النص 🔗
1
00:00:00,600 --> 00:00:08,160
Hello and welcome back to Elise Explains IP, the podcast where we take intellectual property and break it down so that you can use it.
2
00:00:08,640 --> 00:00:14,340
Today I wanna talk about something that sounds simple, but in trade mark law is anything but simple.
3
00:00:14,940 --> 00:00:21,780
Can a company own a colour? Because if it is possible, Cadbury would probably like to own the colour purple.
4
00:00:22,380 --> 00:00:29,310
If you've ever seen a block of Cadbury chocolate, you'll probably picture that distinctive deep purple, almost royal purple packaging.
5
00:00:29,955 --> 00:00:37,335
Capri has spent decades trying to protect that colour around the world, including here in Australia and in the UK.
6
00:00:37,965 --> 00:00:44,355
And they've had some mixed success: in some places they've won, in others they've lost.
7
00:00:44,865 --> 00:00:51,375
And the legal battles tell us something at really important about trade marks that many business owners misunderstand.
8
00:00:52,065 --> 00:00:58,230
Just because trade marks aren't about words and logos, sometimes businesses try to protect.
9
00:00:58,890 --> 00:01:03,280
Other things like colours, shapes, packaging, even scents.
10
00:01:03,300 --> 00:01:08,430
Remember we've had that chat, but the law treats these very differently.
11
00:01:08,850 --> 00:01:24,360
So today we're going to unpack why Cadbury wanted to protect purple, what happened in the famous Cadbury and Darrel Lea dispute in Australia, and why Cadbury lost and then sort of regained a major attempt to register the colour purple in the UK.
12
00:01:25,110 --> 00:01:29,760
And the biggest lessons that you can learn about why colour trade marks are so difficult to secure.
13
00:01:30,330 --> 00:01:37,450
So why did Cadbury want to own purple? I mean, Cadbury has been using purple packaging for chocolate since the early 19 00s.
14
00:01:38,430 --> 00:01:43,950
The particular shade that they use is often referred to as Pantone 2 6 8 5 C.
15
00:01:44,520 --> 00:01:53,730
Over time, the company has invested heavily in marketing that colour so much so that many consumers now associate purple packaging with Cadbury chocolate.
16
00:01:54,765 --> 00:01:58,185
From a brand strategy perspective, that's incredibly valuable.
17
00:01:58,725 --> 00:02:04,605
If consumers instantly recognise your product based on colour alone, you've achieved something really powerful.
18
00:02:05,055 --> 00:02:09,615
Think about Tiffany Blue, Hermes Orange, Barbie pink.
19
00:02:10,095 --> 00:02:15,135
These colours trigger immediate brand recognition and associated feelings.
20
00:02:15,525 --> 00:02:17,565
So Cadbury's thinking was straightforward.
21
00:02:18,105 --> 00:02:25,195
If consumers associate purple with Cadbury chocolate, then maybe Cadbury should be able to register that colour as a trade mark.
22
00:02:26,205 --> 00:02:32,955
And that's where things can become legally complicated because colours are fundamentally limited resources.
23
00:02:33,315 --> 00:02:37,505
There's only so many different combinations of Pantone and things.
24
00:02:37,775 --> 00:02:46,415
If a colour company wants a colour, competitors may be prevented from using that in something that might otherwise be perf perfectly legitimate.
25
00:02:46,985 --> 00:02:49,955
And trade mark law tries to balance those competing interests.
26
00:02:50,930 --> 00:02:57,499.99999762
One of the most well-known Australian cases involving Cadbury's Purple Packaging was the Dispute with Darrell Lea.
27
00:02:58,319.99999046 --> 00:03:04,310
Darrell Lea is an Australian brand that began selling chocolate in a lighter shade of purple packaging.
28
00:03:04,880 --> 00:03:09,590
Cadbury argued that this created confusion and took advantage of Cadbury's reputation.
29
00:03:10,130 --> 00:03:15,680
Essentially, Cadbury's position was consumers see purple chocolate packaging and think Cadbury.
30
00:03:16,300 --> 00:03:17,690
Darrell Lea pushed back.
31
00:03:18,170 --> 00:03:20,520
They argued that purple is just a colour.
32
00:03:20,990 --> 00:03:25,250
It shouldn't be able to be monopolised by any one chocolate manufacturer.
33
00:03:26,150 --> 00:03:29,750
The dispute went through the courts and ultimately reached the Full Federal Court.
34
00:03:30,230 --> 00:03:32,840
The outcome was not what Cadbury had hoped.
35
00:03:33,290 --> 00:03:39,920
The court found that Cadbury did not have exclusive rights to the colour purple for chocolate packaging.
36
00:03:40,730 --> 00:03:43,460
A few key points influence that outcome.
37
00:03:44,300 --> 00:03:57,140
The first one was that purple was not used exclusively by Cadbury Evidence showed that other chocolate brands had used purple packaging over time, and that weakened the argument that purple was uniquely signalled Cadbury.
38
00:03:57,800 --> 00:04:00,010
Two: packaging matters, not just colour.
39
00:04:00,620 --> 00:04:06,890
Consumers are also influenced by the brand names, logos, product shapes, and other design elements in the packaging.
40
00:04:07,340 --> 00:04:12,290
So purple alone was not doing all the work in that recognition space.
41
00:04:12,830 --> 00:04:16,760
Three: trade mark law is cautious about colour monopolies.
42
00:04:17,090 --> 00:04:23,600
The courts are reluctant to give one business control over something as basic as a colour unless the evidence is very strong.
43
00:04:24,140 --> 00:04:38,180
So Darrell Lea was allowed to continue using their colour purple in their packaging, and Cadbury did not gain any exclusive rights over the colour as a whole, maybe for their specific Pantone brand, but not for the colour purple.
44
00:04:38,690 --> 00:04:41,045
Now let's look at Cadbury's attempts in the United Kingdom.
45
00:04:42,080 --> 00:04:45,620
Cadry also tried to secure colour trade mark protection in the UK.
46
00:04:46,190 --> 00:04:51,230
This attempt has become one of
Load full transcript
the most famous and ongoing colour trade mark cases in Europe.
47
00:04:52,330 --> 00:05:01,220
Cadbury implied to register Pantone 2 6 85 C for chocolate products, but the way the application described the colour became a major issue.
48
00:05:02,390 --> 00:05:09,880
Their first application said that the colour purple would be used on packaging "applied to the whole visible surface or being the predominant colour."
49
00:05:10,445 --> 00:05:18,665
And at first glance, that sounds reasonable, but competitors including Nestle challenged that registration and eventually the courts agreed with them.
50
00:05:19,115 --> 00:05:22,745
The key issue in that application was the lack of precision.
51
00:05:23,275 --> 00:05:26,555
Trade marks need to clearly define what is being protected.
52
00:05:27,005 --> 00:05:29,735
The courts said that Cadbury's wording was too vague.
53
00:05:30,185 --> 00:05:42,830
What does predominant colour actually mean? Was it 60% purple, 80% purple, purple, mixed with other colours? Because the scope was unclear, the trade mark failed.
54
00:05:43,160 --> 00:05:53,420
So despite Cadbury's long use of purple, the court, UK courts rejected that application and they made a more successful for few further applications that were later accepted.
55
00:05:54,050 --> 00:05:59,270
So why are colour trade mark so difficult? The Cadbury case illustrates a broader principle.
56
00:05:59,720 --> 00:06:06,140
Registering a colour as a trade mark is much harder than registering a word or a logo, and there are several reasons for that.
57
00:06:06,770 --> 00:06:08,390
Number one: colours are limited.
58
00:06:08,870 --> 00:06:12,950
Unlike words, there are only so many usable colours in an industry.
59
00:06:13,430 --> 00:06:21,050
If a company monopolises a colour, competitors can be unfairly restricted, and courts are very cautious about granting those rights.
60
00:06:21,830 --> 00:06:26,420
Two: as we sort of already discussed, consumers rarely rely on the colour alone.
61
00:06:26,870 --> 00:06:35,750
Most purchasing decisions rely on a combination of brand signals, including the logos, the names, the packaging design, typography, the layout.
62
00:06:36,140 --> 00:06:40,580
So that proving that the colour alone identifies a brand is very difficult.
63
00:06:41,420 --> 00:06:44,750
Three: evidence requirements are very, very high.
64
00:06:45,110 --> 00:06:55,280
To register a colour trade mark, businesses typically need to show strong evidence that consumers associate that colour exclusively with their brand.
65
00:06:55,790 --> 00:07:04,010
This might include long-term use, advertising campaigns, focusing on the colour consumer surveys, sales, data, and marketing investment.
66
00:07:04,505 --> 00:07:09,335
And all of this is expensive to produce, and even then success is not guaranteed.
67
00:07:10,025 --> 00:07:13,355
And four, the application must be extremely precise.
68
00:07:13,805 --> 00:07:16,565
The Cadbury UK case shows that another trap.
69
00:07:17,015 --> 00:07:23,555
When registering non-traditional marks like colours or shapes or scents, that a description must be very precise.
70
00:07:23,875 --> 00:07:28,745
trade marks need to clearly define the legal boundaries of the right that you are protecting.
71
00:07:29,165 --> 00:07:31,835
If the scope is vague, the application can fail.
72
00:07:32,960 --> 00:07:36,110
The Cadbury story is a great reminder of something important.
73
00:07:36,560 --> 00:07:43,730
Just because a brand has used something for a long time does not necessarily mean that they own it, own it legally.
74
00:07:44,210 --> 00:07:50,270
Businesses often assume they automatically own colours or packaging styles, or product shapes or design concepts.
75
00:07:50,780 --> 00:08:02,165
But trade mark law and intellectual property law more broadly requires clear evidence that these elements are unique to the business and in trade marks, function as source identifiers.
76
00:08:02,705 --> 00:08:10,415
It means the consumers must recognize them as pointing to a particular business, and that's a high bar if you are building a brand.
77
00:08:10,505 --> 00:08:13,625
There are a few practical lessons from the Cadbury Purple Saga.
78
00:08:14,135 --> 00:08:16,725
One: focus on strong core trade marks.
79
00:08:17,015 --> 00:08:21,275
Your brand name and logo will almost always be easier to protect than colours or packaging.
80
00:08:21,725 --> 00:08:24,575
Make sure those are properly registered first.
81
00:08:24,965 --> 00:08:28,815
Two: use colour strategically, but don't rely on it alone.
82
00:08:29,395 --> 00:08:36,110
Colours can strengthen brand recognition, but they work best in combination with your other distinctive elements.
83
00:08:36,740 --> 00:08:38,930
Three: consistency matters.
84
00:08:39,110 --> 00:08:43,640
If you want a colour to become associated with your brand, you need consistent use over time.
85
00:08:44,030 --> 00:08:47,810
That means consistent packaging, marketing and brand presentation.
86
00:08:48,440 --> 00:08:50,840
Four: evidence builds over time.
87
00:08:51,290 --> 00:08:55,250
The longer you use something consistently, the easier it may become.
88
00:08:55,250 --> 00:08:58,165
To argue, the consumers associate that with your brand.
89
00:08:59,060 --> 00:09:03,260
And that evidence takes years, sometimes decades, to develop.
90
00:09:03,770 --> 00:09:11,810
Cadbury's long battle over purple shows how complex trade mark law can be when it moves beyond simple words and logos.
91
00:09:12,380 --> 00:09:25,820
Colours can be a powerful branding tool, but turning them into enforceable trade marks is difficult, expensive, and uncertain, and even global brands with decades of marketing behind them don't always succeed.
92
00:09:28,985 --> 00:09:38,975
Which is a useful reminder that brand protection is just as much about strategy as it is about law, because the strongest brands don't rely on just one signal.
93
00:09:39,275 --> 00:09:45,175
It's a multi-pronged attack to build recognition through the combination of elements working together.
94
00:09:46,795 --> 00:09:58,195
If you've enjoyed this episode of Elise Explains IP, make sure you follow the podcast so you don't miss future episodes, where we unpack intellectual property issues affecting businesses.
95
00:10:00,485 --> 00:10:03,995
Thanks for spending time with me on Elise Explains IP.
96
00:10:04,505 --> 00:10:12,395
If you picked up something useful, hit follow, subscribe, leave us a review or send it to a founder friend who could use this information.
97
00:10:12,845 --> 00:10:16,265
And remember, this is general information, not legal advice.
98
00:10:16,325 --> 00:10:23,375
If you do want help with your IP, you can book a strategy call with me at any time via my website, the links into description.
99
00:10:23,765 --> 00:10:26,345
So until next time, own your own ideas.