النص 🔗
Jackie Slaght: Welcome to Beyond Tech, where innovation meets insight. I'm your host, Jackie Slatt, and today I'm joined by a special guest co-host, Director of Business Development, Jeff Ballard. And joining Jeff is Chris Virtue. Chris is a principal engineer at eTech Group. This episode was actually inspired by Jeff, so it only felt right to bring him back into the co-host chair for this conversation. Today we're taking it back to the basics. We're going to plant modernization 101. For so many plant managers, modernization feels overwhelming. You look around the facility and you know upgrades are overdue, but where do you even start? Today we're breaking it all down. We'll walk through how to assess your facility realistically, how to set priorities that make sense, and how to build a practical phase modernization plan that minimizes disruption and maximizes impact. So with that, let's dive in. Thanks, Jeff and Chris, for joining me today.
Jeff B: Thank you, Jackie.
Chris Virtue: Thank you as well.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. let's just begin the conversation. When a plant manager is looking around and saying, My facility needs needs some updates, what sign should they be looking for?
Jeff B: Yeah, so you're you're gonna start to experience certain characteristics from legacy hardware like latency in the system, right? So updates on HMIs, maybe scans on the PLC, older PLCs that have that have cards that are difficult to get or older protocols, whether it's a serial protocol, whether it's non-ethernet protocol. I mean these are all kind of basic signs. older drives that may not talk Ethernet. non-managed switches on your network these are just kind of a few details that that you would see when you're walking the plant floor at certain plants and and those are those are kind of indicators that that hey we need to start addressing this and the question is is how do you address it and do you have to address it all at once or can you do a phased migration and not eat the elephant all at once Yeah.
Chris Virtue: I would say you know maintenance is usually a key is a key player in the control systems in a in a plant. and I would, you know, start up conversations with them about, you know, parts availability, what they feel are critical failure points or things that are failing that are costing them time and money. that sort of thing.
Jeff B: Yeah, critical spares is a is a really good place to start. That gives you an idea of, hey, if I can't get this HMI or this drive or this card, that's gonna that's gonna cause downtime, which is the nightmare of anybody at a facility.
Chris Virtue: Yeah. And I think being a plant manager, you're you're not gonna know all the technical details. So, you know, hearing complaints or you know, topics come up about parts availability or legacy systems, those are definitely, you know, key indicators that there's some opportunities there.
Jackie Slaght: So what is the biggest risk in delaying a modernization effort?
Jeff B: Well, okay, so in the news today or very, very recently, there's been several water, wastewater, and plants that have been attacked from a cybersecurity standpoint. That's first and for foremost, right? So if you have older protocols, maybe you have things on your network that aren't able to be locked down. you have an open system or a non-ethernet system that has cybersecurity in it, that's probably number one. Number two is downtime, right? So anytime You have older Older parts that you may have to get from third-party vendors, or you don't have it on the shelf, or you just plain have to fix it, that's that's probably gonna cost you in downtime and production. So you you may be able to upgrade and also increase production and safety at the same time. I'm gonna give Chris a minute to kind of jump in here as well.
Chris Virtue: Yeah, those were the two points that I would, you know, point out for the biggest risks and delaying. you know, the risks and the reason for modernizing are kind of the same, right? You're trying to avoid these risks, these security risks and downtime or you know, there's there's a laundry list of of things that you run into when you have legacy equipment, but security is w number one. And number two is the extended downtime. So just like Jeff was mentioning about you know having longer downtimes or having long downtimes, you may still have some downtime events, but with a legacy system, your those downtime situations are gonna be much longer and sometimes just astronomical in as far as as far as cost implications. Because these parts aren't available, they're not supported, people don't understand them. So I I think in yeah, in my terms, I would say the extended downtime are extended downtime and security are the biggest. but following up with those is something that the risks show is that you don't get a lot of the information that your newer devices provide. And so people that are wanting to grow their business, grow their plant floor, grow metrics, that sort of thing, it's going to be difficult implementing those strategies on legacy equipment.
Jeff B: Yeah, gr great point. So there's there's actually PLCs and HMIs and drives and network switches that can actually automatically recognize that a new node is on the network and actually update the firmware, update the software, let you know. You can also do a lot of what's called preventive maintenance with the newer hardware nowadays. You can do data collection, you can do you can do reports, you can do all kinds of different things now that you can collect data from the newer the newer hardware. So You know, that I I I think Chris brought up a really, really good point where once you have migrated, there's just a lot more tools that we could help you set
Chris Virtue: Well.
Jeff B: up with dashboards and reports and things like that.
Jackie Slaght: So before we get like too far far into this, what can can you give a very brief explanation of what modernization is versus
Load full transcript
what it is not?
Chris Virtue: I would say anything that is considered a legacy in its availability or offering, such as lacking in support or functionality. So something that lacks in support services in, you know, engineers knowing the product and functionality, you know, being capable of upgrades and future plans.
Jeff B: Yeah, I'll be a little bit more specific, Jackie, because, you know, probably some of some of the folks that are watching this know these, but anything that's, you know, an old series Power Flex 4, Power Flex 40 drives from Rockwell, 1336 drives that are still out there, plc 5s, Slick 500s, Slick 503s, 502s, 504s, even 505s, you know, Siemens S5s PLCs that are still out there. Schneider Electric Quantums. I mean, there's there's a lot of really old equipment that is still out there. Out there. And and I kind of want to add this, and we're not talking about, you know, when you do an assessment to kind of have a systems integrator like us to come in and aid, we're not talking about thousands of dollars. We're talking about, you know, a couple hours, we come in, guys like Chris or myself, or and we do an assessment. We take kind of inventory of what is there, or we would sit down and talk with the managers there, the maintenance managers, maybe. Be a plant engineer and find out what their concern is, and then go do an inventory, and then you know, kind of create a roadmap of what the phased migration would look like, you know, from an old Slick 500
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Jeff B: or an old compact logics to a newer compact logics. What would that entail? How long would it take? How much would it be? But then also the benefits from it. So, you know, that's kind of the approach. Approach and those are the kind of things that people should look for specifically.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, Is there anything else that plant managers should do to kind of begin as their first step?
Jeff B: Yeah, I I think reaching out to either a systems integrator or a third party, and or or sitting down and doing simple things like databasing their programs, right? So making sure that they have backup programs on the in their servers, right? So if they lose a PLC program, they have that as backup. That's that's a real easy thing, right? Checking their versions of their SCADA, of their PLCs, things like that. So a lot of times, SCADA upgrades have patches which add cybersecurity into. them if you're on a much older version that's another kind of vulnerability that's a that's another legacy part of your system as well so it's not just hardware it can also be software and so just kind of taking an inventory of all that stuff and then approaching like somebody like us you know a systems integrator e tech and sitting down and talking about okay what's our path forward what What is this gonna take? What does your staff look like? You know, what other projects have you guys done similar to this?
Chris Virtue: Yeah, do an inventory.
Jackie Slaght: so when when a facility is looking at where where to begin, what would you say are the top two to three priorities with the fastest ROI? And are there general ones or is it kind of plant specific, I guess I should add?
Jeff B: Go ahead, Chris.
Chris Virtue: Biggest return on investment would be taking care of those things that are costing you money. and most likely that's going to be either in support or service fees. so if you're a facility that relies on a systems integrator or a s a support system external, you know, look at those look at those repair bills and and look at the low hanging fruit, the things that you know, they're saying you know, in their notes, you know, a legacy system or upgrade opportunities. Those systems that are you know costing you service calls and that sort of thing are ones that I would address first. The second would just be if if you don't have an external systems service I would look internally at what is costing you downtime in general throughout the plan. what systems. So it may be, you know, a a manufacturing cell or a floor or something like that. But I would start looking at those things that are costing you the most in downtime.
Jeff B: Yeah, I think also something else that you can look at is training. you know, having your staff be familiar with the drives that need to be upgraded. how to do it, how to re how to load a project, right? The some basic things like that, right? But but more most importantly, I think Chris had had touched on before is really take an inventory of critical spares, right? What is gonna cost you downtime? Do you have another HMI that has a program loaded that you can put in, install right away, or an analog card? these things that are the critical spares and do you have them on hand and and and and be able to kind of avoid downtime?
Jackie Slaght: If if a facility is trying to modernize on their own without the help of a kind of third party or a system integrator, what kind of early mistakes do you or have you seen them make along the way?
Jeff B: I I think that one of the challenges with facilities is a lot of times they're kind of spread thin. Right. And they also have the challenge of having people who have a lot of experience that are now retiring and may not be to be able to bring in new talent to kind of replace that talent. So you know, sometimes doing it within a facility really stretches the resources, the engineering resources of that, and they may not be able to dedicate all the time that they need to the The project where the project may drag on for a couple months because they may not have the staff to support it. I'd
Chris Virtue: Yeah.
Jeff B: say that I I have seen that happen. and then maybe somebody leaves or they lose a program or you know, something happens over those couple months, and then the project doesn't get done, and and then the the the the project sort of or the the the issue still exists. Right, it persists. Whereas
Chris Virtue: Mm-hmm.
Jeff B: rather if they sit
sit down with a systems integrator and they plan out a phase migration, they know what they're gonna get, they know the budget, and they know that it's gonna get done and not cause downtime and also not extend into months for the project. So, you know, kind of legacy people leaving, right? We call it brain drain, not new engineers, and then you Using a third party, you know that you're gonna have a dedicated team for that project.
Jackie Slaght: That's a really good point.
Chris Virtue: Yeah. Yeah, I would say that, you know, we've seen a lot of maybe not a lot of customers. Some customers attempt upgrades and migrations themselves, with with success. but you know, where those fall short, I think, are in the expertise of those migrations, because a lot of it is not straightforward. and sometimes it's straightforward because they're choosing the upgrade paths of least resistance. So they're the paths that leave everything maybe the way it was designed and architected 20 years ago and not really modernizing it much. They're they may be changing something about the hardware platform, but they're not, you know, upgrading it to the new the new suggested frameworks. So I I think that, you know, all that being said, I think one of the mistakes that is is made is is not taking advantage of the expertise and the latest technologies when doing a migration.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, it's we I was actually recording an episode yesterday and it was talking about cybersecurity and how much that is changed in the way that just approaching a cybersecurity protocol and the multi-layer approach to to keep networks and facilities more secure. So if I I'm assuming that that could be something that is overlooked if you're keeping it a network or infrastructure the way it was twenty years ago, you're even if an you have an update, you're gonna not be getting all the all the advantages.
Chris Virtue: Right, right, yeah.
Jeff B: And vulnerabilities too, right? You're you you are vulnerable as a facility if you have older protocols that that can be taken advantage of in a DNS attack. Absolutely.
Jackie Slaght: So okay, sorry, it kind of took us on a little journey there, but just hearing hearing you talk about you know how that could be overlooked when when you know you think you're doing the right thing, updating, but if you don't have the expertise and I I think we're we're not alone in that the industry and technology has certainly moved quickly and there's a lot to learn.
Chris Virtue: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Slaght: but when When a facility is kind of looking at this modernization plan, we often say that we've we can help break it into like a phase one, two, or three approach. what does that typically look like? Or is there a typical kind of phased approach or or is it kind of customized per per client need?
Chris Virtue: Go ahead, Jeff.
Jeff B: Yeah, so so I think the one typical thing, Jackie, is that we've had a lot of conversations with plant managers and plant engineers on they don't know how to start, right? So they they're kind of hesitant to start and they don't want to go in a direction and be led into a cul-de-sac, right? So I'm just using the analogy of, hey, I can't turn around now and I've gone down this road and I've spent this money, right? So so there's there's kind of a little Bit of fear and unknown and concern in that. Whereas if we sit down with them and we talk through kind of the process and we gather information, we sit down and we
Chris Virtue: Yeah.
Jeff B: all plan out kind of the phased migration and what what things are gonna happen when and how we're gonna avoid downtime. You know, because we've done phase migrations and upgrades on Saturdays and Saturdays. Sundays. We've done them, we we do them over holidays. We do them we do them overnight, right? From you know, from 11 p.m. to 7 a.m. So there's a lot of ways to kind of approach this, these phased migrations, and we've done it, you know, with a lot of different customers that just cannot have any downtime. So so there's a lot to it, but the biggest thing is to sit down and kind of talk, see what the current condition is and and kind of have a plan.
Jackie Slaght: working with the client on a kind of a phased approach to their long-term modernization goals, how do you balance these long-term goals with short-term quick fixes?
Chris Virtue: Mm-hmm. Yeah, and you usually on our modernization approach, it's one of those elephants, right? it's a large task, especially depending on the size of your facility and what it means to modernize it or upgrade that running equipment that never shuts down. so you really have to tackle it one piece at a time and I think that that's where Working with a systems integrator that understands the path for migrations helps because they can help you develop a strategy and prioritize those key points that need to be addressed immediately and obviously you know gant out towards you know reaching your end goal with the project. So I there's no one answer except that When you work with someone that does know migrations, they will be able to help you prioritize those pain points and seeing everything in a big picture form so that they understand what you can address and when. So, you know, you wouldn't start taking on a very large project replacing something that has no ROI, right? But it may have. it may very well have no ROI but it has a huge security risk. So you wouldn't know that without doing an audit or a system inventory. And when I say inventory, I mean not a parts inventory from like a maintenance perspective, but an inventory as far as an asset, a running production asset inventory. so, you know, your networks, your servers, your PLCs, your automation equipment, everything on the list that You think that could benefit from a modernization of the
Jeff B: Yeah, all great points. All really good pr great points. There's the only thing that I would add is There is a lot of this that takes place offline,
Jackie. So if we were to upgrade a panel with a PLC and a drive, right, we would pull the program from the old PLC and all that work would would be done offline as the project as the as the facility runs, right? So we would test it, load it in there, we would we would build the panel, upgrade the drive. All these things would happen offline and not disturb production. And then that's when we do kind of what we would call the switch over, right? And be a sort of a bumpless switchover, maybe in the evening. And those are the type of things that people have to keep in mind is a lot of this, a lot of these upgrades can happen offline and then be implemented when there's no disturbance in production.
Jackie Slaght: Jeff, I'm going back a little bit to you said when a client starts a modernization journey, you know, you wouldn't want to start that and then realize that you're in a cul-de-sac and can't turn around and don't know how to go forward. And
Jeff B: You bet.
Jackie Slaght: that was making making me think of like when you take on a kind of a a home renovation project and if you're trying to do that yourself, you very easily end up with like stairs that are uneven and things maybe not up to code, but that's most of the time when you're taking on these big big projects in your own home, you would hire, hire someone out. I am kind of relating this modernization phased approach to what we do for just manufacturing facilities.
Jeff B: Well, think of it this way. let's say you were renovating a bathroom b yourself and you had a family of four, and now you have a bathroom project that takes eight months. Tell me that's not gonna be painful, right?
Chris Virtue: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Slaght: It's gonna that's gonna incur
Chris Virtue: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: some some long waits, I guess.
Jeff B: Yes.
Jackie Slaght: Waiting to get into the bathroom.
Chris Virtue: Yeah. Yeah, it's kinda com the comparison of a DIY project or a professional project, right? You know, you may be capable, and you may be able to execute it on time and on budget, but you may not. So
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. so yeah, any anyway, I did that was where where my brain went when you when you had that example. but speaking of examples, can either of you share an example of a a plant that maybe started on their modernization journey and they started small but then started to gain momentum and see the results of and impact of this modernization effort?
Jeff B: So I've been in the water, wastewater facility for I I've been in that in that industry for quite a long time. And those guys are kind of notorious for being slower process. you know, they're they're in they're they're in the situation where they lot of times have to have public bids and public budgets. there there is a lot of times where there's a lot of legacy projects in there. And you know we did a project in Hobbes, New Mexico. We've done a lot of projects in the in the in Northern California where it it really took a while to do it, but
it was done the right way. And it just it just really takes a long So, you know, water, wastewater to me is a is a really good example of of something that's that's critical. It's probably gonna take a while, and and and it has to be well thought out.
Jackie Slaght: That's a great example.
Chris Virtue: And it pays for itself in the end, right?
Jackie Slaght: have you seen the reverse of a facility maybe try to take on too much at once? where did they end up with that situation?
Jeff B: So I've seen a couple plants try and do too much. And one of the challenges is trying to find the time to actually do the install, the upgrade, have the maintenance trained on it. You know, so if it's not a well planned out phase migration and they try and do too much all at once. It c it that that that itself can create downtime, it can create stresses, it can create frustration in the staff, things like that. So I have seen that in some facilities where they've tried to kind of take take on too much and trying to upgrade too much all at once, and and kind of you know really frustrated some of the folks on the on the floor.
Jackie Slaght: Chris, do you have did you have an example or it
Chris Virtue: I I could not think of one. my
Jackie Slaght: Well that's fine.
Chris Virtue: yep, my brain went it fell out.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. No, I s I put you on the spot. It's kinda hard to to think of an exit ex
Chris Virtue: No, I d I just I know they're there. Is that is not yeah, coming in to rescue a client offer an upgrade or for upgrades. It's very specific, yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. So how should plant managers be thinking about cybersecurity as they're also taking on a modernization project?
Chris Virtue: I would say cyber security in the OT operations realm is i it's it's no longer something that you can really push aside or not consider or consider maybe a bonus or unless you have a really picky IT team, you do it, or something like that. it's really becoming mandated and a lot of I'm sure managers or whatever that may see this video will will know that right the insurance companies are basically you know saying you must in order for you to carry this policy right your C V E results and this this and that you know they need to reflect this. and so I I think you need to respect the cybersecurity implementations that are required rather than considering them as an option. Because pretty soon it'll become something that you can't avoid and it'll be costly to address some of the things that you maybe skipped or chose to forego at the beginning.
Jeff B: Or it's too late. I I would agree with all of that, or it's
Chris Virtue: It's or it's too late. Yeah.
Jeff B: too late is do not think that it won't happen to you. Do not be one of those people who like, that you know, they're not gonna look for a little water district out in Iowa. They're they There is DNS attacks happening right now, and we've seen it here at the beginning of August in the news right now. And like Chris said, at this point, you cannot stick your head in the sand anymore and not address cybersecurity. It is just no longer an option. It is now a necessity.
Chris Virtue: Yeah. In a few words, that's that's a way to wrap it up, right? Yeah. Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. Well, that's a one of the the things I think ev everyone is talking about as well, cybersecurity is AI. And I think it's important to also remember that if we're using AI, the threat hunters like they can be used for good or bad. So I wanna thank you guys for joining us today. I think we've covered just about everything. I wanna also just take a few minutes and we'll do a rapid fire. I always like to end on some fun questions. so I will ask first if you could automate one thing in your life, what would it be?
Jeff B: My daughter No, I'm kidding. Seventeen
Jackie Slaght: How old is your daughter? well that makes sense then.
Jeff B: Ha ha ha.
Chris Virtue: You mean automate her responses, right?
Jeff B: Yes, yes.
Chris Virtue: Yep. Yep. I would s I would say the tasks I don't want to do. Yep. That would be
Jeff B: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Chris Virtue: that would be fantastic, but you wouldn't learn anything.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. and if you had to explain your job to a five year old, how would you do that? This is my fun favorite fun question. And I'm bringing it back. I feel like I've I've not asked it in a couple episodes. So
Jeff B: Yeah, I I always tell people the way I got into engineering is I started building stuff with Legos. So I would tell, you know, a five and six year old is I get to play kind of with Legos every day. I get to build stuff.
Chris Virtue: Mm. Yep. That's that's how I have probably explained it to our girls as well, you know. play with Legos and you know, they've they've gotten to visit some of the factories I've I've worked in for a long period of time and you know, they've seen it firsthand. So how it's made is is usually a good description as well, you know.
Jackie Slaght: That's awesome. And last and final question is what would you like to see us cover on future episodes of Beyond Tech? And Jeff, you're an expert on this because you suggested this episode. So anything else? Any other ideas?
Jeff B: you know, I would say probably in the life sciences that I work right now, we should probably do something in validation and GMP. it's very, very important. and it's and it's not super well known by sort of the outside world. I'd say that that would be my suggestion.
Chris Virtue: Yeah. Or what the what the food and bread B U or Vertical could learn from GMP.
Jackie Slaght: That's a that's
Jeff B: That's a really good point.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. that one down right now. well,
Chris Virtue: what food and bev could learn from GMP. Yeah, it's probably yeah. I I love your idea, Jeff. that's yeah, I just piggybacked on what you had.
Jackie Slaght: You're gonna get wrapped into another episode here.
Chris Virtue: That's fine.
Jeff B: All right.
Jackie Slaght: Well, I that is all the questions I have.
Chris Virtue: That will bring his charger
Jackie Slaght: for you guys today. wanna thank you for spending some time with us and sharing sharing some insight. So thank you guys.
Jeff B: Thank you, Jackie. Thanks, Chris.
Chris Virtue: Thank you, Jackie. Thanks,