النص 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:04.958
Welcome to Shallow DeepDive, where we take
a deep-ish dive into the shallow world of
00:00:05.038 --> 00:00:07.058
branding, advertising and creative.
00:00:07.138 --> 00:00:07.958
I'm Joe Qualls.
00:00:08.038 --> 00:00:12.876
Today, we're covering the CBS Eye, which
has just turned seventy-five, and what it
00:00:12.956 --> 00:00:17.855
can teach any brand about when to keep a
logo, when to redraw it, and when to start
00:00:17.935 --> 00:00:18.650
again.
00:00:18.730 --> 00:00:19.909
Here's what happened.
00:00:19.989 --> 00:00:24.708
On Saturday the twentieth of October,
1951, CBS Television started showing a new
00:00:24.788 --> 00:00:26.447
symbol in its station breaks.
00:00:26.527 --> 00:00:30.226
A circle, an almond shape inside it, and a
pupil in the middle.
00:00:30.306 --> 00:00:35.025
It was made under William Golden, the
network's art director, and the story goes
00:00:35.105 --> 00:00:39.703
that he got the idea from the hex signs
painted on barns in Pennsylvania Dutch
00:00:39.783 --> 00:00:42.762
country, which were meant to ward off evil
spirits.
00:00:42.842 --> 00:00:47.621
It worked in black and white, which
mattered, because that's what television
00:00:47.701 --> 00:00:52.419
Seventy-five years later, through colour,
high definition, streaming and several
00:00:52.499 --> 00:00:55.778
changes of owner, it's still essentially
the same shape.
00:00:55.858 --> 00:00:58.058
There's an Australian connection, too.
00:00:58.138 --> 00:01:02.556
CBS bought Network 10 out of
administration in 2017, and earlier this
00:01:02.636 --> 00:01:05.256
Paramount closed its takeover of Warner
Bros.
00:01:05.336 --> 00:01:08.195
Discovery and renamed the whole company
Skydance.
00:01:08.275 --> 00:01:12.034
So the Eye and the 10 on your remote now
sit in the same family.
00:01:12.114 --> 00:01:15.632
An American logo's birthday is closer to
home than it looks.
00:01:15.712 --> 00:01:19.531
The best part of the Eye's story came not
long after it launched.
00:01:19.611 --> 00:01:22.410
Golden reportedly started work on a
replacement.
00:01:22.490 --> 00:01:23.730
He'd had enough of it.
00:01:23.810 --> 00:01:28.709
CBS's president, Frank Stanton, stopped
him, and what he's reported to have said
00:01:28.789 --> 00:01:32.067
worth writing on the wall of every
marketing department.
00:01:32.147 --> 00:01:37.046
Just when you're beginning to be bored
with what you've done is when it's
00:01:37.126 --> 00:01:38.905
to be noticed by your audience.
00:01:38.985 --> 00:01:41.725
That's true of almost every brand we work
with.
00:01:41.805 --> 00:01:45.863
The people inside a business see their
logo hundreds of times a week.
00:01:45.943 --> 00:01:50.182
They're sick of it long before their
customers have properly learned it.
00:01:50.262 --> 00:01:55.220
A new marketing manager arrives, the logo
feels tired, and a rebrand gets started to
00:01:55.300 --> 00:01:58.340
cure a fatigue that only exists inside the
building.
00:01:58.420 --> 00:02:02.838
So the tempting conclusion is that
everyone should leave their logos alone.
00:02:02.918 --> 00:02:05.297
That would make for a very short episode.
00:02:05.377 --> 00:02:09.436
It would also be poor advice, because CBS
hasn't left its logo alone.
00:02:09.516 --> 00:02:13.215
It has kept the shape and kept working on
everything around it.
00:02:13.295 --> 00:02:17.234
In 2020, the New York agency Gretel took
on the whole CBS identity.
00:02:17.314 --> 00:02:18.853
The problem wasn't the Eye.
00:02:18.933 --> 00:02:23.712
It was that news, sport, entertainment and
the studio had each drifted into their
00:02:23.792 --> 00:02:28.690
own habits, with their own type, their own
colours and even their own ways of using
00:02:28.770 --> 00:02:29.485
the Eye.
00:02:29.565 --> 00:02:34.404
Gretel broke the mark into the shapes it's
built from, the circles and the almond,
00:02:34.484 --> 00:02:37.583
and used them as building blocks for
everything else.
00:02:37.663 --> 00:02:41.482
On screen, the Eye bursts outward and
collapses back into itself.
00:02:41.562 --> 00:02:44.601
A new typeface replaced the old condensed
lettering.
00:02:44.681 --> 00:02:49.519
And the sound studio Antfood wrote a short
five-note signature that echoes the old
00:02:49.599 --> 00:02:50.779
spoken line, "This is
00:02:50.859 --> 00:02:55.698
" Judged as a before and after of the
logo, that project looks like almost
00:02:55.778 --> 00:02:56.493
changed.
00:02:56.573 --> 00:03:00.871
In fact, nearly everything did, except the
one thing people already knew.
00:03:00.951 --> 00:03:02.431
NBC took the scenic route.
00:03:02.511 --> 00:03:07.349
The peacock arrived in 1956 to announce
programs in colour, which also helped sell
00:03:07.429 --> 00:03:09.569
colour sets made by NBC's owner, RCA.
00:03:09.649 --> 00:03:12.148
It wasn't even the network's official
logo.
00:03:12.228 --> 00:03:13.288
It was a promotion.
00:03:13.368 --> 00:03:18.086
Over the next twenty years NBC tried a
stacked monogram, then in 1976 a bold new
00:03:18.166 --> 00:03:18.881
letter N.
00:03:18.961 --> 00:03:23.800
That N was not cheap, and within weeks NBC
discovered that a public broadcaster in
00:03:23.880 --> 00:03:27.279
Nebraska had been using almost the same
letter for months.
00:03:27.359 --> 00:03:32.077
NBC settled by handing over new
broadcasting equipment and paying for
00:03:32.157 --> 00:03:32.872
next logo.
00:03:32.952 --> 00:03:34.912
That's the risk of starting again.
00:03:34.992 --> 00:03:39.950
The cleaner and simpler the new mark, the
more likely someone else has already drawn
00:03:40.030 --> 00:03:40.745
it.
00:03:40.825 --> 00:03:45.364
Meanwhile, research inside NBC in 1977
found the peacock still identified the
00:03:45.444 --> 00:03:48.543
network for viewers, even though it had
been retired.
00:03:48.623 --> 00:03:51.662
So in 1979 the bird came back, sitting
inside the N.
00:03:51.742 --> 00:03:56.701
And in 1986 the designer Steff
Load full transcript
Geissbühler
drew the peacock most of us know, reduced
00:03:56.781 --> 00:03:58.380
from eleven feathers to six.
00:03:58.460 --> 00:04:01.439
The asset audiences valued wasn't the
official one.
00:04:01.519 --> 00:04:06.418
NBC's designers had the sense to notice,
and the nerve to change it a great deal on
00:04:06.498 --> 00:04:07.377
the way back in.
00:04:07.457 --> 00:04:09.537
The American ABC took another route.
00:04:09.617 --> 00:04:14.335
In 1962 Paul Rand gave the network three
lowercase letters in a circle, flat and
00:04:14.415 --> 00:04:16.914
simple, made for a world without
computers.
00:04:16.994 --> 00:04:21.593
Over the following decades it picked up
every fashion television branding went
00:04:21.673 --> 00:04:22.388
through.
00:04:22.468 --> 00:04:24.487
Gradients, gel, glass, glow, bevel.
00:04:24.567 --> 00:04:29.526
In 2021 the agency Trollbäck and Company
stripped all of that away and redrew
00:04:29.606 --> 00:04:34.325
mark properly, so it holds up from a phone
icon to a billboard, then built a new
00:04:34.405 --> 00:04:36.904
system of type, motion and sound around
it.
00:04:36.984 --> 00:04:38.643
The idea was right all along.
00:04:38.723 --> 00:04:40.203
The execution needed care.
00:04:40.283 --> 00:04:42.662
We did a small version of this ourselves.
00:04:42.742 --> 00:04:47.640
When we took on Taguchi, the Melbourne
marketing technology company, its symbol
00:04:47.720 --> 00:04:51.479
a ring of orange dots with extra grey dots
worked in among them.
00:04:51.559 --> 00:04:52.559
The idea was good.
00:04:52.639 --> 00:04:54.898
The extra bits were getting in its way.
00:04:54.978 --> 00:04:59.817
So we took them out, made the ring
clearer, and left the typeface beside it
00:04:59.897 --> 00:05:03.296
The mark Taguchi uses today is very close
to that version.
00:05:03.376 --> 00:05:05.275
Nobody had to learn a new symbol.
00:05:05.355 --> 00:05:07.614
They just saw the old one more clearly.
00:05:07.694 --> 00:05:09.834
And then there's Seven, here at home.
00:05:09.914 --> 00:05:14.692
In 1975, when Australia switched to
colour, Seven wrapped its number in a ring
00:05:14.772 --> 00:05:15.652
spectrum colour.
00:05:15.732 --> 00:05:20.571
On the first of January 2000, ahead of the
Sydney Olympics, it launched a new mark
00:05:20.651 --> 00:05:22.670
by Cato, the Melbourne design firm.
00:05:22.750 --> 00:05:24.349
Their explanation is simple.
00:05:24.429 --> 00:05:29.208
The seven and the colour bar were already
part of Seven's history, so they folded
00:05:29.288 --> 00:05:31.427
the colour bar into the seven itself.
00:05:31.507 --> 00:05:36.226
It's a completely new drawing, and it
still feels like Seven, because the memory
00:05:36.306 --> 00:05:37.365
came along with it.
00:05:37.445 --> 00:05:41.024
I understood that properly when I moved to
Australia in 2018.
00:05:41.104 --> 00:05:43.903
The logos on the television meant nothing
to me.
00:05:43.983 --> 00:05:45.223
Seven was a red shape.
00:05:45.303 --> 00:05:49.962
Everyone around me saw decades in it,
years of the news and the cricket and the
00:05:50.042 --> 00:05:50.757
Olympics.
00:05:50.837 --> 00:05:51.596
I saw a seven.
00:05:51.676 --> 00:05:54.236
That's when Stanton's line made sense to
me.
00:05:54.316 --> 00:05:56.635
Recognition doesn't live in the artwork.
00:05:56.715 --> 00:06:00.174
It lives in the audience, and it takes
them years to build.
00:06:00.254 --> 00:06:04.313
When you throw a logo away, that's what
you're throwing away with it.
00:06:04.393 --> 00:06:07.372
None of this means a logo should never be
replaced.
00:06:07.452 --> 00:06:08.167
Some should.
00:06:08.247 --> 00:06:13.085
If the mark tells people something untrue
about the business, or ties it to a past
00:06:13.165 --> 00:06:17.944
it has genuinely left behind, or simply
can't do the work the business now needs,
00:06:18.024 --> 00:06:21.423
keeping it out of respect is just
nostalgia with a budget.
00:06:21.503 --> 00:06:26.401
The point is that the size of the visual
change should follow the business, not the
00:06:26.481 --> 00:06:29.220
boredom of the people who look at it every
day.
00:06:29.300 --> 00:06:33.719
So what does this look like for a business
that isn't a television network?
00:06:33.799 --> 00:06:38.698
Start by finding out what people already
recognise you by, and ask them rather than
00:06:38.778 --> 00:06:42.596
yourselves, because you're the least
reliable judges in the room.
00:06:42.676 --> 00:06:47.515
If the mark carries real recognition and
has room for where you're going, keep it,
00:06:47.595 --> 00:06:50.214
and put the effort into the system around
it.
00:06:50.294 --> 00:06:53.633
If the idea is sound and the drawing is
tired, redraw it.
00:06:53.713 --> 00:06:58.492
If it's working against you, replace it,
and make sure the new one is distinctive
00:06:58.572 --> 00:07:01.311
enough that nobody in Nebraska already
owns it.
00:07:01.391 --> 00:07:04.790
Whichever it is, the logo is the smallest
part of the job.
00:07:04.870 --> 00:07:09.648
The bigger part is the type, the colour,
the motion, the sound and the rules that
00:07:09.728 --> 00:07:12.167
let a busy team use it well on a deadline.
00:07:12.247 --> 00:07:16.186
Seventy-five years of the Eye is an
impressive piece of continuity.
00:07:16.266 --> 00:07:20.025
Gretel's work shows how much invention
that continuity can hold.
00:07:20.105 --> 00:07:24.764
And Stanton's line is still the best test
we know before anyone touches a logo.
00:07:24.844 --> 00:07:25.843
Check who's bored.
00:07:25.923 --> 00:07:27.763
If it's you, that's not a brief.
00:07:27.843 --> 00:07:31.062
Thank you for indulging us in today's
Shallow DeepDive.
00:07:31.142 --> 00:07:33.461
We hope you'll join us for the next one.
00:07:33.541 --> 00:07:34.781
Until then, take care.