النص 🔗
This is Syndication Attorney Field Notes. I'm Tilden Moschetti. Today's note is about how a fund manager actually gets paid. Sponsors often ask me if they should just use '2 and 20' because it's the standard. Here is the problem with that.
The problem is not the numbers. The problem is what happens when you treat compensation as one thing... one package... one line in the documents. Because when you do that, you end up mixing things that should never be mixed. You mix how you keep the lights on with how you get wealthy. And those are not the same. They don't happen at the same time. And your investors deserve to know exactly which one they're paying.
So let me back up and give you the mental model I actually use at the whiteboard.
Fund manager compensation happens in layers. Three of them. And each layer does a different job.
The first layer keeps the operating business running. The second layer rewards you for actually making investors money. And the third layer just makes you whole for costs you fronted. Three different functions. Three different moments in time. Three different lines in your governing documents.
If you can keep those three separate in your head, you're already ahead of most sponsors who show up with a copied term sheet.
Let's take the first layer. The management fee.
The management fee is about operational runway. It is not about getting rich. In plain English — it's the money that pays for the day-to-day of running the fund. Your team. Your software. Your rent. The basic cost of showing up and managing the portfolio.
Usually it's charged on committed capital or deployed capital, depending on how you structure it. And here's the important part... the management fee has to get paid whether or not the fund had a great quarter. That's the whole point of it. It's the thing that lets you operate through the slow stretches.
So the management fee sits outside the waterfall. It's not a reward. It's not tied to performance. It's the runway that keeps the operating company alive so you can go earn the real upside later.
And if it were me, I'd size that fee against your actual operating budget — not against what some other fund charges. Because if you copy someone else's number and it doesn't cover your real costs... that's your problem to solve out of pocket. And that's a problem you do not need.
Now the second layer. This is the fun one. The promote. The carried interest. The incentive allocation. Different names, same idea.
This is your reward for performance. And I want to be really clear about what it is not. It is not the same as owning equity in the fund. Carried interest is a right to a slice of the profits — but only after your investors get what they were promised first.
That's the deal. The investors make money. Then you make money. In that order.
So the timing is completely different from the management fee. The management fee shows up regularly, like a paycheck for operating the business. The carried interest shows up at a liquidation event, or when you clear a distribution hurdle in the waterfall. It's back-end. It's the payoff for doing the job well.
One quick flag here — and I'm not going to pretend I'm your CPA. The tax treatment of carried interest versus management fee income is not the same, and those rules move around. So when you're designing this, have your accountant confirm how the promote and the fee actually get characterized for tax. Don't assume. Check it.
Okay. Now the third layer. And this is where I see sponsors get into real trouble.
The third layer is expense reimbursement. This is simply making the sponsor whole for costs the fund should have paid in the first place. The legal bills to set up the fund. The accounting. The fund formation costs. You front the money, and the fund pays you back.
Here's the key thing. Reimbursement is not compensation. You're not making a profit. You're getting your own money back.
And this is the trap. Let me put a hypothetical on the whiteboard.
Say a sponsor is launching a private debt fund. Blind pool. He's got real overhead — daily operational costs, plus the legal and accounting bills to stand the whole thing up. And to keep it simple, he decides to just write one broad line into the Operating Agreement. He calls it a 'sponsor fee.' And the plan is... that sponsor fee will cover the management effort, and the setup legal bills, and honestly whatever else comes up.
Sounds tidy, right? One line. Easy.
It's a mess. Here's why.
Now you've got a reimbursement — getting paid back for legal bills — sitting in the documents disguised as a fee. So a smart investor reads that and asks a very fair question. Is this money paying your costs? Or is this money going into your pocket as profit? And the sponsor can't cleanly answer it — because he bundled it.
That's a disclosure problem. And underneath the disclosure problem is a trust problem. From the investor's point of view, if you can't tell them what they're paying for... they start assuming the worst. And you never wanted that reaction. You created it by being sloppy in the drafting.
What he should have done is boring and simple. A management fee, defined on its own terms. A carried interest, defined in the waterfall. And expense reimbursements, listed as reimbursements — for actual, documented fund costs. Three lines. Three functions. No confusion.
So here's the practical takeaway.
Don't start with '2 and 20.' Don't start with anyone's template. Start with your actual business. What does it cost you to operate this fund? That drives your management fee. What performance are you promising, and when do you deserve to share in it? That drives your promote and your waterfall. And what real costs are you fronting on behalf of the fund? That drives your reimbursements.
Then — and this is the part that matters — make sure your Private Placement Memorandum and your Operating Agreement break those three things out separately. The fee here. The promote there. The reimbursable expenses over here. Clearly labeled. Never blended.
When an investor can read your documents and instantly see what they're paying for your work, what they're paying for your performance, and what's just paying you back... you've done it right. The clarity does the heavy lifting. It builds trust without you having to say a word.
That's the note for today. Keep the layers separate. That's Field Notes.