is is so valuable in in both the the way it bleeds into the world, but it also captures the ephemeral experiences that we have in these games. And just no I I I I'm very excited to get and use pedagogically the the bleed map.
424
01:00:50,629 --> 01:00:54,597
Jamin Warren: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think it's something people feel in their bones that you remember
425
01:00:54,071 --> 01:00:54,369
Danny Snelson: Mm.
426
01:00:54,597 --> 01:01:15,616
Jamin Warren: a game where you were like what day you maybe you had or that builds resonance, you know, it builds resonance for a particular a particular experience. and trying to find ways to like document that at least for like a personal archive, I think is is really powerful. And I I think it's really yeah, it's really is really important work. So anyway. All right. Well, Danny, thank you so much. As always.
427
01:01:14,273 --> 01:01:15,513
Danny Snelson: Great. Seaman.
428
01:01:16,428 --> 01:01:44,024
Jamin Warren: Buzzed through a ton. We had a wonderful time talking about Threshold and accountability sinks and artificial intelligence and now urban archaeology and games, wide ranging conversation for today. that's the show. you can like, subscribe on any any of your any of your approved podcast or video listening devices. The newsletter is always free. You can always just search for Killscreen and any of things that we that we did and and that tap the first link. Danny.
429
01:01:44,164 --> 01:01:46,084
Jamin Warren: Thank you so much. As always.
430
01:01:46,084 --> 01:01:48,048
Danny Snelson: Thank you, Jamin. What a delight.
431
01:01:48,048 --> 01:01:49,199
Jamin Warren: All right, see you soon.
432
01:01:49,199 --> 01:01:49,600
Danny Snelson: Bye bye.