النص 🔗
Ben: Welcome to Inkhaven Presents, Readings from the Archive. I'm Ben. ⁓ this is the Inkhaven Podcast where I invite ⁓ residents and writers to bring something they've written and to read it and discuss it. My guest today is Itzy Weinstock. ⁓ Itsey has ⁓ many hands. He ⁓ is a ⁓ donor advisor in the animal welfare movement. He also has over three substacks, or precisely three substacks, ⁓ writing about ⁓ very funny things and very serious things. and also has a great online guide to Bayesian optimization, ⁓ which I enjoyed. ⁓ but what have you brought for us to read today? Thanks for having me, Ben. ⁓ today I've brought a Sin as a Physical Particle. It's ⁓ exploration of this curious similarity between Judaism and Jainism. Hmm. Excellent. Yeah, I enjoyed this very much, so ⁓ let's listen to that now. This is Sin as a Physical Particle. My friend Manan greets me with an apology. It's somehow both formal and half arsed. He has no doubt wronged me countless times. But I prod him about it. What's going on here? I waggle my finger in his face. He informs me it's Samvatsari, the most important day in the Jain calendar, where you have to fast, have to go around seeking forgiveness for any wrongdoings and harms you've caused, whether intentionally or not. Hey, that's our thing, I say Jewishly. It's even in the same month as Yom Kippur, the most important day in the calendar, where we fast and have to seek forgiveness for any wrongdoings and harms we've caused, whether intentionally or not. Judaism and Jainism are just about as far apart as any religions can get. Jainism is universal and, with its many Titankaras and deities and cycle of rebirth and obsession with alleviating suffering, is highly spiritual. Judaism is, for its small niche crowd, with its uno big guy in the sky and obsession with feeling like you're suffering, while trying to live one good life than dying, is almost aggressively anti spiritual. But they arrive at a very similar prime holiday of atonement. I think this is a natural consequence of what happens When your religion thinks of sin as a law of physics with its own sin particles. If you're in the business of trying to impart the world with better values that last over thousands of years, then establishing sin as particulate is a very neat trick you might want to learn from. This section is Jainism for Cowards. Think of the Buddhists, who do not have this holiday. Buddhism and Jainism are siblings. They spread together by their contemporaneous founders, the Buddha and Mahavira, intertwined from the religious crucible of the minimal. Middle millennium BC, on the Ganges in northeastern India, countercultures to the dominant Vedic kingdoms. They both preach Ahimsa, nonviolence to all beings, as the central ethic. And they tell of karma and the samsara cycle of endless rebirth that one should want to escape to reach liberation. But from here they depart. Buddhism is, of course, Jainism for cowards. In the Buddha's founding myth, he is a
Load full transcript
prince who is repulsed by the world and becomes an ascetic. Before realizing that it is best to live somewhere in between and follow the middle path. In a monastery in Laos, the monks go around a village every day with their only possession, a container for food, and townspeople drop some of their own cooking into the monks' pots. The Buddha and their texts have quite a lot to say about Ahimsa and not harming animals, and there is some rate of vegetarianism in Buddhist countries. But these monks are receiving and eating meat. They didn't personally kill the animal. They take The middle path. It's pretty shocking. The Jains are repulsed by this. They have the highest vegetarian rate in the world, almost 100%, including the regular non monk people. They have stuck to the teachings of Mahavira and spurn the middle path. The Jains have stuck to nonviolence so seriously because they are consequentialists. They are consequentialists because they see karma as a physical particle. The Buddha once said, I call intention karma. Good intentions are everything. They lead to good results. Bad intentions to bad results. You become a good person by purifying your mind and thoughts. Not so for the Jains. The Jains have a physics problem to contend with. Karma, to them, is fine particulate matter. When you do something bad, whether you know it or not, karma is drawn to you and sticks to your soul, gumming up the works and weighing you down. Thoughts, words, intentions, and actions all attract karma like a nasty magnet. It's a law of the universe. It's not judgmental or personal, just a mechan, just a mechanical process. To Jains, the goal is the prevention and obliteration of their karma particles. And when you see sin as a law of physics, it means you can't get away from it with just good intentions. You must be rigorous. They famously don't eat root vegetables, which are teeming with many souls, all of whom might die when you disturb the soil to rip them out. The monks wear masks to avoid breathing in and killing microscopic beings, and they carry around a broom to brush things away to avoid the violence they could inflict with every step, not to mention sitting their bums down. To get rid of karma, they fast. They repent. They serve others, they meditate, and they study. That seems to do the trick. This section is called Separately. While Mahavira was spreading utilitarian veganism around India, the priests of the Temple of Jerusalem were very concerned about the ineptitude of their own population. They didn't realize how good they had it. God was literally living in a house they'd built him on the top of a hill in the middle of their city, and the people could just not get enough of sinning. They loved to do it. And the priests were terrified that God would leave. He had just abandoned the northern kingdom of Israel, and the Neo Assyrians had come through and completely annihilated the great cities of Samaria, Hatzor, Megido, and Dan. The refugees fled en masse, down into Judea and into the previously irrelevant Jerusalem, which was rapidly growing to accommodate them. The priest the priest took ink to scroll. They needed to explain it to the people so destruction would not follow them again. The Jews, to even many Jews' surprise, also views it also view sin as mechanistically attracting physical stuff, and so are also consequentialists. I will now attempt to describe the logic of impurity and sin in the Hebrew Bible. For my documentary hypothesis heads in the audience, this makes up the bulk of the priestly source, which makes up most of Levit most of Leviticus and Numbers and about half of Exodus. Judaism is extremely preoccupied with the concept of holiness. The meaning of holiness has been confused by the influence of Christianity, Judaism for cowards. So pretend we don't know the word holy, and let's start with a blank slate. The original word, kodesh, means separate. There are common, everyday things, and then there are separate things. God is in the category of separate things. Much of the Hebrew Bible is about establishing separateness in one way or another. For example, eating kosher isn't done for health reasons. It's an arbitrary rule to separate you from everyone else. The Sabbath is a day separate from the rest. Now, we want God to hang out with us because He's really powerful, and we want His protection, but we're all common, and common and separate can't mix. Otherwise separate wouldn't mean anything. So what we're going to do is make him a house to live on on the top of a hill in our city. In English we call this the temple, but in Hebrew the term is Beit Hamiktush, literally the separate house. Much of the second half of Exodus goes into excruciating detail on how you make a house like this. Then an equally excruciating amount of time is spent repeating it word for word as people carry out the instructions and build the thing. The next concept we're going to need is impurity. Christianity, again, has given this a rough makeover. I think we should use the proper Yiddish term, schmutz. Schmutz is a ritual muck that common things can get on them. It does not have valence. But you don't want to have schmutz on you for too long. You get schmutz on you by doing all those common things that have to do with human goops and goo and reproduction. Touching a dead body, having sex, being sick, giving birth, menstruating. None of this is bad. Some of it is good and commanded actually, be fruitful and multiply. But it's just not separate, because it's not what God does. It's very human and corporeal. Because schmutz is physical, if you touch something while you have schmutz on you, it gets schmutz on it too. Common things are absolutely fine being either schmutzy or clean. Now the big problem we want to avoid is if schmutz gets onto something separate, because it makes the separate thing common, and then it's a whole ordeal to make something separate again. You definitely cannot go into the
separate house if you have schmutz on you. But don't worry, it's not hard to get the schmutz off. You just have to have a bath and wait a while. Then you're good to go. Baths, known as mikvas, Are found everywhere in ancient Judea, and still play a central role in religious Jewish communities today. In the first century BC, there's a guy called John who takes the bathing metaphor a bit far. His successor, Jesus, goes even further and subverts the whole schmutz system. Out of the heart proceeds evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, thefts, blafs, blasphemies. These are the things that get schmutz on you. But to eat with unwashened hands does not get schmutz on you. Intentions are everything. But back to the Jews. Most of the rest of Leviticus and Numbers is, again, agonizing detail about how one accumulates schmutz and how to get schmutz off. Apart from human reproduction and death, the main category of thing that is distinctly not separate is sin. Also something God doesn't do. But when you commit a sin, you don't get schmutz on you. ⁓ no. The sinful schmutz travels like a guided missile from the ether into the separate house and gets it all schmutzy. The worse the sin, the further into the house it goes. Murder and idolatry really get in there and schmutz up the place. Now it's not the end of the world if this happens. You can clean the separate house, and this is the function of animal sacrifice. The sacrifice animal's blood cleans the schmutz off. In the academic parlance, they describe it as a ritual detergent. But really, you gotta make sure you own up to your sins and go and deschmutz the place. If the schmutz piles up, the separate house will just become a house. And God will leave. And then the Neo Assyrians will come in and kill you, or the Neo Babylonians, as the case ends up being. You must clean up after yourself and take responsibility for the good of the community. Atonement in Judaism has nothing to do with the individual. Unlike in Jainism, which is ultimately about liberating the individual soul, in Judaism it is about making sure God doesn't get grossed out in his house and leave. You can punish people or whatever to keep your society going, but what matters is cleaning schmutz from the separate house. Because you sinned and made a mess. Professor Joel Baden explains the point of all this. The bib the biblical writers outline a physics, whereby the outcomes of your actions and sins as an individual have an impact on the collective, which has kept people in line for thousands of years. This section is the yearly day. This all leaves a big question in both Judaism and Jainism. There is a particle of sin, karma or schmutz, and we know what causes sin and how to clean ourselves. But what w what do we do about the sins you don't know you're committing? The law of nature is a law of nature, even if you have nice intentions, and accumulating karma and schmutz. The Hebrew Bible has a fantastic solution to this problem. Once a year we're going to all get together and make a whole Day of Atonement and clean the whole place from top to bottom. Every person in the entire country, including the foreigners, come to Jerusalem and stand in the courtyard outside the separate house, and the big priests Get in the humblest apology garb he has, and goes right into the center and cleans it from the inside out with a lot of animal blood. He gets to the outside and then has to clean all the community gathered outside. So they get a goat, and in front of everyone, they put all the schmutz of all the people on the goat's head for the sins they know about and the sins that they don't know about. Then they lead it out of the city to chuck it off a cliff to the wilderness demon. That's how it's done. The separate house was destroyed by the Romans in seventy AD, but the Jews still do their Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, to get rid of sins they know about and the sins that they do not. It starts by bringing in the transgressors and sinners, and then they go through every sin, beating their chest once for each sin, always saying that they, as a collective, have sinned. The schmutz comes right off. Meanwhile, the Jains do samvatsari, the yearly day, where they get together and confess to all sins that they know and do not know about. and send each other Mikami Dukadam, may my wrongdoings be void. The karma is shed. I look at Buddhism and Christianity, with their many sects and strains and disagreements. I look at megachurches that might find it harder than a camel to pass through the eye of a needle. The surface area of interpretation has been a battleground over which centuries of blood has been spilled. But what if you could find a stable way for people to follow your ideas far more closely over thousands of years? Base your ethics on intentions, And you'll find people will play very loose with them. Maybe the flexibility of intention based ethics allows your vi your religion to morph and spread far. But base your ethics on outcomes and you might find people stick with them. I look at almost a hundred percent vegetarianism rates in the Jains, and almost a hundred percent circumcision rates in the Jews. Physical particles are powerful stuff. Alright, well thank very much. I enjoyed hearing you read that. Thanks, Ben. ⁓ what did you notice differently about reading it out loud relative to when you just had it written on It was as perfect this time as it was in my head. So yeah, yeah. No, one of the tips I've heard through doing in Caven was to read the pieces. Yeah. ⁓ as as I'm editing. So I've I've actually had some practice with it already. So ⁓ really? Well not not out loud, but I was like I'm familiar with it. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. But did anything about it stand out differently when you got to reread it out loud? Not particularly I do like saying schmutz though. Yeah, I think ⁓ I mean I really like the writing. The writing is a a combination of ⁓ somehow I feel like there's not a lot of like wasted
rambling words in it. It's like tight, and yet also gets to spend time saying very funny sentences like ⁓ what was Jesus saying that the ⁓ if you ⁓ it really gets the schmutz all up in there. Murder and idolatry really get in there and schmutz up the place was one of the lines I enjoyed. I had I had a lot of fun writing it. yeah, it's it's hard. There's it's hard to explain a lot of these more arcane topics, but it it's I found this was like a good lens to talk about it. Yeah. Why do you know so much about religion? I don't know. For some reason I I just became very interested in it ⁓ maybe starting around twenty eighteen. I mean, I myself am Jewish, but like through my upbringing I never like dug into like what a lot of this actually meant, but that kind of came later. I've watched a lot of ⁓ YouTube lecture series about ⁓ specifically like Old Testament, ⁓ history, how it came to be, ⁓ what we know about how it was written and what we think the people who wrote it ⁓ were thinking. ⁓ and then from there, yeah, it's ⁓ comparative religion becomes really interesting. Yeah, religions are always interesting design artifacts. They're a little ⁓ kind of like they're a little Darwini in some sense in which like no individual often like designed them and yet These are each of these pieces serve functions that you can sometimes find. Totally. how did you get involved interested in Jainism? ⁓ Jainism seems very cool. Like it's ⁓ it's a very serious religion. People take things seriously and they're obsessed with suffering. ⁓ and you know, I've been I've been vegan for a long time and so you know, I'm pretty obsessed with suffering in a certain sense. And it was interesting to see a whole religion ⁓ take this seriously and how how they deal with it. ⁓ I also have ⁓ but I got into it because a friend I was working with in in food science ⁓ was Jain and he invited me to his wedding in India and I took the opportunity to like go explore a whole bunch of pilgrimage sites and Jain sites and really learn about it and this this particular thing really struck me that there was this identical kind of ⁓ holiday. Like these are really, really different religions. I didn't want to say, Hey, there's like all these similarities, there's not, but they have this in common and so I was interested to see what's the commonality. Like how do you get there? Did you ⁓ have to do re s a lot of research when you were rewriting this one, or did you already have it in mind and you just got to sit down and this was mostly off the cuff. Yeah. Yeah. I I think I needed to you know, finer details of it. I did want to search and like even getting the name for the Jane Holiday, which I had forgotten, or ⁓ you know, learning the specific practices about how they got how they do it. But I didn't even know that they fasted. I just knew he was apologizing to me and then I went and looked it and was like, ⁓ they fasted well. This is like identical. Yeah, yeah. ⁓ did you get much feedback on this one here at Inkhaven or did this just come out ⁓ pretty whole? I did. ⁓ I got feedback from I think both Alexander Wales and Justice. Yep. And then ⁓ Clara, who edits Asterix Astros magazine, she's also really into this stuff. And so we we had a really ⁓ she she gave some input as well to help especially time the things on the ⁓ the Jewish side of things. ⁓ was the biggest change that when it happened to it. I was I was a little bit fast and loose because I describe both ⁓ ritual impurity and sin as this schmutz thing, which is kind of true in Judaism, but they are distinct things. Like there's this impurity you get on you from doing daily bodily things. And then there's ⁓ what whatever sin is, but it's described as like sin accrues in the temple. you get rid of them the same way. They are both described as like this dirty thing, but they are technically different and so I needed to like make that distinction a little bit. Yeah. ⁓ when you mention about how like Some sins get into the separate house and they really like get in deep. Yeah. ⁓ am I is that nonetheless you have to have someone has to have sinned and then they walk into it and they touch it. No. So if I murder you right now here, then then the schmutz will enter into the separate house. Yeah. But does everything that is separate become caked in sin or in dirt? ⁓ just just the separate house. Just the just the temple will get sin in it. And this is the main thing that the That the biblical writers are worried about because if you make it too dirty, God leaves. And is it because the the the the separate house is the interface between It is the literal dwelling place dwelling place of God. He's they're like, We want God to live here, we're gonna make him a house. It's got like a chair. When you when they talk about the Ark of the Covenant, it's actually like a a throne. It's a literal chair that he sits in all day. ⁓ and they have like the menorah is the symbol of ⁓ Judaism. Yes. And it's literally the light in the house. ⁓ All these symbols are literally Yeah. It is where he lives. It is his house. You want him to be living with you because then he protects you. But if you make it dirty, he's gonna he's gonna leave. He doesn't want to live in a dirty house. That makes sense. And it but it's just postulated that all the sin goes to this place as opposed to like do they I I assume they have other items that are separate in the world? There are other holy items? Yeah, ⁓ for instance peop ⁓ the Bible talk about like a people being separate, like ⁓ there's the idea of ⁓ potion people. Sorry, people people people are separate, like a it's a separate People in a sense. That is actually like later editions of writing get at it. That's like, ⁓ it's a you're a holy people, you're a separate people. ⁓ the original writing does seem like it's objects and things that are separate. ⁓ but definitely a lot of like why you would be kosher is to keep yourself separate. ⁓ you like this idea is also
like why the Jews are separate to the neighboring Canaanites. Even though they're like the same people, they worship Baal, they do these other things. ⁓ and to distinct and to make yourself an in-group, you just Do this kind of separation practice. Interesting. And the idea just carries throughout the whole religion. Is the word separate is that your translation or is the that's No, that's the literal meaning of the word. Yeah. The word holy is kind of it's a it's a bad word. Yeah. Interesting. Yeah. Interesting. ⁓ I think one thing I was confused by is ⁓ this yearly day. You're talking about how like they're in fact like undoing a lot of sin or they're pushing it they're like ⁓ cleaning a cleaning part. Cleaning. Yeah. ⁓ So I don't think of ⁓ ethics as physics. I think of I think of truth as physics and reasoning as physics is basically similar to law. You know, there are in fact like is so much information you can get and like the laws of physics determine these things. I think of ethics as kind of like engineering. I'm like trying to build a system that is good and like has good incentives and how does an individual like live in such a way that if it generalized, like the system would work and information would flow and ⁓ and so forth. ⁓ I don't ⁓ quite understand This doesn't in fact seem like it is fixing things, the blood. Yeah. ⁓ like I'm almost more I was more gonna like ⁓ there's a line where you mentioned that ⁓ the Jains do ⁓ am I pronouncing that? Samvetsari? Samvetsari? I don't actually know how to pronounce it either, so Great. Yeah. Well I'll We'll dub it over, yeah. they get together and confess to all the sins that they know and do not know about, and send each other and I'm not pronouncing that word, may my wrongdoings be void. and are they s confessing specific sins or are they They are confessing all sins. Okay. So I think ⁓ you'll gen yeah, you'll apologize to everyone to everyone for basically everything as like a catch all. Do you list a bunch of specific things and then a catch all or you just I think when they congregate together they they list them all? That's nice. Yeah. But then that's the same in in Judaism. You list all of them. That would make more sense to me than the washing ⁓ with the blood of a goat. Like in cath can I just say one more thing? In like Christianity, ⁓ like my mum was raised Catholic. Yeah. And she has to go and confess every week and she's like, Yeah, I was making up confessions at some point 'cause man, I didn't not have any things. But like naming specific like sins, I think I would get how that was like pushing back on ethics. I don't quite I I I believe you that they have these incredible hundred percent vegetarianism and hundred percent I mean circumcision, which I'm not whatever. Yeah, yeah. ⁓ but ⁓ the point is that you can make people stick to something. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. And I'm kind of unsure is it just like the the ⁓ The vibes of like we're taking this way more seriously. ⁓ you really need to be clean in the sin is passing through, or do you think it has some like direct causal mechanism? Well yeah, I think like when when you think about your system as like ⁓ you know, truth and reality is physics and then ethics or engineering, like what is the accountability there? Like what makes people be ethical? I don't think we have a very good way to do that, to keep people according to any kind of ethics over a a long period of time. I mean we have norms, we have laws, and th this is an attempt, but I guess like these religions present another way to do it, which is if you have a kind of metaphysics where ⁓ the accountability itself has a physical particle. Sin itself has a physical particle, then you then you can keep to it. ⁓ I see. Yeah. I think that's the way I tend to and this is not an interview with me, but the way I tend to think of it like I recall in ⁓ I think Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, he talks about like, you know, a group of people who will expect everyone to tell the truth and to punish that can like trust each other a bit better. Yeah. Than a group who can't. Yeah. I tend to view most of the world as like a pretty Malachian kind of chaos. Yeah. ⁓ and then if you want to do something good on purpose, it takes a certain level of like ethics and the people inside. So I'm not saying you can force everyone to be ethical, but ⁓ if you want things to happen on purpose, it's good to set up a a good incentive system and trust and a bunch of things. And I I think the interesting thing about it, ⁓ I mean this is also where like Judaism and Jainism divert. Jainism is very ⁓ individualize, right? You want to like liberate your own soul and you know, you get there's this reward system within it where it's like if you be ethical and you're good, then you get this like eternal bliss of motion. ⁓ in Judaism it's like a bit different. It's just like a ⁓ community accountability system. there's like I I didn't get into all the details of animal sacrifice. It's not only during the yearly day that they do the animal sacrifice. Most of the Bible if you read like Leviticus and ⁓ Numbers, it's like when you do this specific sin This is the exact sacrifice that you must do. This amount of grain and this animal at this time you need to bring to and and sacrifice it. And it is your duty to do this, because if you don't do it then then God's gonna leave. I can see that. I can see that. ⁓ like weighing specific sins and having you at the time when you make them take them. Yeah. ⁓ take those actions. Yeah. Knowing immediately, ⁓ gosh, I better this is how bad it is. Yeah. And I better do that, otherwise this is the problem. And I And it's not just for me, it's for for everyone. The house is dirty. The house is dirty. ⁓ his house. Yeah. And we're all gonna get together and do some of the cleaning. Yeah. And I know that if I didn't clean for this one, it's all for nothing. Yeah. I can see I can see how that So the the ritual I think
is more about creating the the reality of the metaphysics than it is about directly like fixing everything. In my Yeah, well but in in their in their metaphysics. They are fixing everything. Yes. ⁓ in my yeah. Yeah, yeah. I see. That makes more sense. Thanks. Yeah, and to be clear, like when they do the this yearly day, mostly it's an accounting for the things that the unknown unknowns. Yes. Yeah. It's you're meant to do these other things throughout the year, like the Jaints throughout the year will, you know, do their other fasting and prayer. Yeah, you just you just have to with a lot of these religious things separate out the like ⁓ stated justification and then the actual like functional like Vaniver who's ⁓ been around in Caven little bit last time, he was around a lot more. has a great less wrong post called Steel Manning Divination. ⁓ and he talks about I think before certain battles and wars they would use certain divination mechanisms, methods to divine which side they should go ⁓ to attack from. And he ultimately explains that one of the one of the common ones was just random, so you couldn't be predicted. And that was in fact like very functionally useful. Well this is what gets to they don't give that story when they tell you. No, this gets to the Darwinian element of it. It's like why do certain things survive? Maybe there's some like useful thing in it. Like maybe you can tell some story which is like Well, Judaism has this thing to bind community together and that's what led it like that's what let it continues over thousands of years. Yeah. ⁓ there's maybe a story like that or th th the story I'm trying to tell is like if you have this conception then you can bind of physical particles, you can bind people over a really long period of time to whatever your ethical system is. Not to make an orange claim about what those ethics are. I mean, for instance, I don't think animal sacrifice is a particularly good thing. But ⁓ fortunately I mean the animal welfare. Yeah, unfortunately this is my yeah, yeah. Sorry, God. Yeah, no. Yeah. ⁓ that makes sense. Yeah. ⁓ which day did you publish this one in Link Haven? This was I think the end of the first week. Uh-huh. Yeah. Uhhuh. ⁓ Was this when you'd come in being like, probably I'll get this one out or did it come to you on the day? No, it came to me on the day. This was definitely a shower thought where I like, Hey, I have been thinking about this one for a while, I'm gonna I'm gonna get it. It was ⁓ nice. Nice. how how many of them are daily posts, most of them? ⁓ that I come with up with on the day. Yeah. ⁓ all but like two or three. I had I had like the only other ones are ones that I've like drafted. Yeah. This one did this one come out easily? Very easily. Nice. Yeah. What's the easiest piece that came out of you during Incaven? This might be up there. Like this was a real joy to write. to I'll have to think through a few of them but this is yeah. What was the hardest? Was there a one
that took a lot of ⁓ screening? There's another one I'm trying to write at the moment, which is very long, which was my only other ⁓ religious piece, which is ⁓ about the origins of the alphabet and of prose and how that influenced the creation of the Hebrew Bible. Crazy. That sounds good. Yeah. So but the problem is this is gonna be really long because I'm trying to explain how the alphabet came into came into being, why the alphabet was like different from the rest of writing that has come before and then ⁓ yeah why my argument for like why this ⁓ created prose which are allowed for all these things. Yeah. I'm looking forward to reading that one. And I think there's a lot of a lot yeah when you read a lot of the Bible it's really, really arcane and you need to come up with like some sort of fiction and narrative to make it accessible like Schmutz. Yeah. Yeah. ⁓ why did you ⁓ why did you come to Encaven? I think I really enjoy writing but haven't done enough of it and ⁓ I like putting myself in containers to do things. That just seems like a great idea. And I had seen I had seen the last Inkhaven, I'd talked with some people who did it and they thought it was fantastic and ⁓ it has really lived up to it. I I really love it. You've you made a cr a great thing here. Wonderful. Yeah, you were in the ⁓ the edition of the ⁓ the loop last time. ⁓ with also more bathroom reviews. Yes. ⁓ I ⁓ Viz husband did a bunch of bathroom reviews this time. ⁓ great. Yeah, yeah. No, last time I was explaining why I think the the the squatty potty, which is ubiquitous in ration in in the bathrooms in Lighthaven, at least, ⁓ I think it's a bunch of missing. I just want to clear. I didn't advocate for that. No one on the team advocated that. A guest bought all of them and was like, You need them. All I could say is I thought this was a rationalist. Space. I presented an argument against the things and I came back six months later and there's still squatty potties everywhere. Yeah, yeah, we'll have to see. did you have any particular writing goals other than just to do more? I had a I guess a few longer pieces that I wanted to write, which I've been unsex unsuccessful in so far, apart from this large one I'm thinking about. ⁓ but it was mostly yeah, just force myself to write every day and that's that's that's that's worked. ⁓ I think writing is very, very slow and laborable. Borious for me. ⁓ especially when it comes to professional writing. I I I I run a blog called ⁓ a website and blog called Vilf.org, which is basically vegan shit posting and a vegan guide to San Francisco. And whenever I write that, it's just so easy. I'm just having fun. I just like put it out there. And I I really have trouble doing that in the professional context, which is like, ⁓ I'm specifically trying to do this thing and it's slow and I want to word it word it correctly. and Yeah, this has been just so incredibly helpful for going, Hey, you know what? The professional thing should be very fun to write about as well. Yeah, yeah, yeah. ⁓ and I've been leaning into that more. I think the slime molds are really great at ⁓ finding the intersection between fun and things I actually want to write that are interesting. Yes. Because they're just having fun all the time. Yeah. And they're always getting writing out of it. Yes. ⁓ they're kind of saying like, ⁓ let's ⁓ let's run a little experiment. Let's do this. Yeah. Let's have fun while we're doing it. They urge me to write some some good pieces. My my most popular piece is one called Is Salt Salty. That one's great. Where basically we gave people salt and a bunch of other like sodium bicarbonate and ⁓ potassium chloride just to see which ion is salty or like how how are we detecting saltiness? ⁓ we just that there was like a bimodal distribution of whether people considered it salty. Sodium bicarbonate. So like baking soda. People either think it's not very salty or extremely salty. Yeah. Which was quite surprising. And do you think that's ⁓ people categorizing it differently or people having genuinely different ⁓ taste buds? Or brains. It is like this is the hard thing about taste, right? ⁓ it's it's so hard to measure because it's this like you've got your actual sensory information coming in, then you've got the cognition that layers over this to figure out what the hell is going on, and we know so little about it, so it's it's it's kind of impossible to make a judgment about that. ⁓ but I think people are actually perceiving things differently. Differently they said it Is it salty? Is this like salt? Yes. Some people said yes, some people said no. Yeah. Yeah. That doesn't That's interesting. Yeah, that was great. which of your pieces of writing here are you ⁓ or what what in your writing? It doesn't have to be a single piece, but what in your writing are you proudest of that that you've done while you're at Inkhaven? ⁓ definitely this one, which is why I wanted to read it. I really enjoyed writing it. It came out very fluidly. I was very proud of it. I think, yeah. The best is it like at the end of it was I was I proud of this work. Yeah, which hasn't happened every day. ⁓ I think that's very hard to happen it every day. Like a lot of times I'm I'm just like, Well, I I gotta get this one out today. ⁓ but this one I went in with a lot of intention and I'm very happy with it. Yeah. ⁓ has ⁓ daily writing done anything to your mind? Yes. Like I I it is so wonderful to just have new ideas in my head every single day. I think I was feeling a like a little bit stagnant before I started this program and I w I was really looking forward to it and it's just been exactly like that. It's just good. Shove something new in there and it's just I I feel very energized. You've been living in SF during this program. ⁓ have you also been working a lot during this program? ⁓ no. I've been working full time and commuting from SF. I do I don't know how you manage it. It is still worth doing in Caven if if
that is the case for you, but I would highly recommend living here at least. Yeah, yeah. ⁓ I'm guessing it's been stressful. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. How many days have you been here of the month? Like fifty percent? Well I try to. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Neat. It's mostly like I'm not here at nighttime when there's that serendipitous people hanging out and Winner's lounge winners lounge and all of that, which I've missed out on, which means I don't get to make as many friends as everyone else. ⁓ that yeah. You came to Big Dega Bay though. I did. I was like, well I gotta I gotta do that at least and that's gonna be a good good way to get some get some botting in. Yeah, hopefully. ⁓ it was. It was great. Good. What's ⁓ the best piece of either feedback or writing advice you got w during Encaden? The feedback from Justice was really good in general. ⁓ kind of just like the the have fun with it. I th I think there was one piece it was just like yeah it needs to in ⁓ when you read this it was like it I'm not having fun when I'm reading this and that's because you weren't having fun when you yeah and you're writing it. ⁓ and I feel like I have I I can have a voice where I'm having fun with something and that's the thing to lean into and yeah that's been the the big big outcome I'd guess. ⁓ I somehow want to hedge this as ⁓ there's no incense in which you were supposed to. But did you go for the ⁓ the the the pin with the challenge with all the different things? Nice. Well By the time you released that I'd already done six out of the seven of them. And I ⁓ the only one I hadn't done was fiction, which I was very afraid of doing. And then I sat down with my girlfriend and we did some flash fiction and I ended up being incredibly well, I I then ran with the f flash fiction piece I made and and made it better. ⁓ I was very happy with how it turned out. ⁓ I think it's great. Yeah. Is that published yet? Yeah. Which what's it called? It's called The Dance Floors of Burn. It's about ⁓ It's about the patent office in in Bern, Switzerland, where where where where Einstein, you know, was a pa patent officer, and it's about how ⁓ everyone wanted a job there so that they could learn from the patents, from the engineering and physics, so they could get better dance moves out of it. And this was the powerhouse behind the the growth of German engineering was this this phenomenon. That's fictional. Yes. They were the story is that they were reading the patents to get dance moves. Yes. Yeah. Sure. I I I got I got no love for this post, but I think it's my second favorite piece. Yeah, yeah. That's funny. Yeah. I almost read that to you. That would be very confusing. Yeah. ⁓ What about Inkaven surprised you? What did you not expect? Hmm. I think it was largely how I expected. I think a lot of it's because I I can't interface like that much with the people 'cause I'm not hanging out that much. But ⁓ also you'd actually been ⁓ you'd visiting Haven once, you a sense of I had seen
it before. That makes sense. ⁓ also I live in San Francisco. I've been to Lighthaven. I kind of know a lot of the at least from the outside I and I understand a bit of what's going on. ⁓ I think the vibe here is a bit different than many other events at Lighthaven. Yeah. ⁓ but I mean it's just so much fun. I mean that's the great thing about like there's all these people here. They've all got a very I think last Lighthaven ⁓ last Ink Haven there was a lot more in the AI safety space than this time. And so there's been a large variety of what people write about and it's been really I wish I had more time to read everything that people were writing. But I I enjoy meeting all these people and it's it's you know, that's that's the interesting thing. Like you you talk with people and then there's this completely different experience you get from like reading their posts. Yes. And you get really get into their brain, you're like, Whoa, that's yeah. Yeah, that's my content experience with bloggers. I couldn't I often could not tell you that they were a great thinker in that way just from chatting with them. Exactly. ⁓ although some of them are very interesting in other ways when you chat with them. ⁓ I'm curious, ⁓ what what of the writing here has ⁓ been to your taste. Is there anything you've ⁓ enjoyed reading? It's been it's kind of been all over the place, ⁓ ch which has been fun. I like Alec Thompson's things a lot. He's a very ⁓ entertaining and good writer and about like kind of topics that I wouldn't have normally been interested in, like ⁓ you know, ⁓ what Nazis thought about Roman law. ⁓ But he makes it very accessible. ⁓ were there any particular ⁓ is there any particular like inkhaven shaped memory that you'll have leaving here? Anything that you can only get when you trap fifty-five writers in a wall surveilles compound for a month? Well, I wrote a mean contra post against someone and then I felt very bad about it. So that's you know, always negative memories stick around. Yeah. That's a place to experiment with that. Exactly. I don't know. It's just I a a lot of it's just like the beautiful walk I get to do every day around Berkeley. And just like this very refreshing coming to somewhere completely different. Just kind of as a haze, this beautiful sunny Berkeley ⁓ haze where I got to just Did you know many of the people coming into any of the people here coming into it? ⁓ I don't think I know knew any of them. Neat. I knew some of the advisors. Yeah, yeah. But that's about it. ⁓ Like the slime old time old and Clara and yeah. You can go keep in touch with any of the people afterwards. ⁓ yeah, for sure. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I'm I I try to bully as many as possible to move to the Bay Area. That's yeah. That might happen. That might happen. ⁓ I fe ⁓ my my girlfriend's mother also helped edit this piece and I would be completely remiss if I didn't mention that. Sure. Yeah, yeah. Great. ⁓ well ⁓ thanks so much for ⁓ sending me. Thank so much, Ben. This is this is so much fun. I'm so glad you're doing this. All right, well ⁓ farewell for now. Before we wrap up, I'd just like to thank our sponsor for this episode, WordPress.com. As a teenager, many of the blogs I grew up reading were built using WordPress, such as Slate Star Codex, Don't Worry About the Vars, and Steffel Optimized. The co-founder of WordPress, Matt Mullenweg, went on to build WordPress.com, a hosting service that supports bloggers. It provides an interface that allows you to design your website and to use the near-infinite family of libraries and plugins that have been built for WordPress. If you're someone who cares to be able to design your own blog for your ideas, for your writing, and for your own aesthetic, then by far one of the best options on the internet today is WordPress.com.