النص 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:02.799
You think that your position is a minority view held
2
00:00:02.839 --> 00:00:03.919
amongst Christians today.
3
00:00:04.160 --> 00:00:07.440
And when Solomon has the two hose and he, you know,
4
00:00:07.599 --> 00:00:09.759
does that wise thing where he tests the hose and
5
00:00:09.839 --> 00:00:11.759
then he says, Okay, now we know who the real
6
00:00:11.800 --> 00:00:12.199
mom is.
7
00:00:12.279 --> 00:00:14.679
Right he mentioned about Usury. I think that's a point
8
00:00:14.800 --> 00:00:18.519
we can agree on. And there's another party that I
9
00:00:18.519 --> 00:00:20.559
don't know. Sometimes we can't say their names, but I
10
00:00:20.600 --> 00:00:23.440
think they're largely responsible for that.
11
00:00:23.760 --> 00:00:26.920
Nigerians. With that Nigerians, Yeah, exactly.
12
00:00:27.320 --> 00:00:30.679
He's applying the principle of the law to the three
13
00:00:30.800 --> 00:00:34.640
zero fours and the thoughts thhot.
14
00:00:34.840 --> 00:00:42.359
That's o testament thought.
15
00:00:43.359 --> 00:00:46.880
Special Daniks to our sponsor Main First Project fighting to
16
00:00:46.880 --> 00:00:51.840
put Maners first. Checkout Maine First project dot org. Huge
17
00:00:51.920 --> 00:00:55.439
thanks to Revival of the Anointed Rule, equipping Christians to
18
00:00:55.520 --> 00:00:59.280
fight for Biblical values through policy victories. Check out Revive
19
00:00:59.399 --> 00:01:04.159
the Rule. Our next speaker is an author and cultural
20
00:01:04.239 --> 00:01:08.560
commentator known for his extraordinary intellectual range, sharp wit, and
21
00:01:08.680 --> 00:01:13.760
aggressive debate style. He's been on prominent platforms including Tucker
22
00:01:13.840 --> 00:01:17.920
Carlson and Tim Cassirol. Please join me in welcoming Jay
23
00:01:18.120 --> 00:01:36.120
Dire and returning to the stage, but before I do that.
24
00:01:36.239 --> 00:01:39.480
One really quick PSA is just to be sure because
25
00:01:39.480 --> 00:01:40.760
I don't want it to happen to anybody. If you
26
00:01:40.799 --> 00:01:44.480
have anything in your car, anything that's sitting out, go
27
00:01:44.719 --> 00:01:46.480
right now and just make sure it's not sitting out
28
00:01:46.519 --> 00:01:49.280
as there was somebody apparently has someone break into.
29
00:01:49.159 --> 00:01:50.319
Their vehicle earlier today.
30
00:01:50.519 --> 00:01:52.439
So even during the day, if you do have something
31
00:01:52.519 --> 00:01:55.359
sitting out on a seat or something, go now and
32
00:01:55.439 --> 00:01:59.640
you'll still make it back on time. Introducing next, Jake
33
00:02:02.319 --> 00:02:05.239
is returning to the stage is Yeah, sorry, but a
34
00:02:05.280 --> 00:02:08.919
little bit out of order. Jake Brancatella is a formidable
35
00:02:09.479 --> 00:02:14.719
Islamic apologist prepared to defend Islam's broader visions for society.
36
00:02:14.759 --> 00:02:26.159
Please join me and welcoming Jake Brancatella. With that, we're
37
00:02:26.159 --> 00:02:28.240
gonna jump right into it. Thanks for being here, folks,
38
00:02:28.599 --> 00:02:30.240
and I've got the timer set for you.
39
00:02:30.919 --> 00:02:31.120
Jay.
40
00:02:31.360 --> 00:02:35.319
The floor is all yours. Oh sorry, thank you so much.
41
00:02:35.639 --> 00:02:37.479
One last thing and this gives those people that went
42
00:02:37.560 --> 00:02:39.159
out to their car a little bit of time is
43
00:02:39.759 --> 00:02:44.759
These events are only possible thanks to sponsors, including Main First.
44
00:02:44.560 --> 00:02:45.639
But also Roar.
45
00:02:45.800 --> 00:02:47.680
So I do want to welcome Mike from Roar as
46
00:02:47.719 --> 00:02:50.000
they make these events possible. Thank you so much for
47
00:02:50.080 --> 00:02:50.960
being with us, Mike.
48
00:02:52.120 --> 00:02:57.759
Thanks James, you need me to stall. I appreciate that. Yeah,
49
00:02:57.840 --> 00:03:00.400
my name is Micha LaFave. I'm the founder and CEO
50
00:03:00.520 --> 00:03:03.400
of ROR. I'll tell you just a little bit about
51
00:03:03.439 --> 00:03:05.000
that in just a second, but first I want to
52
00:03:05.039 --> 00:03:09.080
say this is ROR's launch party. I chose this to
53
00:03:09.159 --> 00:03:12.879
launch our organization and it has been a long road,
54
00:03:12.960 --> 00:03:16.120
both figuratively and literally to get here today. And I'm
55
00:03:16.159 --> 00:03:18.639
sure many of you can relate to that statement. And
56
00:03:18.719 --> 00:03:21.120
I just want to thank our God Jesus Christ forgetting
57
00:03:21.199 --> 00:03:29.680
us all here today. Appreciate that. So here's a big problem.
58
00:03:30.240 --> 00:03:33.639
More than thirty five million Christians don't vote in elections.
59
00:03:34.439 --> 00:03:37.199
Millions more Christians vote the wrong way, against their own
60
00:03:37.199 --> 00:03:40.520
biblical values and elections. ROR thinks that's a problem. We
61
00:03:40.599 --> 00:03:43.639
need to unite Christians voting together. ROR is going across
62
00:03:43.719 --> 00:03:46.360
the country, one congregation at a time, making the case
63
00:03:46.400 --> 00:03:51.120
that's a biblical mandate to get involved in government, civics politics.
64
00:03:51.479 --> 00:03:53.759
I need your guys's help. I need volunteers, I need
65
00:03:54.240 --> 00:03:56.879
church invites, and I need donations. You can find me
66
00:03:56.919 --> 00:03:59.240
in the back or if you're launching online. You can
67
00:03:59.280 --> 00:04:03.000
find me at revivedorar dot app. That's revived theoar dot app.
68
00:04:03.080 --> 00:04:03.840
Thank you guys so much.
69
00:04:03.919 --> 00:04:04.759
Let's get this thing going.
70
00:04:05.479 --> 00:04:06.879
Thanks by thank your brother.
71
00:04:10.599 --> 00:04:12.159
Okay, indeed we will.
72
00:04:12.360 --> 00:04:16.920
With Jay, Your opening timer or opening statement timer is set,
73
00:04:17.040 -->
Load full transcript
00:04:18.600
all started on your first word.
74
00:04:20.240 --> 00:04:25.839
My friend here came in his pajamas, but so did Ah.
75
00:04:28.240 --> 00:04:31.199
I'm just kidding, Jake. Jay gave me his book. I
76
00:04:31.279 --> 00:04:34.120
look through it. I'm already Muslims. So debate's over. I
77
00:04:34.199 --> 00:04:39.319
give up. He convinced me. Dude, all right, what's up Texas.
78
00:04:42.240 --> 00:04:44.199
It is Sunday, two thousand and five. We're gonna be
79
00:04:44.240 --> 00:04:46.759
living in the next four hours. That's all sense, all right.
80
00:04:46.879 --> 00:04:49.000
Deuteronomy twenty one. We're gonna go.
81
00:04:49.040 --> 00:04:51.560
Back to an area that you probably wouldn't expect, because
82
00:04:51.639 --> 00:04:57.000
usually we think of civilization as this political philosophy, this
83
00:04:57.240 --> 00:05:02.000
idea that whatever, no actually Western civilization, our civilization, including
84
00:05:02.319 --> 00:05:04.279
the civilization that I'm going to harken back to, which
85
00:05:04.360 --> 00:05:07.600
is the model Christian civilization in my view, Byzantium, the
86
00:05:07.639 --> 00:05:09.680
continuation of the Roman Empire. We're gonna look at that,
87
00:05:10.120 --> 00:05:13.600
see how it was successful and what ways the Christian
88
00:05:13.680 --> 00:05:19.319
Imperium lasted as the longest Christian civilization and the most
89
00:05:19.560 --> 00:05:23.879
successful civilization in world history. To go back to Deuteronomy
90
00:05:23.920 --> 00:05:26.879
and the Mosaic law, we have laws of warfare. This
91
00:05:27.040 --> 00:05:28.959
is the first time, as far as we know, in
92
00:05:29.120 --> 00:05:34.319
ancient Near Eastern civilization that laws were introduced that protected
93
00:05:35.279 --> 00:05:41.040
captives amongst the slave class or captives amongst war These
94
00:05:41.160 --> 00:05:44.800
laws gave a new level of protection that underclass or
95
00:05:44.920 --> 00:05:47.360
that women, or that others did not have prior to that.
96
00:05:47.519 --> 00:05:50.199
Prior to that, the typical attitude was that these were
97
00:05:50.519 --> 00:05:53.240
in a state of slavery. And so now we have
98
00:05:53.319 --> 00:05:56.519
a new introduction that the husband of these in this situation,
99
00:05:56.639 --> 00:05:59.120
if he would like to marry, he must marry and
100
00:05:59.240 --> 00:06:04.920
give legal datus too captives of warfare. The passage that
101
00:06:05.079 --> 00:06:09.959
is used here to protect these girls is the Hebrew
102
00:06:10.079 --> 00:06:13.759
word that signifies them as esha or young, that is
103
00:06:13.920 --> 00:06:15.480
young girls. So here we have for the first time
104
00:06:15.519 --> 00:06:19.040
the protection of the youth in the ancient world through
105
00:06:19.439 --> 00:06:23.360
Mosaic law. Deuter only twenty one this passage and no
106
00:06:23.560 --> 00:06:27.959
other passage. This passage does not allow for
rape. In fact,
107
00:06:28.040 --> 00:06:31.720
it forbids rape and all other passages that discuss the
108
00:06:31.800 --> 00:06:35.079
possibility of rape. Are also explicit in condemnation in the
109
00:06:35.199 --> 00:06:37.879
Torah and in the Old Testament in numbers thirty one,
110
00:06:38.120 --> 00:06:40.800
which is a passage, a passage offen cited by Muslims
111
00:06:40.800 --> 00:06:43.759
and other who's others who critique this. There's nothing said
112
00:06:43.759 --> 00:06:46.319
about sexuality in this passions. In fact, the context is
113
00:06:46.439 --> 00:06:49.639
numbers twenty five that a moabitte or a midday night
114
00:06:49.720 --> 00:06:53.439
person was to be not allowed in because of the
115
00:06:53.519 --> 00:06:57.680
previous warfare that the Israelites had engaged against them for
116
00:06:57.879 --> 00:07:00.480
enticing them to worship bail and to commit jeezs. But
117
00:07:00.879 --> 00:07:03.959
since these were not that generation, this next generation was
118
00:07:04.079 --> 00:07:08.079
to be protected, and you spared the virgins. They could
119
00:07:08.120 --> 00:07:12.319
then become members of the Covenant community. You raised them,
120
00:07:12.360 --> 00:07:14.879
and then at a certain age you could marry them.
121
00:07:14.959 --> 00:07:17.839
This did not allow for rape. In fact, rape is
122
00:07:17.879 --> 00:07:20.600
forbidden Deuteronomi twenty one ten to fourteen. You are not
123
00:07:20.720 --> 00:07:24.920
allowed to defile the girls, and then later on they
124
00:07:24.959 --> 00:07:28.199
are women in the Numbers and Deuteronomy passages.
125
00:07:28.199 --> 00:07:30.000
So in other words, it goes from young girls too.
126
00:07:30.040 --> 00:07:32.439
As they become older they become members of the Covenant community,
127
00:07:32.759 --> 00:07:36.720
they have certain legality and protection now that is totally
128
00:07:36.800 --> 00:07:41.480
contrary to the typical attitude that we have amongst Muslim
129
00:07:41.560 --> 00:07:45.759
critics of the Old Testament, particularly the passages in numbers
130
00:07:45.800 --> 00:07:46.360
in Deuteronomy.
131
00:07:46.360 --> 00:07:47.000
They're often sighted.
132
00:07:47.000 --> 00:07:50.560
They're actually the opposite, the beginning of the protection of
133
00:07:50.680 --> 00:07:54.759
all classes of society. As we get into modern civilization,
134
00:07:54.959 --> 00:07:58.560
we look back to our precedents, our heritage. That is
135
00:07:59.120 --> 00:08:02.680
Roman law, that is common law, that is Biblical law,
136
00:08:02.800 --> 00:08:06.360
that is canon law. All of these legal traditions have
137
00:08:06.480 --> 00:08:09.959
an important, crucial history when it comes to forming the
138
00:08:10.040 --> 00:08:12.839
society and the order that we have. Certainly, I do
139
00:08:13.000 --> 00:08:16.839
not agree with every aspect of postmodern or even post
140
00:08:17.000 --> 00:08:20.879
Enlightenment society. The Enlightenment certainly had some good critiques of
141
00:08:21.040 --> 00:08:25.879
its previous papal civilization. But prior to that, there is
142
00:08:25.959 --> 00:08:30.399
the unknown imperium again of Byzantium. When the Christian Church
143
00:08:30.480 --> 00:08:32.720
was founded, the Christian Church was a tiny group that
144
00:08:32.840 --> 00:08:36.000
believed that it was the fulfillment of everything that Old
145
00:08:36.039 --> 00:08:40.200
Testament religion was pointing to. The Old Testament bequeathed to
146
00:08:40.279 --> 00:08:43.200
it not just the general law of the Ten Commandments,
147
00:08:43.240 --> 00:08:47.000
but many other principles, including the notion of not just
148
00:08:47.120 --> 00:08:52.240
civil law that's based around the deity, but also canonical
149
00:08:52.320 --> 00:08:55.080
law or church law. Church law, for example, in the West,
150
00:08:55.159 --> 00:08:58.519
began to give the accused rights. We might hear or
151
00:08:58.559 --> 00:09:03.320
think about the Inquisition, and although I don't agree with
152
00:09:03.440 --> 00:09:06.320
everything to do with the Roman Catholic Church, there's sometimes
153
00:09:06.360 --> 00:09:09.919
a bad attitude is given towards the Inquisition because we
154
00:09:10.000 --> 00:09:12.360
think of only the bad things. But actually one of
155
00:09:12.440 --> 00:09:16.240
the things that the Inquisition introduced based on Biblical principles,
156
00:09:16.759 --> 00:09:19.159
was the idea of the rights of the accused, was
157
00:09:19.200 --> 00:09:22.480
the idea of defense of the accused. So a lot
158
00:09:22.519 --> 00:09:24.879
of the great heritage that we have in Western tradition
159
00:09:25.519 --> 00:09:29.320
does come from again, not just Christian civilization, not just
160
00:09:29.440 --> 00:09:34.559
Biblical text, but also many examples of the appropriation and
161
00:09:34.679 --> 00:09:36.559
application of those principles.
162
00:09:37.080 --> 00:09:37.799
It's not just the.
163
00:09:37.840 --> 00:09:41.440
Legal realm, in the realm of duties and obligations, etc.
164
00:09:42.519 --> 00:09:46.159
Or protecting those that might be a lower class. We
165
00:09:46.279 --> 00:09:51.360
also have the notion of universities, the notion of hospitals,
166
00:09:51.679 --> 00:09:55.559
the notion of advancements in technology, which no other civilization
167
00:09:55.679 --> 00:09:57.279
or society was able to.
168
00:09:57.320 --> 00:09:58.840
Achieve like we have achieved.
169
00:09:59.080 --> 00:10:01.879
Again, certainly we have gone off in a wrong direction,
170
00:10:02.600 --> 00:10:05.120
but to blame that on Christianity, as I suspect some
171
00:10:05.679 --> 00:10:09.000
will do, I don't know is exact in fact false.
172
00:10:09.320 --> 00:10:12.200
Now thereas we can look at many religious societies in
173
00:10:12.320 --> 00:10:16.840
Islamic countries who were formerly dedicated to the principles of
174
00:10:16.960 --> 00:10:23.360
Islam and also took a secularizing or a liberalizing journey. Interestingly,
175
00:10:23.519 --> 00:10:25.879
many of the countries that are Islamic that went in
176
00:10:26.000 --> 00:10:32.399
a secularizing, industrializing pathway actually became monetarily successful. Other countries
177
00:10:32.519 --> 00:10:36.159
remained and are noted by many of the features that
178
00:10:36.200 --> 00:10:39.759
I'm sure everybody remembers the Andrew versus Daniel Hikikaju debate.
179
00:10:39.799 --> 00:10:42.799
That's kind of a classic that highlighted a lot of
180
00:10:42.840 --> 00:10:46.480
the moral failures and features of a lot of Islamic society.
181
00:10:46.720 --> 00:10:48.919
I'm not going to rehearse that debate. I think everybody
182
00:10:49.000 --> 00:10:51.799
remembers that, so you have that kind of in your mind.
183
00:10:51.879 --> 00:10:54.480
I want to focus on the other aspects that I
184
00:10:54.559 --> 00:10:58.159
think are also crucial kill shots for the attempt at
185
00:10:58.200 --> 00:11:02.679
thinking that Islamic society is some goal or some beneficial
186
00:11:02.799 --> 00:11:05.759
better position. When we talk about what's the good or
187
00:11:05.879 --> 00:11:09.559
how would we judge between Christianity, it might be Orthodox
188
00:11:09.679 --> 00:11:14.519
Christianity being more advantageous to a society versus Islam. I
189
00:11:14.559 --> 00:11:16.080
think we have done, first of all, think about what
190
00:11:16.200 --> 00:11:18.399
the good is when we think about the type of
191
00:11:18.480 --> 00:11:22.000
deity that we have in Christianity, which is the focal
192
00:11:22.120 --> 00:11:25.039
point right we have, for example, the idea of the
193
00:11:25.080 --> 00:11:27.080
balance of the one and the many. Of course, Jake
194
00:11:27.200 --> 00:11:29.679
does not like the Trinity, but he has the same
195
00:11:29.759 --> 00:11:32.279
problem we've highlighted in our previous debates that when he
196
00:11:32.399 --> 00:11:35.440
tries to harmonize the ninety nine ontologies of a law
197
00:11:35.600 --> 00:11:38.840
with the singular essence of a law, he's got the
198
00:11:38.919 --> 00:11:42.279
same metaphysical problem. For us, we don't actually think that
199
00:11:42.399 --> 00:11:44.240
God being one and three has a problem. In fact,
200
00:11:44.519 --> 00:11:46.600
this becomes the pattern in the principle, not just for
201
00:11:46.799 --> 00:11:51.480
church governance with bishops and many people, also though for
202
00:11:51.840 --> 00:11:55.519
the governance of society. Many Orthodox theologians have pointed out
203
00:11:56.039 --> 00:11:59.639
that the idea of the imperium many nations united by
204
00:11:59.679 --> 00:12:04.480
one was the glue that held the greatest civilization together
205
00:12:04.639 --> 00:12:08.960
in history, namely Byzanteum. Byzantium was founded around the code
206
00:12:09.000 --> 00:12:11.840
of Saint Justinian, one of the great Emperor saints, and
207
00:12:11.960 --> 00:12:16.600
the Saint Justinian was noted for shutting down many of
208
00:12:16.679 --> 00:12:20.759
the Pagan philosophical academies. When those academies were shut down,
209
00:12:20.759 --> 00:12:24.919
particularly the Platonic academies, they were able to apply Aristotilian principles,
210
00:12:25.440 --> 00:12:29.679
not in total, but many Aristotilian practical philosophical principles to
211
00:12:30.240 --> 00:12:34.120
the Eastern Roman Emperium or Byzantium, to again create the
212
00:12:34.240 --> 00:12:38.240
most successful empire in world history. We're talking about one
213
00:12:38.279 --> 00:12:42.759
thousand plus years of thriving and surviving. We're talking about
214
00:12:43.000 --> 00:12:47.320
the greatest monetary policy in world history until they began.
215
00:12:47.600 --> 00:12:52.159
To money clip, okay, money clipping. I think you know
216
00:12:52.440 --> 00:12:58.120
what I'm talking about, basing.
217
00:12:57.879 --> 00:13:01.720
The currency right, And I think again, that's just one
218
00:13:01.799 --> 00:13:06.559
ethical principle that we could think of Christian society forbade usury.
219
00:13:06.399 --> 00:13:06.879
Prior to that.
220
00:13:07.000 --> 00:13:09.120
Now, granted, I think Islam would also agree with that,
221
00:13:09.639 --> 00:13:12.200
But the point here is that what actually began the
222
00:13:12.360 --> 00:13:17.120
unraveling of Byzantium was in fact the principles of monetary debasement,
223
00:13:17.600 --> 00:13:23.639
usury and then opening the door to Islam that led
224
00:13:23.679 --> 00:13:27.919
to the collapse of Byzantium. Islam began to have what
225
00:13:28.120 --> 00:13:30.679
some have called a golden age, and this was what
226
00:13:30.759 --> 00:13:34.240
would characterize the rise of the Ottomans. Now, since the
227
00:13:34.320 --> 00:13:38.879
Ottoman Decline, when the British Empire became the next successful
228
00:13:38.960 --> 00:13:42.720
world empire, the Islamic world has tended. I'm not saying
229
00:13:42.720 --> 00:13:44.919
that they all agree, but they've tended to speak of
230
00:13:45.519 --> 00:13:49.799
a decline and a desire to return to this golden age.
231
00:13:50.399 --> 00:13:52.720
And certainly we could say, well, Jay, don't you also
232
00:13:52.799 --> 00:13:55.759
think that there's a Byzantine golden Age. I don't think
233
00:13:55.799 --> 00:13:58.879
that we can ever rebuild something from the past. The
234
00:13:58.919 --> 00:14:02.440
famous historian Oshwa Spangler philosopher History, noted that you can
235
00:14:02.519 --> 00:14:06.200
never recreate a pastivilization, but you can build on what
236
00:14:06.440 --> 00:14:09.480
is there standing on the shoulders of giants. And so
237
00:14:09.600 --> 00:14:11.399
I would say that the key point that we have
238
00:14:11.600 --> 00:14:14.080
lost in the West is probably something that he and
239
00:14:14.159 -->
00:14:17.480
I would agree on, the transcendent, the idea that law
240
00:14:17.759 --> 00:14:21.519
and society do have to be arranged around the transcendental
241
00:14:21.639 --> 00:14:24.919
idea of a god or of a deity. However, if
242
00:14:25.000 --> 00:14:27.960
that deity is a deity that, as the Kuran says
243
00:14:28.039 --> 00:14:32.120
in multiple places, that he is the greatest of deceivers,
244
00:14:33.519 --> 00:14:37.480
that's probably not going to be good for society. In Christianity,
245
00:14:37.519 --> 00:14:39.399
we have a different idea of who God is.
246
00:14:39.960 --> 00:14:41.039
God is not just a.
247
00:14:41.240 --> 00:14:45.960
Single, unitarian, unknowable deity unlike anything in the world, but
248
00:14:46.039 --> 00:14:48.440
he is rather one of us in the sense of
249
00:14:48.519 --> 00:14:51.799
becoming incarnate. He's not only one of us, but he's
250
00:14:51.840 --> 00:14:55.960
imminent and he's transcendent. He also gives us practical living,
251
00:14:56.120 --> 00:14:58.759
practical ways to understand and to know and to love people.
252
00:14:58.919 --> 00:15:01.919
And so love becomes a very crucial feature that is
253
00:15:02.080 --> 00:15:05.080
not really present in the Islamic ethos. I am not
254
00:15:05.240 --> 00:15:07.639
saying in some hippie dippy sense that we base society
255
00:15:07.759 --> 00:15:10.440
upon just love, bro. No, I'm saying that we base
256
00:15:10.480 --> 00:15:12.600
it around what the Bible and the principles of the
257
00:15:12.720 --> 00:15:16.080
Church say love is, which is the Ten Commandments, and
258
00:15:16.240 --> 00:15:20.200
which is to guard those who are the weak, those
259
00:15:20.240 --> 00:15:24.039
who are our children, those who are our progeny. But
260
00:15:24.159 --> 00:15:27.559
in Quran four four, which is a passage not abrogated,
261
00:15:28.120 --> 00:15:31.159
we have the statement that you may take those in
262
00:15:31.279 --> 00:15:35.559
captivity amongst the women that which your right hand possesses.
263
00:15:35.639 --> 00:15:38.120
This is a very famous phrase. It's discussed many many
264
00:15:38.200 --> 00:15:44.080
times by many Islamic scholars, and the hadiths also explain
265
00:15:44.360 --> 00:15:46.799
that what this means, and it has not been abrogated
266
00:15:46.919 --> 00:15:50.279
is that in many cases you are obliged to marry,
267
00:15:50.759 --> 00:15:53.480
but in some cases, if it's a war captive, you
268
00:15:53.559 --> 00:15:57.960
can sex them up right. That doesn't sound like the
269
00:15:58.000 --> 00:16:00.080
same ethic, It doesn't sound like the same deity. And
270
00:16:00.200 --> 00:16:03.799
remember the passages in Deuteronomy twenty one and numbers thirty one.
271
00:16:04.120 --> 00:16:10.000
We're not advocating for sexual license and grape with those captives.
272
00:16:10.039 --> 00:16:13.320
In fact, it is the opposite. You shall not sell
273
00:16:13.360 --> 00:16:15.240
her for money is in fact what it says. Now
274
00:16:16.279 --> 00:16:19.360
how many second, thirty seconds? And so what I think
275
00:16:19.480 --> 00:16:21.919
we want to see is that in the Islamic conception
276
00:16:22.159 --> 00:16:26.120
of God and society it is a master slave relationship.
277
00:16:26.559 --> 00:16:29.679
In the Christian conception of society, there is the honor
278
00:16:30.120 --> 00:16:32.320
and duty that we owe to God and that forms
279
00:16:32.360 --> 00:16:34.679
the basis of the law in the society, and the
280
00:16:34.799 --> 00:16:38.639
Church becomes that foundation. And in Islamic civilization you'll find
281
00:16:38.679 --> 00:16:41.679
out that all of the great philosophy and the ideas
282
00:16:42.200 --> 00:16:45.720
are actually cribbed from the Greeks, which.
283
00:16:45.639 --> 00:16:47.159
Is actually part of Western civilization.
284
00:16:48.120 --> 00:17:00.840
Thank you very much for that opening. Jake will give
285
00:17:00.879 --> 00:17:05.359
you the same twelve and a half minutes, and the
286
00:17:05.480 --> 00:17:08.400
timer is set for you on your first word, I'll
287
00:17:08.440 --> 00:17:08.799
start it.
288
00:17:30.079 --> 00:17:36.319
Okay, good, yes, all right. Thanks. I'm back here again,
289
00:17:36.640 --> 00:17:40.519
and I'm definitely out numbered as usual, but it's fine.
290
00:17:41.039 --> 00:17:44.480
I have no problem with it. I actually appreciate a
291
00:17:44.559 --> 00:17:49.960
lot of what Jay had to say regarding Christianity, but unfortunately,
292
00:17:50.200 --> 00:17:53.319
I don't think that the biblical tech supports his position,
293
00:17:54.240 --> 00:17:57.519
and I don't think that many people in the audience would.
294
00:17:57.559 --> 00:18:01.799
But we'll see anyway. Tonight's question is not which religion
295
00:18:01.920 --> 00:18:04.799
is true? Jay and I can debate that another night,
296
00:18:04.960 --> 00:18:09.000
and we've kind of debated that in another circumstance. Tonight's
297
00:18:09.079 --> 00:18:13.000
question is practical which faith is better for society? And
298
00:18:13.200 --> 00:18:16.160
Jay has already told us how to decide it. I'm
299
00:18:16.160 --> 00:18:19.079
going to quote some of the things from his previous videos.
300
00:18:19.519 --> 00:18:22.599
In his own lecture on this subject, he said, the
301
00:18:22.720 --> 00:18:25.680
whole matter comes down to one thing, where there is
302
00:18:26.200 --> 00:18:29.839
quote a revealed doctrine of governance or not, whether there
303
00:18:29.920 --> 00:18:34.240
is or not a revealed doctrine. I accept his standard completely,
304
00:18:34.599 --> 00:18:37.359
So hold both of us to it tonight, and let
305
00:18:37.440 --> 00:18:41.160
me propose how we measure the results. A society is
306
00:18:41.279 --> 00:18:45.039
doing well when families hold together, when it's people are sober,
307
00:18:45.119 --> 00:18:47.799
when the poor are provided for when children are
actually
308
00:18:47.920 --> 00:18:50.799
born and when the faith of their fathers actually reaches
309
00:18:50.839 --> 00:18:56.359
the sons family. Sobriety, charity, continuity, transmission. If Jay objects
310
00:18:56.400 --> 00:19:00.720
to any of these, let me know which one clarification
311
00:19:00.839 --> 00:19:03.680
before we begin, and it matters for how you score
312
00:19:03.759 --> 00:19:07.480
this debate. Jay typically, although there was a little bit
313
00:19:07.480 --> 00:19:10.440
of mixture in that opening statement, does not defend the
314
00:19:10.519 --> 00:19:14.920
Christianity of modern America or Europe in his own words
315
00:19:14.960 --> 00:19:19.240
and I quote, in reality, democracies are oligarchies. He rejects
316
00:19:19.279 --> 00:19:23.000
the liberal West's root and branch, so tonight he cannot
317
00:19:23.160 --> 00:19:26.079
borrow its prestige, although I think he kind of did that.
318
00:19:26.839 --> 00:19:29.960
He must defend what his tradition actually built when it
319
00:19:30.240 --> 00:19:32.759
held power, and he has told us what that is.
320
00:19:32.839 --> 00:19:36.319
He did in the opening statement he says, and I quote,
321
00:19:36.920 --> 00:19:41.079
that the Simfonia was the norm throughout the Byzantine period.
322
00:19:41.200 --> 00:19:44.920
He's fixated on Byzantium as an East Orthodox Christian, which
323
00:19:44.960 --> 00:19:49.359
I understand. Byzantium and Sarus Russia that is his exhibit,
324
00:19:49.759 --> 00:19:53.039
so hold him to that. Here is my case. In
325
00:19:53.160 --> 00:19:58.519
one sentence, Islam offers society a revealed order, a living history,
326
00:19:58.960 --> 00:20:03.920
and measurable results. An orthodoxy on all three counts offers none.
327
00:20:04.759 --> 00:20:09.839
First revelation versus improvisation, Jay says, the question is a
328
00:20:09.920 --> 00:20:13.759
revealed doctrine of governance. Very well, open the New Testament
329
00:20:14.240 --> 00:20:17.279
and look for one. There is no criminal code, no
330
00:20:17.440 --> 00:20:22.039
commercial law, no constitution, no system of taxation for the poor.
331
00:20:22.839 --> 00:20:25.799
Jesus Peace be upon him, said plainly, my kingdom is
332
00:20:25.960 --> 00:20:29.000
not of this world. And in Luke chapter twelve, a
333
00:20:29.119 --> 00:20:32.799
man brings him the ordinary social dispute, the most ordinary
334
00:20:32.880 --> 00:20:36.920
social dispute, imaginable and inheritance, and Jesus answers, and I
335
00:20:37.039 --> 00:20:40.279
quote man who made me a judge or an arbiter
336
00:20:40.440 --> 00:20:44.519
over you, he declines to legislate. We must also never
337
00:20:44.640 --> 00:20:49.599
forget that Protestantism came out of Christianity, which Jay critiques
338
00:20:49.640 --> 00:20:51.400
and I appreciated much of what he said in his
339
00:20:51.480 --> 00:20:55.359
recent interview with Tucker, and was the eventual springboard to
340
00:20:55.519 --> 00:20:59.720
modern secular liberalism, which we both critique, which now pervades
341
00:21:00.079 --> 00:21:03.119
throughout Western society, both in government and the minds of
342
00:21:03.160 --> 00:21:06.440
the people. All of this happened because the Bible and
343
00:21:06.559 --> 00:21:11.240
Christianity failed to set down clear regulations for society compared
344
00:21:11.279 --> 00:21:15.039
that with the Qur'an, which in chapter four legislates inheritance,
345
00:21:15.160 --> 00:21:19.079
and whose longest verse is entirely devoted to contracts in debt.
346
00:21:19.680 --> 00:21:23.240
One revelation refuses the question of social order, the other
347
00:21:23.400 --> 00:21:28.079
answers it in detail. The earliest Christians read their scriptures
348
00:21:28.160 --> 00:21:32.960
exactly this way. In the Epistle to Diogenetes boasts that
349
00:21:33.200 --> 00:21:38.799
Christians dwell in their homelands as sojourners. Tertullian declared that
350
00:21:39.000 --> 00:21:42.519
there was nothing more foreign to Christians than public affairs.
351
00:21:43.079 --> 00:21:47.480
Origin explained that Christians declined public office altogether. And on
352
00:21:47.680 --> 00:21:50.960
this remarkably, Jay agrees with me. These are his words,
353
00:21:50.960 --> 00:21:54.119
and I quote, in the first few centuries of Christianity,
354
00:21:54.279 --> 00:21:58.119
they weren't intent on converting the emperor or bringing in
355
00:21:58.440 --> 00:22:03.680
a Christian empire close quote exactly. So for three hundred
356
00:22:03.759 --> 00:22:07.039
years the Church was a political by its own proud
357
00:22:07.119 --> 00:22:11.680
self description and by Jay's own admission. So where did
358
00:22:11.920 --> 00:22:15.319
orthodox civilization come from, Jay kind of already admitted it,
359
00:22:16.119 --> 00:22:19.759
Not from the Gospel, from the empire. Christianity became a
360
00:22:19.799 --> 00:22:23.680
state religion by the decree of a Roman emperor, Theodosius in.
361
00:22:23.799 --> 00:22:24.440
Three point eighty.
362
00:22:24.880 --> 00:22:28.319
Its civil law was Justinian's code, Roman law, which Jay
363
00:22:28.599 --> 00:22:32.680
did say, but it was Roman law lightly sprinkled with
364
00:22:32.799 --> 00:22:38.119
holy water. Sinfonia is Roman imperial architecture with icons on
365
00:22:38.279 --> 00:22:41.759
the walls. I call it what it is. Baptized Rome
366
00:22:42.319 --> 00:22:47.160
Byzantium is not Christianity's design for society. It is Christianity's
367
00:22:47.240 --> 00:22:50.720
lack of a design filled in by Caesar. Islam is
368
00:22:50.799 --> 00:22:54.200
the mirror opposite our profit. Peace and blessings be upon him.
369
00:22:54.279 --> 00:22:57.319
Did not merely preach a society. He governed in one
370
00:22:57.720 --> 00:23:01.640
in Medina under a written constitution with revealed law covering
371
00:23:01.759 --> 00:23:04.759
family contracts, crime, and a
mandatory tax for the poor.
372
00:23:05.319 --> 00:23:08.480
We did not borrow a social order from a dying empire.
373
00:23:08.960 --> 00:23:13.160
We received one from heaven by Jay's own criterion, a
374
00:23:13.279 --> 00:23:16.960
revealed doctrine of governance. There is exactly one candidate on
375
00:23:17.119 --> 00:23:21.240
the stage. Second the historical record suppose we grant him
376
00:23:21.279 --> 00:23:25.160
his baptized Rome, how did it perform? Judge the system
377
00:23:25.240 --> 00:23:28.200
by what it did to its own saints. In the
378
00:23:28.440 --> 00:23:33.440
seventh century, emperors imposed a monothelite heresy, meaning Christ only
379
00:23:33.480 --> 00:23:36.160
had one will in incarnate state. As a state policy.
380
00:23:37.440 --> 00:23:41.519
The man who resisted Maximus the Confessor, whom Jay venerates
381
00:23:41.599 --> 00:23:44.839
as his church's great theologian, had his tongue cut out
382
00:23:45.200 --> 00:23:48.400
and his right hand cut off by the Orthodox Emperor's state,
383
00:23:48.559 --> 00:23:51.920
and died in exile. In the eighth century, Emperor Leo
384
00:23:52.160 --> 00:23:56.119
banned the Icons, and a council under his son ratified it.
385
00:23:56.759 --> 00:23:59.160
It was a doctrine dictated from the throne for over
386
00:23:59.319 --> 00:24:03.279
a century, and in seventeen twenty one fast forwarding, Peter
387
00:24:03.400 --> 00:24:06.920
the Great did not merely pressure the Church. He abolished
388
00:24:06.920 --> 00:24:10.000
the Patriarchate of Moscow and ran the Church as a
389
00:24:10.039 --> 00:24:13.839
government department under a lay bureaucrat for nearly two hundred years.
390
00:24:14.400 --> 00:24:17.000
This is not one bad king. This is a system
391
00:24:17.079 --> 00:24:20.160
with no breaks. And his own church's law tells us
392
00:24:20.200 --> 00:24:23.960
why every state on earth rests at bottom on the
393
00:24:24.039 --> 00:24:28.599
lawful sword, armies, courts and punishment. But listen to Orthodoxy's
394
00:24:28.680 --> 00:24:32.680
own canon law about that sword. Saint Basil's thirteenth Canon,
395
00:24:32.839 --> 00:24:36.960
ratified as binding law by his church's own councils, says
396
00:24:37.000 --> 00:24:39.279
that the killing in war that is not reckoned as
397
00:24:39.400 --> 00:24:43.880
murder is even pardonable in defense of piety, and yet
398
00:24:44.400 --> 00:24:48.119
leaves the hands not clean, and counsels the soldier to
399
00:24:48.240 --> 00:24:53.279
abstain from communion for three years lawful and yet still defiling.
400
00:24:53.839 --> 00:24:57.799
And when Emperor Nikophora's focus, a warrior of the church
401
00:24:57.880 --> 00:25:01.920
itself venerates, asks the patriarch to crown his fallen soldiers
402
00:25:02.039 --> 00:25:06.039
as martyrs when they were facing Muslims. The patriarch refused him,
403
00:25:06.200 --> 00:25:10.079
citing that very canon It is recorded in his church's
404
00:25:10.200 --> 00:25:14.680
own canonical commentaries. A church whose priests may not bear arms,
405
00:25:15.039 --> 00:25:18.519
whose soldiers need three years as cleansing after lawful war,
406
00:25:19.079 --> 00:25:22.519
is a church whose own law declares the state's business
407
00:25:22.759 --> 00:25:27.039
is not our business. Simfonia did not fall fail by accident.
408
00:25:27.319 --> 00:25:30.079
It was a marriage. The bride's own law forbade, which
409
00:25:30.119 --> 00:25:33.119
is why again and again the groom simply took command.
410
00:25:34.519 --> 00:25:38.880
And then later the ledger Byzantium fell fourteen fifty three.
411
00:25:39.000 --> 00:25:44.599
We know who that was to Tsarus, Russia destroyed nineteen seventeen, Serbia, Bulgaria, Romania,
412
00:25:44.920 --> 00:25:48.440
all of the crowns gone. Greece and Orthodox nation voting
413
00:25:48.559 --> 00:25:52.799
freely abolished its monarchy in nineteen seventy four sixty nine
414
00:25:52.839 --> 00:25:57.000
percent to thirty one. Tonight, the number of Orthodox monarchies
415
00:25:57.039 --> 00:25:58.920
on Earth is exactly zero.
416
00:26:00.039 --> 00:26:01.200
Do not need to argue the.
417
00:26:01.279 --> 00:26:05.599
Conclusion because Jay has argued it for me. His words reached,
418
00:26:05.799 --> 00:26:07.720
although he was a little bit softer, but this is
419
00:26:07.759 --> 00:26:10.079
what he said in the video on a topic restoring
420
00:26:10.200 --> 00:26:13.559
this system is quote not viable and way down the
421
00:26:13.680 --> 00:26:17.960
road his words quote it's LARPing to act like we're
422
00:26:18.000 --> 00:26:22.440
going to resurrect the Byzantine Empire. It's come and gone. Dude, Yeah,
423
00:26:22.480 --> 00:26:25.720
it has, it's coming gone and dude LARPing. Jay's word,
424
00:26:26.079 --> 00:26:30.240
not mine. Meanwhile, Islamic law has been continuously practiced for
425
00:26:30.359 --> 00:26:33.519
fourteen centuries and orders the daily lives of two billion
426
00:26:33.559 --> 00:26:37.880
people today. His model is a museum piece. Mine opens
427
00:26:37.920 --> 00:26:42.559
for prayer five times a day. Third, measurable results, because
428
00:26:42.640 --> 00:26:45.440
better for society is an empirical claim. Let us measure
429
00:26:46.079 --> 00:26:49.759
take one social poison alcohol two point six million deaths
430
00:26:49.839 --> 00:26:53.039
every year by the world health organizations count with a
431
00:26:53.119 --> 00:26:57.160
massive share of the world's homicides, traffic deaths, and battered families.
432
00:26:57.880 --> 00:27:01.000
Islam solved this by revelation for four teen centuries ago,
433
00:27:01.400 --> 00:27:04.039
and Muslim societies sit at the bottom of the world's
434
00:27:04.079 --> 00:27:07.920
consumption tables, while the heartland of Orthodox monarchy became the
435
00:27:08.000 --> 00:27:12.759
world's case study in alcohol catastrophe, and Islam does not
436
00:27:12.960 -->
00:27:16.839
merely prohibit, It provides zakat, a mandatory transfer of wealth
437
00:27:16.880 --> 00:27:20.920
to the poor. Not charity we recommend, but law we obey.
438
00:27:21.680 --> 00:27:25.839
And the deepest measure, does the society continue and does
439
00:27:25.880 --> 00:27:31.119
the faith transmit? Orthodoxy's heartlands are demographically collapsing, and after
440
00:27:31.200 --> 00:27:34.680
a thousand years of Simphonius, six percent of Orthodox Russians
441
00:27:34.720 --> 00:27:40.240
attend church weekly. Meanwhile, Muslims maintained the highest religious retention
442
00:27:40.480 --> 00:27:43.400
on earth. Islam is the fastest growing faith in the world.
443
00:27:43.759 --> 00:27:46.720
And on this once more, I called Jay as my witness.
444
00:27:47.160 --> 00:27:51.079
His words in his own lecture, Islam is quote destroying
445
00:27:51.160 --> 00:27:57.200
the West, theologically, philosophically speaking, demographically speaking close quote. He
446
00:27:57.400 --> 00:28:00.440
meant it as an indictment of the West's weakness. But
447
00:28:00.599 --> 00:28:03.319
hear what he conceded on the very measures its debate
448
00:28:03.440 --> 00:28:08.240
is about. He grants that Islam prevails. One tradition kept
449
00:28:08.279 --> 00:28:11.599
its children, the other kept its icons. So let me
450
00:28:11.720 --> 00:28:15.440
close where I began. Jay said, the question is whether
451
00:28:15.519 --> 00:28:18.400
there is a revealed doctrine of the magistrate. I agree,
452
00:28:18.799 --> 00:28:21.359
I have shown you the revealed order. His scriptures lack
453
00:28:21.440 --> 00:28:24.799
and mind contain a history in which his system devoured
454
00:28:24.839 --> 00:28:28.759
its saints, was disqualified by its own canons, and then
455
00:28:28.799 --> 00:28:32.920
when extinct, not coming back by Jay's words, while mine
456
00:28:33.000 --> 00:28:37.039
never stopped, and measurable results in sobriety, charity, families, and
457
00:28:37.119 --> 00:28:41.480
faith transmitted results he has conceded in his own voice.
458
00:28:42.640 --> 00:28:45.839
Now he must now show you a Christian social order
459
00:28:46.119 --> 00:28:49.440
that came from Christ rather than Caesar, a mechanism that
460
00:28:49.559 --> 00:28:53.079
stops the next Peter the Great, a single living example
461
00:28:53.119 --> 00:28:57.279
of what he proposes, and results measured in lives, not incense.
462
00:28:57.759 --> 00:29:00.599
A kingdom not of this world cannot govern this world.
463
00:29:01.119 --> 00:29:04.200
Islam was sent to do exactly that. That is why
464
00:29:04.319 --> 00:29:07.160
on the question before us tonight, the answer is Islam.
465
00:29:07.400 --> 00:29:08.160
Thank you very much.
466
00:29:09.400 --> 00:29:11.079
Thank you very much for that opening.
467
00:29:15.440 --> 00:29:18.480
We have like a like a little rebuttal, because if
468
00:29:18.480 --> 00:29:21.000
we immediately go into the sixty minutes, we won't be
469
00:29:21.240 --> 00:29:23.039
There's a lot that came up. So could we have
470
00:29:23.079 --> 00:29:24.759
like a five minute back and forth and then can
471
00:29:24.799 --> 00:29:27.240
do the open part or no, I have to.
472
00:29:27.319 --> 00:29:29.480
Defer to Jake, just because you guys already agreed on
473
00:29:29.519 --> 00:29:31.839
the format. So Jake, whether you want to grant that
474
00:29:32.359 --> 00:29:34.319
or a hybrid of something like that or.
475
00:29:35.960 --> 00:29:39.240
Five minutes, yeah, yeah, five and five deal and then
476
00:29:39.359 --> 00:29:39.720
and then.
477
00:29:40.680 --> 00:29:41.079
You got it.
478
00:29:42.039 --> 00:29:44.319
I've got the timers set for you for that five
479
00:29:44.400 --> 00:29:46.720
minute revital jay. The floor is all yours.
480
00:29:47.599 --> 00:29:49.400
Yeah, only because a lot of things were brought up,
481
00:29:49.400 --> 00:29:51.000
which is fine. I know in an opening statement, a
482
00:29:51.000 --> 00:29:52.359
lot's going to be brought up, and so of course
483
00:29:52.400 --> 00:29:53.240
he can respond to you.
484
00:29:53.279 --> 00:29:54.279
I want to note that.
485
00:29:55.480 --> 00:29:58.039
So first of all, yeah, I've said democracies are faking
486
00:29:58.119 --> 00:30:02.160
gay many times over. So I mean a lot of
487
00:30:02.279 --> 00:30:03.960
repeating all this stuff that I said, and I think
488
00:30:03.960 --> 00:30:06.079
everybody here would agree with democracy is faking gay. So
489
00:30:06.279 --> 00:30:09.680
now we have a constitutional republic, and it is possible
490
00:30:09.720 --> 00:30:12.359
for a consortis republic to be Christian or to be Christianized.
491
00:30:12.359 --> 00:30:14.880
I don't deny that, it's just that that doesn't exist
492
00:30:14.960 --> 00:30:17.160
in the history of the church. The normative, principal history
493
00:30:17.160 --> 00:30:19.359
of the church is in the Orthodox Church. For example,
494
00:30:19.400 --> 00:30:22.480
a coronation service, where you have a king coronated by
495
00:30:22.559 --> 00:30:25.400
the church, and so the authority for the temporal realm
496
00:30:25.480 --> 00:30:28.799
comes from the spiritual. The church is not a political
497
00:30:29.039 --> 00:30:33.079
it's separate. There's a division of spheres, and this is
498
00:30:33.160 --> 00:30:35.400
unfortunately one of the mistakes of the Enlightenment and the
499
00:30:35.440 --> 00:30:37.640
Protestant Reformation, but not even the first generation of the
500
00:30:37.680 --> 00:30:40.759
Project Reformers. They were, in fact, many of them monarchists.
501
00:30:40.799 --> 00:30:43.960
In fact, Luther's Reformation wouldn't have been successful in Germany
502
00:30:44.079 --> 00:30:45.680
had he not had the support of the German princes.
503
00:30:45.759 --> 00:30:48.720
So the early Reformers were, except for Calwen, you know,
504
00:30:48.960 --> 00:30:51.559
monarchists or republican,
but they were still theocrats. And so
505
00:30:51.720 --> 00:30:54.319
my position, by the way, is not that the Church
506
00:30:54.440 --> 00:30:55.839
is a political In fact, the Church has a lot
507
00:30:55.880 --> 00:30:58.000
to say about politics. I wrote an article an essay
508
00:30:58.039 --> 00:30:59.400
many years ago you can find in my website and
509
00:30:59.440 --> 00:31:02.519
won't read it all about the principle the death penalty.
510
00:31:02.599 --> 00:31:05.039
For example, that's a principle that is carried over from
511
00:31:05.079 --> 00:31:08.720
the Old Testament to the New Testament, cited many times
512
00:31:08.759 --> 00:31:10.480
the New Testament that you have that the king has
513
00:31:10.519 --> 00:31:13.680
a duty to punish evildoers Romans thirteen. Peter says that
514
00:31:13.720 --> 00:31:16.640
the king has a duty to enforce the moral law
515
00:31:16.759 --> 00:31:20.039
and its punishments. That does include the death penalty. Because
516
00:31:20.079 --> 00:31:22.279
there was a debate in the first, second and third
517
00:31:22.359 --> 00:31:24.920
century about whether a Christian could be a member of
518
00:31:25.160 --> 00:31:27.359
the army or the state does not mean that the
519
00:31:27.559 --> 00:31:30.960
Church taught some other thing. There's a period a time
520
00:31:31.000 --> 00:31:33.240
of controversy and debate, and at the Council of Nicia
521
00:31:33.279 --> 00:31:36.599
they actually decide and determine that yes, you can be
522
00:31:36.759 --> 00:31:39.880
a soldier and be a Christian. So the Canon and
523
00:31:40.000 --> 00:31:43.640
Nicia include this principle, and they looked to the New Testament. Actually,
524
00:31:44.000 --> 00:31:47.200
when John the Baptist is asked, what must we do
525
00:31:47.480 --> 00:31:50.480
when the soldiers, the Roman soldiers ask him, he says,
526
00:31:50.960 --> 00:31:53.640
do not abuse the people, and do not charge too
527
00:31:53.680 --> 00:31:56.759
much in taxes. Thus it is possible to be a soldier.
528
00:31:57.279 --> 00:32:01.279
The entire Byzantine model of the basilis he's called is
529
00:32:01.359 --> 00:32:04.079
that he is likened to King David. King David is
530
00:32:04.119 --> 00:32:08.319
the classic iconographic image of the king or the emperor
531
00:32:08.359 --> 00:32:11.240
in the Byzantine model. The New Testament has many, many,
532
00:32:11.279 --> 00:32:14.680
many passages that site not just the Old Testament laws
533
00:32:15.039 --> 00:32:18.000
in a typological sense, but many of the moral principles
534
00:32:18.039 --> 00:32:20.440
of the Old Testament laws are carried over. Paul in
535
00:32:20.559 --> 00:32:24.480
his letters, for example, sites not sewing together two cloths
536
00:32:24.640 --> 00:32:28.359
in the same garment, not sewing together the same.
537
00:32:28.240 --> 00:32:29.000
Seeds in a field.
538
00:32:29.400 --> 00:32:32.559
Those are ceremonial commands, but they carry a moral significance.
539
00:32:32.680 --> 00:32:35.480
In early Christian society because it was not dominant, because
540
00:32:35.480 --> 00:32:38.599
it was in the catacombs, still had the principle, as
541
00:32:38.680 --> 00:32:41.200
you see with Saint Clement, for example, who taught the
542
00:32:41.279 --> 00:32:44.200
death penalty, Saint Athanasius, for example, who taught the death penalty,
543
00:32:44.200 --> 00:32:47.319
who also said it's virtuous to kill in war in
544
00:32:47.519 --> 00:32:50.079
the right scenario, in the right situation, it can be
545
00:32:50.720 --> 00:32:53.319
a virtue. Now in the case of why there's a
546
00:32:53.400 --> 00:32:56.440
cannon to forbid a person from communing in certain instances,
547
00:32:56.799 --> 00:33:00.319
that's because like in the Old Testament, David was told,
548
00:33:00.359 --> 00:33:02.480
even though he was a virtuous hero in war and
549
00:33:02.599 --> 00:33:04.759
God taught him to use his bow and to fight,
550
00:33:05.519 --> 00:33:08.160
because he had killed so many, he was told, I
551
00:33:08.200 --> 00:33:11.039
don't want you to build the temple that will be Solomon,
552
00:33:11.119 --> 00:33:13.039
because your son is a son of peace. And the
553
00:33:13.160 --> 00:33:16.319
Church maintains that principle that although you can still be saved,
554
00:33:16.640 --> 00:33:19.759
it is appropriate, because of the nature of violence and warfare,
555
00:33:19.799 --> 00:33:24.079
that there's a time of repentance, even in a virtuous
556
00:33:24.200 --> 00:33:29.279
time of warfare, because warfare is nasty. Jake's own position
557
00:33:30.039 --> 00:33:32.640
was actually riddled with a bunch of inconsistencies because he
558
00:33:32.720 --> 00:33:35.000
pointed to some bad leaders. Of course, there's going to
559
00:33:35.039 --> 00:33:37.279
be bad tyrants in kings. That has nothing to do
560
00:33:37.400 --> 00:33:41.119
with whether Christianity is successful in building a civilization. In fact,
561
00:33:41.119 --> 00:33:44.599
I gave the example of the Christian Byzantine Empire as
562
00:33:44.720 --> 00:33:48.279
the longest lasting and most successful. Yes, it fell apart,
563
00:33:48.359 --> 00:33:51.559
But Jake, there's been many bad sultans according to your
564
00:33:51.640 --> 00:33:54.000
own position. Does that mean that because I found a
565
00:33:54.039 --> 00:33:55.960
bad sultan here and there from your view, that, oh,
566
00:33:56.000 --> 00:33:57.599
I guess the whole thing has failed. It's just a
567
00:33:57.680 --> 00:34:02.359
really bad argument. Again, the fact that an emperor could apostatize,
568
00:34:02.519 --> 00:34:04.920
or that an emperor could try to enforce heresy is
569
00:34:05.000 --> 00:34:08.119
irrelevant to the question of whether Christianity or Islam is
570
00:34:08.199 --> 00:34:10.639
better for society, because, of course we all would admit
571
00:34:10.719 --> 00:34:12.679
that you could have a corrupt ruler. That has
nothing
572
00:34:12.760 --> 00:34:16.079
to do with which system is actually beneficial to society.
573
00:34:16.159 --> 00:34:19.280
To society, you said that the social order is not
574
00:34:19.360 --> 00:34:20.039
in the New Testament.
575
00:34:20.079 --> 00:34:20.679
It's borrowed.
576
00:34:20.760 --> 00:34:23.760
Again, There's countless passages in the New Testament that are
577
00:34:23.960 --> 00:34:26.920
also principled in the Old Testament. So the New Testament
578
00:34:26.960 --> 00:34:31.239
doesn't abrogate these principles. It continues these principles. For example,
579
00:34:31.320 --> 00:34:33.239
we have the laws of the Kings in the Old
580
00:34:33.280 --> 00:34:36.360
Testament and the limitations in the Torah on Kings. So
581
00:34:36.480 --> 00:34:40.159
those principles carried over into Christian civilization in Christian law.
582
00:34:40.599 --> 00:34:42.800
So the fact that there's a separation between church and
583
00:34:42.880 --> 00:34:45.039
state is not a division between church and state. So
584
00:34:45.119 --> 00:34:47.480
most of your argument hinged on a sort of Protestant
585
00:34:47.559 --> 00:34:49.840
understanding of what symphonia actually.
586
00:34:49.679 --> 00:34:55.519
Is is that it Okay, already, thank you very much
587
00:34:55.559 --> 00:35:03.280
for that rebuttal appreciated. Jay got the timer said for
588
00:35:03.360 --> 00:35:04.760
you as well, Jake, five minutes.
589
00:35:05.360 --> 00:35:05.639
Okay.
590
00:35:07.000 --> 00:35:09.039
I just want to say at the outset, I was
591
00:35:09.119 --> 00:35:12.079
not planning to machine gun tactic Jay at all. That
592
00:35:12.199 --> 00:35:16.199
wasn't the point, and it wasn't originally part of the rebuttal,
593
00:35:16.239 --> 00:35:18.360
which I also thought was a bit strange. I thought
594
00:35:18.360 --> 00:35:21.679
there should be rebuttal. So that's fine with me. But
595
00:35:21.840 --> 00:35:24.760
Jay has mentioned a lot of things, but one thing
596
00:35:24.920 --> 00:35:28.199
he mentioned about Protestantism, and it's true what I'm saying.
597
00:35:28.800 --> 00:35:30.800
But I want to actually give a quote from my
598
00:35:31.000 --> 00:35:35.760
previous debate opponent earlier today, Michael Jones inspiring philosophy. He
599
00:35:35.840 --> 00:35:39.960
says this Christianity is not a political system or a culture.
600
00:35:40.400 --> 00:35:43.360
When you try to weaponize Christianity to be something it
601
00:35:43.519 --> 00:35:46.719
was never intended to be, you will always lose. So
602
00:35:46.800 --> 00:35:50.119
you're right, Jay, I am actually running an argument that
603
00:35:50.559 --> 00:35:54.159
is I think an outgrowth of Protestantism. But I think
604
00:35:54.239 --> 00:35:57.519
the question that we need to ask ourselves is why
605
00:35:57.719 --> 00:36:02.079
is that the case? How? And I'm actually genuinely interested
606
00:36:02.119 --> 00:36:05.400
to have this discussion in the open discussion section. Hopefully
607
00:36:05.559 --> 00:36:09.400
we'll all learn a lot, But I'm generally questioning, how
608
00:36:09.519 --> 00:36:15.000
is it the case that secular liberalism became so abundant
609
00:36:15.079 --> 00:36:18.159
and so popular in the West. It seems to be
610
00:36:18.440 --> 00:36:24.119
a natural outgrowth of Protestantism and its movement, which I see,
611
00:36:24.320 --> 00:36:28.280
actually with respect to the political sphere, to be an
612
00:36:28.320 --> 00:36:31.320
outgrowth of the Bible. Now that's obviously the debate. That's
613
00:36:31.360 --> 00:36:35.480
where Jay would disagree, but I'd like to really understand
614
00:36:35.559 --> 00:36:39.880
that from his perspective, So this isn't necessary. I mean,
615
00:36:40.199 --> 00:36:43.239
Michael might even be willing to come on the stage
616
00:36:43.280 --> 00:36:45.440
and debate Jay because I don't think he agrees with
617
00:36:45.960 --> 00:36:48.719
monarchies and theocracies and that sort of thing, And that's
618
00:36:49.119 --> 00:36:51.519
totally fine, But I'm just saying that this position is
619
00:36:51.599 --> 00:36:54.440
not merely mine, and I'm openly admitting that this is,
620
00:36:55.559 --> 00:36:58.559
at least this aspect of it is a critique from
621
00:36:59.239 --> 00:37:03.760
a form of product stantism. Jay said a lot in
622
00:37:03.880 --> 00:37:06.480
his opening statement. Most of what he had to say,
623
00:37:06.559 --> 00:37:10.280
if you notice, regarding laws and legislation and all of that,
624
00:37:10.960 --> 00:37:13.800
came from two places, One the Old Testament, and then
625
00:37:13.880 --> 00:37:18.119
two which he mentioned earlier, was from Saint Justinian. Now
626
00:37:18.800 --> 00:37:22.400
I'm agreeing that that's where Jay's framework is for the debate,
627
00:37:22.519 --> 00:37:25.199
but I think we have to question why is it
628
00:37:25.480 --> 00:37:28.679
not embedded in the New Testament. Maybe Jay would argue
629
00:37:28.719 --> 00:37:30.800
that it is, And I'm happy to look at some
630
00:37:30.960 --> 00:37:36.920
of those passages. Yes, you made a point about the
631
00:37:38.400 --> 00:37:41.360
evil rulers and those who were tyrants and you know,
632
00:37:41.480 --> 00:37:44.559
not necessarily following the law. Yes, I agree that this
633
00:37:44.679 --> 00:37:48.519
happened in Islamic history, and that this happens even today
634
00:37:49.199 --> 00:37:52.960
in certain Islamic nations or Muslim nations. I wasn't making
635
00:37:53.000 --> 00:37:55.920
the argument purely based on that. I was saying that
636
00:37:56.280 --> 00:37:58.719
as opposed to Islam, and I'm happy to argue that
637
00:37:59.159 --> 00:38:02.239
there seems to be a much greater pattern of that
638
00:38:03.159 --> 00:38:08.320
in Jay's understanding, or not Jay's understanding, but the history
639
00:38:08.360 --> 00:38:11.039
and Christianity. That's what I was trying to argue, not
640
00:38:11.239 --> 00:38:14.440
that one ruler makes it null and void. That's, you know,
641
00:38:14.519 --> 00:38:18.480
an evil ruler, but it seems to be much more pervasive.
642
00:38:20.559 --> 00:38:23.679
Let's see what else I made some notes he mentioned
643
00:38:23.679 --> 00:38:26.320
about usury. I think that's a point we can agree on.
644
00:38:26.679 --> 00:38:29.960
And there's another party that I don't know. Sometimes we
645
00:38:30.039 --> 00:38:34.320
can't say their names, but I think they're largely responsible.
646
00:38:33.760 --> 00:38:35.039
For that, Nigerians.
647
00:38:35.920 --> 00:38:40.599
Nigerians, Yeah, exactly, So I think that's something that we
648
00:38:40.719 --> 00:38:42.760
can actually agree on. In fact, I think there's a
649
00:38:42.880 --> 00:38:47.239
lot that Jay and I can agree on. I think
650
00:38:47.360 --> 00:38:52.039
that both he and I deplore secular liberalism, which is
651
00:38:52.119 --> 00:38:55.440
pervasive in the West. I think we both do think
652
00:38:55.480 --> 00:38:59.039
it's what he said, gay and and weird. But at
653
00:38:59.079 --> 00:39:03.039
the same time, I'm arguing that the reason why this
654
00:39:03.280 --> 00:39:05.840
came about in Western society is because I do think
655
00:39:06.400 --> 00:39:09.519
that there is a lack of clarity on the doctrine
656
00:39:09.559 --> 00:39:11.840
of the governance of the Church and how it relates
657
00:39:11.880 --> 00:39:15.239
to society, especially in the New Testament, And because of that,
658
00:39:16.920 --> 00:39:20.320
that's why I think you get this outgrowth of Protestantism
659
00:39:20.519 --> 00:39:23.639
and even what we have in the US a separation
660
00:39:23.960 --> 00:39:27.519
of church and state, to the point where people like
661
00:39:27.920 --> 00:39:31.880
Michael Jones would criticize much of what Jay I think
662
00:39:31.960 --> 00:39:36.159
has to say about the monarchy and theocracy. Let me
663
00:39:36.280 --> 00:39:38.000
just see a couple more points here.
664
00:39:40.199 --> 00:39:40.679
Hmm.
665
00:39:43.039 --> 00:39:45.639
Yeah, so oh yeah, back to that point that a
666
00:39:45.760 --> 00:39:47.639
lot I want people to notice a lot of what
667
00:39:47.760 --> 00:39:50.880
Jay is saying is coming from the Old Testament, not
668
00:39:51.039 --> 00:39:53.519
the New Testament. The question is why why did Christ
669
00:39:54.079 --> 00:39:56.639
re establish that? It seems to be that everything that
670
00:39:56.719 --> 00:39:59.519
he was trying to say was not a political order.
671
00:40:00.039 --> 00:40:02.840
And yes, I agree that just because some people disagreed
672
00:40:02.840 --> 00:40:05.480
in the early Church that doesn't mean necessarily that's the
673
00:40:05.559 --> 00:40:08.400
correct position. But it seems that that was there very
674
00:40:08.519 --> 00:40:11.320
early on, and we don't see that in Islam anyway.
675
00:40:11.320 --> 00:40:12.119
I think my time's up.
676
00:40:12.800 --> 00:40:15.159
Thank you very much for that rebuttal as well from Jake.
677
00:40:15.840 --> 00:40:17.760
We will jump into the open dialogue. Gentlemen.
678
00:40:18.320 --> 00:40:20.679
We will let this be as organic as you'd like
679
00:40:20.760 --> 00:40:23.199
it to be. If it gets crazy, I'll jump in
680
00:40:23.400 --> 00:40:24.360
the floor. Is all yours?
681
00:40:25.760 --> 00:40:27.880
Yeah, I have a question, if you don't mind, Jay,
682
00:40:28.079 --> 00:40:31.559
So yeah, maybe you can help me out with this.
683
00:40:32.519 --> 00:40:37.599
So I think you agree with me that Western the
684
00:40:37.880 --> 00:40:41.480
sort of secular liberalism that we experience in the West
685
00:40:41.559 --> 00:40:46.000
and the US and most European countries is an event
686
00:40:46.039 --> 00:40:48.159
and the Protestants in the audience might not liked this,
687
00:40:48.280 --> 00:40:53.360
but is an eventual outgrowth of Protestantism. Now I'm making
688
00:40:53.400 --> 00:40:56.440
it a further one step back further that I think
689
00:40:57.280 --> 00:41:01.840
that it's because Christianity didn't have clear dictates on the
690
00:41:02.840 --> 00:41:06.119
doctrine of you know, how the church should relate to
691
00:41:06.199 --> 00:41:08.199
the state. Now, obviously you don't agree with that, So
692
00:41:08.760 --> 00:41:12.559
how do you explain how this came to be out
693
00:41:12.559 --> 00:41:13.400
of Protestantism.
694
00:41:14.360 --> 00:41:16.760
One thing I would say is the concerns of the
695
00:41:16.800 --> 00:41:20.000
first second, third century Church was not mainly politics. But
696
00:41:20.119 --> 00:41:25.079
it doesn't follow from a focus that's different that therefore
697
00:41:25.239 --> 00:41:27.199
there is no doctrine of the state. There is no
698
00:41:27.400 --> 00:41:33.719
idea of a basilais or theocracy. I would actually argue
699
00:41:33.719 --> 00:41:38.920
for theocracy. So you have, for example, setting aside principles
700
00:41:38.960 --> 00:41:41.639
in Mosaic law, you have, for example, many Old Testament
701
00:41:41.719 --> 00:41:46.760
prophecies in Daniel two. From our perspective that the kingdom
702
00:41:46.920 --> 00:41:49.599
under which the empire or the Messiah would be born
703
00:41:49.679 --> 00:41:52.960
would eventually permeate and become the Kingdom of the Messiah.
704
00:41:53.599 --> 00:41:55.880
For us, that's a prophecy of Christ's birth under the
705
00:41:55.960 --> 00:41:59.079
Roman Empire and the Christianization over time of the Roman Empire.
706
00:41:59.159 --> 00:42:00.119
So there's also in.
707
00:42:00.159 --> 00:42:04.320
Many passages of Isaiah we believe prophecies about the Christian
708
00:42:04.519 --> 00:42:06.679
kings that would come to be in the future. So
709
00:42:07.159 --> 00:42:09.280
these are principles that are there that you can even
710
00:42:09.320 --> 00:42:13.000
see the earliest Church fathers citing these Messianic
prophecies as
711
00:42:13.079 --> 00:42:15.639
giving the idea at least that yeah, there's going to
712
00:42:15.800 --> 00:42:19.199
be the notion of Christian states in the future, but
713
00:42:19.639 --> 00:42:21.639
it was not their primary concern in the first second,
714
00:42:21.719 --> 00:42:24.199
third century when they're in the Catacombs, for example, to
715
00:42:24.320 --> 00:42:27.920
figure out the mechanics of the relationship of state and church.
716
00:42:28.239 --> 00:42:32.760
So it's only natural that when the imperium does become Christianized,
717
00:42:33.079 --> 00:42:35.480
that's when we would start to see from the idict
718
00:42:35.519 --> 00:42:39.039
to toleration with Constantine and then Theodosius is really the
719
00:42:39.119 --> 00:42:43.000
first emperor to put some Christian laws into practice, and
720
00:42:43.159 --> 00:42:46.880
then Saint Justinian with his code being explicitly Christian. So
721
00:42:47.000 --> 00:42:49.320
the fact that it sort of evolves, it doesn't follow
722
00:42:49.440 --> 00:42:54.039
from that that the application evolves, that the principles were
723
00:42:54.320 --> 00:42:56.559
not in the new assessment, or that they evolved, because
724
00:42:56.719 --> 00:42:59.719
I could give you tons of examples of legal principles
725
00:42:59.800 --> 00:43:04.119
of continuity from Oltimate Testament which are in the New
726
00:43:04.199 --> 00:43:07.719
Testament and in the Church Fathers that are principles applied. Again,
727
00:43:07.800 --> 00:43:11.320
the death penalty is one classic example. It's assumed that
728
00:43:11.480 --> 00:43:16.039
the early Church tended to not affirm the death penalty.
729
00:43:16.400 --> 00:43:18.880
There are a couple Church fathers that do not, but
730
00:43:19.000 --> 00:43:20.800
actually the majority if you look at the essay that
731
00:43:20.840 --> 00:43:23.840
I wrote on this at my website, I cite examples
732
00:43:23.960 --> 00:43:27.159
from Clements to Athenasians to Ambrose, all affirming the death penalty.
733
00:43:27.360 --> 00:43:28.239
It's just one example.
734
00:43:30.559 --> 00:43:35.320
I appreciate that my question is not more so about
735
00:43:35.360 --> 00:43:39.679
what happened in the early period, but from what you're
736
00:43:39.760 --> 00:43:42.639
saying is that wasn't their focus in the first three centuries.
737
00:43:42.679 --> 00:43:45.440
I understand that then you have, as you said, and
738
00:43:45.559 --> 00:43:51.079
we both agree with this historical narrative, Justinian becomes explicitly
739
00:43:51.320 --> 00:43:55.000
a Christian and then kind of develops further. But I
740
00:43:55.119 --> 00:43:59.440
guess my question is from that point, from Justinian going
741
00:43:59.639 --> 00:44:03.880
forward to wherever you demarket where I don't know either
742
00:44:04.079 --> 00:44:07.440
Byzantium fell or maybe even after that, because there's really
743
00:44:07.519 --> 00:44:12.239
no true Christian monarchies today. I mean, unless you can
744
00:44:12.320 --> 00:44:17.559
tell me one from from from that period. What changed?
745
00:44:17.719 --> 00:44:21.719
Why did it change from the Church having this vision
746
00:44:21.760 --> 00:44:24.719
which you deemed to be correct, to all of a sudden,
747
00:44:25.920 --> 00:44:28.159
you know, having what we experienced today in the West.
748
00:44:28.199 --> 00:44:30.639
I mean, because it's it's not governed by Christian law.
749
00:44:31.320 --> 00:44:36.039
So basically, even the Roman Catholic West, after the schism,
750
00:44:36.599 --> 00:44:40.760
for many centuries, still maintained the same principle of the
751
00:44:40.880 --> 00:44:45.159
need for a Christian state for Christian laws. So even
752
00:44:45.199 --> 00:44:48.079
within the schism of East and West, there's literally no
753
00:44:48.199 --> 00:44:52.000
difference between these two groups on this principle. Now, how
754
00:44:52.079 --> 00:44:54.599
that's applied, Yeah, of course, the Roman Catholic West has
755
00:44:54.599 --> 00:44:57.920
a tendency to put the papacy in a greater geopolitical
756
00:44:57.960 --> 00:44:59.400
position that we would disagree with.
757
00:44:59.519 --> 00:44:59.920
I noticed it.
758
00:45:00.039 --> 00:45:02.440
One of your arguments, for example, was hinging on the
759
00:45:02.519 --> 00:45:06.159
idea that the church is a political No no, no.
760
00:45:06.440 --> 00:45:09.400
What those canons mean is that members of the clergy
761
00:45:09.559 --> 00:45:13.280
are not supposed to be in the state. So that's
762
00:45:13.400 --> 00:45:16.679
our perspective on that. But to say explicitly where it
763
00:45:16.719 --> 00:45:20.400
began to devolve. I would say, is you have a
764
00:45:20.519 --> 00:45:23.960
series of events that occur in the West, particularly Protestant Reformation,
765
00:45:24.119 --> 00:45:28.639
Scientific Enlightenment, Enlightenment itself, so tide of revolution Enlightenment. So
766
00:45:29.000 --> 00:45:33.280
these three events I think are a cascading series of
767
00:45:33.400 --> 00:45:37.119
revolutions that really don't have much to do with Christianity.
768
00:45:37.159 --> 00:45:40.199
I think to be I would criticize Protestants in that
769
00:45:40.639 --> 00:45:44.880
they might have helped that revolutionary fervor. I don't think
770
00:45:44.920 --> 00:45:47.960
they necessarily meant to do that, but I would say
771
00:45:48.000 --> 00:45:51.400
that I know that. I think Jake's tactic is to
772
00:45:51.519 --> 00:45:54.800
set the Protestants in, the Catholics and the Orthodox against
773
00:45:54.840 --> 00:45:55.159
each other.
774
00:45:55.400 --> 00:45:56.840
If that's a classic.
775
00:45:56.880 --> 00:45:58.599
Tactic, which I don't blame you for doing it, because
776
00:45:58.599 --> 00:45:59.920
I did the same thing right, So I was like
777
00:46:00.199 --> 00:46:02.639
the naim guys like a Kuran only and they don't
778
00:46:02.719 --> 00:46:04.199
like each other. So I don't blame Jake for doing it.
779
00:46:04.239 --> 00:46:07.679
It's what you do in debates. But again, I think
780
00:46:07.760 --> 00:46:11.719
that the Protestant Reformation has a revolutionary ethos to it
781
00:46:12.559 --> 00:46:17.719
that it even didn't intend because of the fact that
782
00:46:17.920 --> 00:46:22.119
the earliest reformers were still monarchists. The English Reformation, even
783
00:46:22.119 --> 00:46:23.800
with Henry the Eighth as the so called head of
784
00:46:23.840 --> 00:46:26.679
the Church. I mean, it still was a monarchical structure
785
00:46:26.760 --> 00:46:30.880
of the state. Even the Vatican with upheld this principle
786
00:46:30.920 --> 00:46:33.119
to Christian state until the time of Vatican too. So
787
00:46:34.079 --> 00:46:35.639
I mean, I'm trying to take up the time. But
788
00:46:36.280 --> 00:46:39.000
the simple answer is there's a series of revolutions, and
789
00:46:39.079 --> 00:46:41.719
those revolutions affect the Islamic world just as much as
790
00:46:41.800 --> 00:46:45.320
the West. So I mean, perhaps you could argue that
791
00:46:46.039 --> 00:46:51.320
Islam more explicitly maintained the belief that it should be
792
00:46:52.360 --> 00:46:54.360
the God's law should apply to the state.
793
00:46:54.880 --> 00:46:56.679
I would agree with you, but I.
794
00:46:56.679 --> 00:47:00.639
Would not say that that's the consistent traditional Christian position.
795
00:47:00.760 --> 00:47:04.679
It happens to be the Protestant tendency, even though the
796
00:47:04.719 --> 00:47:06.639
first generation Protestants didn't really believe that.
797
00:47:07.119 --> 00:47:10.000
Right, I'm not trying to do that in a, you know,
798
00:47:10.559 --> 00:47:14.079
a bad way. I genuinely believe that narrative. I believe
799
00:47:14.199 --> 00:47:18.639
the narrative that this was an outgrowth of Protestantism. I mean,
800
00:47:18.800 --> 00:47:24.199
I think when you have solo scriptura, which is essentially
801
00:47:24.280 --> 00:47:28.960
a denial of the Church's authority to preach and teach,
802
00:47:29.440 --> 00:47:32.079
what is the correct understanding of scripture, and then you
803
00:47:32.239 --> 00:47:38.880
make yourself that authority. This sort of individualism rightly, not rightly,
804
00:47:38.960 --> 00:47:43.039
but naturally leads to I'm not saying there obviously links
805
00:47:43.079 --> 00:47:45.719
in the chain along the way, but I'm thinking. I'm
806
00:47:45.840 --> 00:47:49.599
saying that I think this Protestant doctrine of solo scriptora
807
00:47:49.719 --> 00:47:52.480
and in its crudest form, just me and my Bible
808
00:47:52.559 --> 00:47:56.480
in my closet, eventually leads to, well, not only do
809
00:47:56.519 --> 00:47:58.400
you not want Rome to tell you what is the
810
00:47:58.480 --> 00:48:01.960
understanding of scripture? You don't want any legislative authority over
811
00:48:02.079 --> 00:48:06.039
you to be governing by laws that they see as
812
00:48:06.119 --> 00:48:08.639
Christian when you don't agree with that. And so I
813
00:48:08.800 --> 00:48:14.159
think it is an eventual, natural outgrowth of Protestantism and
814
00:48:14.320 --> 00:48:17.239
the doctrine of solar scriptora which leads to this kind
815
00:48:17.280 --> 00:48:22.159
of fundamental societal individualism that we experience in the West.
816
00:48:22.280 --> 00:48:26.159
I don't think, really, I don't think anybody should deny that,
817
00:48:26.320 --> 00:48:28.639
especially if you're not Protestant. So I'm not using that
818
00:48:28.719 --> 00:48:33.360
as agatcha. I genuinely believe that that was the trajectory. However,
819
00:48:34.719 --> 00:48:36.519
I want to give the Protestants a little bit more
820
00:48:36.599 --> 00:48:39.079
credit in saying that well, I don't think that this
821
00:48:39.400 --> 00:48:42.440
happened out of nowhere. Where did they Where did they
822
00:48:42.519 --> 00:48:47.519
get this idea or belief from that the church should
823
00:48:47.559 --> 00:48:50.920
not really be involved in the state. I mean, it
824
00:48:51.039 --> 00:48:53.280
seems to me, and and what you said, I do
825
00:48:53.480 --> 00:48:57.679
kind of appreciate that that from the Islamic perspective, I
826
00:48:57.760 --> 00:49:00.880
think the reason why this happens is because Islam, whether
827
00:49:00.920 --> 00:49:02.719
you agree with the laws or not, that's not really
828
00:49:02.800 --> 00:49:06.679
the discussion right now. Is that it is very clearly political.
829
00:49:06.840 --> 00:49:09.599
There is no separation between church and state or church
830
00:49:09.679 --> 00:49:13.199
and mosque. It's very very explicit and clear. And I
831
00:49:13.280 --> 00:49:17.480
think that lack of clarity that exists or doesn't exist
832
00:49:17.920 --> 00:49:21.400
in Christianity is the reason why you eventually had the
833
00:49:21.840 --> 00:49:25.519
Protestant Reformation, and then what I think this sort of
834
00:49:25.559 --> 00:49:29.440
secular liberalism, which eventually is an outgrowth of Protestantism, is
835
00:49:29.559 --> 00:49:33.559
because the Church and the Bible were not as clear
836
00:49:33.840 --> 00:49:36.559
on its doctrine of church and state. That's what I'm arguing.
837
00:49:36.719 --> 00:49:38.800
If they were not that clear, you would not have
838
00:49:39.159 --> 00:49:43.559
the level of unanimity from the fourth century until even
839
00:49:43.960 --> 00:49:47.159
literally up until seventeen eighteen hundreds when the Revolutions took
840
00:49:47.159 --> 00:49:50.119
over Europe. I mean, you have over a thousand years
841
00:49:50.239 --> 00:49:55.079
of really no dissension amongst significant groups East and West
842
00:49:55.840 --> 00:50:00.280
in this principle of symphonia. In fact, Holy Roman prior
843
00:50:00.320 --> 00:50:03.840
amongst the Catholics, had the exact same symbol of the
844
00:50:03.960 --> 00:50:06.960
double headed eagle that the Eastern Byzantine Empire has of
845
00:50:07.039 --> 00:50:08.880
the double headed eagle. And for those that don't know
846
00:50:09.199 --> 00:50:11.119
the meaning of that is you have one body of
847
00:50:11.199 --> 00:50:14.519
the people in two heads. The two heads just simply
848
00:50:14.519 --> 00:50:18.480
symbolize two different aspects of human society, the spiritual.
849
00:50:18.039 --> 00:50:18.719
And the temporal.
850
00:50:19.320 --> 00:50:22.239
They work in harmony because it's the same body, but
851
00:50:22.360 --> 00:50:24.360
they have two different spheres or roles.
852
00:50:24.840 --> 00:50:26.920
This actually comes out of the Old Testament.
853
00:50:26.920 --> 00:50:29.039
If you look at the Old Testament, there's a clear
854
00:50:29.159 --> 00:50:33.519
delineated spheres of authority to where for example, you can't
855
00:50:34.039 --> 00:50:37.000
you know, Saul in one case is castigated because Saul
856
00:50:37.079 --> 00:50:40.480
tries to do priestly functions. And within the Mosaic law,
857
00:50:40.559 --> 00:50:43.360
they had this clear delineation that there's a difference between
858
00:50:43.360 --> 00:50:46.159
the laws of kings. Again, Moses had a little book
859
00:50:46.199 --> 00:50:49.239
about laws of kings from the Torah, and then principles
860
00:50:49.320 --> 00:50:53.880
that governed the levitical priesthood. That principle was then adopted.
861
00:50:53.960 --> 00:50:56.480
I'm not saying the levitical laws themselves, but the principle
862
00:50:56.559 --> 00:51:01.079
was adopted when society became Christianized. There were some groups
863
00:51:01.280 --> 00:51:04.480
in the first and second century who were not the
864
00:51:04.599 --> 00:51:07.039
most educated Christians, who thought that it was into the
865
00:51:07.079 --> 00:51:08.840
world he was going to immediately come back, and so
866
00:51:09.280 --> 00:51:11.679
they didn't think under this time of persecution that they
867
00:51:11.719 --> 00:51:14.280
would be put in a situation where they would apply
868
00:51:14.639 --> 00:51:19.519
biblical principles and then later canonical canon law principles, church
869
00:51:19.599 --> 00:51:23.480
law principles to society. Once the imperium became Christianized, it's
870
00:51:23.559 --> 00:51:25.360
only natural that they would apply those.
871
00:51:25.400 --> 00:51:28.320
But here's the thing. The New Testament is not unclear
872
00:51:28.360 --> 00:51:28.679
about that.
873
00:51:29.199 --> 00:51:31.599
And if you've got over a thousand years of unanimity
874
00:51:31.679 --> 00:51:34.280
between between East and West, even if they disagree theologically,
875
00:51:34.519 --> 00:51:36.960
they still agree on this principle all the way up
876
00:51:37.039 --> 00:51:39.760
until perhaps the seventeen eighteen hundreds is really when this
877
00:51:39.880 --> 00:51:44.320
begins to be questioned. So where's that lack
of clarity
878
00:51:44.480 --> 00:51:47.119
for those for that millennium plus?
879
00:51:48.199 --> 00:51:52.199
Okay, So what I see is that in the early period,
880
00:51:52.280 --> 00:51:59.000
as you said, there wasn't consensus on the correct view
881
00:51:59.079 --> 00:52:01.559
of the church and state, and then in the latter
882
00:52:01.639 --> 00:52:04.199
portion we also have this confusion. But then we have
883
00:52:04.360 --> 00:52:09.280
a middle period which I agree in the Roman West
884
00:52:09.599 --> 00:52:13.119
and in the East you do have an agreed upon
885
00:52:13.360 --> 00:52:18.079
standard in which Christians seem to be agreeing that, no,
886
00:52:18.559 --> 00:52:23.760
there is this sinfonia and there is this involvement in
887
00:52:23.960 --> 00:52:26.719
the state, but from the church. I agree with that.
888
00:52:27.119 --> 00:52:30.320
But I'm saying is in Islam you don't have that.
889
00:52:30.480 --> 00:52:32.599
You can disagree with the laws, you can disagree with
890
00:52:33.360 --> 00:52:37.199
whatever else the application of it. But we see very
891
00:52:37.360 --> 00:52:41.280
early on that Islam is political. There was no There
892
00:52:41.320 --> 00:52:46.239
were many disputes and debates, even theologically in early Islam,
893
00:52:46.760 --> 00:52:48.760
but this wasn't really one of them. There was debate
894
00:52:48.840 --> 00:52:52.360
over who should be the political leader, sure, but there
895
00:52:52.480 --> 00:52:56.760
wasn't debate over there being political leaders and them fundamentally
896
00:52:57.199 --> 00:53:01.199
instituting Islamic law. You see that all the way up
897
00:53:01.519 --> 00:53:02.400
to the current day.
898
00:53:02.519 --> 00:53:02.639
Now.
899
00:53:02.719 --> 00:53:07.199
Of course, as you rightly said that, this sort of
900
00:53:07.280 --> 00:53:11.480
secular liberalism has also hit Muslim lands, and sure there
901
00:53:11.559 --> 00:53:15.440
are problems there, but I don't think it is nearly
902
00:53:15.599 --> 00:53:18.679
as bad as it is in the West. And I
903
00:53:18.760 --> 00:53:24.119
think it's because Muslims have a much more foundational understanding
904
00:53:24.280 --> 00:53:29.400
of the relationship between Islamic law and society where that's really,
905
00:53:30.559 --> 00:53:33.840
to be honest, I think it's lacking in if you're correct,
906
00:53:34.239 --> 00:53:37.760
if you're correct about the correct view of how Christianity
907
00:53:37.880 --> 00:53:41.599
sees church and state, then you should be doing a
908
00:53:41.679 --> 00:53:44.360
lot more lectures on this, because it seems that most
909
00:53:44.440 --> 00:53:48.760
Americans and most supposed Christians in the West don't view
910
00:53:48.840 --> 00:53:51.159
it this way. They don't view it this way really
911
00:53:51.199 --> 00:53:54.480
at all. And that's why you have people like Michael
912
00:53:54.559 --> 00:53:57.559
Jones or I know, and you've not criticized him, but
913
00:53:57.880 --> 00:54:01.960
Trent Horn and even Catholics, where the Catholics previously or
914
00:54:02.039 --> 00:54:04.800
the Roman West would have agreed with the East and
915
00:54:04.920 --> 00:54:09.079
kind of your view of government and structure, where today
916
00:54:09.119 --> 00:54:11.440
you don't really see that. There aren't too many Catholics
917
00:54:11.480 --> 00:54:14.920
who believe that, other than maybe some trad Cats, not
918
00:54:15.039 --> 00:54:17.519
too many Protestants who believe that, and then it's just
919
00:54:17.599 --> 00:54:19.079
a small amount of Diarites.
920
00:54:19.159 --> 00:54:22.400
To be honest with you, is Trent still here, by
921
00:54:22.440 --> 00:54:25.599
the way, is Trent did Trent leave? Oh? God was
922
00:54:25.639 --> 00:54:27.719
going to say a cussword to make him leave, because.
923
00:54:27.480 --> 00:54:31.239
Trent Horn was here before. Because I saw a guy
924
00:54:31.400 --> 00:54:33.960
that was wearing a Trent Horn badge, but it didn't
925
00:54:33.960 --> 00:54:34.920
look like Trent Horn.
926
00:54:35.039 --> 00:54:37.719
It was weird. That was his impost body double.
927
00:54:38.039 --> 00:54:41.000
So he didn't want to get assassinated, so he has
928
00:54:41.039 --> 00:54:43.480
a hired body double in case, like he's around me.
929
00:54:43.639 --> 00:54:44.280
So now I'm joking.
930
00:54:45.039 --> 00:54:48.519
Well, so you said one thing I want to highlight.
931
00:54:48.639 --> 00:54:51.360
That's not the main point. But you said there wasn't
932
00:54:51.360 --> 00:54:56.840
a consensus, And but who do you do you mean
933
00:54:56.920 --> 00:54:58.519
in the first three centuries when when the church is
934
00:54:58.559 --> 00:55:01.280
being persecuted. Why would there be a consensus when you
935
00:55:01.360 --> 00:55:04.519
admitted that the correct position could still be there in
936
00:55:04.599 --> 00:55:07.079
a period when it's debated. I mean, Islam is full
937
00:55:07.119 --> 00:55:11.480
of non consensus and debates. So who are you talking
938
00:55:11.480 --> 00:55:13.039
about when there's not a consensus? Do you just mean
939
00:55:13.079 --> 00:55:13.920
the first three centuries?
940
00:55:14.199 --> 00:55:16.559
Yeah, I'm just talking about the early period. And I
941
00:55:16.679 --> 00:55:20.079
agree that just because there wasn't a consensus doesn't mean
942
00:55:20.159 --> 00:55:23.239
that your representation or your position is incorrect. I'm not
943
00:55:23.320 --> 00:55:26.840
saying that. I'm just saying that it appears that it's
944
00:55:27.000 --> 00:55:31.599
not as clear in early Christianity as it in Islam.
945
00:55:32.280 --> 00:55:35.920
As you said, there were theological debates. If for example,
946
00:55:36.000 --> 00:55:37.760
is the kron created or not. I'm not trying to
947
00:55:37.800 --> 00:55:40.760
waste time, but there wasn't a debate. And there were
948
00:55:40.800 --> 00:55:43.920
debates about who should be the ruler politically in Islam,
949
00:55:44.280 --> 00:55:47.039
and that's why we have a division between Sunni and Shiah,
950
00:55:47.320 --> 00:55:50.039
But there was no debate about whether or not Islam
951
00:55:50.119 --> 00:55:52.440
should be political in that way. That's what I was
952
00:55:52.480 --> 00:55:52.960
trying to say.
953
00:55:53.039 --> 00:55:57.119
Okay, But I mean in the case of Nicia, for example,
954
00:55:57.280 --> 00:56:00.679
if there's debate in Nicia settles a dispute in the cannons,
955
00:56:00.760 --> 00:56:02.639
note that you can be a Christian and a soldier,
956
00:56:03.239 --> 00:56:05.360
then how does that How is that a problem for
957
00:56:05.480 --> 00:56:07.760
my position because something is debated for a period.
958
00:56:07.960 --> 00:56:11.400
I justerstand that the argument that I'm making, and it's
959
00:56:11.480 --> 00:56:14.559
not it doesn't follow necessarily. I'm not arguing that, but
960
00:56:14.639 --> 00:56:18.280
I think it counts as evidence against a position, is
961
00:56:18.400 --> 00:56:22.559
that it seems that because there is this and not
962
00:56:22.719 --> 00:56:25.039
a small difference a why I would say, a wide
963
00:56:25.079 --> 00:56:28.559
difference for several hundred years. And then you also have
964
00:56:28.840 --> 00:56:31.880
that taking place again today where your position, I mean,
965
00:56:31.920 --> 00:56:34.480
I'll ask you this, do you think that your position
966
00:56:34.639 --> 00:56:37.119
is a minority view held amongst Christians today?
967
00:56:38.480 --> 00:56:41.800
Well, if you use the term Christian broadly in a broadway.
968
00:56:41.840 --> 00:56:47.159
Yeah, I'm saying, including people who call themself Orthodox, Catholic,
969
00:56:47.360 --> 00:56:48.039
and Protestant.
970
00:56:48.440 --> 00:56:50.639
Yeah, I know you would agree. You would probably say.
971
00:56:50.599 --> 00:56:53.119
Some of these guys are phonies, I understand, But I'm saying,
972
00:56:53.159 --> 00:56:57.199
and people who identify as Christian today. Wouldn't you agree
973
00:56:57.280 --> 00:56:59.719
that your position is a minority and most people don't
974
00:56:59.760 --> 00:57:01.519
believe than that who call themselves Christian.
975
00:57:01.719 --> 00:57:04.960
Yes, But in terms of the prompt of the debate,
976
00:57:05.039 --> 00:57:07.280
in terms of how this would prove which is better
977
00:57:07.400 --> 00:57:12.039
for society, it only really betters society if the Islamic
978
00:57:12.119 --> 00:57:15.800
position actually has the good for society. And if it's
979
00:57:15.960 --> 00:57:21.239
correct that the church's focus is not primarily political, it
980
00:57:21.800 --> 00:57:23.880
just simply doesn't follow from that that it has nothing
981
00:57:23.960 --> 00:57:26.400
to say about the political. So if the argument is
982
00:57:26.480 --> 00:57:31.960
that the Bible gives rise to the revolutions of
Protestantism
983
00:57:32.079 --> 00:57:34.280
or something like that, I just simply think that's a
984
00:57:34.400 --> 00:57:38.360
correlation without causation in the sense that, oh so, because
985
00:57:38.400 --> 00:57:42.320
the Bible existed, and Jake's understanding that the Bible's New
986
00:57:42.360 --> 00:57:45.280
Testament is more Protestant in its view of church and state,
987
00:57:45.880 --> 00:57:47.920
I think you have to demonstrate that first, I don't
988
00:57:47.920 --> 00:57:50.440
think you could demonstrate that. And the fact that in
989
00:57:50.480 --> 00:57:52.559
the first, second, third century some people disputed that it
990
00:57:52.639 --> 00:57:56.039
simply just doesn't follow that there is no Christian doctrine
991
00:57:56.119 --> 00:57:59.960
the state. So it's it's not that strong of an argument.
992
00:58:01.320 --> 00:58:04.079
Yet the same flaws apply to it. By the way,
993
00:58:04.480 --> 00:58:09.280
So the fact that Islam does believe quote in a theocracy,
994
00:58:10.000 --> 00:58:13.480
has that actually successfully always been applied throughout the centuries
995
00:58:13.519 --> 00:58:17.199
of Islamic history. Just think about terms like the way
996
00:58:17.320 --> 00:58:20.199
that the legal rulings infick and whatnot in your system
997
00:58:20.239 --> 00:58:23.480
are applied. I mean, it's not always consistently applied, is
998
00:58:23.559 --> 00:58:28.400
it No? Okay, So the idea that the consistent application
999
00:58:28.639 --> 00:58:34.559
somehow necessarily proves or shows that your position is better,
1000
00:58:34.679 --> 00:58:35.960
I just simply think doesn't follow.
1001
00:58:37.000 --> 00:58:40.880
So the original question I asked, and that's what I'm
1002
00:58:40.920 --> 00:58:43.519
inviting you to do. And maybe I'm just missing it.
1003
00:58:44.039 --> 00:58:48.000
So I have my own thesis about why this happened.
1004
00:58:48.039 --> 00:58:50.360
I explained it, and you were saying, well, it's a correlation,
1005
00:58:50.519 --> 00:58:54.159
but not necessarily causation. I understand that. So that's why
1006
00:58:54.199 --> 00:58:56.840
I'm inviting you to explain. And maybe I'm missing it.
1007
00:58:57.400 --> 00:59:01.320
What was the clear causation of Okay, forget about the
1008
00:59:01.360 --> 00:59:03.480
first three hundred years. I understand what you're saying this,
1009
00:59:03.960 --> 00:59:09.239
but what was exactly the clear causation from where the
1010
00:59:09.400 --> 00:59:13.519
Roman West, the Catholics, and the East, even after they separated,
1011
00:59:14.039 --> 00:59:17.039
had this agreement. And now it's like, and I'm not
1012
00:59:17.159 --> 00:59:20.639
saying this to be funny, I'm just saying, in reality,
1013
00:59:20.800 --> 00:59:23.639
now it's just Jay Dyer and his crew and some
1014
00:59:23.920 --> 00:59:27.480
Orthodox who believe this, and pretty much everybody else has
1015
00:59:27.559 --> 00:59:30.320
gone by the
wayside. It seems like a really sharp
1016
00:59:30.480 --> 00:59:35.079
decline that happened very quickly. Now I gave my reasoning
1017
00:59:35.239 --> 00:59:39.719
or how of you know, historical kind of argument of
1018
00:59:39.800 --> 00:59:42.280
why I think this happened. Now, you don't believe it's
1019
00:59:42.280 --> 00:59:44.480
the Bible's fault. You don't believe it's the New Testament fault.
1020
00:59:44.559 --> 00:59:47.000
So that's why I'm kind of inviting you to explain
1021
00:59:47.079 --> 00:59:47.559
the causation.
1022
00:59:47.719 --> 00:59:50.920
So if we set aside that early issue, then I
1023
00:59:50.960 --> 00:59:53.239
would say, if you look at the eleventh century, there's
1024
00:59:53.280 --> 00:59:56.199
a huge revolution that even Roman Catholic scholars would admit.
1025
00:59:56.320 --> 00:59:59.320
You have people like Kungar and de Vornik, the famous
1026
00:59:59.400 --> 01:00:01.840
union a schol or they admit that there's a revolution
1027
01:00:02.039 --> 01:00:05.280
in ecclesiology in the West. It's known as their Grigorian reforms.
1028
01:00:05.800 --> 01:00:08.440
And what's unique about this is that the papacy began
1029
01:00:08.559 --> 01:00:12.239
to take on a new geopolitical role. I think that
1030
01:00:12.360 --> 01:00:14.239
we can try to be charitable and fair, as fair
1031
01:00:14.239 --> 01:00:16.559
as we can to the Roman Catholics of that period.
1032
01:00:16.599 --> 01:00:19.320
I'm not blaming every romany of that time period. I
1033
01:00:19.440 --> 01:00:21.920
think that the schism began in ten fifty four and
1034
01:00:22.000 --> 01:00:23.679
then sort of flourished.
1035
01:00:23.559 --> 01:00:25.719
Or grew apart over time.
1036
01:00:26.320 --> 01:00:29.960
But it's unanimously nowadays admitted even amongst Catholic scholars, that
1037
01:00:30.320 --> 01:00:34.679
this period is a revolution in ecclesiology. Now, that might
1038
01:00:34.840 --> 01:00:37.559
sound abstract and not like a huge deal, but the
1039
01:00:37.679 --> 01:00:40.719
reason that matters is that prior to that, canon law
1040
01:00:40.800 --> 01:00:44.360
in the East and the West forbade the Church from
1041
01:00:44.760 --> 01:00:47.599
being the state. So we're not saying that the Church
1042
01:00:47.679 --> 01:00:49.679
has no thing to say to the state, or that
1043
01:00:49.719 --> 01:00:51.519
the Church doesn't work in symphony. Again, that was the
1044
01:00:51.559 --> 01:00:54.480
norm even prior to the eleventh century. But when you
1045
01:00:54.639 --> 01:00:58.559
have the papacy saying I am now a geopolitical power,
1046
01:00:59.039 --> 01:01:01.639
I am now going to take the sword the papacy
1047
01:01:01.679 --> 01:01:04.400
begins to have standing armies, they begin to have warrior monks,
1048
01:01:04.519 --> 01:01:08.639
monastic orders that have the sword. Again, in the Byzantine model,
1049
01:01:08.880 --> 01:01:13.159
the sword isn't bad, it's exercised. As Romans thirteen says,
1050
01:01:13.880 --> 01:01:17.920
the imperium has the diaconos. That's the same word as
1051
01:01:18.119 --> 01:01:21.480
deacon in Romans thirteen. So Paul is calling the emperor
1052
01:01:21.559 --> 01:01:24.599
a deacon. That means he has a quasi religious role.
1053
01:01:25.079 --> 01:01:27.199
So even in the New Testament, the idea of Romans
1054
01:01:27.239 --> 01:01:30.000
thirteen is not a radical separation of church and state.
1055
01:01:30.039 --> 01:01:33.280
That's a Roger Williams Baptist idea, very very late. So
1056
01:01:33.599 --> 01:01:36.239
eleventh century is a key move to where the papacy
1057
01:01:36.360 --> 01:01:41.599
takes on geopolitical world power. That begins a process in
1058
01:01:41.719 --> 01:01:46.559
my view, that culminates in a reformation rejection of some
1059
01:01:46.800 --> 01:01:49.800
of those papal excesses and most of the reformers. As
1060
01:01:49.840 --> 01:01:54.280
we all know, Protestantism is protesting the papal Roman Catholic system.
1061
01:01:54.559 --> 01:01:57.599
So not everything in the papal Roman Catholic system is wrong,
1062
01:01:58.039 --> 01:02:02.239
but what they are protesting is in some cases the overstepping,
1063
01:02:02.519 --> 01:02:04.639
particularly in the political realm. If you look at Western
1064
01:02:04.639 --> 01:02:09.039
European history, the German princes, other princes, they did not
1065
01:02:09.719 --> 01:02:12.599
like the papacy stepping into the temporal sphere.
1066
01:02:12.880 --> 01:02:16.519
They resented that. So the Reformation was partly a rejection
1067
01:02:16.800 --> 01:02:17.039
of that.
1068
01:02:17.440 --> 01:02:19.760
So if you want the long sort of causal chain,
1069
01:02:20.760 --> 01:02:22.880
which I do think is there, you could say, yeah,
1070
01:02:23.159 --> 01:02:27.079
there's a long series of revolutions that begins with regarding
1071
01:02:27.119 --> 01:02:29.639
reforms in eleventh century. And by the way, many of
1072
01:02:29.679 --> 01:02:31.960
those popes in eleventh century, I want to say the
1073
01:02:32.039 --> 01:02:35.559
majority of them actually for seventy years, were actually appointed
1074
01:02:35.639 --> 01:02:39.920
by German kings, So it's nepotism that set the stage
1075
01:02:40.000 --> 01:02:43.840
for down the road what would become the Reformation. So yeah,
1076
01:02:44.199 --> 01:02:46.559
I do think you could trace it this way and
1077
01:02:46.639 --> 01:02:48.679
then past that if you want to get up into
1078
01:02:48.800 --> 01:02:50.960
like the Bolsheviks and all that. I mean, that's all
1079
01:02:51.079 --> 01:02:53.599
Western banking money that was funding all of that.
1080
01:02:53.840 --> 01:02:56.119
So that's the long of it.
1081
01:02:56.199 --> 01:02:58.960
But none of that has anything to do with whether
1082
01:02:59.199 --> 01:03:01.519
the position was actually in the New Testament.
1083
01:03:02.400 --> 01:03:07.639
Okay, you mentioned about warrior monks
and stuff like that.
1084
01:03:07.760 --> 01:03:11.400
I'd know obviously it did exist. But what do you
1085
01:03:11.760 --> 01:03:17.760
make of my citation of Basil's canon that specifically mentions
1086
01:03:17.840 --> 01:03:22.559
that even if the war is quote unquote justified that
1087
01:03:22.800 --> 01:03:25.280
people who come back from that are not actually to
1088
01:03:25.480 --> 01:03:28.280
partake in communion for three years. So you have a
1089
01:03:28.400 --> 01:03:33.000
case in which it's supposedly legitimate, and yet in Saint
1090
01:03:33.079 --> 01:03:36.280
Basils canon it explicitly says that they're they're not clean
1091
01:03:36.719 --> 01:03:39.719
in the sense that they can't take communion.
1092
01:03:40.440 --> 01:03:40.639
Yeah.
1093
01:03:40.719 --> 01:03:42.760
So again, just like with knon I was part of
1094
01:03:42.880 --> 01:03:44.960
Sorry to cut it, that was part of canon that
1095
01:03:45.159 --> 01:03:46.719
was instituted as canon law.
1096
01:03:46.920 --> 01:03:49.239
Right, So the way canon law functions in Orthodox Church,
1097
01:03:49.360 --> 01:03:52.360
you can look at the canon's of Trollo, one of
1098
01:03:52.519 --> 01:03:54.880
the very last Canona. Trollo in the Orthodox Church says
1099
01:03:54.960 --> 01:03:58.679
that the application of these principles is up to the
1100
01:03:58.760 --> 01:04:01.320
prerogatives of the bit, so that for us, the local
1101
01:04:01.400 --> 01:04:04.440
bishop is the applier of that. That doesn't mean that
1102
01:04:04.599 --> 01:04:06.960
it's do whatever you want, but that he does have
1103
01:04:07.079 --> 01:04:09.280
the final say so, because for us there's not really
1104
01:04:09.280 --> 01:04:12.119
a higher authority than that. So for us, that type
1105
01:04:12.159 --> 01:04:15.119
of application would be applied first of all, on a
1106
01:04:15.199 --> 01:04:18.519
case by case basis. So it is possible that a
1107
01:04:18.599 --> 01:04:21.599
person doesn't have to be under the canonical penalty of
1108
01:04:21.840 --> 01:04:25.000
three years, but the principle is there because as we said,
1109
01:04:25.519 --> 01:04:28.840
even King David in the Old Testament was a righteous
1110
01:04:28.920 --> 01:04:29.719
warrior whom.
1111
01:04:29.599 --> 01:04:30.880
God taught how to fight.
1112
01:04:31.960 --> 01:04:34.400
Because he had shed so much blood, there were certain
1113
01:04:34.440 --> 01:04:36.679
things that were not appropriate for him. So it's a
1114
01:04:36.719 --> 01:04:38.960
canonical penalty that has nothing to do with saying you're
1115
01:04:39.000 --> 01:04:42.000
not saved. It's just saying, out of reverence for the sacrament,
1116
01:04:42.280 --> 01:04:46.039
we're going to impose a time where you do penance.
1117
01:04:46.119 --> 01:04:46.800
Because most of.
1118
01:04:46.800 --> 01:04:50.159
The time, even if you're just in the war, in
1119
01:04:50.199 --> 01:04:52.920
the battle, you still probably send in
some way in
1120
01:04:53.000 --> 01:04:57.880
our perspective, So it's simply a sort of a penance
1121
01:04:58.039 --> 01:05:00.280
that's restorative. It has nothing to do with say, like
1122
01:05:00.440 --> 01:05:01.960
you're excommunicated from the church.
1123
01:05:02.039 --> 01:05:03.280
It's not done at all. Yeah.
1124
01:05:03.599 --> 01:05:05.480
Yeah, I'm not saying that, But okay, I guess you
1125
01:05:05.599 --> 01:05:08.559
kind of answered at the end that you would agree.
1126
01:05:09.079 --> 01:05:11.000
I mean, I don't have this position, but for you
1127
01:05:11.880 --> 01:05:14.880
and the way you see this canon law, which comes
1128
01:05:14.920 --> 01:05:21.199
from Basil, is that inevitably in war, there's going to
1129
01:05:21.280 --> 01:05:23.880
be sins committed, even if it's supposed to be a
1130
01:05:24.039 --> 01:05:28.320
just war, and therefore because of that, I mean, do
1131
01:05:28.400 --> 01:05:30.960
you still see that as justified today? Is that something
1132
01:05:31.039 --> 01:05:35.000
that you would agree? What should be reinstated if there
1133
01:05:35.199 --> 01:05:38.840
was such a monarchy that that would be something to reinstate.
1134
01:05:39.480 --> 01:05:42.159
And again these penalties are not applied by the monarch.
1135
01:05:42.280 --> 01:05:45.039
These are penalties applied by the Church. So the church
1136
01:05:45.239 --> 01:05:49.599
applies the canons at the local setting. So all the
1137
01:05:49.719 --> 01:05:53.360
monarch's job is to do is to enforce what the
1138
01:05:53.440 --> 01:05:55.679
New Testament, not just in Romans thirteen, but for example,
1139
01:05:55.679 --> 01:05:59.360
Paul says to Timothy that the state has the job
1140
01:05:59.519 --> 01:06:03.039
the duty to punish evildoers, and then he lists a
1141
01:06:03.119 --> 01:06:06.360
series of offenses that are particularly egregious, such as murder,
1142
01:06:06.440 --> 01:06:10.679
et cetera. So the state's role is not to enforce
1143
01:06:10.960 --> 01:06:14.400
Church code. Even the Roman Catholic West had a distinction
1144
01:06:14.599 --> 01:06:17.239
between the penalties that the Church would give and so
1145
01:06:17.360 --> 01:06:20.320
for example, even when there were heretic laws in the
1146
01:06:20.400 --> 01:06:23.840
medieval West, the inquisition would hand those people over to
1147
01:06:24.079 --> 01:06:27.360
the state. They typically accept For the Spanish inquisition, which
1148
01:06:27.440 --> 01:06:31.119
was under Isabella, it was separate from the papal inquisition.
1149
01:06:32.039 --> 01:06:34.480
You handed over to the state. So in the same
1150
01:06:34.679 --> 01:06:37.599
case with Saint Justinian, like the church might make a ruling.
1151
01:06:38.519 --> 01:06:42.400
For example, Basil has a canon about abortion, the Church
1152
01:06:42.480 --> 01:06:46.280
doesn't say, like you're sentenced to death, it's handed over
1153
01:06:46.360 --> 01:06:48.599
to the state, and then the king makes that decision.
1154
01:06:48.679 --> 01:06:51.920
And we simply see that as modeled with Solomon. You know,
1155
01:06:51.960 --> 01:06:54.960
when Solomon has the two hoes and he, you know,
1156
01:06:55.199 --> 01:06:57.280
does that wise thing where he tests the hose and
1157
01:06:57.400 --> 01:06:59.320
then he says, Okay, now we know who the real
1158
01:06:59.400 --> 01:07:03.000
mom is. Right, So he's applying the principle of the
1159
01:07:03.119 --> 01:07:07.840
law to the three zero fours and the thoughts thhot,
1160
01:07:08.039 --> 01:07:09.480
that's old Testament thought thought.
1161
01:07:11.039 --> 01:07:15.320
Anyway, that's a thought exercise right there.
1162
01:07:17.559 --> 01:07:21.320
Yes, oh, so you're all week yeah, so let me
1163
01:07:21.440 --> 01:07:24.079
get because you didn't respond to this, but I mentioned
1164
01:07:24.079 --> 01:07:27.400
a lot, so it's fine. I mentioned Luke chapter twelve
1165
01:07:27.800 --> 01:07:31.679
in the scenario where a man brings an issue of
1166
01:07:31.760 --> 01:07:36.159
inheritance and Jesus answers, men, who made me a judge
1167
01:07:36.320 --> 01:07:40.920
or an arbiter over you? Why if he If Jesus
1168
01:07:41.000 --> 01:07:42.880
is supposed to be the head of the church, right
1169
01:07:43.320 --> 01:07:47.519
and you see that, or as you're claiming, the church
1170
01:07:47.800 --> 01:07:51.440
is not supposed to be completely a political why would
1171
01:07:51.559 --> 01:07:52.800
Jesus respond in this way?
1172
01:07:53.360 --> 01:07:55.719
Great question in fact, and a lot of Protestants would
1173
01:07:55.719 --> 01:07:56.800
bring up that same passage.
1174
01:07:56.880 --> 01:07:58.880
So for us, first of all.
1175
01:07:58.920 --> 01:08:02.679
In Jesus's first come, in his quote Humiliation, we see
1176
01:08:02.719 --> 01:08:06.440
the ministry that he's doing as specifically fulfilling.
1177
01:08:06.039 --> 01:08:07.440
The role of the humble servant.
1178
01:08:08.119 --> 01:08:10.800
But even in the Old Testament that would not be
1179
01:08:11.199 --> 01:08:13.920
something that you would only take that kind of a
1180
01:08:14.039 --> 01:08:16.880
ruling to the state. So in his first coming he
1181
01:08:17.000 --> 01:08:20.640
is specifically not in any role of state. In the
1182
01:08:21.119 --> 01:08:25.439
exaltation and ascension, we think that when he ascended, he
1183
01:08:25.640 --> 01:08:29.880
then became king of kings. Thus monarchy continues on even
1184
01:08:30.039 --> 01:08:31.800
via the Book of Revelation calling.
1185
01:08:31.640 --> 01:08:32.680
Him King of King.
1186
01:08:32.760 --> 01:08:37.520
So all earthly kings are underneath the Supreme King. So
1187
01:08:38.000 --> 01:08:40.319
it wouldn't be sensible. And it's the same with the
1188
01:08:40.399 --> 01:08:43.600
woman in adultery. We believe Jesus is the one that
1189
01:08:43.680 --> 01:08:45.640
gave those Old Testament laws. I know you
know that
1190
01:08:45.680 --> 01:08:47.439
we believe that, But I'm saying that for the audience, right,
1191
01:08:47.439 --> 01:08:49.159
So it's not a different god of the Old Testament
1192
01:08:49.279 --> 01:08:50.880
or something like that. So Jesus is the one that
1193
01:08:50.960 --> 01:08:54.000
laid down those penalties, and certainly, as the supreme judge,
1194
01:08:54.039 --> 01:08:59.079
he has the authority to abrogate or to relax a penalty.
1195
01:09:00.359 --> 01:09:02.960
But there's several cases in the New Testament where people
1196
01:09:03.039 --> 01:09:06.960
come to Jesus with legal matters or personal vengeance matters,
1197
01:09:07.239 --> 01:09:09.680
and he simply says, that's not what my mission is
1198
01:09:09.800 --> 01:09:12.920
at this point. But that does not mean and let's
1199
01:09:12.960 --> 01:09:17.680
take one one example in Matthew five, when he talks about,
1200
01:09:19.039 --> 01:09:22.680
you know, don't if if somebody slaps you give him
1201
01:09:22.720 --> 01:09:25.279
the other cheek, right, And this is oftentimes cited as, oh,
1202
01:09:25.279 --> 01:09:28.199
we're supposed to be pacifist. We don't read the Bible
1203
01:09:28.640 --> 01:09:31.760
in isolation from the rest of the passages. Right, this
1204
01:09:31.960 --> 01:09:34.920
is talking about personal vengeance. It has another day was
1205
01:09:34.960 --> 01:09:38.439
saying that you can't have, you know, righteous judgment in
1206
01:09:38.560 --> 01:09:40.920
a law court. Because there's many places where the New
1207
01:09:40.960 --> 01:09:45.560
Testament gives principles for judges and for rulers. The Book
1208
01:09:45.640 --> 01:09:48.399
of Proverbs, which is always used by the early Church.
1209
01:09:48.479 --> 01:09:52.720
It was, according to athanacious the Catechism for converts, including
1210
01:09:52.760 --> 01:09:57.199
the Judo Canon. It's full of principles of justice in
1211
01:09:58.079 --> 01:10:02.439
weights and balances, that's money, principles of kings and judges
1212
01:10:02.520 --> 01:10:05.840
that they shouldn't take bribes. Those are all statements to
1213
01:10:06.279 --> 01:10:09.560
rulers in the political room, in the police. It's just
1214
01:10:09.640 --> 01:10:12.199
simply not what Jesus' focus was in his three years
1215
01:10:12.239 --> 01:10:15.840
of ministry, which was about accomplishing what the Father had
1216
01:10:15.840 --> 01:10:16.479
set him out to do.
1217
01:10:17.239 --> 01:10:20.359
Okay, So it seems like to kind of summarize, you're
1218
01:10:20.359 --> 01:10:25.720
saying that that was not Jesus's initial earthly ministry, correct,
1219
01:10:25.920 --> 01:10:28.840
was not to be you know, a political figure or
1220
01:10:29.760 --> 01:10:33.039
to be instituting you know, these specific laws in that way.
1221
01:10:34.359 --> 01:10:34.640
Okay.
1222
01:10:34.720 --> 01:10:37.399
So I mean maybe that's where you're trying to say
1223
01:10:37.479 --> 01:10:43.239
that Protestantism or the eventual outgrowth of complete separation between
1224
01:10:43.399 --> 01:10:47.359
church and state, is due to a misunderstanding of applying
1225
01:10:47.760 --> 01:10:52.600
Jesus's initial earthly ministry. Yes, and his initial kind of
1226
01:10:53.399 --> 01:10:55.880
you know, campaign and what he was supposed to be
1227
01:10:55.960 --> 01:10:59.560
doing too later after the ascension and going forward.
1228
01:10:59.680 --> 01:11:00.520
Is that Yeah.
1229
01:11:00.560 --> 01:11:02.680
So like in the Old Testament, you have many places again,
1230
01:11:02.840 --> 01:11:06.079
like where there's prophecies that the kings of the nations
1231
01:11:06.199 --> 01:11:08.520
and the gentiles would convert. You have you know, Sowing
1232
01:11:08.600 --> 01:11:11.319
forty five, which is about in our view Jesus and Mary,
1233
01:11:11.439 --> 01:11:15.000
but we also think it's about kings and magistrates converting.
1234
01:11:15.520 --> 01:11:18.720
So there's laws for magistrates and even those penal sanctions
1235
01:11:18.760 --> 01:11:22.560
at times you can see throughout Byzantine Code Like, I'm
1236
01:11:22.600 --> 01:11:25.479
not saying that they're being judaizers and like copy pasting,
1237
01:11:25.680 --> 01:11:29.680
but they're using the principles of the Old Testament penal
1238
01:11:29.760 --> 01:11:33.359
sanctions and the Mosaic law, and even applying those in
1239
01:11:33.439 --> 01:11:37.079
a social setting. So it's only natural that when Christian
1240
01:11:37.159 --> 01:11:41.920
societies become predominantly Christian that they would function that way.
1241
01:11:42.079 --> 01:11:44.600
And I just don't see why any of that. None
1242
01:11:44.640 --> 01:11:47.760
of that demonstrates that it's unclear in the New Testament.
1243
01:11:48.239 --> 01:11:52.119
Okay, is there any Christian monarchy today or theocracy?
1244
01:11:54.079 --> 01:11:57.760
I don't not that I'm aware of other than nominally okay,
1245
01:11:58.279 --> 01:12:02.159
And I mean there are, they're monarchs, but they're nominally okay.
1246
01:12:02.720 --> 01:12:06.439
Now, when I quoted you from a video where you
1247
01:12:06.479 --> 01:12:12.760
discuss this topic in detail as attempting to reinstitute it,
1248
01:12:12.960 --> 01:12:14.800
and you kind of mentioned it in your opening statement,
1249
01:12:14.840 --> 01:12:21.239
I don't mean making you know society exactly what the
1250
01:12:21.279 --> 01:12:25.720
Byzantine Empire was, Like, I'm not saying that, but how
1251
01:12:25.800 --> 01:12:29.319
do you envision anything coming remotely close to that given
1252
01:12:29.359 --> 01:12:31.239
the situation that we're in. And I think it is
1253
01:12:31.720 --> 01:12:34.920
related to the question of the debate, because you know,
1254
01:12:35.039 --> 01:12:37.880
we're talking a lot about theory here and kind of
1255
01:12:38.279 --> 01:12:41.800
you know, what the principles are of Christianity as you
1256
01:12:41.880 --> 01:12:43.840
see it in the Old Testament in the New Testament,
1257
01:12:44.199 --> 01:12:47.359
but in terms of practical application, it seems to be
1258
01:12:47.479 --> 01:12:51.600
really lacking. You know, you're representing I'm not saying it's
1259
01:12:51.720 --> 01:12:53.720
incorrect view. I mean, I've tried to argue for that,
1260
01:12:53.880 --> 01:12:57.079
but you're representing a view which you're admitting is held
1261
01:12:57.119 --> 01:13:01.840
by a minority of quote unquote Christians today. So even
1262
01:13:01.880 --> 01:13:06.039
if you're correct, it seems like there's no genuine practical
1263
01:13:06.119 --> 01:13:08.960
application of that anyway. So how does that really help
1264
01:13:09.119 --> 01:13:12.279
society if it's never been instituted or it's not for
1265
01:13:12.439 --> 01:13:13.159
several hundred years.
1266
01:13:13.199 --> 01:13:14.039
Yeah, that's a fair question.
1267
01:13:14.119 --> 01:13:16.159
I think if you look at as we mentioned in
1268
01:13:16.279 --> 01:13:19.279
last night's Today, right, if I was Isaiah and it
1269
01:13:19.479 --> 01:13:22.319
was you know, I was being taken into Babylonian captivity,
1270
01:13:22.840 --> 01:13:26.039
and I'd been given these prophecies that, from our perspective,
1271
01:13:26.079 --> 01:13:29.279
are predicting the conversion of the Gentile nations to worship
1272
01:13:29.319 --> 01:13:31.479
the God of Israel, to worship Yahweh, that would seem
1273
01:13:31.760 --> 01:13:32.640
totally impossible.
1274
01:13:32.680 --> 01:13:35.079
How could that ever be? If you look at the.
1275
01:13:35.079 --> 01:13:37.600
First century, when Jesus is doing his ministry. Right in
1276
01:13:37.640 --> 01:13:40.520
the Book of John, he says, if I be lifted up,
1277
01:13:40.560 --> 01:13:44.239
I will draw all nations under myself. I mean, Christianity
1278
01:13:44.359 --> 01:13:47.880
is a tiny sect. This seems absolutely outlandish and impossible.
1279
01:13:48.039 --> 01:13:51.720
In the Magnificat in Luke the Theotokos, Saint Mary says,
1280
01:13:53.239 --> 01:13:56.680
all generations henceforth will call me blessed. These are pretty
1281
01:13:56.720 --> 01:14:00.520
profound prophecies. And again, at that time that would seem postrous.
1282
01:14:00.560 --> 01:14:02.119
How would all the nations call.
1283
01:14:02.039 --> 01:14:06.960
This random virgin in Israel blessed? That seems crazy.
1284
01:14:07.520 --> 01:14:11.319
And yet here we are two thousand years later, and many,
1285
01:14:11.439 --> 01:14:14.600
many millions, perhaps billions of people have called her blessed.
1286
01:14:14.920 --> 01:14:19.439
So even the latest scholars dating those texts would still
1287
01:14:19.600 --> 01:14:22.880
date it within the timeframe when the Church was a
1288
01:14:23.039 --> 01:14:25.439
tiny minority being persecuted. My point in all that is
1289
01:14:25.640 --> 01:14:28.640
simply to say that just because something is
not the
1290
01:14:28.880 --> 01:14:32.239
present dominant idea has nothing to do with whether it
1291
01:14:32.359 --> 01:14:34.319
could be. And when you look at the way that
1292
01:14:34.439 --> 01:14:37.479
the first three centuries of the Church eventually took over
1293
01:14:37.520 --> 01:14:39.880
the Roman Empire, it wasn't with swords, it was with
1294
01:14:40.079 --> 01:14:44.319
the blood of the martyrs. That's what actually converted made
1295
01:14:44.359 --> 01:14:46.079
Byzantium what it is. It was built in the blood
1296
01:14:46.079 --> 01:14:49.199
of the martyrs. So in the same way, just because
1297
01:14:49.359 --> 01:14:53.000
at this present moment there's not explicitly Christian states, and
1298
01:14:53.079 --> 01:14:56.039
by the way, it doesn't necessarily have to be a monarchy.
1299
01:14:56.079 --> 01:14:57.720
It's just simply that in the history of the Church,
1300
01:14:58.079 --> 01:15:00.880
what we have is the imperium as norm. So we
1301
01:15:00.960 --> 01:15:03.199
would argue that it is an emperor, is an imperium,
1302
01:15:03.239 --> 01:15:05.720
and it is kings and queens, the one in the
1303
01:15:05.760 --> 01:15:08.199
many relationship in that sort of Byzantine.
1304
01:15:07.760 --> 01:15:10.920
Model that is the ideal. Is it possible to have
1305
01:15:11.159 --> 01:15:14.039
a Christian republic. It's possible.
1306
01:15:14.359 --> 01:15:17.439
Perhaps there have been theologians that have argued as possible.
1307
01:15:17.640 --> 01:15:21.720
It hasn't existed really yet. But again I don't have
1308
01:15:21.920 --> 01:15:24.680
to prove that right now. My position has to be dominant.
1309
01:15:24.920 --> 01:15:27.399
If in the first three centuries it took over and
1310
01:15:27.479 --> 01:15:31.119
perhaps the internet will you know, bring Orthodox Christianity. It's
1311
01:15:31.159 --> 01:15:33.479
bringing millions of people, you know, into the church. I
1312
01:15:33.520 --> 01:15:35.479
think in the next ten years. We've already seen tens
1313
01:15:35.479 --> 01:15:39.840
of thousands just this year. So I think that, well, again,
1314
01:15:39.960 --> 01:15:43.960
Orthodox Christianity isn't Diarites. But I'm just simpodly saying that
1315
01:15:44.279 --> 01:15:48.159
we don't know if three centuries conquered the Roman Empire
1316
01:15:48.199 --> 01:15:52.079
and those prophecies were fulfilled, there's no reason why. And
1317
01:15:52.279 --> 01:15:55.359
some of the even the most you know anti Christian
1318
01:15:55.439 --> 01:15:58.319
global elites actually right in their text that they are
1319
01:15:58.479 --> 01:16:02.760
concerned of a rise of Christian deocracy. So again the
1320
01:16:02.880 --> 01:16:04.439
fact that but none of that has anything to do
1321
01:16:04.520 --> 01:16:06.279
with proving that Islam is better for society.
1322
01:16:06.920 --> 01:16:11.720
Correct. But what my basic proposal throughout my opening statement
1323
01:16:12.039 --> 01:16:16.960
and what I've been questioning, is that if one religion
1324
01:16:17.079 --> 01:16:19.199
is going to be better for society, it has to
1325
01:16:19.359 --> 01:16:24.319
have a political view, of political perspective. Obviously, I've tried
1326
01:16:24.359 --> 01:16:28.319
to argue that I don't think that Christianity has an
1327
01:16:28.399 --> 01:16:32.600
explicit enough political doctrine, and that's why we see in
1328
01:16:32.680 --> 01:16:36.920
the early period where there's some disagreement, as you said,
1329
01:16:37.119 --> 01:16:39.640
and then today where pretty much nobody believes in that,
1330
01:16:39.720 --> 01:16:42.560
and then we have a period which you know, whatever
1331
01:16:42.760 --> 01:16:43.319
that would.
1332
01:16:43.079 --> 01:16:46.119
Just be appealed to masses, like so what if you
1333
01:16:46.239 --> 01:16:48.800
know it doesn't it does None of those things prove
1334
01:16:48.880 --> 01:16:51.199
that there isn't that teaching just because a lot of
1335
01:16:51.239 --> 01:16:52.680
people don't believe it or know it.
1336
01:16:53.079 --> 01:16:55.399
No, But I'm saying to you that I think it
1337
01:16:55.479 --> 01:16:59.800
stands to reason that if it's so uh, if the
1338
01:17:00.000 --> 01:17:02.840
pyosicians regarding it are so diverse in the early period
1339
01:17:02.920 --> 01:17:05.720
in the late period, I don't think it's it's merely
1340
01:17:05.880 --> 01:17:09.199
because of what you stated earlier. I think that there
1341
01:17:09.319 --> 01:17:11.920
is a lack of clarity in the New Testament. I
1342
01:17:11.960 --> 01:17:16.520
think that even Jesus's earthly ministry, as you said, in
1343
01:17:16.600 --> 01:17:19.439
the way that you're interpreting it, he was not a
1344
01:17:19.560 --> 01:17:20.600
political figure.
1345
01:17:20.319 --> 01:17:20.880
In this way.
1346
01:17:21.000 --> 01:17:27.000
But when Jesus is ministering, right, the apostles epistles for example,
1347
01:17:27.079 --> 01:17:29.760
have not been written, Okay, So to take an instance
1348
01:17:29.840 --> 01:17:32.439
and say, well, in this case, because Jesus didn't give
1349
01:17:32.479 --> 01:17:36.119
a legal ruling, therefore, the New Testament doesn't have clear
1350
01:17:36.199 --> 01:17:39.199
teachings on the rules and principles of the state. And
1351
01:17:39.239 --> 01:17:42.439
I'm saying there's many many passages that from our perspective,
1352
01:17:42.520 --> 01:17:46.279
providentially would be included in scripture, which do consistently comment
1353
01:17:46.399 --> 01:17:48.520
on that. And even if there's debate in the first
1354
01:17:48.560 --> 01:17:50.520
and second century amongst a lot of the you know,
1355
01:17:50.640 --> 01:17:53.119
apologists and people that end up even not being in
1356
01:17:53.239 --> 01:17:56.279
the church like origin, that's really irrelevant to whether there
1357
01:17:56.439 --> 01:17:59.119
is a doctrine of the state in the New
Testament.
1358
01:17:59.159 --> 01:18:02.640
And I'm not saying how you've shown any significant evidence
1359
01:18:02.720 --> 01:18:04.760
yet that there's not a Christian doctrine of the state,
1360
01:18:04.840 --> 01:18:07.199
because I can keep going with more passages that demonstrate.
1361
01:18:07.279 --> 01:18:09.760
Okay, so what do you think is that? And it's
1362
01:18:09.840 --> 01:18:11.720
not built upon one. If you want to give two
1363
01:18:11.840 --> 01:18:15.760
or three, that's fine. What do you think are the clearless, clearest, sorry,
1364
01:18:16.159 --> 01:18:19.159
passages in the New Testament specifically, not the Old Testament,
1365
01:18:19.399 --> 01:18:22.000
in the New Testament specifically that support your position.
1366
01:18:23.520 --> 01:18:26.279
Well, the first most obvious one would be Romans thirteen,
1367
01:18:26.279 --> 01:18:29.000
whereas I said, Paul specifically calls and note this is
1368
01:18:29.039 --> 01:18:31.560
at the time when it's a persecuting pagan emperor. This
1369
01:18:31.680 --> 01:18:34.880
is Nero, who absolutely hates the Church, and Paul still
1370
01:18:34.960 --> 01:18:37.720
calls Nero much like you see in the Book of Daniel,
1371
01:18:37.800 --> 01:18:41.960
with the way Daniel treats Nevcanezer. Paul still calls him
1372
01:18:42.039 --> 01:18:46.960
a diacinos, a providential ordained ruler of God. So that
1373
01:18:47.159 --> 01:18:49.800
means that there's a duty, and his duty specifically is
1374
01:18:49.800 --> 01:18:55.199
outlined there in Romans thirteen to punish evildoers with the sword,
1375
01:18:55.279 --> 01:18:58.359
and that is the death penalty. I don't think any executes,
1376
01:18:58.359 --> 01:19:00.520
even if they're liberals, would disagree. That's what Paul thought
1377
01:19:00.560 --> 01:19:02.800
it meant. And then if we look at for example,
1378
01:19:02.920 --> 01:19:05.199
Romans one and two, there's very similar principles there that
1379
01:19:06.239 --> 01:19:07.279
even the natural law.
1380
01:19:07.239 --> 01:19:09.119
Teaches us that the state has this role.
1381
01:19:09.239 --> 01:19:12.720
He says explicitly to Timothy that the law exists, and
1382
01:19:12.840 --> 01:19:15.920
that's of course enforced by the legal the ruler, the king.
1383
01:19:16.399 --> 01:19:19.920
The law exists to punish. And then he lists a
1384
01:19:20.039 --> 01:19:23.039
series of sins that are particularly egregious. And again the
1385
01:19:23.119 --> 01:19:27.319
assumption is there in Romans Romans thirteen and in the
1386
01:19:27.479 --> 01:19:31.439
passage to Timothy those are particularly egregious, and perhaps even
1387
01:19:31.520 --> 01:19:32.520
capital offenses.
1388
01:19:32.880 --> 01:19:34.880
So these are just three off of the cuff. There
1389
01:19:34.920 --> 01:19:35.560
are many more.
1390
01:19:35.600 --> 01:19:38.960
And like I said, it was normative even in Athenasius
1391
01:19:39.039 --> 01:19:42.079
and sat Alexander's
day. This is like the year three hundred,
1392
01:19:42.479 --> 01:19:45.520
it was normative for every catechuman to come into the
1393
01:19:45.640 --> 01:19:50.800
church to read the Dudo canon and to read proverbs. Now,
1394
01:19:51.319 --> 01:19:53.119
I know a lot of protests might not be familiar
1395
01:19:53.159 --> 01:19:55.560
with the due economical texts, but the dudiconoical texts have
1396
01:19:56.439 --> 01:20:02.479
tons of information about kings, magistrates, judges, rulers. For example,
1397
01:20:02.520 --> 01:20:05.319
the Book of Sirric again with Saint Anthonatius has every
1398
01:20:05.399 --> 01:20:10.039
categhuman reading. It's full of practical advice and practical principles
1399
01:20:10.079 --> 01:20:12.319
that relate to all the things that we're talking about.
1400
01:20:12.720 --> 01:20:15.439
Simply reading the Book of Syric alone, as St. Anthonasius
1401
01:20:15.560 --> 01:20:18.680
mandates all of the converts do, would actually answer every
1402
01:20:18.720 --> 01:20:19.399
one of these qualms.
1403
01:20:19.479 --> 01:20:20.159
That's just Zirric.
1404
01:20:20.880 --> 01:20:26.680
So you first mentioned Romans thirteen, and it seems to
1405
01:20:26.760 --> 01:20:31.159
be advocating for submission to Nero, right, So I don't
1406
01:20:31.239 --> 01:20:34.760
understand how this supports your position because it seems like
1407
01:20:35.039 --> 01:20:38.800
it's an example of the apostles making peace with a
1408
01:20:38.880 --> 01:20:42.960
pagan state, which would basically be my argument, not yours.
1409
01:20:43.640 --> 01:20:47.399
No, So again, if you look at Nebuicaneser in the
1410
01:20:47.399 --> 01:20:50.439
Book of Daniel, nebu ca Andeser is a pagan and
1411
01:20:50.760 --> 01:20:52.560
the whole purpose and point of the Book of Daniel
1412
01:20:52.720 --> 01:20:57.600
is that eventually nebu Caanzer is humbled and he converts
1413
01:20:57.720 --> 01:20:59.960
to believe in some sense in the once you're going.
1414
01:21:00.720 --> 01:21:04.520
But that doesn't mean that it's the job of Daniel
1415
01:21:04.640 --> 01:21:07.600
to revolt or overthrow him, right, Obviously, he's in a
1416
01:21:07.800 --> 01:21:09.640
situation where they're taken into captivity.
1417
01:21:10.000 --> 01:21:10.359
And so the.
1418
01:21:10.439 --> 01:21:14.079
Recognition is that even though he's a pagan, there's a
1419
01:21:14.239 --> 01:21:17.439
providential role that he serves. So Paul is talking about
1420
01:21:17.520 --> 01:21:21.720
Rome thirteen, the providential duty that any ruler or head
1421
01:21:21.720 --> 01:21:24.640
of state has to God. Now, whether those people follow
1422
01:21:24.760 --> 01:21:27.319
those duties or whether they're wicked, that's a different question
1423
01:21:27.399 --> 01:21:31.159
because they're providentially there. So our perspective is that, and
1424
01:21:31.239 --> 01:21:34.720
this is why there's so many martyrs. We don't worship Nero.
1425
01:21:35.560
--> 01:21:40.279
We can allow Nero to be the providentially ordained ruler.
1426
01:21:40.399 --> 01:21:42.840
That doesn't mean that God doesn't want Nero to follow
1427
01:21:42.920 --> 01:21:45.600
Christian principles, but whether he does is a different question,
1428
01:21:46.039 --> 01:21:48.239
And that's a separate question from when there is a
1429
01:21:48.439 --> 01:21:50.520
Christian king, he has even more of an.
1430
01:21:50.439 --> 01:21:53.079
Obligation and duty to follow the biblical principles.
1431
01:21:53.920 --> 01:21:57.960
Is there such thing as righteous rebellion against people like Nero?
1432
01:21:59.359 --> 01:22:03.119
Is that possible a new Orthodox Church? It's so this
1433
01:22:03.319 --> 01:22:04.359
is a different question.
1434
01:22:04.800 --> 01:22:07.600
Uh the terms in terms of like could there be
1435
01:22:07.760 --> 01:22:12.600
situations where case by case basis you could have a
1436
01:22:12.680 --> 01:22:17.399
civilizational struggle of something like that? And there is in
1437
01:22:17.439 --> 01:22:21.199
the Byzantine history situations where there could be legitimate revolution.
1438
01:22:21.680 --> 01:22:24.159
But that's a separate question from whether or not the
1439
01:22:24.239 --> 01:22:27.600
New Testament teaches that we are supposed to. For example,
1440
01:22:27.640 --> 01:22:30.239
the New Testament is there to confirm the fulfillment of
1441
01:22:30.279 --> 01:22:33.119
the prophecies of Christ. But again, the reason I went
1442
01:22:33.159 --> 01:22:36.439
to Syric is that it's not the mindset even of
1443
01:22:36.479 --> 01:22:38.399
the first second, third century Church, because they were all
1444
01:22:38.560 --> 01:22:41.960
using the deuteroconomical text. It's not our mindset that we
1445
01:22:42.159 --> 01:22:45.079
only look into the New Testament to see are there
1446
01:22:45.199 --> 01:22:48.359
verses that give a list of legal principles. There's actually
1447
01:22:48.479 --> 01:22:51.199
are some, But I'm saying that the catechumens are not
1448
01:22:51.279 --> 01:22:53.840
just reading the New Testament, because they don't even necessarily
1449
01:22:53.840 --> 01:22:56.439
have an entire New Testament. They're also reading the Book
1450
01:22:56.479 --> 01:23:00.520
of Syric, which is literally full of every aspect of society.
1451
01:23:00.560 --> 01:23:04.600
It's like sixty plus chapters, all aspects of society being covered,
1452
01:23:06.239 --> 01:23:09.960
even magistrates, judges, rulers, kings. The Book of Proverbs has
1453
01:23:10.079 --> 01:23:13.640
dozens of proverbs about kings, so all of those would
1454
01:23:13.640 --> 01:23:16.000
be being read. And so the argument seems to hinge
1455
01:23:16.039 --> 01:23:19.119
on everybody just reading the Gospels and then coming up
1456
01:23:19.199 --> 01:23:22.119
with a vague notion of the state that's not true.
1457
01:23:23.039 --> 01:23:25.760
Well, it seems to me in this case and in
1458
01:23:25.960 --> 01:23:27.399
other passages.
1459
01:23:26.920 --> 01:23:28.800
That one more point on that.
1460
01:23:29.920 --> 01:23:32.439
Actually, the Dudo canon is a great point here because
1461
01:23:33.439 --> 01:23:36.920
to the point of the Reformation, because the Reformation doesn't
1462
01:23:37.039 --> 01:23:40.800
believe in the Dudo canon, they didn't have that for Catechumens,
1463
01:23:41.359 --> 01:23:45.079
you're actually leaving out a gigantic portion of the Book
1464
01:23:45.079 --> 01:23:48.359
of syric which would be about Christian kings.
1465
01:23:49.199 --> 01:23:53.800
Okay, the question, the reason why I think it's related,
1466
01:23:53.880 --> 01:23:58.640
why I'm asking about possible rebellion, is because if you
1467
01:23:58.840 --> 01:24:03.239
have this idea of you know, the Church being involved
1468
01:24:03.319 --> 01:24:07.439
in political affairs and submitting to the ruler, is there
1469
01:24:07.720 --> 01:24:10.600
supposed to be submission to the ruler in this case,
1470
01:24:10.840 --> 01:24:14.199
even if he's a pagan. That's what I'm trying to understand. Okay, So,
1471
01:24:14.960 --> 01:24:20.399
if the Christian laws are supposed to be instituted, why
1472
01:24:20.479 --> 01:24:25.119
would Christians be required It seems like they're required actually
1473
01:24:25.279 --> 01:24:27.960
not to rebel, to render on to Caesar, to just
1474
01:24:28.159 --> 01:24:33.880
basically submit to the authority, whether they're Christian and instituting
1475
01:24:33.960 --> 01:24:35.439
Christian values or not.
1476
01:24:36.079 --> 01:24:38.840
So basically, the Church again at the in the first
1477
01:24:38.840 --> 01:24:41.520
second third century, when they're under in the catacombs being pursued.
1478
01:24:41.560 --> 01:24:44.880
They have the same attitude as for example, Daniel and Babylon. Right,
1479
01:24:45.000 --> 01:24:47.720
So first of all, just practically speaking, it's not feasible
1480
01:24:47.840 --> 01:24:50.000
to engage in or there's no way Daniel could have
1481
01:24:50.079 --> 01:24:52.800
like politically revolted. So it's different from the case of
1482
01:24:52.920 --> 01:24:56.039
like say the Maccabees, where there was a potentiality.
1483
01:24:55.359 --> 01:24:57.039
Of some successful revolt.
1484
01:24:57.119 --> 01:24:59.800
That's just practically speaking, that's a separate question from when
1485
01:25:00.119 --> 01:25:03.680
or if you could revolt. So, but in the case
1486
01:25:03.720 --> 01:25:05.840
of the early Church Fathers, there's a lot of discussion
1487
01:25:05.880 --> 01:25:10.119
of this, and the principle is that there's authorities, and
1488
01:25:10.199 --> 01:25:13.119
there's authorities above those authorities. So for example, and I
1489
01:25:13.199 --> 01:25:16.319
think even Roman Catholics everybody agrees with us, perhaps even Protestants,
1490
01:25:16.840 --> 01:25:20.000
we believe that we are to obey the existing authorities
1491
01:25:20.920 --> 01:25:24.680
except when they go outside of their legitimate sphere. So
1492
01:25:24.960 --> 01:25:28.439
when Nero said you have to worship the image of
1493
01:25:28.520 --> 01:25:30.760
Me and say that I'm God, that's when the early
1494
01:25:30.920 --> 01:25:33.279
martyrs thought, no, that's where we have to draw the line.
1495
01:25:33.399 --> 01:25:36.600
Now you are going against the higher authority. So in
1496
01:25:36.760 --> 01:25:40.920
anything that they're not directly violating God's law, et cetera.
1497
01:25:41.039 --> 01:25:42.640
Ten commandments, then.
1498
01:25:42.560 --> 01:25:45.159
We do have a duty actually to obey the higher authority.
1499
01:25:45.359 --> 01:25:47.319
And this is a I mean, the same principle is
1500
01:25:47.359 --> 01:25:50.199
applied all over Western law. That's why you couldn't get
1501
01:25:50.199 --> 01:25:52.479
away with just saying, you know, in warfare, oh well,
1502
01:25:52.560 --> 01:25:55.920
my commanding, you know, officer told me to rape and kill,
1503
01:25:56.039 --> 01:25:58.399
so I'm not guilty. You're still guilty because there's a
1504
01:25:58.479 --> 01:25:59.439
higher authority above that.
1505
01:25:59.640 --> 01:26:00.680
That's a legal principle.
1506
01:26:01.760 --> 01:26:06.159
Okay, But in the case of Nero, for example, or
1507
01:26:06.279 --> 01:26:10.319
somebody else who's a pagan ruler and they are requiring
1508
01:26:10.760 --> 01:26:16.840
or demanding that Christians engage in idolatry, then I mean,
1509
01:26:17.319 --> 01:26:20.279
I guess at what point is it to say, okay,
1510
01:26:20.479 --> 01:26:24.279
we're not following this particular law that the Nero or
1511
01:26:24.319 --> 01:26:28.199
this pagan ruler is trying to institute. Versus when does
1512
01:26:28.239 --> 01:26:30.640
it go so far to say, well, we're not only
1513
01:26:30.760 --> 01:26:32.760
not following it, but we need to remove this guy
1514
01:26:32.880 --> 01:26:36.279
because he's going so far beyond him that we actually
1515
01:26:36.399 --> 01:26:40.520
now have to remove him and institute a Christian ruler
1516
01:26:40.600 --> 01:26:41.119
in that place.
1517
01:26:41.960 --> 01:26:44.720
Well, I think that in the history of Western civilization,
1518
01:26:44.920 --> 01:26:48.479
when societies became predominantly Christian is when they began to
1519
01:26:48.600 --> 01:26:51.479
think about Christian law and a Christian ruler, and so
1520
01:26:51.720 --> 01:26:54.119
when you have that majority, and that's why wor the
1521
01:26:54.199 --> 01:26:56.840
ox Christianity is not primarily a political movement, So it's
1522
01:26:56.960 --> 01:26:59.560
again it's just a source. It's like a situation of emphasies.
1523
01:27:00.039 --> 01:27:02.720
So we're not going to emphasize the political. But by
1524
01:27:02.840 --> 01:27:05.560
not emphasizing that as number one, it doesn't follow from
1525
01:27:05.600 --> 01:27:07.680
that that we don't have anything to say the political.
1526
01:27:07.760 --> 01:27:09.760
That's the divide that I think the modern sort of
1527
01:27:09.800 --> 01:27:14.279
Baptist evangelical mindset has about church and state. So if
1528
01:27:14.319 --> 01:27:16.720
there were a situation where I don't know, there was
1529
01:27:16.840 --> 01:27:20.000
a majority Christian country, and you see this in the
1530
01:27:20.039 --> 01:27:23.319
history of Byzantium, at times there were revolutions. If for example,
1531
01:27:23.359 --> 01:27:27.399
there was a subversive ruler or something like that, there
1532
01:27:27.439 --> 01:27:28.840
could conceivably a revolution.
1533
01:27:28.960 --> 01:27:30.439
In that case that could be argued for.
1534
01:27:30.840 --> 01:27:34.159
But again I don't like that's not analogous to when
1535
01:27:34.279 --> 01:27:36.720
the church is being persecuted, because it's not in a
1536
01:27:36.840 --> 01:27:40.880
Christian society. It's having to function within a society persecuting it.
1537
01:27:41.560 --> 01:27:44.680
And so when it permeates though, and there's Christian laws,
1538
01:27:45.159 --> 01:27:48.800
then those rulers are held accountable to those Christian laws.
1539
01:27:48.920 --> 01:27:52.079
Prior to that, he's accountable to God. But the Church
1540
01:27:52.199 --> 01:27:54.840
doesn't have political power. Christians don't have political power, but
1541
01:27:54.920 --> 01:27:57.680
when they do, there is a change of situation.
1542
01:27:59.159 --> 01:28:01.840
Would you consider the US to be a Christian nation?
1543
01:28:03.960 --> 01:28:06.600
I typically argue that the United States is half Christian?
1544
01:28:07.399 --> 01:28:09.640
What is that the end of the open dialogue? You
1545
01:28:09.680 --> 01:28:10.359
finished that thought?
1546
01:28:10.640 --> 01:28:13.960
Okay, it just simply means that some of the principles
1547
01:28:14.199 --> 01:28:18.159
of the founding of America were Christian and nature and ethos,
1548
01:28:18.279 --> 01:28:20.720
it's history, but it was also mixed up with a
1549
01:28:20.760 --> 01:28:23.600
lot of Enlightenment ideas that are fundamentally fundamentally not Christian.
1550
01:28:23.840 --> 01:28:27.119
Okay. The reason why I'm asking because I think that
1551
01:28:27.800 --> 01:28:30.359
the US would be an example, or should be an
1552
01:28:30.399 --> 01:28:34.560
example of where it's gone beyond a certain point. That
1553
01:28:35.600 --> 01:28:38.159
I mean, I'm not Christian, but I would advocate for
1554
01:28:38.279 --> 01:28:40.720
a rebellion because of the fact that there are so
1555
01:28:40.880 --> 01:28:44.840
many laws in the US that are fundamentally against Christianity
1556
01:28:44.880 --> 01:28:49.239
and Christian values. You know, abortion, I can name several
1557
01:28:49.760 --> 01:28:54.760
and that I think I think would demand Actually what what.
1558
01:28:56.039 --> 01:28:58.720
Well, So from the orthodox perspective, we
don't believe that
1559
01:28:59.199 --> 01:29:01.960
we even really have a relevance to the political realm
1560
01:29:02.720 --> 01:29:04.960
in terms of power, not in terms of our moral
1561
01:29:05.239 --> 01:29:07.680
you know, teaching and saying what ought to be the case.
1562
01:29:07.760 --> 01:29:10.720
We can always exercise that, but in terms of political power,
1563
01:29:11.479 --> 01:29:13.920
that's only when you have a majority of a society.
1564
01:29:14.000 --> 01:29:16.439
As an Orthodox Christian, would you even entertain that type
1565
01:29:16.439 --> 01:29:18.640
of a question from our perspective at that point when
1566
01:29:18.680 --> 01:29:19.600
there's Christian laws?
1567
01:29:19.720 --> 01:29:19.920
Yeah?
1568
01:29:19.960 --> 01:29:21.720
Maybe, But first of all, America's found it as a
1569
01:29:21.760 --> 01:29:24.840
Protestant nation. You know, maybe in two three hundred years
1570
01:29:24.840 --> 01:29:26.960
it could be an Orthodox country, but that's not a
1571
01:29:27.039 --> 01:29:30.119
present question. And no, Orthodox Christians are not called to
1572
01:29:30.560 --> 01:29:31.880
engage in political revolution.
1573
01:29:32.680 --> 01:29:35.600
Okay, I'll leave it there you very much, gentlemen of
1574
01:29:35.680 --> 01:29:36.680
that open dialogue.
1575
01:29:36.800 --> 01:29:38.760
We'll jump into the five minute.
1576
01:29:48.079 --> 01:29:51.239
We'll jump into the five minute closings, and I will
1577
01:29:51.319 --> 01:29:53.520
start it on your first word, Jay.
1578
01:29:55.239 --> 01:29:58.560
Yeah, I think you know, this is interesting because I
1579
01:29:58.600 --> 01:30:00.239
didn't know where this debate was going to go, and
1580
01:30:01.119 --> 01:30:04.800
it got very historical, which is cool because this is
1581
01:30:05.039 --> 01:30:06.840
not the type of debate that I've usually done.
1582
01:30:07.000 --> 01:30:11.159
Usually the debates are very heavily philosophical. So this was engaging.
1583
01:30:11.319 --> 01:30:13.439
It was a new kind of pathway. I appreciate that.
1584
01:30:13.600 --> 01:30:17.239
I appreciate Jake asking a lot of questions, but I
1585
01:30:17.319 --> 01:30:21.399
don't think that out of this argument, because there's lack
1586
01:30:21.479 --> 01:30:26.479
of clarity at certain times in the West about the
1587
01:30:26.560 --> 01:30:29.399
relationship to church and state, that it follows from that
1588
01:30:29.720 --> 01:30:33.439
that somehow, there therefore Islam would be the solution, or
1589
01:30:33.560 --> 01:30:38.279
therefore Islam has a better answer. As Jake admitted, many
1590
01:30:38.399 --> 01:30:42.039
Islamic countries are also susceptible to all of the same
1591
01:30:42.119 --> 01:30:48.279
problems of excuse me, secular enlightenment ideas, et cetera. Islamic
1592
01:30:48.399 --> 01:30:50.680
society is I think plagued with again, many of the
1593
01:30:50.760 --> 01:30:53.720
problems that Andrew highlighted in the debates that he's had
1594
01:30:53.800 --> 01:30:57.520
with Daniel Hikikachu and others. I think those are problems
1595
01:30:57.560 --> 01:31:01.079
that are pretty kind of glaring that Western societies, for
1596
01:31:01.239 --> 01:31:04.520
all of their problems, they're not subject to those problems.
1597
01:31:05.039 --> 01:31:08.279
So I don't think that Islam is going to be
1598
01:31:08.560 --> 01:31:11.760
a solution, especially when if we're looking for unanimity, if
1599
01:31:11.760 --> 01:31:14.960
we're looking for you know, sort of black and white answers. Well,
1600
01:31:15.000 --> 01:31:17.800
if in Islamic law there's thick which does not have
1601
01:31:17.920 --> 01:31:22.319
consistent rulings on a host of moral issues, I don't
1602
01:31:22.319 --> 01:31:24.840
think that that's going to be a solution. Again, if
1603
01:31:24.880 --> 01:31:29.239
he's admitted that there's ambiguity and contradictions perhaps in the
1604
01:31:29.359 --> 01:31:32.159
rulings of Islamic law or thick, I don't see how
1605
01:31:32.359 --> 01:31:35.079
his position is in any better state than what he
1606
01:31:35.199 --> 01:31:38.319
was arguing about my position having a lack of clarity
1607
01:31:38.359 --> 01:31:40.399
in the first three centuries. And he even sort of
1608
01:31:40.439 --> 01:31:43.720
admitted throughout the debate that, yeah, I mean, you do
1609
01:31:43.920 --> 01:31:48.239
have a consistent, you know, millennia plus of a position
1610
01:31:48.439 --> 01:31:51.079
of Christian theocracy and Byzanty. But a lot of people
1611
01:31:51.119 --> 01:31:53.199
today don't believe that. Again, that has nothing to do
1612
01:31:53.279 --> 01:31:56.159
with which one's correct, which one is therefore better for society.
1613
01:31:56.159 --> 01:31:59.000
I think in my opening statement I outline many principles
1614
01:32:00.079 --> 01:32:05.239
ideas that Christian Western civilization does possess. Because we are
1615
01:32:05.439 --> 01:32:08.079
still having the remnants of Christianity, there's a lot of
1616
01:32:08.159 --> 01:32:10.920
potential as to where we could go. And we see
1617
01:32:10.920 --> 01:32:12.640
this in the Old Testament as well. In many cases
1618
01:32:12.720 --> 01:32:17.479
in the Old Testament, Israel is unfaithful. Israel falls into idolatry,
1619
01:32:17.520 --> 01:32:19.600
They fall into all the same sins that we're falling
1620
01:32:19.640 --> 01:32:20.239
into today.
1621
01:32:20.800 --> 01:32:22.920
And Israel is always called.
1622
01:32:22.680 --> 01:32:26.319
Back to repentance and to God, and by following God's
1623
01:32:26.439 --> 01:32:28.920
law they find, as we read in you know chronicles,
1624
01:32:28.960 --> 01:32:31.439
the famous passes right, if my people who are called
1625
01:32:31.439 --> 01:32:34.000
by my name, if they humble themselves and repent, then
1626
01:32:34.079 --> 01:32:36.079
I will come and I will bless their land. Now,
1627
01:32:36.640 -->
01:32:39.159
ultimately we know that's about in our view, a type
1628
01:32:39.199 --> 01:32:41.760
of the church, but it still applies to the civil
1629
01:32:41.840 --> 01:32:43.600
society as well. The fact that a lot of the
1630
01:32:43.640 --> 01:32:47.720
New Testament focuses on the spiritual, it doesn't follow from
1631
01:32:47.800 --> 01:32:50.640
that that we're supposed to be Marcianites or Gnostics and
1632
01:32:50.640 --> 01:32:53.239
therefore think that, well, the state doesn't matter, we don't care.
1633
01:32:53.359 --> 01:32:57.680
And in fact, at Debate Content to Debates with Trent Horn,
1634
01:32:57.960 --> 01:33:00.439
I will be debating Trent Horn on that very principle.
1635
01:33:00.680 --> 01:33:04.560
Did the Catholic Church depart from church and state teaching?
1636
01:33:04.720 --> 01:33:07.920
And does the Orthodox Church still maintain a consistent symphony
1637
01:33:07.960 --> 01:33:09.920
of teaching? So that will be fun at Debaten ten.
1638
01:33:11.000 --> 01:33:13.000
Just a little plug, But again, I just don't think.
1639
01:33:13.119 --> 01:33:15.960
I didn't hear anything in Jake's argumentation that made me
1640
01:33:16.279 --> 01:33:20.920
convinced or or would make me think that Islam would
1641
01:33:20.920 --> 01:33:24.039
be better for society. I think that again, I didn't
1642
01:33:24.039 --> 01:33:26.359
really get into the philosophical side of it. But even
1643
01:33:26.439 --> 01:33:30.159
some of the philosophical advancements that you find supposedly in Islam,
1644
01:33:30.600 --> 01:33:33.600
and you could find this in even standard Sunny texts.
1645
01:33:34.000 --> 01:33:37.079
It's really just stuff that came from Greek philosophers, from
1646
01:33:37.119 --> 01:33:39.720
Aristotle and others, which are part of our heritage of
1647
01:33:39.760 --> 01:33:43.520
Western civilization. And I don't think those things are somehow
1648
01:33:43.600 --> 01:33:47.039
magically in the Qur'an. I think they're literally clearly borrowed
1649
01:33:47.079 --> 01:33:52.960
from the Western tradition, and as Western civilization people, we
1650
01:33:53.119 --> 01:33:57.039
can include and we can say that Greek philosophers had
1651
01:33:57.039 --> 01:33:59.840
a lot of insights. We can appreciate, Aristotle we can appreciate,
1652
01:34:00.880 --> 01:34:04.520
we can look at elements of Roman law, canon law,
1653
01:34:04.640 --> 01:34:07.640
not because they're quote pagan. In our view, there's nothing
1654
01:34:07.680 --> 01:34:10.840
inherently bad if there was a just law in Rome
1655
01:34:11.960 --> 01:34:13.079
under the Pagan period.
1656
01:34:13.159 --> 01:34:15.119
There's nothing wrong with the Church.
1657
01:34:14.960 --> 01:34:17.319
When it gets a tendency and when Christianity and Christians
1658
01:34:17.399 --> 01:34:20.560
have temporal power, there's nothing wrong with them baptizing and
1659
01:34:20.720 --> 01:34:23.479
using those principles, as long as they're not idolatrous.
1660
01:34:23.640 --> 01:34:25.199
So that we have to be careful we're.
1661
01:34:25.079 --> 01:34:29.239
Not engaging in idolatry, but we can still baptize these
1662
01:34:29.359 --> 01:34:32.640
elements of culture that are existing that are good. Hence
1663
01:34:32.760 --> 01:34:36.000
why our civilization has a confluence of interest. It could
1664
01:34:36.000 --> 01:34:39.239
be Roman law, it could be English common law. Even
1665
01:34:39.279 --> 01:34:43.600
those things have a precedent in Christian ideas, Biblical ideas,
1666
01:34:44.199 --> 01:34:47.840
and because the modern world has rejected that theocratic principle,
1667
01:34:48.119 --> 01:34:50.600
it doesn't follow from that that that's I mean, I
1668
01:34:50.600 --> 01:34:52.840
would just simply say that that's why we're seeing a
1669
01:34:52.920 --> 01:34:54.760
lot of the bad things happening, is that we simply
1670
01:34:54.800 --> 01:34:56.920
don't recognize that God has something to say to the
1671
01:34:56.960 --> 01:34:57.560
state as well.
1672
01:34:58.600 --> 01:35:01.079
Thank you very much for that, Jay. We'll kick it
1673
01:35:01.159 --> 01:35:03.520
over to Jake for his five minute closing as well.
1674
01:35:13.439 --> 01:35:16.279
Okay, I do want to say that I agree with
1675
01:35:16.439 --> 01:35:19.960
Jay that I'm kind of happy the way the debate
1676
01:35:20.119 --> 01:35:24.960
went in terms of discussing mainly the historical aspect and
1677
01:35:25.279 --> 01:35:28.800
some texts in the Bible, because Jay and I previously
1678
01:35:28.960 --> 01:35:32.159
had a debate that was mainly philosophical, so this one
1679
01:35:32.319 --> 01:35:36.840
is pretty much completely different, mostly historical. I do want
1680
01:35:36.880 --> 01:35:40.760
to say that the reason why I'm arguing that Islam
1681
01:35:40.920 --> 01:35:43.800
is better for society, although we didn't go into many
1682
01:35:43.960 --> 01:35:47.640
specifics on this point, but from an abstract perspective, it
1683
01:35:47.800 --> 01:35:52.680
seems to me that Islam, from the Kuran and authentic Kadith,
1684
01:35:53.000 --> 01:35:58.000
is very clearly political. There is no separation between mosque
1685
01:35:58.039 --> 01:36:01.159
and state, or church and state for an analogy, And
1686
01:36:02.159 --> 01:36:04.920
I'm making the argument that the reason why we see
1687
01:36:04.960 --> 01:36:08.399
Western society in the position that it is in today
1688
01:36:08.720 --> 01:36:11.720
is because there is a lack of clarity in the
1689
01:36:11.760 --> 01:36:15.840
Biblical text. Jay tried, and respect to him for that,
1690
01:36:16.079 --> 01:36:20.159
but I don't see very clear texts in the Bible
1691
01:36:20.279 --> 01:36:25.840
that are supporting the theocracy or monarchy vision that Jay
1692
01:36:26.800 --> 01:36:29.560
deems fit. I just don't see it. I think that yes,
1693
01:36:29.680 --> 01:36:33.520
there's a lot of laws and principles from the Old
Testament,
1694
01:36:34.000 --> 01:36:36.279
and Jay was making a lot to do about biblical
1695
01:36:36.359 --> 01:36:40.840
prophecies that prophesy things that are going to happen in
1696
01:36:40.920 --> 01:36:46.319
the future, but again, supposed prophecies and things from the
1697
01:36:46.399 --> 01:36:49.079
Old Testament that are supposed to be in stated in
1698
01:36:49.199 --> 01:36:52.640
the New Testaments, which don't clearly seem to be. And
1699
01:36:52.760 --> 01:36:55.119
I think the example that you brought from, I think
1700
01:36:55.279 --> 01:37:00.239
was Romans of Nero. I think actually goes against your
1701
01:37:00.359 --> 01:37:03.520
vision and what you've said, because it's an idea where
1702
01:37:03.680 --> 01:37:08.239
someone who's completely opposed to Christianity, we're just not maybe
1703
01:37:08.279 --> 01:37:12.479
in your private lives, maybe you can reject worshiping idols
1704
01:37:12.520 --> 01:37:15.399
and things like that, but we're supposed to just allow
1705
01:37:15.479 --> 01:37:19.560
this person to institute any of these laws that he wants,
1706
01:37:19.600 --> 01:37:22.680
even if they're totally against Christianity and Christian principles. And
1707
01:37:22.760 --> 01:37:28.600
I just see that as fundamentally problematic. I have made
1708
01:37:28.640 --> 01:37:31.680
a lot to do about Jay's position being a minority
1709
01:37:31.800 --> 01:37:34.680
today because we're talking. Part of the debate is about
1710
01:37:34.720 --> 01:37:40.079
the practical application of the view can Islam and its principles?
1711
01:37:40.600 --> 01:37:44.000
Can it actually be applied today? And I think that
1712
01:37:44.119 --> 01:37:46.399
it can. Then that it is not one hundred percent
1713
01:37:46.720 --> 01:37:48.680
in the way that I would like it to be,
1714
01:37:49.119 --> 01:37:52.640
but it certainly is much more in Muslim countries than
1715
01:37:52.760 --> 01:37:56.560
you see in the supposed Christian West. And we have
1716
01:37:56.680 --> 01:37:59.319
to ask the question, well, why is that? Why is
1717
01:37:59.359 --> 01:38:03.680
it that the supposed Christian West has been affected in
1718
01:38:03.800 --> 01:38:08.359
a much greater sense by secular liberalism than anything that
1719
01:38:08.479 --> 01:38:12.199
you see in Muslim countries. I myself, I live in
1720
01:38:12.239 --> 01:38:16.920
a Muslim country, Morocco. Of course, it doesn't institute all
1721
01:38:17.000 --> 01:38:19.119
of the laws and Islamic laws in the way that
1722
01:38:19.279 --> 01:38:22.880
I think it should, but nevertheless, it does so in
1723
01:38:23.600 --> 01:38:27.319
much greater terms than anything that we see in the West,
1724
01:38:27.399 --> 01:38:32.279
in my opinion, So I think that Islam has a
1725
01:38:32.359 --> 01:38:36.239
lot to say about the society, some of that Christians
1726
01:38:36.319 --> 01:38:38.399
wouldn't like, and I think part of the reason is
1727
01:38:38.479 --> 01:38:42.199
because they've been affected by the secular West. For example,
1728
01:38:42.199 --> 01:38:45.720
I think Jay would probably agree with me that blasphemy
1729
01:38:45.840 --> 01:38:48.520
laws should be in stated, and that he wouldn't have
1730
01:38:48.600 --> 01:38:52.359
a problem with the you know, Christian Church advocating for that.
1731
01:38:52.640 --> 01:38:55.800
I do as well, But many Christians who live in
1732
01:38:55.840 --> 01:38:58.319
the West have been affected by this idea of secular
1733
01:38:58.399 --> 01:39:02.520
liberalism that okay, as we're not sort of physically harming anyone,
1734
01:39:02.680 --> 01:39:05.439
then basically we should let people do whatever they want,
1735
01:39:05.520 --> 01:39:07.319
and love is love, so we can have all of
1736
01:39:07.359 --> 01:39:11.439
these different kinds of marriages. Although they don't allow it's
1737
01:39:11.439 --> 01:39:14.680
illegal for mus some men to marry more than one woman,
1738
01:39:15.079 --> 01:39:20.520
But that's another inconsistency within the sort of secular liberal framework.
1739
01:39:21.039 --> 01:39:24.640
But my argument is that secular liberalism comes pretty much
1740
01:39:24.800 --> 01:39:28.479
out of the Protestant movement, not immediately but eventually leads
1741
01:39:28.520 --> 01:39:31.319
to that. And I think that it's very clearly the
1742
01:39:31.439 --> 01:39:34.920
case that it's because there is a lack of clarity
1743
01:39:35.399 --> 01:39:39.079
regarding church government and the government structure that is supposed
1744
01:39:39.119 --> 01:39:42.600
to be in place that is envisioned by Christianity in
1745
01:39:42.680 --> 01:39:45.000
the Bible. I don't think it's clear at all. I
1746
01:39:45.079 --> 01:39:48.119
think that Jay has tried to give passages, try to
1747
01:39:48.199 --> 01:39:52.359
give examples of prophecies from the Old Testament and so
1748
01:39:52.479 --> 01:39:55.199
on and so forth, but the New Testament doesn't really
1749
01:39:55.479 --> 01:39:59.720
clearly reinstitute any of that from the Old Testament. There's
1750
01:39:59.760 --> 01:40:03.680
no details about exactly what's supposed to happen and business
1751
01:40:03.760 --> 01:40:06.720
transactions and all the nitty gritty details that are supposed
1752
01:40:06.760 --> 01:40:10.439
to run society that exists in developed Jewish law and
1753
01:40:10.600 --> 01:40:14.960
Islamic law. Yes, there are differences amongst scholars in Islamic law,
1754
01:40:15.039 --> 01:40:17.640
but the fact that we have clear Islamic law and
1755
01:40:17.760 --> 01:40:21.520
debates amongst the scholars shows that there is a clear position.
1756
01:40:21.920 --> 01:40:24.880
Thank you, thank you very much for that. Closing Jake,
1757
01:40:31.960 --> 01:40:33.479
with that, we're going to go into the Q and A.
1758
01:40:33.600 --> 01:40:35.720
But first one he give a huge thank you to
1759
01:40:35.800 --> 01:40:41.520
our sponsors,
including Main First Project, Roar, Uncensored America, and
1760
01:40:41.840 --> 01:40:45.319
Apologetics Art. We appreciate their support of fair debates. Check
1761
01:40:45.319 --> 01:40:48.960
out their links in the description box right now. Also,
1762
01:40:50.119 --> 01:40:53.960
quick housekeeping note is if you can let me know,
1763
01:40:56.760 --> 01:40:59.560
is there anyone here who only has a ticket for
1764
01:40:59.680 --> 01:41:01.880
Sada and who wanted to do a meet and greet
1765
01:41:01.960 --> 01:41:03.159
and photo with Ja.
1766
01:41:05.000 --> 01:41:05.359
Too many?
1767
01:41:06.279 --> 01:41:09.720
Then immediately after this debate we'll do those.
1768
01:41:09.960 --> 01:41:13.159
Listenly, we got about five people, So after this debate,
1769
01:41:13.319 --> 01:41:15.279
please do a favor and don't come up to the
1770
01:41:15.359 --> 01:41:17.880
stage just yet. We're gonna have those five people get
1771
01:41:17.920 --> 01:41:21.199
their meet and greet and photo with Jay before.
1772
01:41:20.920 --> 01:41:22.680
They have to leave for the rest of the weekend.
1773
01:41:22.920 --> 01:41:26.039
But with that will start the Q and a come
1774
01:41:26.079 --> 01:41:31.960
on up, Marian, thank you one second, just so people
1775
01:41:32.039 --> 01:41:32.319
can hear.
1776
01:41:32.439 --> 01:41:34.800
I know that it's a if you can do.
1777
01:41:34.840 --> 01:41:37.560
A favor, just so people around you can hear when
1778
01:41:37.640 --> 01:41:39.399
Jay or when the question is asking a question, if
1779
01:41:39.439 --> 01:41:41.760
you can keep a conversation down otherwise, if you want
1780
01:41:41.760 --> 01:41:43.399
to have a conversation in the hallway, it's totally cool.
1781
01:41:44.920 --> 01:41:48.840
So Jake, I've appreciated the intellectual honesty and sincerity you've
1782
01:41:48.840 --> 01:41:51.880
brought this whole day. It's actually quite joyous. So my
1783
01:41:52.000 --> 01:41:55.159
background is I I've never watched Jay Dyer I was
1784
01:41:55.239 --> 01:41:58.039
brought here by a friend, but I am an Orthodox Christian.
1785
01:41:58.079 --> 01:42:00.960
I do agree with a lot of what mister Dyer's saying.
1786
01:42:01.960 --> 01:42:06.600
My question really is, like Orthodoxy posits a new way
1787
01:42:06.640 --> 01:42:09.680
of life for for people that addresses more of the
1788
01:42:10.239 --> 01:42:13.680
root cause of humanity's condition, more than say, the surface
1789
01:42:13.760 --> 01:42:17.600
causes with polity and the governance of people's So really,
1790
01:42:19.720 --> 01:42:21.640
I know that we don't have a system, but is
1791
01:42:21.680 --> 01:42:24.319
it safe to say that, like, you know, Bronze age
1792
01:42:24.520 --> 01:42:29.680
esque mosaics are the solution for addressing the root cause
1793
01:42:30.000 --> 01:42:32.039
in people when that has obviously.
1794
01:42:31.720 --> 01:42:32.760
Not worked with the Jews.
1795
01:42:33.800 --> 01:42:35.279
I didn't hear the last part.
1796
01:42:35.439 --> 01:42:35.880
I'm sorry.
1797
01:42:37.720 --> 01:42:41.560
So would you say that would mosaics be like would
1798
01:42:41.640 --> 01:42:45.880
mosaic esque solutions say with like with like the Law
1799
01:42:45.920 --> 01:42:48.279
of Moses or like what or like with the Quran?
1800
01:42:48.359 --> 01:42:50.840
And forgive me, I don't I know very little about Islam.
1801
01:42:51.319 --> 01:42:54.039
But what are these solutions the way to address the
1802
01:42:54.159 --> 01:42:57.640
root cause with people? You know, when it did not
1803
01:42:57.800 --> 01:42:59.359
work with say the Jews.
1804
01:43:00.920 --> 01:43:02.600
I think that it is. I don't know. I think
1805
01:43:02.960 --> 01:43:05.800
Jay might even agree with me about that that I
1806
01:43:06.000 --> 01:43:08.840
think that we have to get back to. I mean,
1807
01:43:09.000 --> 01:43:10.840
of course, I don't agree with the Bible. So I'm
1808
01:43:10.840 --> 01:43:15.319
going to say, from my perspective Islamic principles and Islamic law,
1809
01:43:16.119 --> 01:43:19.720
I think that that is the way. And unfortunately a
1810
01:43:19.800 --> 01:43:22.279
lot of people think, oh, well, just you know, there
1811
01:43:22.279 --> 01:43:24.720
shouldn't be any pressure from the state, and there shouldn't
1812
01:43:24.720 --> 01:43:30.399
be any obvious leanings of what religion and laws are
1813
01:43:30.479 --> 01:43:33.800
being instituted based upon said religion. I just think that
1814
01:43:33.920 --> 01:43:37.920
that's wrong. I think that most people are not equipped
1815
01:43:38.439 --> 01:43:40.399
to make their own decisions a lot of the times,
1816
01:43:40.520 --> 01:43:42.800
and they need to be told what is correct and
1817
01:43:42.880 --> 01:43:44.560
what is right, and I think that it needs to
1818
01:43:44.640 --> 01:43:47.399
be enforced by the state. And I think the problem
1819
01:43:47.439 --> 01:43:50.479
that we see in the West is allowing everybody to
1820
01:43:50.640 --> 01:43:52.720
just kind of make up their own mind and follow
1821
01:43:52.760 --> 01:43:55.239
whatever they want, and it leads to chaos and destruction.
1822
01:43:56.720 --> 01:44:03.560
Well why are you in a scientist, onesie, Oh, I
1823
01:44:03.720 --> 01:44:05.840
like it. It's crazy. Ready for you with a tie?
1824
01:44:05.960 --> 01:44:06.279
All right?
1825
01:44:06.319 --> 01:44:08.159
So Jay clearly one because he's got the better hat.
1826
01:44:09.399 --> 01:44:11.119
So a woman's had too. By the way, my wife's
1827
01:44:11.159 --> 01:44:13.079
had my questions for Jake.
1828
01:44:13.199 --> 01:44:15.159
So you said that the Christian scriptures don't have any
1829
01:44:15.159 --> 01:44:17.880
teachings on political systems. If that's true, then why did
1830
01:44:17.960 --> 01:44:19.680
God appoint the monarchy of David? And I have two
1831
01:44:19.720 --> 01:44:23.479
different scriptures to quote for that. Samuel five twelve said,
1832
01:44:23.479 --> 01:44:25.720
and David knew that the Lord had established him king
1833
01:44:25.800 --> 01:44:28.199
over Israel, that he had exalted his kingdom for the
1834
01:44:28.199 --> 01:44:29.520
sake of the people of Israel.
1835
01:44:29.760 --> 01:44:30.960
And then Chronicles twenty.
1836
01:44:30.760 --> 01:44:33.720
Eight four says David says, the Lord God of Israel
1837
01:44:33.840 --> 01:44:36.279
chose me for all, from all of my father's house,
1838
01:44:36.319 --> 01:44:37.640
to be king over Israel forever.
1839
01:44:38.880 --> 01:44:39.079
Yeah.
1840
01:44:39.199 --> 01:44:43.319
So again, and Jay, I don't think Jay mentioned specifically
1841
01:44:43.399 --> 01:44:46.640
those passages he might have, I'm not sure, but much
1842
01:44:46.760 --> 01:44:50.239
of must most and much of what's quoted is coming
1843
01:44:50.399 --> 01:44:54.079
from the Old Testament. Okay. So I agree that the Jews,
1844
01:44:54.159 --> 01:44:57.079
and this is why you see this, right, the Jews
1845
01:44:57.159 --> 01:45:01.720
and the Muslims have a very developed tradition of Jewish
1846
01:45:01.840 --> 01:45:04.800
law and Islamic law. You don't see that in the
1847
01:45:04.880 --> 01:45:07.560
Christian West or even the East. There's not a very
1848
01:45:07.680 --> 01:45:11.000
developed system of law. Now, you do have things like
1849
01:45:11.119 --> 01:45:13.640
canon law, and we discussed some of those things before,
1850
01:45:14.039 --> 01:45:17.640
but it's nowhere near as developed as anything that exists
1851
01:45:18.079 --> 01:45:21.840
in Jewish law or Muslim law, which Jay mentioned earlier.
1852
01:45:21.880 --> 01:45:24.840
As Fip and I think that the reason is because
1853
01:45:25.199 --> 01:45:28.439
the New Testament is not clear. It doesn't have any
1854
01:45:28.520 --> 01:45:32.319
clear passages like you mentioned in the Old Testament, it
1855
01:45:32.399 --> 01:45:33.119
just doesn't exist.
1856
01:45:33.560 --> 01:45:36.079
So in response to that, as I noted, it's an
1857
01:45:36.079 --> 01:45:39.359
assumption that the early Christians and even the later Christians
1858
01:45:39.800 --> 01:45:41.600
only cared about what the New Testament said.
1859
01:45:42.359 --> 01:45:45.560
We always held all of those principles to be the case.
1860
01:45:45.680 --> 01:45:49.119
Again, Saint Athanasius, and one of the most important patriarchates
1861
01:45:49.199 --> 01:45:52.399
in the entire history of the Church is the Alexander Patriarchate,
1862
01:45:52.800 --> 01:45:56.439
and their norm, according to Athanasius's letters was all catechumans
1863
01:45:56.479 --> 01:45:59.000
are brought into the church reading all the due to
1864
01:45:59.039 --> 01:45:59.960
orcononical texts.
1865
01:46:00.680 --> 01:46:02.039
That would mean again.
1866
01:46:02.640 --> 01:46:07.640
Countless versus throughout syric about kings and the principles of
1867
01:46:08.079 --> 01:46:13.720
the
Davidic iconographic representation that every basilaeis that's the Byzantine
1868
01:46:13.760 --> 01:46:17.319
idea of the ruler. He's a basilis that's based on
1869
01:46:17.439 --> 01:46:20.119
the idea of David. So it's just simply not the
1870
01:46:20.199 --> 01:46:22.720
case that the Church didn't look to all these old
1871
01:46:22.800 --> 01:46:23.520
husband principles.
1872
01:46:24.439 --> 01:46:26.039
And then for the Q and A line, if you
1873
01:46:26.079 --> 01:46:27.760
guys can do be a favor and slide all the way,
1874
01:46:27.880 --> 01:46:29.640
just single file. That way the cameras are able to
1875
01:46:29.640 --> 01:46:32.479
see the speakers, all right, and then we'll keep you
1876
01:46:32.640 --> 01:46:33.600
tight this way that way.
1877
01:46:33.800 --> 01:46:34.640
There you go, all right.
1878
01:46:35.800 --> 01:46:38.439
So this debate is about what is better for society,
1879
01:46:38.800 --> 01:46:42.319
and you argue that Islam is better because protestantm led
1880
01:46:42.319 --> 01:46:45.880
to individuality, which eventually led to liberalism, which I agree
1881
01:46:45.960 --> 01:46:48.520
liberalism is not the best for society. But I think
1882
01:46:48.560 --> 01:46:51.479
your argument fails and that Islam would also have this
1883
01:46:51.640 --> 01:46:54.319
liberal ideology influence, except every time it starts up in
1884
01:46:54.359 --> 01:46:57.119
a free Islamic society, they crush it through violence, war
1885
01:46:57.159 --> 01:47:00.600
and dictatorship, killing their own people. And you can see
1886
01:47:00.640 --> 01:47:03.760
that in places like Iran and other places where revolution
1887
01:47:03.880 --> 01:47:05.920
have taken place. And I would go on farther that
1888
01:47:06.000 --> 01:47:08.319
even with the richest nation in the world, Saudi Arabia,
1889
01:47:08.600 --> 01:47:11.159
Islaming nations have done nothing over the last two centuries
1890
01:47:11.199 --> 01:47:14.880
to invent any revolution for society. Meanwhile, a bunch of
1891
01:47:14.960 --> 01:47:17.840
Christian farmers over through the greatest colonizing nation the world
1892
01:47:17.880 --> 01:47:20.039
has ever seen, and built the most powerful nation of
1893
01:47:20.079 --> 01:47:23.359
the modern era. And even in this liberal revolution, America
1894
01:47:23.680 --> 01:47:27.079
has maintained its Christian foundation while peacefully exploring revolutionary ideas
1895
01:47:27.239 --> 01:47:31.920
and democracy, and so I would say ask you, if
1896
01:47:32.079 --> 01:47:35.000
Islam is better, why are your people massively immigrating to
1897
01:47:35.039 --> 01:47:36.920
all the Christian nations and don't stay in their own.
1898
01:47:38.159 --> 01:47:41.479
One of the reasons is because supposed Christian nations like
1899
01:47:41.560 --> 01:47:44.279
the US keep bombing the crap out of Muslim nations,
1900
01:47:44.680 --> 01:47:48.720
and so they're living in situations in which there's not
1901
01:47:49.159 --> 01:47:53.239
a good economy. They're being bombed. I can go through
1902
01:47:53.319 --> 01:47:56.279
so many examples of that. But I myself, I left
1903
01:47:57.199 --> 01:47:59.239
the US to live in a Muslim country, and I
1904
01:47:59.279 --> 01:48:01.560
think too, So maybe we agree on that.
1905
01:48:02.159 --> 01:48:04.920
Well, Okay, I just wanted to say the word shit
1906
01:48:05.279 --> 01:48:07.560
because I see that Trent Horne is in the back
1907
01:48:07.600 --> 01:48:08.800
and I want to know if he's going to leave
1908
01:48:08.800 --> 01:48:10.479
the room if I say the four letter word.
1909
01:48:11.680 --> 01:48:13.600
No, okay, I'm just joking.
1910
01:48:13.960 --> 01:48:16.560
I think Trent should take my place for the rest
1911
01:48:16.600 --> 01:48:17.000
of the debate.
1912
01:48:20.840 --> 01:48:24.119
Oh No, I just agree that the Muslim should go
1913
01:48:24.119 --> 01:48:25.279
back to their nation and leave am marry.
1914
01:48:25.319 --> 01:48:26.000
You disagree with that.
1915
01:48:26.199 --> 01:48:28.680
No, I agree they should stop immigrating here and taking
1916
01:48:28.720 --> 01:48:30.000
over Frisco.
1917
01:48:30.199 --> 01:48:31.479
It'd be great. I agree too.
1918
01:48:33.560 --> 01:48:34.720
That's one thing I agree on.
1919
01:48:38.680 --> 01:48:40.640
Hey, Jack, I just wanted to ask you. You say
1920
01:48:40.680 --> 01:48:43.039
that Islam is better or would be better for American
1921
01:48:43.119 --> 01:48:47.840
society because prosthentism liberal Christianity imposes liberalism. But I want
1922
01:48:47.880 --> 01:48:52.279
to ask you if Islam would better American society, why
1923
01:48:52.359 --> 01:48:55.000
is it the case that every single congress person on
1924
01:48:55.119 --> 01:48:58.600
the federal level level in the United States have all
1925
01:48:58.680 --> 01:49:03.000
been liberal Democrats that actually contribute to these things that
1926
01:49:03.079 --> 01:49:03.800
you criticize.
1927
01:49:05.000 --> 01:49:08.279
In other words, you're saying that liberal democracy is a
1928
01:49:08.319 --> 01:49:09.880
good thing. Is that what you're trying to say?
1929
01:49:10.479 --> 01:49:13.760
No, I said, if you're saying it's a bad thing
1930
01:49:14.079 --> 01:49:16.960
and that Islam would be the alternative. Why is it
1931
01:49:17.079 --> 01:49:21.039
that every single Muslim representative on the federal level in Congress,
1932
01:49:21.279 --> 01:49:23.840
every single one of them were Liberal Democrats.
1933
01:49:24.000 --> 01:49:26.159
Well, there's hardly any of them. There's a few, and
1934
01:49:26.279 --> 01:49:27.159
they're all phonies.
1935
01:49:32.079 --> 01:49:32.920
I guess that's the answer.
1936
01:49:38.439 --> 01:49:39.680
I don't think that's gonna happen.
1937
01:49:39.960 --> 01:49:43.439
Hi, this question is actually directed at This question is
1938
01:49:43.439 --> 01:49:47.119
actually directed at both of you
guys. As an ex atheist,
1939
01:49:47.520 --> 01:49:49.319
this question needs to be kind of the center point
1940
01:49:50.079 --> 01:49:54.000
of why I was an atheist. I think both Christianity
1941
01:49:54.079 --> 01:49:57.840
and Islam agree and teach that human beings often fail
1942
01:49:57.920 --> 01:50:01.600
to live according to God's will and what he teaches us. However,
1943
01:50:01.720 --> 01:50:05.600
if followers repeatedly misuse or distort the religion throughout history
1944
01:50:05.680 --> 01:50:08.960
we see in Christianity, through the Crusades Islam, I think
1945
01:50:08.960 --> 01:50:10.880
a lot of it goes without saying we see isis,
1946
01:50:10.920 --> 01:50:14.319
we see what happens in the Middle East. How should
1947
01:50:14.359 --> 01:50:18.840
an outsider determine whether these failures reflect the human nature
1948
01:50:18.880 --> 01:50:22.960
itself or actually something did that it reveals about the
1949
01:50:23.279 --> 01:50:26.199
religion itself? And is there any threshold where the consistent
1950
01:50:26.279 --> 01:50:29.399
fruit of a movement should cause us to question the
1951
01:50:29.479 --> 01:50:30.720
movements teachings themselves.
1952
01:50:32.520 --> 01:50:33.600
Do you want to answer first?
1953
01:50:33.640 --> 01:50:37.239
Yeah, well, I mean the examples were kind of complex.
1954
01:50:37.359 --> 01:50:40.079
I don't think that with you know, issues like the Crusades,
1955
01:50:40.159 --> 01:50:42.920
there's a simple you know, good guy, bad guy, and
1956
01:50:43.000 --> 01:50:44.760
oh that was all bad or that was all good.
1957
01:50:44.840 --> 01:50:49.399
I mean, all of these situations or examples are extremely complex,
1958
01:50:49.640 --> 01:50:55.960
and it's very difficult to say in broad brushstrokes that
1959
01:50:56.560 --> 01:50:58.520
this is all the fault of the religion, right Like
1960
01:50:58.560 --> 01:51:01.680
I wouldn't want to say that because the Western civilization
1961
01:51:02.720 --> 01:51:05.720
birds you know, liberalism and atheism in the modern era
1962
01:51:05.920 --> 01:51:07.680
that therefore all of Christianity.
1963
01:51:07.760 --> 01:51:09.920
It's just very difficult. It's a complex question.
1964
01:51:10.039 --> 01:51:14.279
I just don't know if you can immediately identify unless
1965
01:51:14.319 --> 01:51:17.960
it's something egregious. And I think that in my perspective,
1966
01:51:18.079 --> 01:51:21.079
you know a lot of Islamic teachings are egregiously wrong.
1967
01:51:21.800 --> 01:51:24.479
Those things would be to me indicators. But that's also
1968
01:51:24.560 --> 01:51:27.199
going to be based on my paradigm. So I think ultimately,
1969
01:51:27.279 --> 01:51:28.920
you know, this is I'm not trying to cop out,
1970
01:51:29.000 --> 01:51:31.439
but ultimately it's going to be a paradigm level question
1971
01:51:31.520 --> 01:51:34.079
depending upon what you consider to be good and bad.
1972
01:51:34.119 --> 01:51:36.680
And if you're an atheist, I don't think atheists even
1973
01:51:36.720 --> 01:51:38.720
have a basis to say what's good and bad. So
1974
01:51:39.279 --> 01:51:42.720
they're just going to confirm with their own assumptions whatever
1975
01:51:42.760 --> 01:51:45.840
they don't like, based on interpreting some events like the
1976
01:51:45.960 --> 01:51:46.960
Crusades or whatever.
1977
01:51:48.840 --> 01:51:51.239
And did you say you're an atheist or ex atheist?
1978
01:51:51.399 --> 01:51:53.119
Oh okay, yeah, So I was just.
1979
01:51:53.159 --> 01:51:55.920
Confused attribute a lot of my atheism towards the fact
1980
01:51:55.960 --> 01:52:03.359
that many religions justify evil acts through texts or through
1981
01:52:03.560 --> 01:52:04.560
their religion itself.
1982
01:52:04.760 --> 01:52:07.840
So okay, yeah, I mean that certainly happens. It happens
1983
01:52:07.880 --> 01:52:10.800
in Christianity happens in Islam, but I don't think that
1984
01:52:11.000 --> 01:52:17.680
that necessarily refutes the religion or indicates it. Right, if
1985
01:52:17.760 --> 01:52:21.039
there is a clear pattern that happens over and over again,
1986
01:52:21.079 --> 01:52:24.319
and that the people themselves, pretty much all of them
1987
01:52:24.439 --> 01:52:28.039
are agreeing that it's from the religion, then that would
1988
01:52:28.079 --> 01:52:30.760
call into question, as as Jay said, whether or not
1989
01:52:30.960 --> 01:52:34.760
you agree with said position. So for example, of course
1990
01:52:34.800 --> 01:52:37.880
I don't support Isis at all, but I do believe
1991
01:52:37.960 --> 01:52:43.720
that jihad or warfare is legitimate. So yeah, it just
1992
01:52:43.920 --> 01:52:45.520
all depends on the situation.
1993
01:52:47.720 --> 01:52:47.920
For you.
1994
01:52:48.920 --> 01:52:54.319
My question is for the Muslim you say that the
1995
01:52:54.720 --> 01:52:58.039
Islamic religion is best for society.
1996
01:52:58.359 --> 01:53:01.720
So from a society like the.
1997
01:53:04.319 --> 01:53:08.840
The al Qaeda under in Afghanistan, you have the education
1998
01:53:08.960 --> 01:53:12.159
of women that is barred after grade six. You have
1999
01:53:12.880 --> 01:53:16.640
their restriction of public employment, you have their freedom move
2000
01:53:16.720 --> 01:53:17.600
movement restricted.
2001
01:53:17.960 --> 01:53:18.239
You have.
2002
01:53:19.800 --> 01:53:24.119
Women being spit on and beaten for not wearing a
2003
01:53:24.199 --> 01:53:24.680
head covering.
2004
01:53:25.159 --> 01:53:25.520
You have.
2005
01:53:27.359 --> 01:53:31.960
Muslim women being attacked just for whatever whatever the man wants,
2006
01:53:32.640 --> 01:53:36.239
and you have mass rape of Muslim women, and you
2007
01:53:36.319 --> 01:53:40.800
also have harlots and harm for Muslim women where a
2008
01:53:40.920 --> 01:53:44.840
man can take multiple wives. And then you also you
2009
01:53:44.960 --> 01:53:48.439
also have a
batcha Bazzi boys. So how do you
2010
01:53:48.880 --> 01:53:52.800
reconcile this with the original premise of the debate being
2011
01:53:53.520 --> 01:53:55.560
how is this better for society?
2012
01:53:56.479 --> 01:53:59.680
You seem pretty upset by what you said. You got
2013
01:53:59.760 --> 01:54:04.000
a hat there it's better than jays, But no, just
2014
01:54:04.079 --> 01:54:06.800
because there are some Muslims and I would dispute a
2015
01:54:06.840 --> 01:54:08.439
lot of the things that you said. But even if
2016
01:54:08.520 --> 01:54:11.039
I granted that there are some Muslims who are doing
2017
01:54:11.199 --> 01:54:15.600
things like as you mentioned, Baschabazi stuff in Afghanistan, that
2018
01:54:15.680 --> 01:54:19.199
doesn't mean that it's correct. There's nothing in the Quran
2019
01:54:19.319 --> 01:54:22.279
or Islamic law which supports that type of behavior at all.
2020
01:54:22.479 --> 01:54:25.520
So there's always going to be people who claim to
2021
01:54:25.600 --> 01:54:30.279
be a particular religion who actually do heinous things, and
2022
01:54:30.399 --> 01:54:33.159
there's no way around that. That's just gonna happen.
2023
01:54:33.840 --> 01:54:34.680
Out of curiosity.
2024
01:54:35.520 --> 01:54:38.359
Is there a society that you do think exists that
2025
01:54:38.600 --> 01:54:41.960
has a good form of Islamic law and practice.
2026
01:54:43.680 --> 01:54:47.640
There are some more than others, but none completely are
2027
01:54:47.720 --> 01:54:51.199
instituting Islamic law. But I mean, I can give you
2028
01:54:51.920 --> 01:54:54.159
my view of which ones I think are better. I
2029
01:54:54.279 --> 01:54:56.199
think a lot of the Gulf States are.
2030
01:55:01.279 --> 01:55:04.960
Would you agree that your supposed prophet and in my opinion,
2031
01:55:05.079 --> 01:55:08.359
demon who married a six year old girl is the
2032
01:55:08.640 --> 01:55:13.439
pinnacle of your religion and the ideal state of your society.
2033
01:55:14.359 --> 01:55:17.079
No, it's not the pinnacle of the religion. Just because
2034
01:55:17.119 --> 01:55:19.800
the prophet did something that doesn't make it the pinnacle
2035
01:55:19.880 --> 01:55:20.439
of the religion.
2036
01:55:21.560 --> 01:55:24.800
The next question, my quest is.
2037
01:55:24.840 --> 01:55:27.760
In the line of the relationship between the church and
2038
01:55:27.920 --> 01:55:32.560
the state. The Eastern Orthodox Church historically have been tied
2039
01:55:33.039 --> 01:55:36.359
or married to the political unit that they exist in
2040
01:55:36.680 --> 01:55:39.640
the Russian Orthodox Church, the Ukraine and Orthodox Church, Greek,
2041
01:55:39.920 --> 01:55:45.600
Ethiopian Editorian. Now usually they tend to support the state
2042
01:55:46.119 --> 01:55:49.760
even in times of war. Now doesn't that put the
2043
01:55:50.159 --> 01:55:54.640
Christian communities in those political units in danger of warring
2044
01:55:54.760 --> 01:55:58.239
with each other? And we can see at the example
2045
01:55:58.319 --> 01:56:01.920
of the Russian Orthodox Church support in putting the Ukraine
2046
01:56:01.960 --> 01:56:05.520
and Orthodox Church support in Ukraine warring with each other. Yeah,
2047
01:56:05.520 --> 01:56:09.560
I have first hand witnessed Eritreans and Ethiopian Scoptic Christians
2048
01:56:09.920 --> 01:56:13.239
warring with each other. How is that good for Christian
2049
01:56:13.359 --> 01:56:14.920
societies in what states?
2050
01:56:14.960 --> 01:56:16.960
Why would that be good? What in anything that I
2051
01:56:17.159 --> 01:56:19.520
argued would make you think that I'm saying that would
2052
01:56:19.600 --> 01:56:19.960
be good?
2053
01:56:20.520 --> 01:56:24.399
Well, because the Eastern Orthodox Church is always tied to
2054
01:56:24.520 --> 01:56:25.439
the political unit.
2055
01:56:26.479 --> 01:56:30.520
Well, because the church has something to say to politics
2056
01:56:30.600 --> 01:56:34.920
and has a doctrine of symphonia, it again doesn't follow
2057
01:56:35.039 --> 01:56:39.279
from that that it will always be explicated or done
2058
01:56:39.319 --> 01:56:41.560
in the right way. We would simply say that it's
2059
01:56:41.640 --> 01:56:44.600
actually impossible, which I would agree with Jake. It's really
2060
01:56:44.680 --> 01:56:47.680
not possible to have a secular view of the state.
2061
01:56:48.039 --> 01:56:51.479
If you are a religious believer. It becomes really you
2062
01:56:51.560 --> 01:56:54.600
really just cut God off from that area of society
2063
01:56:54.680 --> 01:56:58.840
and you act as if, as many Baptists think right that, well,
2064
01:56:59.199 --> 01:57:01.039
I have my own per some religious belief, but it's
2065
01:57:01.079 --> 01:57:02.720
nothing really to do with the state. So you kind
2066
01:57:02.760 --> 01:57:07.000
of create this division between two realms. But there's never
2067
01:57:07.119 --> 01:57:09.640
been a situation in Christian history or the Old Testament
2068
01:57:09.720 --> 01:57:12.720
where God didn't have principles and things to say to
2069
01:57:12.920 --> 01:57:15.760
the state. So the fact that you find examples and
2070
01:57:15.800 --> 01:57:18.720
by the way, there is no historical Ukrainian Orthodox Church
2071
01:57:18.800 --> 01:57:19.439
that doesn't exist.
2072
01:57:19.560 --> 01:57:21.039
What exists is the church?
2073
01:57:21.479 --> 01:57:26.199
Huhur Existinkay?
2074
01:57:26.239 --> 01:57:27.359
Where did they come from? Do you know where it
2075
01:57:27.399 --> 01:57:27.720
came from?
2076
01:57:27.880 --> 01:57:30.399
Well, we can go into that, but either way, well,
2077
01:57:30.439 --> 01:57:30.680
it was.
2078
01:57:30.680 --> 01:57:33.840
Created by the state, Department. It was created by the
2079
01:57:33.960 --> 01:57:34.760
State department.
2080
01:57:35.039 --> 01:57:37.880
So that's why there's a Ukrainian Orthodox Church. Prior to
2081
01:57:38.000 --> 01:57:40.239
the existence of Ukraine, which comes out of World War One,
2082
01:57:40.880 --> 01:57:42.960
there was only the Russian Church there. There was no
2083
01:57:43.119 --> 01:57:45.560
Ukrainian Orthodox Church separate from Moscow.
2084
01:57:45.680 --> 01:57:47.239
That's a creation of the West.
2085
01:57:47.399 --> 01:57:51.239
So if your idea is that the separation of church
2086
01:57:51.279 --> 01:57:54.039
and state is the ideal, it's ironic that it's actually
2087
01:57:54.199 --> 01:57:58.960
the American government that created that separation there with the
2088
01:57:59.079 --> 01:58:02.960
Church of Ukraine with Moscow. So I'm simply saying that
2089
01:58:03.359 --> 01:58:06.039
there will always be As Paba Nazi have said in
2090
01:58:06.119 --> 01:58:08.840
his famous book Reflections of a Russian Statesman, if you
2091
01:58:08.960 --> 01:58:12.079
have this strict division of church and state, not just separation,
2092
01:58:12.199 --> 01:58:14.319
but division of the church and the state, you don't
2093
01:58:14.359 --> 01:58:17.319
actually get freedom and liberty. What you get is a
2094
01:58:17.800 --> 01:58:21.279
new church running the state. Namely, the state becomes the
2095
01:58:21.359 --> 01:58:24.439
church running the state. So I'm saying it's not possible
2096
01:58:24.520 --> 01:58:27.800
to have what you're assuming. I'm assuming you're arguing.
2097
01:58:29.359 --> 01:58:34.159
Either way, Christians in those countries are voting with each other.
2098
01:58:34.359 --> 01:58:38.720
That's my point. Also, if Russia or Ukraine, or Ethiopia
2099
01:58:38.800 --> 01:58:41.880
or editora in which these churches exist. If they were
2100
01:58:41.960 --> 01:58:46.520
to collapse, the church also is affected or would collapse
2101
01:58:46.560 --> 01:58:50.800
with them the state where adding the Protestant tradition, if
2102
01:58:50.840 --> 01:58:53.319
the US were to go down, the Metodist Church or
2103
01:58:53.439 --> 01:58:55.640
any Protestant church wouldn't go down with the state.
2104
01:58:55.760 --> 01:58:56.880
No, I don't think that's true at all.
2105
01:58:56.920 --> 01:59:00.479
Again, there were no Protestant Methodist churches for sin trees
2106
01:59:00.640 --> 01:59:03.439
of existence for the first fifteen hundred years of the church, right,
2107
01:59:03.520 --> 01:59:05.239
I mean John Wesley Methodism.
2108
01:59:05.319 --> 01:59:06.359
That's seventeen hundreds.
2109
01:59:06.640 --> 01:59:10.600
So the idea that somehow Protestantism is protected because it's
2110
01:59:10.680 --> 01:59:12.359
not tied to the state, that's.
2111
01:59:12.239 --> 01:59:13.720
Not even classical Protestantism.
2112
01:59:13.800 --> 01:59:18.079
All the first generation Reformers utilized the state to promote
2113
01:59:18.119 --> 01:59:22.520
their reformation. Luther used the German princes. The history of
2114
01:59:22.560 --> 01:59:25.920
the Methodist Church is bound up with the
Anglican Church.
2115
01:59:26.279 --> 01:59:28.000
So what you're arguing for is really just a fiction
2116
01:59:28.119 --> 01:59:29.119
that doesn't actually exist.
2117
01:59:29.720 --> 01:59:30.520
Gotta go to the next quest.
2118
01:59:30.560 --> 01:59:32.399
I'm sorry are giving you like I just want to
2119
01:59:32.399 --> 01:59:34.199
make sure that they get to ask their questions before
2120
01:59:34.960 --> 01:59:35.279
go ahead.
2121
01:59:35.840 --> 01:59:39.439
Okay, this is for Jake. I just had a question.
2122
01:59:39.600 --> 01:59:44.159
Isn't the abolition of slavery in the Christian world that
2123
01:59:44.239 --> 01:59:46.760
began in the Christian world. Isn't that a good argument
2124
01:59:46.840 --> 01:59:49.920
for the strength of Christian ethics and establishing a just
2125
01:59:50.000 --> 01:59:53.239
society because it's rooted in a recognition of everybody being
2126
01:59:53.279 --> 01:59:55.560
made in God's image and the primacy of love of
2127
01:59:55.600 --> 01:59:56.840
neighbor as a duty.
2128
01:59:57.960 --> 02:00:01.920
Only if you think that slavery in any condition is unjust,
2129
02:00:02.000 --> 02:00:02.960
which I don't agree.
2130
02:00:02.760 --> 02:00:07.119
With, Okay, but surely you would agree that we're in
2131
02:00:07.199 --> 02:00:09.960
a much better state now that the conditions of things
2132
02:00:10.039 --> 02:00:13.039
like chattel slavery are gone in the country after country
2133
02:00:13.039 --> 02:00:16.479
has abolished slavery. Don't you think that's on net a
2134
02:00:16.560 --> 02:00:17.119
good effect.
2135
02:00:17.720 --> 02:00:19.159
I think that that is a good thing.
2136
02:00:19.239 --> 02:00:19.439
Yeah.
2137
02:00:22.680 --> 02:00:26.239
I just have a question for Jake. Your whole debate,
2138
02:00:26.319 --> 02:00:29.720
your whole deal, was that liberalism is bad, which we
2139
02:00:29.880 --> 02:00:33.000
agree on. My question to you is, if it's so bad,
2140
02:00:33.079 --> 02:00:39.479
why are the hypocrisy that every city that is Muslim
2141
02:00:39.600 --> 02:00:41.800
here in the United States votes for them?
2142
02:00:42.960 --> 02:00:45.560
Why do Muslims vote for liberals? I guess is your question.
2143
02:00:47.079 --> 02:00:51.319
They work for democratic liberalism ideology that you guys do
2144
02:00:51.479 --> 02:00:54.600
not support, but you're using it to take over this country.
2145
02:00:55.439 --> 02:00:57.479
I don't think we're taking over the country, or about
2146
02:00:57.520 --> 02:01:02.560
one percent of the population. So that's your goal, that's
2147
02:01:02.600 --> 02:01:03.159
not my goal.
2148
02:01:03.359 --> 02:01:04.159
Well, I left.
2149
02:01:04.239 --> 02:01:05.720
I'm oud of here. I don't want nothing to do
2150
02:01:05.760 --> 02:01:06.239
with the US.
2151
02:01:06.439 --> 02:01:06.680
Sure.
2152
02:01:07.880 --> 02:01:14.159
So I think that the reason is because secular liberalism
2153
02:01:14.399 --> 02:01:17.960
has the facade of allowing people to do whatever they want.
2154
02:01:18.479 --> 02:01:21.199
And that's what a lot of these democrats and leftists
2155
02:01:21.319 --> 02:01:25.960
promise Muslims. They think that because they're the extreme minority,
2156
02:01:26.359 --> 02:01:28.880
they have to support that they want. They're okay to
2157
02:01:29.039 --> 02:01:32.520
allow gays to get married and do those things, so
2158
02:01:32.680 --> 02:01:35.239
long as they can have their mosque and do whatever
2159
02:01:35.319 --> 02:01:38.159
they want. That's the reasoning behind it. But I don't
2160
02:01:38.199 --> 02:01:39.000
agree with it at all.
2161
02:01:39.159 --> 02:01:42.479
All right, Well, you're one of the few, but I mean,
2162
02:01:42.560 --> 02:01:45.680
in my personal opinion, I agree with you, there should
2163
02:01:45.680 --> 02:01:47.560
be more religion in the government.
2164
02:01:47.640 --> 02:01:48.840
Maybe we keep you all of you.
2165
02:01:48.880 --> 02:01:49.800
Guys out of this country.
2166
02:01:50.319 --> 02:01:51.800
I'm not here, so it's fine with me.
2167
02:01:52.159 --> 02:01:53.720
I would just like to I would like to thank
2168
02:01:53.800 --> 02:01:58.640
both Muslims that came to debate to me for actually
2169
02:01:58.760 --> 02:02:02.479
just arguing against protestanism. I guess both Muslims so the
2170
02:02:02.520 --> 02:02:04.079
whole argument was against productism.
2171
02:02:04.199 --> 02:02:08.520
So and arguing against Trent Horn too. Don't forget about that.
2172
02:02:10.359 --> 02:02:12.159
Do you want to do a couple of quick housekeeping
2173
02:02:12.239 --> 02:02:15.600
things before we do one final round of applause. Jay
2174
02:02:15.760 --> 02:02:18.640
is correct, Trent Horn and Jay have agreed to a
2175
02:02:18.720 --> 02:02:23.000
debate late this year. That will be December thirteenth, in
2176
02:02:23.079 --> 02:02:26.239
that weekend. We're still negotiating on venues, but we also
2177
02:02:26.319 --> 02:02:28.760
want to show this beauty as my editor just made
2178
02:02:28.800 --> 02:02:32.760
this today as Jad Dyer will be also facing doctor
2179
02:02:32.840 --> 02:02:36.239
David Wood this fall, so that'll be at Debate Con
2180
02:02:36.399 --> 02:02:40.239
nine in Orlando. Tickets will go on sale within the
2181
02:02:40.319 --> 02:02:43.079
next week. We have a newsletter if you'd like to
2182
02:02:43.199 --> 02:02:46.800
join that. That's at our YouTube about page and that's
2183
02:02:46.800 --> 02:02:49.960
where we send out basically whenever we do launch our
2184
02:02:50.079 --> 02:02:52.880
next tickets for our next event. So we are looking
2185
02:02:52.920 --> 02:02:56.359
forward to Jay and doctor David Wood facing off twice
2186
02:02:56.520 --> 02:02:59.159
at that fall conference in Orlando, which, by the way,
2187
02:02:59.479 --> 02:03:02.439
that Hotel Hell has a water park. I'm not joking,
2188
02:03:02.560 --> 02:03:05.720
it's amazing. But with that, all right, we're good, Bob.
2189
02:03:06.760 --> 02:03:08.840
Other housekeeping thing and then we'll give a final round
2190
02:03:08.840 --> 02:03:11.199
of applause. Remember to take anything out of your car,
2191
02:03:11.319 --> 02:03:14.199
don't leave anything in your car. Don't let it be
2192
02:03:14.239 --> 02:03:17.359
a temptation to anybody with that. One final round of
2193
02:03:17.560 --> 02:03:17.920
go ahead.
2194
02:03:17.960 --> 02:03:18.079
Jay.
2195
02:03:18.319 --> 02:03:20.840
Also, I do have about five books left.
2196
02:03:20.880 --> 02:03:22.760
We sold out almost all the books last night, but
2197
02:03:22.880 --> 02:03:24.880
there are some books, and I'll be out there if
2198
02:03:24.880 --> 02:03:25.800
you guys want to get some books.
2199
02:03:25.960 --> 02:03:27.520
That was right, and then we'll also do that meet
2200
02:03:27.520 --> 02:03:29.399
and greet for those like four or five people really
2201
02:03:29.479 --> 02:03:32.840
quick after the debate. But one last round of applause,
2202
02:03:32.960 --> 02:03:34.720
Jake and j It's been a true pleasure to have
2203
02:03:34.840 --> 02:03:44.399
you guys. Special thanks to our sponsors Main First Project,
2204
02:03:44.680 --> 02:03:50.640
Revival of the Anointed Rule, Uncensored America, Patrick O'Neill, Archipologetics,
2205
02:03:51.039 --> 02:03:57.680
Yona Goni International Cuisine, and SDA Special danks to our
2206
02:03:57.760 --> 02:04:02.039
sponsor Main First projecting to put maners first. Check out
2207
02:04:02.199 --> 02:04:06.359
main First project dot org. Huge thanks to Revival of
2208
02:04:06.359 --> 02:04:10.319
the Anointed Rule, equipping Christians to fight for Biblical values
2209
02:04:10.399 --> 02:04:15.680
through policy victories. Check out Revivetharule dot org. Special thanks
2210
02:04:15.720 --> 02:04:19.880
to our sponsor Uncensored America. Want to host a controversial
2211
02:04:19.960 --> 02:04:23.039
speaker on your college campus? Start a chapter now on
2212
02:04:23.199 --> 02:04:27.760
your campus at Uncensored America dot us. Huge thanks to
2213
02:04:27.880 --> 02:04:31.720
our sponsor Apologetics ARC check out their app today by
2214
02:04:31.800 --> 02:04:35.119
downloading it first. Peter three fifteen says, always be ready
2215
02:04:35.199 --> 02:04:35.960
to give a defense.
2216
02:04:37.560 --> 02:04:38.239
Huge thank you to.
2217
02:04:38.239 --> 02:04:43.479
Our sponsor, Yonnaguni International Cuisine of Aguadilla, Puerto Rico. Check
2218
02:04:43.560 --> 02:04:46.840
them out and your next trip special thanks to our
2219
02:04:46.880 --> 02:04:48.520
Sage sponsor SDA